Ethnicity. Genogram/Ecomap completed. Age. %BOHFS )BSN. (SFZ "SFBT. 4BGFUZ. Likelihood of maltreatment. Describe strengths demonstrated over time.
!5'534
&EJUPSJBM &JMFFO.VOSPMPPLTBUUIFSPMFPGSFBTPOJOHJO TVQFSWJTJPO
+P'JFMEDPOTJEFSTUIFDVSSFOUTUBUFPG TVQFSWJTJPOBOEJUTGVUVSF
4V[BOOF-PISCBDIEJTDVTTFTUIFSPMFPGHSPVQ TVQFSWJTJPO
.BSJF$POOPMMZ :WPOOF$SJDIUPO)JMM BOE5POZ8BSEFYBNJOFGBNJMJFTBOEIPX TVQFSWJTJPODBOIFMQXPSLFSTOBWJHBUFDVMUVSBM MBOETDBQFT
-J[#FEEPFBOE"MMZTPO%BWZTNBLFUIFDBTF GPSJOUFSQSPGFTTJPOBMMFBSOJOH
1SBDUJDFOPUF/PWB4BMPNFOJOUSPEVDFT$IJME :PVUIBOE'BNJMZ¥TTVQFSWJTJPOUSJHHFST
#PPLSFWJFXT *OGPSNBUJPOGPSDPOUSJCVUPST 4PDJBM8PSL/PXBJNT
4PDJBM8PSL/PXISPUBLISHEDTHREETIMESAYEARBY#HILD 9OUTHAND&AMILY 6IEWSEXPRESSEDINTHEJOURNALARENOTNECESSARILYTHOSEOF#HILD 9OUTHAND&AMILY-ATERIAL "6(645
MAYBEREPRINTEDINOTHERPUBLICATIONSONLYWITHPRIORWRITTENPERMISSIONANDPROVIDEDTHE
MATERIALISUSEDINCONTEXTANDCREDITEDTO4PDJBM8PSL/PX
EDITORIAL
Responding to the challenges of supervision $R-ARIE#ONNOLLY 4HISISANIMPORTANTEDITIONOF3OCIAL7ORK.OW
RESPONSESTOTHECHALLENGESOFSUPERVISION)
$EDICATEDTOSUPERVISION ITCONCERNSONEOF
AMDELIGHTEDTHAT%ILEEN-UNROHASBEENABLE
THEMOSTIMPORTANTACTIVITIESINCHILDWELFARE
TOCONTRIBUTETOTHISEDITION(ERWORKISAT
THESUPPORTANDDEVELOPMENTOFBESTPRACTICE
THEFOREFRONTOFCHILDPROTECTIONPRACTICE
3UPERVISORSWITHINCHILDWELFARESYSTEMSAREIN
INTERNATIONALLY ANDWEAREFORTUNATETOHAVE
AKEYPOSITIONTOINFLUENCETHEWAYINWHICH
HEREXCELLENTANALYSISOFSOCIALWORKREASONING
SOCIALWORKWITHCHILDREN YOUNGPEOPLEAND
INTHECONTEXTOFSUPERVISION,IZ"EDDOE WHO
THEIRFAMILIESEVOLVESANDSTRENGTHENS4HEIR
HASWRITTENEXTENSIVELYINTHEAREAFROMA.EW
LEADERSHIPISCRITICALTOOURCOLLECTIVECAPACITYTO
:EALANDPERSPECTIVE REMINDSUSOFTHERICH
REALISEGOODOUTCOMESFORTHECHILDRENWEWORK
POTENTIALOFCROSS DISCIPLINARYSUPERVISION)
WITH3UPERVISIONISTHEMECHANISMTHROUGH
AMPARTICULARLYPLEASEDTOSEEPAPERSFOCUSING
WHICHTHENURTURINGOFPRACTICEOCCURS AND
ONTHEDEVELOPMENTOFCASECONSULTMODELSOF
SO)AMDELIGHTEDWEHAVEBEENABLETOBRING
SUPERVISIONINCHILDWELFAREPRACTICE&ROMA53
TOGETHERANEDITIONTHATFOCUSESONTHISCRITICAL
PERSPECTIVE 3UE,OHRBACHDESCRIBESINNOVATIVE
AREAOFOURWORK
PRACTICEIN-INNESOTA WHILE*O&IELDUPDATES USON.EW:EALANDINITIATIVES4HESEREPRESENT
)NRECENTYEARS)HAVEREFLECTEDUPONDISCOURSES
IMPORTANTSTEPSFORWARDINTHEEVOLUTIONOF
OFSUPERVISIONTHATSEEMTOHAVECHANGED
CHILDWELFARESUPERVISIONPRACTICEANDREFLECTTHE
LITTLESINCE)BEGANSOCIALWORKSOMEDECADES
COMPLEXPARTICULARITYOFCHILDPROTECTIONAND
AGONOW7HILSTTHEREISNODOUBTTHATTHERE
YOUTHJUSTICEWORK)TISPARTICULARLYHEARTENING
AREKEYASPECTSOFSUPERVISIONTHATREMAIN
TOSEESUPERVISIONMODELSSUCHASTHESEBEING
IMPORTANTOVERTIME FOREXAMPLETHEREFLECTIVE
SPECIFICALLYDEVELOPEDFORWORKINCHILDAND
OPPORTUNITYITPROVIDES ITISCURIOUSTONOTE
FAMILYWELFARE
THELIMITEDADVANCEMENTSWEHAVEMADE PARTICULARLYGIVENTHEDYNAMICENVIRONMENT
)HOPETHISEDITIONWILLSTIMULATEDEBATEAND
THATREPRESENTSCHILDWELFAREPRACTICE)NDIVIDUAL
ENCOURAGEUSTORETHINKSUPERVISIONPRACTICE
SUPERVISIONCONTINUESTODOMINATEOURPRACTICE
INWAYSTHATWILLSTRENGTHENOURWORKWITH
SUPPLEMENTEDATTIMESBYINNOVATIVEKAUPAPA
CHILDREN YOUNGPEOPLEANDTHEIRFAMILIES
-iORISUPERVISIONANDSTRENGTHS BASEDPEER SUPPORTMODELS 4HEARTICLESINTHISEDITIONAFINECOLLECTIONOF $R-ARIE#ONNOLLYISTHE#HIEF3OCIAL7ORKERATTHE -INISTRYOF3OCIAL$EVELOPMENT
.EW:EALANDANDINTERNATIONALCONTRIBUTIONS PROVIDEIMPORTANTANDATTIMESPROVOCATIVE 3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
Improving reasoning in supervision %ILEEN-UNRO )NTRODUCTION
RESPONSIBILITY/URINTUITIVECAPACITYHASSOME PERSISTENTBIASES ANDWORKERSNEEDHELPFROM
3OCIALWORKERSUSEFORMALKNOWLEDGEASWELLAS
OTHERSTOSCRUTINISETHEIROWNTHINKINGAND
INTUITIVEANDEMPATHICUNDERSTANDINGINTHEIR
CHECKFORTHESEBIASES3UPERVISORSPLAYAN
PRACTICE(OWTHESETWODIFFERENTSOURCESOF
ESSENTIALROLEINHELPINGWORKERSTOCRITIQUE
WISDOMSHOULDORCANBEINTEGRATEDHASLONG
THEIROWNREASONING-UNRO 4HEAGENCY
BEENTHESUBJECTOFDEBATE#LARK
TOO PLAYSANESSENTIALROLEINDESIGNINGA
3OMEWANTTHEPROFESSIONTOAIMATBEING
MANAGEMENTFRAMEWORKTHATGIVESVALUEAND
BASEDONFORMAL EXPLICITKNOWLEDGE WITH
TIMETOIMPROVINGREASONINGSKILLS
ABURGEONINGEMPIRICAL EVIDENCEBASEGRADUALLY ERADICATINGINTUITIONAND EMPATHY/THERSARGUE FORTHEESSENTIALROLEOF INTUITIONANDEMPATHYIN UNDERSTANDINGANDHELPING
4UVEJFTTIPXUIBUXFIBWF "RAINPROCESSESIN REASONING UXPTFQBSBUFNFUIPETPG )THASLONGBEENKNOWNTHAT QSPDFTTJOHEBUBJOPVS CSBJOT POFBOBMZUJDBOEUIF PEOPLEHAVETWOMODESOF REASONINGTHEINTUITIVEAND PUIFSJOUVJUJWF
THEANALYTIC!NALYTICTHINKING
PEOPLE TAKINGTHEVIEW
ISEXPLICITANDSYSTEMATICALLY
THATFORMALKNOWLEDGECAN
WORKEDOUT STEP BY STEP)NTUITIVEREASONING
NEVERREPLACETHESESKILLS2ECENTRESEARCHIN NEUROPHYSIOLOGYPUTSTHISDEBATEINANEWLIGHT
HOWEVER ISLESSCONSCIOUSANDSWIFTLYPRODUCESA
3TUDIESSHOWTHATWEHAVETWOSEPARATEMETHODS
CONCLUSION2ECENTDEVELOPMENTSINTECHNOLOGY
OFPROCESSINGDATAINOURBRAINS ONEANALYTIC
HAVEALLOWEDMUCHCLOSERSTUDYOFHOWTHE
ANDTHEOTHERINTUITIVE"OTHARENECESSARYFOR
BRAINOPERATES ANDCOMBINEDWITHPSYCHOLOGICAL
THEHIGHESTLEVELOFREASONING.EITHERINTUITIVE
STUDIES THISHASLEDTOAMOREDETAILED
ORANALYTICREASONINGARE£THEBEST¤BUTEACH
KNOWLEDGEOFTHENATUREOFBOTHINTUITIVEAND
HASDIFFERENTSTRENGTHSANDWEAKNESSES ANDIN
ANALYTICREASONING
REALITY WEUSEBOTHINMOSTREASONINGTASKS
)NTUITIVEREASONINGTAKESPLACEINTHEOLDBRAIN
4HISARTICLEPRESENTSTHEFINDINGSONHOWWE
WHILEOURANALYTICSKILLISINTHENEOCORTEX
REASONANDCONSIDERSTHEIMPLICATIONSFOR
4ABLELISTSTHEKEYDIFFERENCESBETWEENTHEM
UNDERSTANDINGBOTHOFTHESEROLESINSOCIALWORK
)NTUITIONISLARGE SWIFT ANDUNCONSCIOUS SEEKING
PRACTICE)TALSOHIGHLIGHTSTHEIMPORTANCEOF
PATTERNSINTHEDATA PERMEATEDWITHEMOTIONS
VIEWINGTHEQUALITYOFREASONINGASASHARED
ANDUSINGSHORTCUTSTOREACHFASTCONCLUSIONS
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
4ABLE )NTUITIVEREASONING
!NALYTICREASONING
5NCONSCIOUSANDAUTOMATIC
#ONSCIOUSANDDELIBERATE
,ARGEPROCESSINGCAPACITY
%FFORTFUL
$ RAWSONWEALTHOFWISDOMABOUTTHE SOCIALWORLDINCLUDINGPREJUDICES AND ONEXPERTKNOWLEDGE
3LOW
,OOKSFORPATTERNS
,OGICAL LINEARTHINKING
%MOTION LADEN
"UILTONINTUITIVEREASONING
&ASTUSESSHORTCUTSHEURISTICS
$RAWSONFORMALKNOWLEDGE
"IASEDBECAUSEUSESSHORTCUTSHEURISTICS
#ANBEREADILYMADEPUBLIC
,IMITEDCAPACITY
!NALYTICREASONING INCONTRAST ISSLOWAND
THEWORKER THEMOREABLETHEYARETONOTICE
EFFORTFUL WITHLIMITEDCAPACITY)TISLINEARAND
PATTERNSOFBEHAVIOURTHATSENDANEMOTIVE
LOGICAL NOTPATTERN SEEKING ANDCANMORE
SIGNALTOTHEMINDICATING£LOOKMORECAREFULLY
READILYBEMADEPUBLICTHANINTUITIVEREASONING
HERESOMETHINGDOESN¤TFEELRIGHT¤
4HETWOPROCESSESOPERATEQUITEDIFFERENTLYAND
4HISLASTPOINTILLUSTRATESTHEROLEOFEMOTIONS
THISHELPSILLUMINATEWHYPEOPLEFINDITSOHARDTO
!GAIN THETRADITIONALVIEWOFHUMANREASONING
MAKETHEIRINTUITIVEREASONINGPUBLIC)TISN¤TJUST
ISCHALLENGEDBYRECENTWORKEMOTIONSHAVE
ACASEOFBRINGINGITINTOCONSCIOUSAWARENESS
TYPICALLYBEENVIEWEDAS
BUTOFTRANSLATINGFROM
UNWANTEDNOISEINTHE
ANEMOTION LADENPATTERN INTOACOOL LOGICALCHAINOF REASONINGSOTHATTHEANALYTIC MINDCANWORKONIT
0VSFNPUJPOTIFMQVT JEFOUJGZXIJDIPQUJPOTMPPL NPTUQSPCBCMFBOEXPSUI FYQMPSJOHNPSF
SYSTEM ASOURCEOFBIAS ANDDISTRACTIONTHEIDEAL THINKERHASBEENSEENAS DEVOIDOFEMOTIONANDWHOLLY LOGICAL4HISISNOWSEENTO
0EOPLEGENERALLYUSEBOTH
BEMISTAKEN%MOTIONSCAN
REASONINGSKILLSBUTINVARYINGDEGREES3OCIAL WORKERSENTERINGAFAMILYHOMEFORTHEFIRST
CERTAINLYDISTORTOURTHINKINGBUTTHEYCANNOT
TIMEARELIKELYTOBEHIGHLYINTUITIVEINTHE
BEWIPEDOUT4HEYHAVEALSOBEENSHOWNTO
FIRSTFEWMINUTESWHILETHEYGETASENSEOFTHE
BEAVALUABLESOURCEOFEVIDENCE USEDWITH
FAMILY PICKINGUPTHEEMOTIONALATMOSPHERE
CAUTION$AMASIO¤S STUDIESOFPEOPLEWITH
ANDSENSINGHOWWELCOMETHEYARE4HEYMAY
BRAINDAMAGEFOUNDTHATTHOSEWHOSEEMOTIONAL
THENMOVETOAMOREANALYTICMODEWHILE FOR
CAPACITYWASDAMAGEDBECAMEBADATCOGNITIVE
EXAMPLE EXPLAININGTHATTHEYARETHEREINA
TASKS(ETHEORISEDTHATEMOTIONSPLAYTHEROLE
STATUTORYROLETOFOLLOWUPANALLEGATIONOF
OF£MARKERS¤INREASONING)NMAKINGADECISION
CHILDABUSE#ONSCIOUSKNOWLEDGEOFLAWAND
FOREXAMPLE WEFACEAPOTENTIALLYVASTRANGEOF
PROCEDURESARENEEDEDHEREWHILETHEREISSTILLA
OPTIONS ANDIFWEWERETOCONSIDERTHEMALL WE
NEEDTOKEEPOPERATINGINTUITIVELYINCONDUCTING
WOULDTAKESOLONGTHATWEWOULDFAILTOMAKE
THEINTERVIEWANDRESPONDINGTOTHENUANCESIN
DECISIONSINATIMELYWAY/UREMOTIONSHELP
THEFAMILY¤SBEHAVIOUR4HEMOREEXPERIENCED
USIDENTIFYWHICHOPTIONSLOOKMOSTPROBABLE
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
ANDWORTHEXPLORINGMORE4HOSEPATIENTSWHO
BECAMEMOREEXPERIENCED4HEYFOUNDTHAT AT
LACKEDSUCHEMOTIONALHINTSCOULDNOTFIND
THEBEGINNING THEYWEREMAINLYATTHEANALYTIC
AWAYTOLIMITTHETASKANDHENCEHADGREAT
END MAKINGCONSCIOUS EXPLICITUSEOFCHECKLISTS
TROUBLECOMINGTOADECISION
PROTOCOLS ETC!STHEYACQUIREDSKILL MUCHOF THISBECAMEINCORPORATEDINTOTHEIRINTUITIVE
3OCIALWORKERSWHORESPONDTOTHEIREMOTIONAL
WISDOMANDCOULDBEUSEDLESSFORMALLY
SIGNALSAREABLETOPRIORITISEWHICHASPECTSOF THEFAMILY¤SSITUATIONTOFOCUSON7ITHOUTSUCH
0ROGRESSINSOCIALWORKISSIGNIFICANTLYDIFFERENT
HINTS THEWORKERHASTOPLODSYSTEMATICALLY
FROMMEDICINEBECAUSESOCIALWORKNOVICES
THROUGHALLTHERELEVANTCATEGORIES NOTKNOWING
APPROACHTHEWORKWITHANEXISTINGANDWELL
WHICHONESTOGIVEMORETIMEANDENERGYTO
DEVELOPEDRANGEOFINTUITIVEUNDERSTANDING!
EXPLORING4HERESULTINGASSESSMENTTENDSTOALSO
MEDICALSTUDENTWOULDHAVELITTLEKNOWLEDGEOF
LACKANYPRIORITISATION MAKINGITLESSINFORMATIVE
HOWTOBEGINTOCUTOUTABRAINTUMOUR BUTA
TOOTHERS
SOCIALWORKSTUDENTDOESHAVECOMPETENCESIN TALKINGTOPEOPLEANDMAKING
4HEEMOTIONALMARKERSHELP NARROWDOWNOURREASONING TASKSBUTTHEYAREALSO FALLIBLE3UPERVISORSNEEDTO ENCOURAGEWORKERSTOREPORT THEIRFEELINGSSOTHATTHEY CANCONSIDERWHETHERTHEY AREDISTORTINGTHEIRWORK /NCETHEEMOTIONS WHETHER
1SPHSFTTJOTPDJBMXPSLJT TJHOJGJDBOUMZEJGGFSFOUGSPN NFEJDJOFCFDBVTFTPDJBM XPSLOPWJDFTBQQSPBDIUIF XPSLXJUIBOFYJTUJOHBOE XFMMEFWFMPQFESBOHFPG JOUVJUJWFVOEFSTUBOEJOH
POSITIVEORNEGATIVE ARE
SENSEOFTHEM7ITHOUTTAKING AFORMALCOURSEINCHILD DEVELOPMENT MANYSTUDENTS WILLHAVEAGRASPOFTHEBASIC MILESTONESANDMAYFEEL COMPETENTTOJUDGEHOWWELL ACHILDISFARING4HEREFORE THESEQUENCEOFDEVELOPMENT INSOCIALWORKHASANEXTRA STAGE.OVICESHAVETOLEARN
OUTINTHEOPEN ITBECOMES
TOUSEFORMALKNOWLEDGEASWELLASTHEIRPRE
POSSIBLETOPREDICTHOWTHEYMAYDISTORTTHE
EXISTINGWISDOM(OWEVER THEYTHENFOLLOWTHE
THINKINGANDCOUNTERACTTHEBIAS!TYPICAL
SAMEPATHASTHEYBECOMEMOREEXPERIENCED
SCENARIO FOREXAMPLE ISASOCIALWORKERFORMING
THEIRUSEOFFORMALTHEORIESBECOMESABSORBED
AGOODRELATIONSHIPWITHTHEMOTHERSOTHATSHE
INTOTHEIRINTUITIVEAPPROACH7HENINTERVIEWING
FEELSCOMPASSIONANDINADVERTENTLYSEESTHE
AFAMILY ANASSESSMENTFORMMAYBEUSEDBYA
PROBLEMTHROUGHHEREYES TOTHEDETRIMENTOF
NOVICEINAMECHANICAL SYSTEMATICWAYWHERE
OTHERFAMILYMEMBERS(ERNEEDSANDWORRIES
THESOCIALWORKER¤SPRIMEFOCUSISONTHETASK
WILLPROVOKEASTRONGEREMOTIONALTUGINTHE
SOTHATSHEHASLITTLESPAREATTENTIONTOPAYTO
WORKERANDSOCANRECEIVEANUNFAIRAMOUNTOF
WHATELSEISGOINGONINTHEINTERVIEW!MORE
THEPROFESSIONALHELP)FTHESUPERVISORKNOWSOF
EXPERIENCEDWORKERCANBEMOREFLEXIBLEAND
THISEMOTIONALBOND THENITISPOSSIBLETOENSURE
PERCEPTIVE ALTERINGTHESEQUENCEOFTHEISSUES
THATOTHERSINTHEFAMILYAREGETTINGSUFFICIENT
ADDRESSEDINRESPONSETOTHEMESSAGESSHEIS
ATTENTION
PICKINGUPFROMTHEFAMILY
4HEDISTINCTIONBETWEENANALYTICANDINTUITIVE ALSOILLUMINATESWHATISINVOLVEDINMOVING
4HEANALYTICINTUITIVECONTINUUM
FROMANOVICETOANEXPERT$REYFUSAND$REYFUS
4HELATESTTHINKINGONHUMANREASONINGSKILLS
STUDIEDHOWDOCTORSCHANGEDASTHEY
CHALLENGESTHECLASSICVIEWIN7ESTERNCULTURE
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
THATCREATESADICHOTOMYBETWEENANALYTICAND
INTUITION WORKINGONITTOATTAINAHIGHERLEVEL
INTUITIVETHINKING WITHINTUITIONBEINGSEEN
OFRIGOUR)FINDTHISIMAGEAVERYPERSUASIVE
ASANINFERIORFORMTOBEAVOIDEDASMUCHAS
PICTUREOFWHATCANBEACHIEVEDINGOOD
POSSIBLE)NSTEAD BOTHFORMSOFREASONINGARE
SUPERVISIONTHESUPERVISORPROMPTSTHEWORKER
CONSIDEREDTOHAVEANESSENTIALROLETOPLAY
TOTEASEOUTTHEBACKGROUNDREASONINGTHATLED
WITHBOTHBEINGUSEDINVARYINGPROPORTIONS
TOHISHERCURRENTAPPRAISALOFTHEFAMILYAND
INDIFFERENTREASONINGTASKS(OWEVER WHILE
THENHELPSHIMHERPUTITUNDERTHEMICROSCOPE
INTUITIONSORAS'IGERENZERCALLSTHEM£GUT
LOOKINGATTHERELIABILITYOFTHEEVIDENCEWHO
FEELINGS¤AREGIVENHIGHERSTATUS ITISESSENTIAL
SAIDTHIS HOWWELLDOESHEKNOWTHECHILD
TOHAVEAREALISTICVIEWOFTHEIRSTRENGTHSAND
ETC THINKINGOFASPECTSTHATHAVEBEENLEFTOUT
WEAKNESSES
WHATABOUTTHEOLDERBOYWHOISN¤TDRAWING ATTENTIONTOHIMSELF ANDSUGGESTINGWAYSOF
'UTFEELINGSAREINFACT NEITHERIMPECCABLE ORSTUPIDTHEYTAKE ADVANTAGEOFTHEEVOLVED CAPACITIESOFTHEBRAIN ANDAREBASEDONRULES OFTHUMBTHATENABLE
GETTINGMOREEVIDENCETO
4VQFSWJTJPOJTUIFDPOUFYU JOXIJDIFYQMJDJUBUUFOUJPO OFFETUPCFHJWFOUP DIFDLJOHGPSUIFQSFEJDBCMF CJBTFT
USTOACTFASTANDWITH
TESTTHEASSESSMENTFINDOUT WHETHERTHESCHOOLSUPPORTS THEMOTHER¤SACCOUNT 3UPERVISIONISTHECONTEXTIN WHICHEXPLICITATTENTIONNEEDS TOBEGIVENTOCHECKINGFOR THEPREDICABLEBIASES
ASTOUNDINGACCURACY 'IGERENZER P
0REDICTABLEANDAVOIDABLEBIASES
4HERULESOFTHUMBWEHAVEINTUITIVELYDEVELOPED
#LINGINGTOBELIEFS
AREBOTHASOURCEOFTHEPOWERANDOFTHE FALLIBILITYOFINTUITION4HEYENABLEUSTOHANDLE
4HISISTHEMOSTPERVASIVEBIASINOURREASONING
VASTAMOUNTSOFINFORMATIONVERYQUICKLYBY
/NCEWEHAVEFORMEDAPICTUREOFAPERSONOR
TAKINGSHORTCUTSBUTTHESEALLCARRYIDENTIFIABLE
FAMILY WEHAVEASTRONGTENDENCYTOKEEPTO
BIASESANDLEADTOPREDICTABLEERRORSINOUR
IT NOTICINGANYNEWINFORMATIONTHATSUPPORTS
CONCLUSIONS)NSOMECIRCUMSTANCES THEVALUE
ITBUTTENDINGTOOVERLOOKORDEVALUEANY
OFTHESPEEDOUTWEIGHSANYINACCURACYBUT
THATCHALLENGESIT)TISAMAJORCONTRIBUTORTO
INSOCIALWORK MANYOFTHEJUDGMENTSAND
TRAGEDIESINCHILDPROTECTIONWORKPROFESSIONALS
DECISIONSWORKERSMAKEAREOFCRUCIALIMPORTANCE
FOREXAMPLE FORMTHEVIEWTHATTHEMOTHERIS
TOTHESAFETYORWELLBEINGOFSERVICEUSERSSO
CO OPERATINGWELLWITHTHEMANDFAILTONOTICE
THATAHIGHERLEVELOFACCURACYISNEEDED)NTHE
EVIDENCETHATTHECHILDRENARESUFFERINGHARM
EMOTIONAL INFORMATION LADENSETTINGSOFDIRECT
)TISVERYHARDFORPEOPLETOSTANDBACKANDBE
WORK INTUITIVEREASONINGCANBEDOMINANTBUT
OBJECTIVEABOUTTHEIRTHINKINGONTHEIROWN
WORKERSNEEDTOTAKETIMELATERTOSTOPANDREFLECT
)FTHEYTRYTOEXAMINETHEIRJUDGEMENT THEIR
INQUIETERCIRCUMSTANCES3UPERVISIONISCLASSICALLY
INTUITIONWILLAUTOMATICALLYPRODUCEALLTHE
THEFORUMFORDOINGTHISALTHOUGHMANYWORKERS
EVIDENCETOBACKITUP)FSOMEONEOFFERSCOUNTER
GAINSUBSTANTIALHELPFROMTHEIRTEAMCOLLEAGUES
EVIDENCE THEIRINTUITIONWILLSWIFTLYPRODUCEA 4HIELE OFFERSTHEIMAGEOFSEEINGOUR
REASONFORREJECTINGIT3OTHISISANAREAWHERE
ANALYTICCAPACITYASA£PERSONALTRAINER¤FOR
SUPERVISORSANDINDEEDCOLLEAGUES NEEDTO
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
PULLTHEIRWEIGHTINOFFERINGALTERNATIVEWAYSOF
PASTEVIDENCE'LEITMAN &RIDLUND2EISBERG
LOOKINGATTHEEVIDENCE
4HESECANBEHELPFULMARKERSINCHILD ABUSECASESBUTTHEREAREALSOSITUATIONSWHERE
2ESEARCHHASFOUNDTHATTHEMOSTEFFECTIVE
THESEFREQUENCYESTIMATESCANLEADTOERRORSIN
METHODISTOPLAY£DEVIL¤SADVOCATE¤TOTAKETHE
REASONING4HESIMPLESTRATEGYOFTHINKINGABOUT
OPPOSITEVIEWANDARGUEFORIT4HISTRIGGERSOUR
PERTINENTCASESRELEVANTTOOURJUDGEMENT OFTEN
INTUITIONTOPRODUCEALLTHEEVIDENCETOSUPPORT
REFERREDTOASTHE£AVAILABILITYHEURISTIC¤ MEANS
THATOPPOSINGPOINTOFVIEW5NFORTUNATELY
THATWETENDTOMAKEDECISIONSONTHEEXAMPLES
THEREISNOSIMPLERULEFORDECIDINGWHICHVIEWIS
THATCOMEQUICKLYTOMIND BELIEVINGTHEMTOBE
CORRECT"OTHSIDESINTHEDISPUTENEEDTOWEIGH
USUAL ANDTHENWEASSESSFREQUENCYFROMTHESE
UPTHETWOSETSOFEVIDENCEANDDECIDEWHICHTO
4HISAVAILABILITYBIASMAYBEEFFICIENTINMANY
ACCEPT
SITUATIONSBUTITCANALSOCOMPROMISEDECISION MAKINGORINTERVENTION!SOCIALWORKERWHO
"IASEDRANGEOFEVIDENCE
)NTUITIVEREASONINGTAKES SHORTCUTSBYBEINGSELECTIVE ABOUTTHEEVIDENCEITUSES %XPERIENCEHASTAUGHTUSTHAT CERTAINTYPESOFEVIDENCE
QUICKLYRECALLSFROMHISHER
8IFOXFBSFFYQMBJOJOH PUIFSQFPQMF¥TCFIBWJPVS XFUFOEUPBTDSJCFJUUP JOUFSOBMQFSTPOBMJUZUSBJUT
AREFAIRLYRELIABLEMARKERSSO
OWNEXPERIENCETHATCHILDREN ARENOTGENERALLYPHYSICALLY HURTINCASESOFDOMESTIC VIOLENCEMAYTHENOVERLOOK THESAFETYISSUESWHEN RESPONDINGTOACASEINVOLVING
WEDONOTNEEDTOLOOKAT
PARTNERVIOLENCE
THEWHOLERANGE(OWEVER INSOCIALWORK BEING £FAIRLYRELIABLE¤ISNOTGOODENOUGHWITHTHE
3IMILARLYTHE£REPRESENTATIVENESSHEURISTIC¤
IMPORTANTJUDGEMENTSANDDECISIONS SOWENEED
ASSUMESTHATEACHCASEISTYPICALOFAPARTICULAR
TOBEDELIBERATEININCLUDINGTHEEVIDENCEWEARE
CATEGORYOFTENASTEREOTYPE EVENIFTHERE
INTUITIVELYLIKELYTOOVERLOOK
AREINDICATORSTHATTHECASEMAYBEDIFFERENT 'LEITMANETAL )NTHESESITUATIONSWE
)NTUITIONPAYSMOSTATTENTIONTOEVIDENCETHAT
OFTENASCRIBEACERTAINNUMBEROFCHARACTERISTICS
ISVIVID CONCRETE EMOTION LADEN ANDRECENT ALTHOUGHFIRSTIMPRESSIONSHAVEANENDURING
TOTHECASEANDDRAWCONCLUSIONSTHATMAY
IMPACT )TTENDSTOOVERLOOKEVIDENCETHATIS
BEUNJUSTIFIED ORALTERNATIVELYWEMAKE
DULL ABSTRACT EMOTION FREE ANDINTHEPAST)N
INAPPROPRIATEGENERALISATIONSFROMONECASETO
SOCIALWORK THISBIASISAPPARENT FOREXAMPLE
OTHERSTHATARESIMILAR&OREXAMPLE ASOCIAL
INTHETENDENCYTOFOCUSONTHEPRESENT
WORKERMAYMAKEAPREMATUREJUDGEMENTABOUT
PROBLEMWITHOUTLOOKINGATTHEHISTORIESOFTHE
APARENTWITHSCHIZOPHRENIA BELIEVINGHERTOBE
PEOPLEINVOLVEDANDSEEINGWHETHERTHEREARE
DANGEROUSORNEGLECTFULANDUNABLETOPROVIDE
PERCEPTIBLEPATTERNSINHOWTHEYBEHAVE)TIS
ADEQUATECAREFORHERCHILDREN BECAUSEOF
ALSODEMONSTRATED FOREXAMPLE INTHEGREATER
PREVALENTVIEWSABOUTTHISMENTALHEALTHISSUE
ATTENTIONPAIDTOTHEEMOTIVECONTRIBUTIONOF
4HEFUNDAMENTALATTRIBUTIONERROR
ATEACHERINAMEETINGTHANTOTHESTATISTICSON RISKFACTORSINATEXTBOOK
7HENWEAREEXPLAININGOTHERPEOPLE¤S
&REQUENCYJUDGEMENTSCANLEADTOHYPOTHESES
BEHAVIOUR WETENDTOASCRIBEITTOINTERNAL
WHICHAREHEAVILYINFLUENCEDBYTHEPATTERNOF
PERSONALITYTRAITS)NCONTRAST WHENEXPLAINING
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
OUROWNBEHAVIOUR WETENDTOASCRIBEIT
3OCIALWORKERSCANSHOWTHESAMEBIASWITH
TOTHECONTEXTYOUGETANGRYBECAUSEYOU
SERVICEUSERS BLAMINGPARENTSAFTERANACCIDENT
AREANAGGRESSIVEPERSONALITY)GETANGRY
FOREXAMPLE FORNOTFORESEEINGASOURCEOF
ASAREASONABLERESPONSETOTHEPROVOKING
DANGERTOTHEIRCHILDREN ANDOVERLOOKINGTHE
CIRCUMSTANCES
FACTTHATTHELIKELIHOODOFITBEINGASOURCEOF DANGERWASMINUTE
4HISISLINKEDTOOURBIASEDUSEOFEVIDENCE 7HENWEAREOBSERVINGSOMEONEELSE¤S
4HEHINDSIGHTERRORISVERYHARDTOTACKLE%VEN
BEHAVIOUR THEIRPERSONANDTHEIRACTIONSARETHE
WHENWEAREAWAREOFITSDANGERS WECANNOT
MOSTVIVIDANDCONCRETEDETAILS7HENEXPLAINING
ERADICATEITFROMOURWAYOFLOOKINGATTHE
OUROWNBEHAVIOUR WEAREMOREAWAREOFWHAT
EVIDENCE/NEMETHODWITHSOMESUCCESSISTO
ISGOINGONAROUNDUS THECONTEXTTOWHICHWE
ASKPEOPLETOCONSIDERHOWTHINGSMIGHTHAVE
AREREACTING
TURNEDOUTBESIDESTHEACTUALOUTCOME HELPING TODIMINISHTHESENSEOFINEVITABILITYTHAT
)NSOCIALWORK THISBIASISAPPARENTINTHE
HINDSIGHTCREATES
TENDENCYTOOVER GENERALISEABOUTSOMEONE ONTHEBASISOFVERYLIMITED ANDSPECIFICOBSERVATIONS &OREXAMPLE ABOYMAYBE DESCRIBEDASAGGRESSIVEWHEN ALLTHATTHESOCIALWORKER HASOBSERVEDISTHATHEWAS AGGRESSIVEWHENINCLASSWITH 4EACHER!)FWEWERETOTAKE
(ELPINGTOREDUCEBIAS
*UJTFTTFOUJBMUPSFDPHOJTF UIBUXFDBOOPUBWPJEUIF CJBTFTPGPVSJOUVJUJWF SFBTPOJOHDPOTDJPVT BXBSFOFTTEPFTOPUXJQF UIFNPVUPGUIFCSBJO
THISASASINGLESAMPLEOFHIS
)TISESSENTIALTORECOGNISE THATWECANNOTAVOIDTHE BIASESOFOURINTUITIVE REASONINGCONSCIOUS AWARENESSDOESNOTWIPE THEMOUTOFTHEBRAIN!LLWE CANHOPETODOISTORECOGNISE THEVULNERABILITYINOURSELVES
BEHAVIOURANDINVESTIGATE FURTHER WEMIGHTFINDTHATHEGETSONWELLWITH
ANDOTHERSANDTOCONSCIOUSLYTRYTOSPOTBIASES
4EACHERS"AND# ANDWITHHISFRIENDSINTHE
ANDREDUCETHEM+NOWINGHOWDIFFICULTITIS
PLAYGROUND4HISTHENLEADSTOEXPLANATIONSTHAT
TOBEOBJECTIVEABOUTOUROWNTHINKING WE
FOCUSONTHEINTERACTIONWHENHEISAGGRESSIVE
NEEDTOACKNOWLEDGETHATGOODREASONINGIS
RATHER THANATTRIBUTINGITENTIRELYTOFACTORS
THERESPONSIBILITYOFTHEWHOLEAGENCYNOTTHE
INTERNALTOTHEBOY
INDIVIDUAL &ORSUPERVISORS THISREQUIRESCREATINGACULTURE
(INDSIGHTERROR
INWHICHCHALLENGINGASSESSMENTSANDDECISIONS
/NCEWEKNOWWHATHASHAPPENED WE
ISNOTSEENASAPERSONALCRITICISMBUTAN
OVERESTIMATEHOWOBVIOUSITWASORSHOULD
INTELLECTUALTASKTHATISMORALLYNECESSARYIN
HAVEBEEN TOPEOPLEBEFOREHAND3OCIALWORKERS
ORDERTOPROVIDETHEBESTSTANDARDOFREASONING
AREMOSTAWAREOFTHISBIASASTHEVICTIMSOFIT
FORSERVICEUSERS
7HENACHILDDIESFROMABUSE THEPUBLICHEAR THESTORYOFTHESOCIALWORKINVOLVEMENTWITH
4HEWORKDONEBY$REYFUSAND$REYFUS
THEBENEFITOFHINDSIGHTANDBECOMEANGRYTHAT
ONDOCTORSFOUNDTHATTHEIRABILITYTOARTICULATE
THESOCIALWORKERSATTHETIMEDIDNOTHAVETHE
THEIRINTUITIVEREASONINGWASMOREDEVELOPED
INTELLIGENCETOSEEWHATISNOWSOOBVIOUS
INTHOSEWHOHADBECOMETEACHERSANDNEEDED
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
TOEXPLAINTHEMSELVESTOSTUDENTS4HISSUGGESTS
TRANSFORMATIONOFPRACTICEINRECENTYEARSHAS
THAT WITHPRACTICE WECANIMPROVEOURABILITY
FOCUSEDONWHATISMEASURABLEANDRECORDABLE
TOPULLOUTTHEUNDERLYINGINTUITIVEREASONING
ANDTHISHAS PERHAPSUNINTENTIONALLY LEDTO
ANDLOOKATITMORESYSTEMATICALLYANDCRITICALLY
ANUNDERVALUINGOFTHEIMPORTANCEOFINTUITIVE ANDEMPATHICSKILLS7ITHOUTSUCHSKILLS WEARE
"UTSUPERVISIONOFTHISCHALLENGINGYET
INDANGEROFCREATINGALEVELOFPRACTICEWHERE
SUPPORTIVEKINDCANONLYOCCURIFTHEAGENCY
WORKERSCANCOMPLETETHEPRESCRIBEDPAPERWORK
CULTUREPERMITSIT3OCIALWORKPRACTICEINRECENT
ORELECTRONICFORMS INTHEPRESCRIBEDTIMEBUT
YEARSHASBEENRADICALLYRESHAPEDTHROUGH
LACKINGADEQUATEINTUITIVEANDEMPATHICSKILLS
CHANGESINMANAGEMENTANDAUDITPROCESSES
AREATTHEMERCYOFTHEIRUNCONSCIOUSBIASES
ANDTHEWIDERSOCIALPREOCCUPATIONWITHRISK
ANDARESOCLUMSYINTALKINGTOSERVICEUSERS
4HEREHASBEENASUBSTANTIALINCREASEINTHE
THATTHEDATATHEYENTERISUSELESS)NCONTRAST
NUMBEROFFORMALPROCEDURESPRESCRIBINGHOWTO
BYMAXIMISINGANDINTEGRATINGOURINTUITIVEAND
CONDUCTTHEWORKANDINCREASEDREQUIREMENTS
ANALYTICREASONINGWECANSUPPORTTHECONTINUED
FORDETAILEDRECORDSOFMEASURABLEASPECTSOFTHE
DEVELOPMENTOFOURHIGHLEVELREASONING
WORK4HECUMULATIVEEFFECTOFTHESECHANGESIS TOPRIORITISETHEFORMALASPECTSOFTHEWORKWHILE
3OCIALWORKSEEMSTOMETOREQUIREAN
UNDERVALUINGTHEINTUITIVE
EXCEPTIONALLYHIGHLEVELOFSKILLINBOTHMODESOF REASONING3UPERVISORSPLAY
#ONCLUSION !SHUMANS WEHAVE TWOWAYSOFPROCESSING INFORMATIONTHEINTUITIVE ANDTHEANALYTIC"OTH
4PDJBMXPSLTFFNTUPNF UPSFRVJSFBOFYDFQUJPOBMMZ IJHIMFWFMPGTLJMMJOCPUI NPEFTPGSFBTPOJOH
ANESSENTIALROLEINHELPING SOCIALWORKERSTOIMPROVEON BOTHDIMENSIONSANDTOVALUE THEIRRESPECTIVECONTRIBUTIONS TOANACCURATEUNDERSTANDING OFSERVICEUSERSANDEFFECTIVE
ARENECESSARYINVARYING
WORKINGRELATIONSHIPS4IMEANDEFFORTNEEDSTO
PROPORTIONSDEPENDINGONTHEREASONINGTASK)F YOUSEEADANGEROUSSNAKE YOURINTUITIONNOTES
BEDEVOTEDTOHELPINGWORKERSARTICULATETHEIR
THEDANGERANDRAPIDLYGALVANISESYOURBODYINTO
INTUITIONSANDEMOTIONSSOTHAT INSUPERVISION
THEPHYSICALSTATETODEALWITHANEMERGENCY
THEIRREASONINGCANBEMORERIGOROUSLY
9OURCONSCIOUSANALYTICSKILLOPERATESATASLOWER
SCRUTINISEDANDTHEPREDICTABLEBIASESREMOVED
PACE SOBYTHETIMEYOUHAVEDECIDEDTOSCREAM
!NINVESTMENTINQUALITYSUPERVISIONGIVESUSA
ANDRUN YOURBODYISALREADYPREPAREDTOCARRY
SIGNIFICANTOPPORTUNITYTOREFINETHEREASONING
OUTYOURDECISION"OTHREASONINGSKILLSPLAYA
SKILLSOFWORKERSANDTOENHANCETHELEARNINGAND
PARTINHANDLINGTHESITUATIONSUCCESSFULLY4HERE
PRACTICECULTURESOFTHEORGANISATION
ISNOHIERARCHYOFTHINKINGITISTHEREASONING
2%&%2%.#%3
TASKTHATDETERMINESWHATCOMBINATIONISBEST
#LARK * #OMPLEXAPPROACHESTOWICKED PROBLEMS!PPLYING3HARON"ERLIN¤SANALYSISOF £DICHOTOMOUSTHINKING¤3OCIAL7ORK.OW
4HERECENTWORKONREASONINGSKILLSHIGHLIGHTS THEIMPORTANCEOFAGENCIESASSUMINGASHARED
$AMASIO ! $ESCARTES¤%RROR 3ECOND%DITION ,ONDON6INTAGE"OOKS
RESPONSIBILITYFORTHEQUALITYOFREASONING MOVINGAWAYFROMTHEIDEATHATINDIVIDUALS
$REYFUS ($REYFUS 3 -INDOVER-ACHINE 4HE0OWEROF(UMAN)NTUITIONAND%XPERTISEINTHE %RAOFTHE#OMPUTER.EW9ORK&REE0RESS
SHOULDBEABLETOPOLICETHEIROWNTHINKINGAND NOTICETHEFLAWSANDBIASES4HEMANAGERIAL
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
'IGERENZER ' 'UT&EELINGS4HE)NTELLIGENCEOF THE5NCONCIOUS.EW9ORK6IKING 'LEITMAN ( &RIDLUND !AND2EISBERG $ 0SYCHOLOGY 3IXTH%DITION.EW9ORK77.ORTON #OMPANY -UNRO % %FFECTIVE#HILD0ROTECTION 3ECOND %DITION,ONDON3AGE0UBLICATIONS 4HIELE , 4HE(EARTOF*UDGMENT0RACTICAL 7ISDOM .EUROSCIENCE AND.ARRATIVE#AMBRIDGE #AMBRIDGE5NIVERSITY0RESS
%ILEEN-UNROISA2EADERIN3OCIAL0OLICYATTHE,ONDON 3CHOOLOF%CONOMICS(ERCURRENTRESEARCHINTERESTSAREIN HOWBESTTOCOMBINEINTUITIVEANDANALYTICREASONINGIN RISKASSESSMENTANDDECISIONMAKINGINCHILDPROTECTION ANDTHEROLEOFTHEWIDERORGANISATIONALSYSTEMIN PROMOTINGORHINDERINGGOODCRITICALTHINKING
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
Rethinking supervision and shaping future practice *O&IELD )NTRODUCTION
THEMSELVESBALANCINGTHENEEDSOFFAMILIES WORKERSANDTHEORGANISATION4HEROLEIS
2ESPECTFUL COMPETENTPRACTICEISATTHE
PIVOTALANDCHALLENGING)NDEED DEMONSTRATED
HEARTOFEFFECTIVESOCIALWORKRESPONSESTO
SUPERVISORYLEADERSHIPISCRITICALTOTHESAFE
CHILDREN YOUNGPEOPLEANDTHEIRFAMILIESAND
FUNCTIONINGOFCHILDWELFARESYSTEMS
SUPERVISIONULTIMATELYMIRRORSANDNURTURESTHE WORKERCLIENTRELATIONSHIP3KILLEDSUPERVISION
4HISCHALLENGINGENVIRONMENTPROVIDESUS
STRENGTHENSSOCIALWORKPRACTICEANDENSURES
WITHOPPORTUNITIESTORETHINKSUPERVISIONAND
ROBUSTDECISION MAKING4HIS ARTICLEEXPLORESTHECURRENT SHAPEOFSUPERVISIONAND QUESTIONSITSFUTUREARETHE PRINCIPLES ASSUMPTIONSAND METHODSFROMTHELASTTO
TOQUESTIONTHEWAYSTHAT
4LJMMFETVQFSWJTJPO TUSFOHUIFOTTPDJBMXPSL QSBDUJDFBOEFOTVSFTSPCVTU EFDJTJPONBLJOH
YEARSTHEONESWEWANT
FACILITATEQUALITYPRACTICEIN THESTATUTORYENVIRONMENT )TREQUIRESUSTOQUESTION WHETHERSUPERVISIONINTHE STATUTORYCONTEXTHASEVOLVED ANDPROGRESSEDINLINEWITH
TOCARRYINTOPRACTICEINTHENEWMILLENNIUM
CONTEMPORARYPRACTICETRENDSANDNEEDS$OWE
/RISITTIMELYTORETHINKTHETRADITIONALNOTION
CLINGTOOUTDATEDMODELSTHATREFLECTADIFFERENT
OFFORMALINDIVIDUALSUPERVISION ANDTOWIDEN
ERAOFPRACTICE 7HENREVIEWSORRESEARCH
ANDSUPPLEMENTSUPERVISIONWITHDIFFERENT
EXPOSEGAPSINSUPERVISIONPRACTICESWHYDOWE
APPROACHESANDRESOURCESTOENHANCETHEQUALITY
NECESSARILYASSUMETHATINDIVIDUAL SYSTEMICOR
OFOURPRACTICE
ORGANISATIONALISSUESAREATFAULT RATHERTHANTHE MODELOFSUPERVISIONITSELF
3UPERVISIONHASLONGBEENIDENTIFIEDASAKEY COMPONENTTOSAFEPRACTICEBOTHINTHECARE
4HISARTICLEFIRSTCONSIDERSTHELITERATURE
ANDPROTECTIONANDYOUTHOFFENDINGDOMAINS
PERTAININGTOSUPERVISIONPRACTICE ANDTHEN
(OWEVER SOCIALWORKINTHESTATUTORYSETTING
GOESONTODESCRIBETHEINTRODUCTIONOFTHE
CANBEFRAUGHTWITHCONSTANTCHANGEAND
GROUPCONSULTSUPERVISIONMODELINTOFRONTLINE
ANXIETYFORBOTHPRACTITIONERSANDMANAGERS
CHILDWELFAREPRACTICEIN!OTEAROA.EW:EALAND
4HECOMPETINGDEMANDSOFCASEWORKCOMPLEXITY
GROUPCONSULTISBASEDONTHE3IGNSOF3AFETY
FISCALRESTRAINT WORKLOADISSUESANDSHIFTING
APPROACH4URNELL%DWARDS ANDTHE
IDEOLOGIESCANPRESENTCHALLENGESTOPRACTICE
REFINEDMODELBASEDONTHISWORKDEVELOPEDBY
)TISATTHISINTERFACETHATSUPERVISORSFIND
,OHRBACHAND3AWYER )WILLARGUETHAT
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
CONTEMPORARYCHILDANDFAMILYWELFAREPRACTICE
!DOPTINGAMORESYSTEMICAPPROACH WRITERS
REQUIRESNEWWAYSOFRESPONDINGTOSUPERVISION
HAVEARGUEDTHEIMPORTANCEOFWORKER
WITHINCAREANDPROTECTIONANDYOUTHJUSTICE
TEAM AGENCYANDORGANISATIONALSYSTEMSIN
CONTEXTS#OMPLEMENTINGINDIVIDUALMODELSOF
THEPROVISIONOFQUALITYSUPERVISION"ROWN
SUPERVISIONPRACTICEWITHACASECONSULTATION
"OURNE -ORRISON (UGHES
GROUPSUPERVISIONMODELPROVIDESTHEPOTENTIAL
0ENGELLY INCLUDINGTHESIGNIFICANCEOF
FORUSTORETHINKSUPERVISIONANDCREATEENGAGING
THESOCIALWORKSETTING /¤$ONOGHUE -UNFORD
SUPERVISIONPRACTICESTHATRESPONDTOTHE
4RLIN -ORRISON ASSERTSTHAT
DEMANDSOFSTATUTORYSOCIALWORK
SUPERVISIONISTHEKEYSTRATEGYTOCONTAINTHE ANXIETYOFWORKERSANDMINIMISE£0ROFESSIONAL
"EFOREDESCRIBINGTHEGROUPSUPERVISIONMODEL
!CCOMMODATION3YNDROME¤ STRESSINGTHENEED
INDETAIL )WILLBRIEFLYDISCUSSKEYMESSAGES
TOGROWAHEALTHYORGANISATIONALENVIRONMENT
FROMTHELITERATURERELATINGTOSUPERVISIONAND
TOWARDSAVISIONOFAN£EMOTIONALLYCOMPETENT
ARGUETHECASEFORTHINKINGABOUTSUPERVISION
ORGANISATION¤(UGHESAND0ENGELLY ARGUE
DIFFERENTLYINTHESTATUTORYCONTEXT
ALONGSIMILARLINESTHATTHETURBULENCEAND CONTRADICTIONSOFSTRUCTUREANDIDEOLOGYPUT
+EYMESSAGESFROMTHELITERATURE
ENORMOUSPRESSUREONTHECAPACITYTOPROVIDE
4RADITIONALLY SUPERVISIONHASBEENSEENAS
CONTAINMENTINSUPERVISION4HEYSTATETHAT
INDIVIDUALSUPERVISIONFORMAL PREARRANGED
¡AMIDINCESSANTCHANGE TEAMSOFPRACTITIONERS INEACHORGANISATION WITH
ANDCONTRACTEDBYBOTH PARTIESSUPERVISEEAND SUPERVISOR $ISCOURSESABOUT SUPERVISIONOFTENBEGIN WITHREFERENCETO+ADUSHIN WHOIDENTIFIEDTHREE FUNCTIONSOFSUPERVISIONTHE ADMINISTRATIVETHEEDUCATIVE
5SBEJUJPOBMMZ TVQFSWJTJPO IBTCFFOTFFOBTJOEJWJEVBM TVQFSWJTJPO GPSNBM QSFBSSBOHFEBOEDPOUSBDUFE CZCPUIQBSUJFT TVQFSWJTFF BOETVQFSWJTPS
MANAGERSWHOAREUSUALLY THEIRSUPERVISORS STRUGGLETO DELIVERASERVICE¢ P 4HEISSUEOFAUTHORITYIN SUPERVISIONHASALSOBEEN EXPLOREDEXTENSIVELYIN THELITERATURE RAISINGTHE
ANDTHESUPPORTIVE4HESE
CONTENTIOUSNOTIONOFPOWER
FUNCTIONSHIGHLIGHTTHEEXPECTATIONSOFALL
ANDCONTROL-ANYAUTHORSHAVEGRAPPLEDWITH
PARTIESSUPERVISEE SUPERVISORANDORGANISATION
THISTENSION"ROWN"OURNE (AWKINS
REGARDINGTHESUPERVISIONPROCESS%SSENTIALLY
3HOHET +ADUSHIN -ORRISON
THISISAMIXTUREOFACCOUNTABILITY PROFESSIONAL
PARTICULARLYWHENTHEFUNCTIONSOF
DEVELOPMENTANDSUPPORT+ADUSHIN¤SCONCERN
ACCOUNTABILITYANDPROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENTARE
WASTHATANYINCREASEDEMPHASISONTHE
INVESTEDINONEHIERARCHICALSUPERVISOR5NSAFE
MANAGERIALASPECTSOFSOCIALWORKSUPERVISION
PRACTICECANRESULTFROMEITHERTHEOVERUSEOF
WOULDBEATTHEEXPENSEOFTHEPROFESSIONAL
POWERORALTERNATIVELY THEFAILURETOEXERCISE
ASPECTS3UPERVISIONASAMIRRORPARALLEL
APPROPRIATEAUTHORITY"ROWN"OURNE
PROCESS OFTHECASEWORKPROCESSHASALSO
(AWKINS3HOHET -ORRISON
BEENHIGHLIGHTEDBY+ADUSHINANDOTHERSSEE
"ROWNAND"OURNEHAVEALSOEXTENDEDTHISIN
#LARKSON +ADUSHIN¤SWORKHASCONTINUED
THECONTEXTOFANTI DISCRIMINATORYPRACTICEIN
TOBEINFLUENTIALWITHRESPECTTOTHEDEVELOPMENT
SUPERVISIONANDPROFESSIONALCARE PARTICULARLY
ANDPRACTICEOFSOCIALWORKSUPERVISION
ASTHEYRELATETOPRACTITIONERBURN OUT4HE
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
EMOTIONALIMPACTOFSTATUTORYPRACTICEINCARE
)NAREVIEWOFTHELITERATURE ITISCLEARTHATMANY
ANDPROTECTIONANDYOUTHJUSTICEWORKCANBE
OFOURIDEASSUPPORTINGSUPERVISIONPRACTICE
CONSIDERABLE4HEDYNAMICSINVOLVEDINWORKING
HAVEBEENDRAWNFROMKEYWRITINGSOFTHES
WITHABUSE NEGLECTANDYOUTHOFFENDINGCAN
ANDS0ERHAPSNOTSURPRISINGLY THESEWERE
BECOMPLEXANDDISTURBINGPARTICULARLYWHEN
INFLUENCEDBYBROADERSOCIALSERVICELITERATUREIN
WORKERSARECONSTANTLYDEALINGWITHTHESEVERE
WHICHNOTIONSSUCHAS£THERAPY¤ £COUNSELLING¤
ENDOFTHEPRACTICESPECTRUM
£SELF ACTUALISATION¤AND£SELF AWARENESS¤WERE PREDOMINANT)NMANYRESPECTS RECENTLITERATURE
$OUGLAS P RELATESSUPERVISIONTO
HASTENDEDTOREWORKEXISTINGIDEASANDUPDATE
THECAREANDPROTECTIONCONTEXTBYSTATING
EARLIERCONCEPTS THEORIESANDMODELSSEEFOR
¡A UTHORITY RESPONSIBILITYANDSUPPORTNEED
EXAMPLE3HOHET !TTHESAMETIMETHERE
TOBEWITHTHESAMEMANAGINGSUPERVISORIN
ARENUMEROUSDESCRIPTIONSOFTHECURRENTISSUES
THESAMEWAYTHATFRONTLINEWORKERSHAVETO
ANDCHALLENGESTHATCONFRONTPRACTITIONERS
INTEGRATEBOTHACAREANDCONTROLFUNCTION
INTHETURBULENTWORLDOFPRACTICETHATDRAW
INTHEIRPRACTICE¢4HISNOTIONHASAPARALLEL
ATTENTIONTOTHESAFETYANDSELF CAREASPECTSOF
INYOUTHJUSTICEPRACTICE ASTHEREISFREQUENT
THESUPERVISIONPROCESS7HILETHESEMESSAGES
TENSIONBETWEENTHEIDEAS OFADDRESSINGBOTHTHE ACCOUNTABILITYANDWELLBEING ISSUESFORTHEYOUNGPERSON 4HISFUNDAMENTALTENSION BETWEENTWORESPONSIBILITIES ISNOTINTRACTABLE)TSIMPLY
AREBOTHIMPORTANTAND
3FUIJOLJOHUIFOPUJPO PGTVQFSWJTJPOPGGFSTBO PQQPSUVOJUZUPCSPBEFOBOE EFFQFOPVSBQQSPBDIBOE UPJOGMVFODFGVUVSFQSBDUJDF
MEANSTHATTHEISSUEIS
ESSENTIALINCONSTRUCTINGOUR UNDERSTANDINGOFSUPERVISION ANDOURUNDERSTANDINGOF THEHISTORY NATUREANDTHE CURRENTPARADIGMSAROUND SUPERVISIONPRACTICEAND CULTURE THEYNEVERTHELESS
COMPLEXANDREQUIRES
REFLECTAPREVIOUSERATHAT)WOULDARGUE
ADEQUATETHOUGHTTOHOWTHEPOSITIONSCANBE
STRUGGLESTORESPONDTOCONTEMPORARYISSUESIN
RECONCILEDORINTEGRATED
CHILDWELFARE
.OTIONSOFCULTURALLYAPPROPRIATESUPERVISION
2ETHINKINGTHENOTIONOFSUPERVISIONOFFERS
"RADLEY *ACON"RADLEY ANDSTRENGTHS
ANOPPORTUNITYTOBROADENANDDEEPENOUR
BASEDMODELSOFPRACTICE#OHEN HAVE
APPROACHANDTOINFLUENCEFUTUREPRACTICE
BEENINCREASINGLYINFLUENTIALINRECENTYEARS
%XPLORINGALTERNATIVEWAYSOFDELIVERING
0ARTICULARLYRELEVANTTOPRACTICEIN!OTEAROAHAS
SUPERVISIONENSURESTHATWEARENOTLIMITED
BEENACALLLARGELYBORNEOUTOFFRUSTRATION
TONARROWLYPRESCRIBED TRADITIONALVIEWSOF
WITHTHEONGOINGCOLONISATIONOFSOCIALWORK
SUPERVISIONTHATHAVETHEPOTENTIALTOIMPOSE
SUPERVISIONBYTRADITIONAL%UROPEANAND
INFLEXIBILITYONTHESUPERVISIONSYSTEM7HILST
!MERICANMODELSFORDEVELOPMENTOFTANGATA
FORMALINDIVIDUALSUPERVISIONISAPPROPRIATE
WHENUAMODELSOFSOCIALWORKSUPERVISION
INTHECONTEXTOFSTAFFPERFORMANCEISSUESAND
"RADLEYANDHISCOLLEAGUES P COMMENT
AREASOFPERSONALSENSITIVITY RELYINGENTIRELYON
THAT¡-iORIPERSPECTIVESWITHINNON -iORI
INDIVIDUALSUPERVISIONSUPPORTSTHENOTIONTHAT
SETTINGSCONTINUETOBECONSIDEREDASAN
ONEPERSONIETHESUPERVISOR ISABLETOPROVIDE
ETHNICORINDIGENOUSCULTURALADD ONTOTHE
FORALLPRACTICENEEDSINALLCIRCUMSTANCES
PREDOMINANTNON -iORIDISCOURSE¢
!LTERNATIVELY WEMAYBENEFITFROMTHERICHNESS
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
OFOTHERPERSPECTIVESANDWAYSTOSHARE
ASIGNIFICANTFEATUREOFTHISMODELISTHATITWAS
KNOWLEDGEANDEXPERIENCEINATEAMORGROUP
DESIGNEDTOBEUSEDANDSHAREDWITHTHEFAMILY
SETTING)NTHEGROUPSUPERVISIONCONTEXTWECAN
4HEGROUPCONSULTPROCESSCANALSOBEUSED
BECHALLENGEDANDSUPPORTEDBYOTHERSINWAYS
EFFECTIVELYINYOUTHJUSTICEWORK(AVINGAN
THATCANASSISTOURGROWTHANDDEVELOPMENTAS
UNDERSTANDINGOFTHENATUREOFACHILDOR
PRACTITIONERS
YOUNGPERSON¤SOFFENDINGANDANANALYSISOFTHE
!DOPTINGTHEGROUPCONSULTMODELOFSUPERVISION
FACTORSCONTRIBUTINGTOTHEIROFFENDINGENABLES
ANDADDINGTHISTOOUREXISTINGSUPERVISION
INTERVENTIONTHATISFOCUSEDONENHANCING
CULTURESEEMSANIDEALWAYTORECONCILETHE
THEYOUNGPERSON¤SWELLBEINGANDREDUCING
CHALLENGESANDDEMANDSOFSTATUTORYPRACTICE
REOFFENDING)NFORMATIONFROMANYSCREENSOR ASSESSMENTSTHATHAVEBEENUNDERTAKENFOR
)NTRODUCINGTHEGROUPCONSULTINTO .EW:EALANDCHILDWELFAREPRACTICE
EXAMPLE WELLBEINGASSESSMENTS HEALTHAND
4HETRIED AND TRUE£ACTION REFLECTION¤PROCESS
FUTUREACTION4HISMAYALSOINCLUDEANYCARE
FACILITATEDBYSUPERVISORSINBOTHINDIVIDUAL
ANDPROTECTIONASSESSMENTS/URYOUTHJUSTICE
ANDGROUPSUPERVISIONSESSIONSMODELS
PRACTICEISSTRENGTHENEDWHENWECONSIDERAND
EDUCATIONASSESSMENTS ISSTRUCTUREDTOINFORM
DISCUSSTHEWIDERCONTEXT
TRANSPARENTPRACTICEAND BUILDSPROFESSIONALCAPABILITY INTHEWORKERSINVOLVED 4HEGROUPCONSULTPROCESS WHICHISAVARIATIONOFAN ACTION REFLECTIONAPPROACH ISCURRENTLYBEINGINTRODUCED INTOSITESASAPROACTIVEWAY OFDEVELOPINGSUPERVISOR
*OUIFHSPVQTVQFSWJTJPO TFUUJOH XPSLFSTBSFBCMF UPEJTDVTTBOEEFCBUF JTTVFTBOEUIVTDPOUSJCVUF UIFJSLOPXMFEHF TLJMMTBOE FYQFSJFODFUPUIFDBTF EJTDVTTJPO
CAPABILITYANDIMPROVING
IMPACTINGONTHEYOUNG PERSON 7HILETHISAPPROACHPROVIDES MULTIPLEOPPORTUNITIES FORCASECONSULTATIONFOR EXAMPLE ITCANBEUSEDIN INDIVIDUALSUPERVISIONORIN CO WORKINGSITUATIONS ITS REALPOTENTIALISUNLEASHEDIN
PRACTICE
ATEAMORGROUPSETTING)N
4HEGROUPCONSULTPROCESSISADAPTEDFROM THE
THEGROUPSUPERVISIONSETTING WORKERSAREABLE
3IGNSOF3AFETYAPPROACH4URNELL%DWARDS
TODISCUSSANDDEBATEISSUESANDTHUSCONTRIBUTE
ANDTHEREFINEDMODELBASEDONTHISWORK
THEIRKNOWLEDGE SKILLSANDEXPERIENCETOTHE
BY,OHRBACHAND3AWYER INTHECONTEXT
CASEDISCUSSION4HEGROUP LEDBYAPRACTICE
OFCAREANDPROTECTIONWORK4HEAPPROACH
LEADERORSUPERVISOR HELPSTOSTRUCTURETHECASE
FOCUSESONSTRENGTHSANDPROTECTIVEFACTORS
INFORMATIONANDPLACEITAPPROPRIATELYINTHE
ENABLINGBOTHTHEFAMILYANDPRACTITIONERTO
VARIOUSDOMAINSONTHECONSULTFORM4HEGROUP
USETHESETOINCREASETHESAFETYOFTHECHILDOR
SETTINGENRICHESDECISION MAKINGBYPROVIDING
YOUNGPERSON)TEMPHASISESTHENEEDTOBUILD
COLLECTIVEEXPERTISEANDAPPROPRIATECHALLENGE
SAFETYFROMTHEPROTECTIVEFACTORS WITHTHE
4HEORGANISATIONOFTHEMATERIALONTOTHE#HILD
FAMILYACTIVELYENGAGINGINTHEPROCESS$ANGER
AND&AMILYOR9OUTHAND&AMILYCONSULTFORMS
ANDHARMFACTORSAREALSOELICITEDTOUNDERSTAND
LEADSTOEASEINANALYSINGTHERESPECTIVEISSUES
THERISKSTOTHECHILDREN¤SSAFETY2ATHERTHAN
ANDPROPELSTHEDISCUSSIONTOWARDNEXTSTEPSAND
BEINGDEVELOPEDPURELYASATOOLFORTHEWORKER
SOLUTIONS
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
!DAPTINGTHEAPPROACHTOTHE .EW:EALANDCONTEXT
/LMSTEAD#OUNTYIN-INNESOTA 53! HASBEEN USINGTHISPROCESSFORMANYYEARS ANDINMANY RESPECTSHASBECOMETHE£PRACTICELABORATORY¤IN
$RAWINGONTHEWORKOF4URNELL AND
THEUSEOFTHESUPERVISIONCONSULTTOOL,OHRBACH
,OHRBACHAND3AWYER WEHAVEADOPTED
DESCRIBESTHEIRPRACTICEANDTHEWAYSINWHICH
THEFOUNDATIONALELEMENTSFROMTHE3IGNSOF
THEMODELUNFOLDSWITHINTHEIRSYSTEMSEEPAGE
3AFETYAPPROACH4HE.EW:EALANDGROUPCONSULT
INTHISISSUE )MPORTANTLY SHEARGUESTHAT
TEMPLATEFIGURE MIRRORSTHEORIGINALINITS
THESIGNIFICANTPRACTICEIMPROVEMENTSTHEYHAVE
COREEMPHASISONTHEDANGERHARMANDSAFETY
REALISEDOVERTHEPASTDECADECANBEATTRIBUTED
CONTINUUM(OWEVER ITDIFFERSSLIGHTLYFROM
TOTHEADOPTIONOFTHEGROUPCONSULTAPPROACH
THEORIGINALBYEXPLICITLYLINKINGITTOTHE.EW :EALANDPRACTICEFRAMEWORKS#ONNOLLY
&URTHERSTRENGTHENINGTHEMODELIS4URNELL¤S
ANDTHEIRPRACTICETRIGGERS TOENSURETHATTHE
NOTIONOF£SAFETYORGANISEDPRACTICE¤"UILT
FRAMEWORKSCONTINUETOGUIDEOURWORKWITH
UPONHISORIGINALCONCEPTOFTHE3IGNSOF3AFETY
CHILDREN YOUNGPEOPLEANDFAMILIES
APPROACH4URNELL%DWARDS 4URNELL ADVOCATESSTRONGLYFORTHECENTRALPRACTICE
4HE.EW:EALANDPROCESSINCAREANDPROTECTION
FOCUSTOBEONTHESAFETYANDWELLBEINGOFTHE
ANDYOUTHJUSTICEWORK FOCUSESONTHE
CHILDRENCOUPLEDWITHRIGOROUSSAFETYPLANNING
DEVELOPMENTOFTHERISKSTATEMENT HELPING
4URNELL%SSEX "OTHTHEORIGINAL3IGNS
WORKERSTOCRYSTALLISEWHATTHEYAREWORRIED
OF3AFETYMODELAND4URNELL¤SRECENTWORK
ABOUT INLANGUAGETHATFAMILIESCANUNDERSTAND
RELATINGTOSAFETYORGANISEDPRACTICEHAVEBEEN
4AKINGTHETIMEINTHEEARLYPHASEOFLEARNING
INFLUENTIALINTHEDEVELOPMENTOF.EW:EALAND¤S
ANDWORKINGWITHTHEAPPROACH TOGETRISK
ADAPTATIONOFTHEGROUPCONSULTMODELINTO
STATEMENTSACCURATEANDCONCISE ISWORTH
STATUTORYCHILDWELFAREPRACTICE
THELONG TERMINVESTMENT)THELPSWORKERS
&IGURE
#HILDAND&AMILY#ONSULT /BNF
1IBTFPGXPSL
&UIOJDJUZ
(FOPHSBN&DPNBQDPNQMFUFE
"HF %BOHFS)BSN
(SFZ"SFBT
4BGFUZ
-JLFMJIPPEPGNBMUSFBUNFOU QBTUQSFTFOUGVUVSF
%FTDSJCFTUSFOHUITEFNPOTUSBUFEPWFSUJNF 1BUUFSOIJTUPSZPGFYDFQUJPOT
3JTL4UBUFNFOUT
/FFET
4USFOHUIT1SPUFDUJWFGBDUPST
%FTDSJCFBOZIFBMUIBOEFEVDBUJPOOFFETPGUIF DIJMEZPVOHQFSTPO $POTJEFSUIFOFFETPGUIFVOEFS¥T
$PNQMJDBUJOHGBDUPST
/FYU4UFQT JNNFEJBUFQSPHSFTT
3FMFWBOUQSBDUJDFUSJHHFST
1VSQPTFPG$POTVMU
4BGFUZQSPUFDUJPO SFRVJSFE
&OPVHITBGFUZ UPDMPTF
1BSUOFSJOH"DUJPOXJUIGBNJMZJOUIFJSQPTJUJPO8JMMJOHOFTT DPOGJEFODFBOEDBQBDJUZUPDIBOHF 5IJTDPOTVMUBUJPOUPPMXBTBEBQUFEGSPN0MNTUFE$PVOUZ$IJMEBOE'BNJMZ4FSWJDFT .JOOFTPUBBOEUIF4JHOTPG4BGFUZ"TTFTTNFOUBOE1MBOOJOH'SBNFXPSL
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
&IGURE
9OUNG0ERSONAND&AMILY#ONSULT /BNF
1IBTFPGXPSL
&UIOJDJUZ
(FOPHSBN&DPNBQDPNQMFUFE
"HF %BOHFS)BSN
(SFZ"SFBT
4BGFUZ
%FTDSJCFUIFQPUFOUJBMIBSNUPUIFZPVOHQFSTPO
%FTDSJCFTUSFOHUITEFNPOTUSBUFEPWFSUJNF 1BUUFSOIJTUPSZPGFYDFQUJPOT
3JTL4UBUFNFOUT
/FFET
4USFOHUIT1SPUFDUJWFGBDUPST
%FTDSJCFBOZIFBMUIBOEFEVDBUJPOOFFETPGUIF ZPVOHQFSTPO
$PNQMJDBUJOHGBDUPST
4BGFUZXFMMCFJOH SFRVJSFE
$IBOHFJOCFIBWJPVS SFRVJSFE
/FYU4UFQT JNNFEJBUFQSPHSFTT
3FMFWBOUQSBDUJDFUSJHHFST
1VSQPTFPG$POTVMU
4BGFUZXFMMCFJOH BEESFTTFE
$IBOHFJOCFIBWJPVS BDIJFWFE
1BSUOFSJOH"DUJPOXJUIGBNJMZJOUIFJSQPTJUJPO8JMMJOHOFTT DPOGJEFODFBOEDBQBDJUZUPDIBOHF 5IJTDPOTVMUBUJPOUPPMXBTBEBQUFEGSPN0MNTUFE$PVOUZ$IJMEBOE'BNJMZ4FSWJDFT .JOOFTPUBBOEUIF4JHOTPG4BGFUZ"TTFTTNFOUBOE1MBOOJOH'SBNFXPSL
TOSIGNIFICANTLYSHARPENTHEIRASSESSMENTAND
ALLPRACTICESITUATIONSTHEREFOREMAKESITAVERY
ANALYTICALSKILLS ANDTOCLARIFYTHEIRROLEINTHE
VALUABLEANDFLEXIBLETOOL
FAMILY¤SLIFE)FWECANNOTCLEARLYARTICULATETHE
4HEGROUPCONSULTSUPERVISIONMODELISBEING
CONCERNSWEHAVEABOUTTHECHILDORYOUNG
USEDINSITESACROSSTHECOUNTRYANDHASNOW
PERSONTOTHEPARENTSORCAREGIVERS THEYWILLBE
BEENINTRODUCEDINTOPRACTICEFOUNDATION
HARDPLACEDTOWORKWITHUSTOADDRESSSAFETY
MODULESFORALLNEW#HILD 9OUTHAND&AMILY
ANDWELLBEING4HISTRANSPARENCYOFPRACTICE
STAFF)TISALSOBEINGINCLUDEDINTHEPROFESSIONAL
OPENSTHEDOORTOBETTERENGAGEMENTAND
SUPERVISIONCOURSETRAININGFOR#HILD 9OUTH
PARTICIPATIONFROMFAMILIESBOTHADULTSAND
AND&AMILYSUPERVISORS#HILD 9OUTHAND&AMILY
CHILDREN4HERISKSTATEMENTCANTHENBECHECKED
STAFFHAVERESPONDEDENTHUSIASTICALLYTOTHE
ANDREVISEDONCEALLTHEINFORMATIONISGATHERED
INTRODUCTIONOFTHEGROUPCONSULTSUPERVISION
STRUCTUREDANDANALYSEDTOENSUREITSCLARITYAND
MODEL ANDFEEDBACKFROMWORKERSCURRENTLY
RELEVANCE
USINGTHETOOLISPOSITIVE
!SSTATEDEARLIER THEGROUPCONSULTPROCESSCAN
;4HECONSULT=HELPSCOMPILEINFORMATIONAND
BESUCCESSFULLYUSEDINBOTHCAREANDPROTECTION
GIVESFOCUS;SOCIALWORKER=
ANDYOUTHJUSTICECASESFIGUREPROVIDESTHE
)TISEASYTOUSEITMAKESSENSEIT¥SLOGICAL
ADAPTEDYOUTHJUSTICEGROUPCONSULTTEMPLATE
IT¥SALLUPTHEREITISAGOODPROCESS
4HECONSULTFORMANDGROUPCONSULTPROCESSCAN
REINFORCESWHATYOUTHINKYOUSHOULDDOOR
ALSOBEUSEDINPERMANENCYANDADOPTIONWORK
GIVESYOUNEWDIRECTIONAWESOMEDIRECTION
INTHERESIDENCESANDINASSESSINGCAREGIVERSIN
;SOCIALWORKER=
FACT ANYPRACTICECIRCUMSTANCEWHEREPRACTICE PATHWAYSAREDETERMINEDANDWHEREDECISION
4HECONSULTBALANCESRISKSANDSTRENGTHS
MAKINGNEEDSSTRENGTHENING)TSRELEVANCETO
ITBREAKSITDOWNANDTHEPROBLEMSARE
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
SEPARATEDFROMSTRENGTHSITKEEPSUSINTHE
PROBLEMATICIFTHEYARENOTADDRESSED&OR
PRESENTANDHELPSUSDECIDEONNEXTSTEPS
EXAMPLE THESILENTONEWHOMAYLEAVETHE
)THASMADEADIFFERENCEINOURDECISION
SESSIONNOTOWNINGTHEOUTCOMES ORTHEDEVIL¤S
MAKING;SOCIALWORKER=
ADVOCATEWHOMAYNOTATTENDSOMESESSIONSAND NO ONEASKSTHECHALLENGINGQUESTIONSINHISHER
4HESTAFFARECOMFORTABLEWITHTHEPROCESS
ABSENCE3KILLEDFACILITATIONWILLADDRESSTHESE
ANDTHEYENJOYTHEM;THECONSULT=ISGOOD
DYNAMICSBYIDENTIFYINGANDNAMINGTHEMIFTHEY
FORSHARINGINFORMATIONIT¥SENLIGHTENING
AREIMPACTINGONTHESITUATION"UTITISALSOTHE
ANDOFFERSANEWPERSPECTIVE;PRACTICE
RESPONSIBILITYOFEACHGROUPMEMBERTOBEAWARE
LEADER=
OFTHEIROWNBEHAVIOURINTHEGROUPANDTO
)TISTHECALM DOWNTOOL;PRACTICELEADER=
MODERATEORCORRECTTHIS £'ROUPTHINK¤ISTHENOTIONOFPEOPLEAGREEING
)SSUESINGROUPFACILITATION
WITHAPOSITIONTOFALLINWITHTHERESTOFTHE
4HEGROUPCONSULTMODELREQUIRESSKILLED
GROUP EVENTHOUGHTHEYMAYNOTHAVEACTUALLY
FACILITATION'ROUPDYNAMICSDONEEDTOBE
CHANGEDTHEIRVIEWPOINT4HEYBECOMEUNABLEOR
CONSIDEREDTOENSURETHEYDONOTHINDERTHE
UNWILLINGTOEXPRESSADIFFERINGORCONTRARYVIEW
GROUPCONSULTPROCESS IN PARTICULAR THEPOTENTIALFOR GROUPPOLARISATION UNHELPFUL £ROLES¤INGROUPSAND£GROUP
FORFEAROFWHATOTHERSMAY
5IFHSPVQDPOTVMUNPEFM SFRVJSFTTLJMMFEGBDJMJUBUJPO
THINK¤'ROUPPOLARISATION
THINKABOUTTHEIRPRACTICE 4HEYMAYNOTFEELCONFIDENT INTHEIROPINIONIETHEY DEFERTOTHEVIEWSOFOTHERS
OCCURSWHENPEOPLETAKE
PARTICULARLYSUPERIORS THINKTHEYWILLNOTBE
OPPOSINGPOSITIONSANDARGUETOCONVINCEOTHERS
HEARD ORDONOTCONSIDERTHEIRINPUTIMPORTANT
OFTHEIRVIEWSRATHERTHANSTAYINGFOCUSEDON THESOLUTIONSTHATWILLWORKFORCHILDREN YOUNG
/FCOURSETHESEDYNAMICSARENOTSOLELYTHE
PEOPLEANDTHEIRFAMILIES4HISCANLEADTOA
PURVIEWOFGROUPSUPERVISIONMODELS)NDEED
REFUSALTOACKNOWLEDGEOTHERPERSPECTIVESANDOR
THEYCANALSOFINDTHEIRWAYINTOANYINTERACTIVE
FORTHEGROUPTOGET£STUCK¤INTHECONFLICT
PROCESSBETWEENHUMANBEINGS4HATSAID GROUP FACILITATIONDOESHAVEAPARTICULARSTYLEANDIT
4HEROLESPEOPLEPLAYINGROUPSISALSOAN
CANBEMOSTHELPFULFORSUPERVISORSTOACCESS
IMPORTANTREFERENCEPOINTTHATCANREQUIRE
ADDITIONALTRAININGANDONGOINGFEEDBACKAND
MANAGEMENTINTHEGROUPPROCESS3OMEPEOPLE
MENTORINGTOENSURETHATTHEYCANGETTHEMOST
TAKETHESAMEROLEINEACHGROUPSITUATION
OUTOFTHEGROUPCONSULTSUPERVISIONMODEL
WHICHCANTYPECASTTHEMINTOEXTREMESSUCH AS£DEVIL¤SADVOCATE¤WHOALWAYSASKSTHEHARD
#ONCLUSION
QUESTIONS THEQUIETPERSONWHORARELYSPEAKS THE£BULLY¤WHOALWAYSWANTSTOWINTHEDEBATE
4HEPRIMARYOBJECTIVEOFSUPERVISIONISTOENSURE
THECONTROLLERWHOLIKESTOBEINCHARGEOF
SAFEPRACTICEWITHCHILDREN YOUNGPEOPLEAND
EVERYTHING THE£TALKER¤WHOMONOPOLISESTHE
THEIRFAMILIES BUTITISALSOAKEYMECHANISMTO
CONVERSATION ANDTHE£PACIFIER¤WHOALWAYS
PROMOTEBOTHSTAFFDEVELOPMENTANDPRACTICE
WANTSTOSMOOTHOVERCONFLICTANDENSURE
CAPABILITY4HEINVESTMENTTHATANORGANISATION
EVERYONEISFEELINGSAFE4HESEROLESARETOBE
MAKESINTHESUPERVISIONANDDEVELOPMENTOF
EXPECTEDINTHEGROUPPROCESSBUTCANBECOME
ITSSTAFFWILLINVARIABLYIMPACTPOSITIVELYONTHE
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
$OUGLAS ! .OTHINGTOLOSE#OMMUNITY#ARE
QUALITYOFPRACTICEANDTHEOUTCOMESACHIEVED FORCHILDREN YOUNGPEOPLEANDTHEIRFAMILIES
(AWKINS 0 3HOHET 2 3UPERVISIONINTHE HELPINGPROFESSIONS"UCKINGHAM/PEN5NIVERSITY 0RESS
4HEEXPERIENCEOFUSINGTHEGROUPCONSULT MODELINSUPERVISIONQUICKLYBUILDSCAPACITY
(UGHES , 0ENGELLY 0 3TAFFSUPERVISION INATURBULENTENVIRONMENT-ANAGINGPROCESSAND TASKINFRONT LINESERVICES,ONDON*ESSICA+INGSLEY 0UBLISHERS
BYMAXIMISINGTHECOLLECTIVESTRENGTHSOF AWIDERGROUPOFSTAFF!NALYTICALTHINKING ISSHARPENEDTHROUGHTHEPROCESSOFCASE DISCUSSIONANDPRACTICEFOCUSESONSOLUTIONS
+ADUSHIN ! 3UPERVISIONINSOCIALWORK 4HIRD %DITION.EW9ORK5NIVERSITYOF#OLOMBIA0RESS
)NSIGHTSFROMONEPRACTICEEXPERIENCEAREREADILY TRANSFERREDTOOTHERPRACTICESCENARIOS3OCIAL
,OHRBACH 3 3AWYER 2 #REATINGA CONSTRUCTIVEPRACTICE&AMILYANDPROFESSIONAL PARTNERSHIPINHIGH RISKCHILDPROTECTIONCASE CONFERENCES0ROTECTING#HILDREN
WORKERS SUPERVISORSANDPRACTICELEADERSHAVE ACTIVELYENGAGEDWITHTHEPROCESSANDTHERE AREINDICATIONSTHATTHEYARECOMMITTEDTO
-ORRISON 4 0ARTNERSHIPANDCOLLABORATION 2HETORICANDREALITY#HILD!BUSEAND.EGLECT
DEVELOPINGTHEIRGROUPSUPERVISIONSKILLAND EXPERTISE
-ORRISON 4 3TAFFSUPERVISIONINSOCIALCARE "RIGHTON 5+0AVILION
3TRENGTHENINGSUPERVISIONISAKEYIMPERATIVE WITHINANYCHILDWELFARESYSTEM$EVELOPINGAND
/¤$ONOGHUE + -UNFORD 2 4RLIN ! 7HAT¤SBESTABOUTSOCIALWORKSUPERVISIONACCORDING TO!SSOCIATIONMEMBERS3OCIAL7ORK2EVIEW 86)))
USINGMODELSTHATRESONATEWITHTHEEXPECTATIONS OFTHECONTEMPORARYENVIRONMENTHASTHE POTENTIALTOBOTHENHANCEPRACTICEANDSUPPORT GOODOUTCOMESFORCHILDREN YOUNGPEOPLEAND
3HOHET 2 0ASSIONATESUPERVISION,ONDON *ESSICA+INGSLEY0UBLISHERS
THEIRFAMILIES
4URNELL ! %DWARDS 3 3IGNSOF3AFETY !SOLUTIONANDSAFETYORIENTEDAPPROACHTOCHILD PROTECTION.EW9ORK.ORTON
2 % & % 2 % . # % 3 "RADLEY * *ACOB % "RADLEY 2 2EFLECTIONS ONCULTURALLYSAFESUPERVISION ORWHY"ILL'ATES MAKESMOREMONEYTHANWEDO3OCIAL7ORK2EVIEW 4E+OMAKO 8)
4URNELL !%SSEX 3 7ORKINGWITH£$ENIED¤ #HILD!BUSE-AIDENHEAD/PEN5NIVERSITY0RESS
"ROWN ! "OURNE ) 4HESOCIALWORK SUPERVISOR"UCKINGHAM/PEN5NIVERSITY0RESS #LARKSON 0 /NPSYCHOTHERAPY,ONDON 7HURR0UBLISHERS
*O&IELDISTHE-ANAGER0ROFESSIONAL0RACTICEINTHE -INISTRYOF3OCIAL$EVELOPMENT¥S/FFICEOFTHE#HIEF3OCIAL 7ORKER
#OHEN " )NTERVENTIONANDSUPERVISION INSTRENGTHS BASEDSOCIALWORKPRACTICE&AMILIES IN3OCIETY4HE*OURNALOF#ONTEMPORARY(UMAN 3ERVICES #ONNOLLY - 0RACTICEFRAMEWORKS #ONCEPTUALMAPSTHATGUIDEINTERVENTIONSINCHILD WELFARE"RITISH*OURNALOF3OCIAL7ORK #ONNOLLY - (EALY + 3OCIALWORKPRACTICE THEORIESANDFRAMEWORKS)N-#ONNOLLYAND, (ARMS%DS 3OCIAL7ORK#ONTEXTSANDPRACTICE 3ECOND%DITION#HAPTER-ELBOURNE/XFORD 5NIVERSITY0RESS
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
Group supervision in child protection practice 3UZANNE,OHRBACH )NTRODUCTION
+ADUSHIN HASDESCRIBEDTHEIMPORTANCE OFSUPERVISIONANDITSROLEINJOBSATISFACTION
3UPERVISIONISAKEYMECHANISMTHROUGHWHICH
ANDMORALEBUILDING!NAGENCYDEMONSTRATES
SOCIALWORKPRACTICEWITHCHILDREN YOUNG
ITSVALUEOFSUPERVISION SUPPORTANDCASE
PEOPLEANDTHEIRFAMILIES INTHECONTEXTOFCHILD
CONSULTATIONBYPROVIDINGCONSISTENTAND
PROTECTIONWORK CANBESTRENGTHENED/VER
SUBSTANTIALTIMEANDRESOURCESSEPARATEFROM
MANYYEARS SUPERVISIONPRACTICEINCHILDWELFARE
PROCEDURALOVERSIGHTOFCASES4HEPROCESS
SYSTEMSHASTENDEDTOFOLLOWATRADITIONAL
INCLUDESANOPPORTUNITYFORSHAREDEXPERIENCES
PATTERNOFINDIVIDUAL REGULARSUPERVISION
EMOTIONALSUPPORT SOLUTIONBUILDINGTOSAME
'ROUPSUPERVISION BASEDONAVARIATIONOF
ORSIMILARCHALLENGES PREVENTIONOFSTRESSAND
THEINDIVIDUALMODEL HAS BEENUSEDTOSUPPLEMENTTHIS APPROACH3HULMAN DESCRIBESSTAFFGROUPSASBEING MORESIGNIFICANTRESOURCES WHENEFFECTIVELEADERSHIP ISEMPLOYEDTOHELPSOCIAL WORKERSJOINTOGETHERTO SERVICETHEGROUP¤SPURPOSE 4HESUPERVISORASFACILITATOR PROVIDESSUCHLEADERSHIP
REDUCTIONOFTHEIMPACTOF
"OBHFODZEFNPOTUSBUFT JUTWBMVFPGTVQFSWJTJPO TVQQPSUBOEDBTF DPOTVMUBUJPOCZQSPWJEJOH DPOTJTUFOUBOETVCTUBOUJBM UJNFBOESFTPVSDFT TFQBSBUFGSPNQSPDFEVSBM PWFSTJHIUPGDBTFT
STRESSBYDIRECTDISCUSSIONS ANDREMEDIESPROVIDED FORSOCIALWORKERSAFETY +ADUSHIN¤S DESCRIPTION OFCULTUREINCLUDES OPPORTUNITIESFORSHARED RISKANDACCOUNTABILITYAND AIDSINTHEMOVEAWAYFROM INDIVIDUALSOCIALWORKER LIABILITY'ROUPSUPERVISION
ANDTHEUSEOFASPECIFIED
CANRAISEAWARENESSOF
FRAMEWORKFORSTRUCTURINGTHEPRIMARYFUNCTION
WORKLOADISSUESANDREMEDIESMAYBEMORE
OFCASECONSULTATIONBEGINSWITHASTATEMENTOF
EFFECTIVELY EFFICIENTLY ANDCREATIVELYCRAFTEDIN
FOCUSANDPURPOSE'ROUPSUPERVISIONPROVIDES
ANEFFORTTOREDUCESTRESSANDTENSION
THEOPPORTUNITYFORMUTUALAIDANDMUTUAL DEMANDFORWORK4HISAIDISEVIDENTWITHIN
"UILDINGCOMPETENCY PRACTICECONFIDENCE
THEDESCRIPTIONOFCULTUREWHEREINFORMATIONIS
ANDSOUNDCRITICALDECISION MAKINGISAKEY
SHARED DIFFERENTVIEWSAREDISCUSSED ANDSPACE
FUNCTIONOFSUPERVISION'ROUPSUPERVISION
ISAVAILABLEFORTHEDISCUSSIONANDEXPLORATIONOF
PARTICULARLYWHENITINVOLVESTHEUSEOFA
CONTROVERSIALTOPICS
SPECIFIEDFRAMEWORKFORORGANISINGANDANALYSING
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
INFORMATIONINCASECONSULTATION,OHRBACH
WHICHPRACTICEISDEVELOPEDANDSTRENGTHENED
3AWYER 4URNELL%DWARDS
4HISCASECONSULTMODELOFGROUPSUPERVISION
HASTHEPOTENTIALTOBUILDCOMPETENCYAND
HASBEENIMPLEMENTEDASTHEPREFERREDMETHOD
CONFIDENCEASPRACTITIONERSSHAREANDCRITIQUE
OFSUPERVISIONFORALLTEAMSIN/LMSTED#OUNTY
SOCIALWORKPATHWAYS DECISION MAKINGAND
-INNESOTA INCLUDINGINTAKESCREENING FAMILY
PRACTICERESPONSES+LEIN DESCRIBESHOW
ASSESSMENTINVESTIGATION ONGOINGFIELDSERVICE
PRACTITIONERSMOVEFROMNOVICETOADVANCED
TEAMS ANDALLEARLYINTERVENTIONANDRESOURCE
COMPETENCYINWORKENVIRONMENTSWHERETHERE
TEAMSWITHINTHECHILDPROTECTIONPRACTICE
ISTHEOPPORTUNITYTOLEARNFROMEXPERIENCE4HE
7HILSTTHECASECONSULTMODELPROVIDESTHE
DESCRIPTIONOFPROCESSANDTHEUSEOFASPECIFIED
PRIMARYMEANSOFSTRENGTHENINGPRACTICE
FRAMEWORKILLUSTRATESOCIALWORKERENGAGEMENT
INDIVIDUALSUPERVISIONREMAINSACCESSIBLE)T
INDELIBERATEANDPURPOSEFULPRACTICEWHERE
ISAVAILABLEFORSTAFFPERFORMANCEEVALUATION
GOALSAREEVIDENCEDANDCRITERIACANBE
SPECIFICREQUESTSREGARDINGSENSITIVEPERSONAL
DEVELOPEDFOREVALUATION!PRACTICECULTURE
ISSUES ANYNEEDFORCORRECTIVEACTION ANDUPON
DEVELOPSWHICHALLOWSFORHONESTDISCUSSIONAND
REQUESTINSITUATIONSREQUIRINGIMMEDIATEANDOR
OPEN MINDEDNESSREGARDINGINSIGHTSGAINEDAND
CRISISRESPONSE
LESSONSLEARNEDFROMPREVIOUS FAMILYCASEPRESENTATIONS -UNRO DESCRIBESTHE NECESSITYFORSOUNDCRITICAL THINKINGANDREASONINGSKILLS INDECISION MAKINGINCHILD PROTECTIONPRACTICEAND ASSERTSTHATITISTHEAGENCY¤S FUNDAMENTALRESPONSIBILITYTO PROVIDESUCHANENVIRONMENT #ASECONSULTATIONWITHINTHE
$BTFDPOTVMUBUJPOXJUIJO UIFDPOUFYUPGHSPVQ TVQFSWJTJPOQSPWJEFTB SFHVMBSBOEDPOTJTUFOU JNNFSTJPOJOUIJOLJOH UISPVHIUIFQSBDUJDF FYQFSJFODFTBOEUIF BQQMJDBUJPOPGSFTFBSDI GJOEJOHTUPFBDIDBTF
$ESCRIPTIONOFTHE /LMSTED#OUNTYPHYSICAL ENVIRONMENT 3OCIALWORKPRACTITIONERS AREMEMBERSOFPRIMARY TEAMSWHOSHARETHESAME ORSIMILARFUNCTIONS%ACH TEAMISORGANISEDINTOGROUP SUPERVISIONFORUMSCONSISTING OFEIGHTTOTENSOCIALWORKERS 4HEYMEETWEEKLYFORTWOTO
CONTEXTOFGROUPSUPERVISION
THREEHOURSATTENDANCEIS
PROVIDESAREGULARANDCONSISTENTIMMERSIONIN
EXPECTEDANDREQUIRED4HEGROUPSAREFACILITATED
THINKINGTHROUGHTHEPRACTICEEXPERIENCESAND
BYONEORTWOSUPERVISORS4HEMEETINGSPACE
THEAPPLICATIONOFRESEARCHFINDINGSTOEACH
INCLUDESCHAIRS ALARGEWHITEBOARDWITHTHE
CASE
CONSULTATIONTEMPLATEPERMANENTLYINSCRIBED
4HISARTICLEDESCRIBESAMODELOFGROUP
WHITEBOARDMARKERS ANERASER ANDPAPERSHEETS
SUPERVISIONWITHINTHECONTEXTOFCHILD
ALSOWITHTHECONSULTATIONFRAMEWORKTEMPLATE
PROTECTIONPRACTICE USINGASPECIFIEDFRAMEWORK
SEE,OHRBACH3AWYER FORTHETEMPLATE
FORORGANISINGANDANALYSINGINFORMATIONINCASE
USEDIN/LMSTED#OUNTYSEEALSOTHETEMPLATES
CONSULTATION,OHRBACH3AWYER 4URNELL
MODIFIEDFOR.EW:EALAND ONPAGEAND
%DWARDS 3HIFTINGFROMARELIANCEON
OFTHISISSUE 4HECHAIRSARECLUSTEREDAROUND
TRADITIONINDIVIDUALSUPERVISION ITEXTENDS
THEWHITEBOARD THEWHITEBOARDISUTILISEDINALL
THEGROUPSUPERVISIONMODELBYUSINGCASE
CASECONSULTATIONS ANDTHEPAPERSHEETSAREFOR
CONSULTATIONSASTHEPRIMARYMEANSTHROUGH
RECORDINGTHEWHITEBOARDINFORMATIONFORTHE
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
PRESENTINGSOCIALWORKERTOHAVEFORTHEIRCASE
FAMILYCASEUPDATEREQUEST INFORMATIONTOBE
RECORDANDFURTHERREVIEWWITHTHEFAMILYIF
SHAREDTHATISMOREIMMEDIATETHANCANWAITFOR
DESIRED
AMOREBUSINESS ORIENTEDMEETING ANDANYTOPIC AREAFORFURTHERDISCUSSIONREGARDINGPRACTICE
$ESCRIPTIONOFCONTENT
APPROACHES ETHICS PHILOSOPHY RESEARCH AND
3OCIALWORKERSAREEXPECTEDTOBRIEFLYDESCRIBE
BEHAVIORALSUPPORTANDMANAGEMENTEG
THEFAMILYHISTORYANDPRESENTINGISSUESINFULL
PRACTITIONERSAFETY DE ESCALATIONSKILLBUILDING
CASECONSULTATIONFORMAT ENSURINGTHATTEAM MEMBERSANDSUPERVISORSAREKNOWLEDGEABLE
$ESCRIPTIONOFPROCESS
OFALLBEGINNINGINFORMATION&AMILYCASE
)NTHE/LMSTED#OUNTYMODEL EACHCONSULTATION
INFORMATIONISSUBSEQUENTLYPRESENTEDFOR
BEGINSWITHTHESUPERVISORASFACILITATOR
CONSULTATIONATANYDECISIONPOINT SAFETY
ASKINGTHESOCIALWORKERWHATTHEPURPOSE
PLANDEVELOPMENTORREFINEDDEVELOPMENT
FOCUSOFTHECONSULTATIONISWHATARETHEY
CONSIDERATIONOFCOURTINVOLVEMENT ALTERNATIVE
LOOKINGFORHOPINGFORINTHISCONSULTATION
CAREARRANGEMENTSFORCHILDREN ANDCLOSURE
%ACHCONSULTATIONENDSWITHTHESUPERVISORAS
3OCIALWORKERSALSOTYPICALLY PRESENTWHEN SEEKINGADDITIONALINPUT REGARDINGSPECIFICSTRATEGIES FORFAMILYFAMILYMEMBER ENGAGEMENT SEEKINGINVOLVEMENTOF EXTENDEDKINANDSUPPORT
FACILITATORASKINGTHESOCIAL
5IFDPOTVMUBUJPOCFHJOT XJUIBHFOPHSBN B QJDUPSJBMSFQSFTFOUBUJPOPG UIFGBNJMZXJUIOBNFTBOE BHFTXIFSFLOPXO
WORKERIFTHEIRGOALSHOPES WEREMET4HISENSURESTHAT THEDIRECTIONISCLEARAND AGREEDUPONANDPROVIDESTHE OPPORTUNITYFOREACHSOCIAL WORKERTOHAVETHETIME NECESSARYFORTHESUPPORTAND
GUIDANCETHEYNEED4HISALSOENSURESTHATEACH
SEEKINGCOLLABORATIONAMONGSERVICEPROVIDERS
SOCIALWORKERGIVESTHOUGHTANDATTENTIONTO
SEEKINGREQUESTSFORCOMMUNITYSERVICE PROVISIONEGEVALUATIONSREGARDING PARENTING PSYCHOLOGICALISSUES PSYCHOSEXUAL ISSUES CHEMICALADDICTIONOROTHERTREATMENT
THEIRQUESTIONSPRIORTOTHECONSULT SOTHATTHE TIMECANBEEFFECTIVELYANDEFFICIENTLYUTILISED PREPARATIONANDDISCIPLINECONTRIBUTETOA
SEEKINGFEEDBACKONTRANSFERENCECOUNTER TRANSFERENCEOROTHERWISEPERCEIVED COMPLICATIONSIMPASSES
CONSTRUCTIVEWORKINGENVIRONMENT!SILLUSTRATED
ELICITINGSTRENGTHSPROTECTIVECAPACITY CROSS CULTURALCONSIDERATIONS SHARINGOF CONSTRUCTIVEWORK CREATIVESOLUTIONBUILDING
OFINFORMATION4HEFRAMEWORKISOUTLINEDON
BYTHETEMPLATE ASPECIFICFRAMEWORKISUTILISED FORSTRUCTURINGTHEORGANISATIONANDANALYSIS THEWHITEBOARDANDPROVIDESAFOCALPOINTAND COLLECTIVETASKFORTHELARGERGROUP
OCCASIONALLY ATTHEFAMILY¤SREQUEST FORTEAM VIEWSONSPECIFICQUESTIONS
4HECONSULTATIONBEGINSWITHAHFOPHSBNA
!TTHEBEGINNINGOFANYCONSULTANAGENDAIS
ANDAGESWHEREKNOWN4HEGENOGRAMISONE
USUALLYDEVELOPEDSOCIALWORKERSTYPICALLYWRITE
WAYOFBRINGINGTHEFAMILYINTOTHEROOMWHEN
ONTHEWHITEBOARDTHEFAMILYCASETHEYARE
THEYAREPHYSICALLYABSENTANDCONTRIBUTESTOA
SEEKINGCONSULTATIONONORANYQUESTIONSTHEY
RESPECTFULREFERENCETOMEMBERS4HEGENOGRAM
HAVE3UPERVISORSWILLROUTINELYADDANYSPECIFIC
ALSOEXPOSESGAPSINKNOWLEDGEANDPROVIDES
PICTORIALREPRESENTATIONOFTHEFAMILYWITHNAMES
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
EARLYIDENTIFICATIONOFKINFORFUTUREINCLUSION
BSFB WHICHCOMPRISESINFORMATIONTHATIS
!NFDPNBQORATJNQMFMJTUJOHISCOMPILED
INCOMPLETEORSPECULATIVEANDREQUIRESAMORE
OFTHESERVICEPROVIDERS COMMUNITYSUPPORT
DETAILEDCONVERSATIONWITHFAMILYANDORSERVICE
PEOPLEANDOROTHERSINVOLVEDWITHTHEFAMILY
PROVIDERS
4HISPROVIDESINFORMATIONSPECIFICTOTHESOCIAL
4HEANALYSISOFTHEINFORMATIONINVOLVESTHE
WORKER¤SEFFORTSREGARDINGCOLLABORATION
FORMULATIONOFSJTLTUBUFNFOUT2ISKSTATEMENTS
BRINGINGALLRESOURCESTOANYMEETINGWITHTHE
AREDEVELOPEDSPECIFICTOEACHINDIVIDUALFAMILY
FAMILYEXTENDEDFAMILY
SITUATIONANDARECOMPRISEDOFTWOCOMPONENTS
4HEINFORMATIONISORGANISEDUNDERTHE
4HEFIRSTPARTOFTHESTATEMENTARTICULATES
APPROPRIATEHEADINGS%BOHFSIBSNCAPTURES
THEWORRYEGPHYSICALHARM SEXUALHARM
THEINFORMATIONCONTAINEDINANYREPORTTOTHE
DEATH ILLNESS EMOTIONALHARM ANDTHESECOND
AGENCYEG¡/NTHISDATETHEAGENCYRECEIVED
ARTICULATESTHECONTEXTOFTHEWORRYEGA
AREPORTALLEGINGTHATSOMETHINGHAPPENED¢
PARENTISUSINGCOCAINEANDTHEIRJUDGMENTAND
$ETAILSAREINCLUDEDANDAREASCLEARANDSPECIFIC
CAREMAYBEIMPAIREDWITHOUTSUPERVISIONOR
ASPOSSIBLEANDSTATEDINSUCHAWAYASTOBE
BEINGWATCHEDOVERSPECIFICTOTHECHILD¤SNEEDS
UNDERSTOODBYALL!NYPAST HISTORYOFCHILDPROTECTIVE SERVICEINVOLVEMENTISALSO LOCATEDUNDERTHISHEADING 5NDERTHEHEADINGOF TUSFOHUITQSPUFDUJWFGBDUPST ISINFORMATIONSPECIFIC TOTHEASSETS RESOURCES
WHENAPARENTHITSORSHAKES
5IFTVQFSWJTPSBTGBDJMJUBUPS JTSFTQPOTJCMFGPSNBOBHJOH UIFHSPVQQSPDFTTJOTVDI BXBZUIBUUIFGPDVT QVSQPTFPGFBDIDPOTVMUJT NBJOUBJOFE
THECHILD 4HESESTATEMENTS BRINGFOCUSTOTHEWORKAND CLARIFYTHESOCIALWORKER¤S NEXTSTEPSINTALKINGWITH THEFAMILYANDBUILDINGA SHAREDUNDERSTANDINGOF GOALS2ISKSTATEMENTSCANBE
ANDCAPACITIESWITHINTHE
LINKEDTONATIONALOUTCOMES
INDIVIDUAL FAMILY AND
EGCHILDSAFETY WELLBEING
COMMUNITY4HISHEADINGISINCLUSIVEOFRESEARCH
ANDSTABILITYSECURITYOFCARE INANEFFORTTO
BASEDPROTECTIVEFACTORSEGSOCIALSUPPORT
MAKETHECONNECTIONSBETWEENPOLICY LAWAND
EMOTIONALEXPRESSIVENESS ANDPROVIDESTHE
PRACTICE4HEOVERARCHINGGOALWOULDREQUIRE
OPPORTUNITYFORTHESUPERVISORASFACILITATOR
THATSAFETYBEBUILTINTOTHECONTEXTSOFRISK AND
ANDTHEGROUPTOPRACTICETRANSLATINGRESEARCH
THEREWOULDBE ATSOMEPOINT ANADEQUATELY
INTOPRACTICE)NTHESECTIONDPNQMJDBUJOH
SAFESITUATIONTOBRINGTHECHILDPROTECTIVE
GBDUPST SITUATIONSOREVENTSTHATCONTRIBUTE
SERVICEINTERVENTIONTOCLOSURE4HESECTION
TODIFFICULTYFORFAMILYMEMBERS THESOCIAL
ONOFYUTUFQTCAPTURESTHEPRESENTINGSOCIAL
WORKER ANDORANYONEELSEWHOISINVOLVEDWITH
WORKER¤STASKSANDPROVIDESCONCRETEDIRECTIONIN
THEFAMILY2ESEARCH BASEDSJTLGBDUPSTEG
RESPONSETOTHEORIGINALPURPOSEOFTHECONSULT
MATERNALDEPRESSION TEENPREGNANCY WOULD ALSOBELOCATEDUNDERTHISHEADING4HESECTION
4HEROLEOFOTHERGROUPMEMBERSDURINGA
ONTBGFUZCOVERSSTRENGTHSDEMONSTRATEDAS
CASECONSULTATIONISDEPENDENTONTHENEEDS
PROTECTIONOVERTIMEANDCAPTURESINFORMATION
OFTHEPRESENTINGSOCIALWORKER3OMETIMES
SPECIFICTOAHISTORYOFEXCEPTIONSEGTIMES
CLARIFYINGQUESTIONSAREASKEDANDATOTHER
WHENOTHERMETHODSOFDISCIPLINEWEREUSED
TIMESTHEPRESENTINGSOCIALWORKERSEEKSIDEAS
SUCCESSFULLY !NOTHERCATEGORYISTHEHSFZ
FEEDBACK INFORMATION OROTHERKINDSOFHELP
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
4HESUPERVISORASFACILITATORISRESPONSIBLEFOR
TOCONFORMCANBEMINIMISED THEREBY
MANAGINGTHEGROUPPROCESSINSUCHAWAYTHAT
STRENGTHENINGCRITICALTHINKINGSKILLSAND
THEFOCUSPURPOSEOFEACHCONSULTISMAINTAINED
GUARDINGAGAINST£GROUPTHINK¤*ANIS #ASECONSULTATIONINTHECONTEXTOFGROUP
$ESCRIPTIONOFCULTURE
SUPERVISIONREQUIRESTHATEACHSOCIALWORKER
4HESUPERVISORISRESPONSIBLEFORSETTINGTHE
EXPOSEMAKETRANSPARENTTHEIRPRACTICE4HE
CULTUREFORTHEGROUPPROCESS4HEYPROVIDE
SUPERVISORISRESPONSIBLEFORCREATINGASAFE
FORANENVIRONMENTOFRESPECT SHARED
ENVIRONMENTINWHICHTODOSO"YASKING
ACCOUNTABILITYANDRISKFACILITATERESPONSIBLE
QUESTIONSOFINTERESTANDGUIDINGTHESOCIAL
USEOFAUTHORITY RECIPROCITY THOUGHTFULNESS
WORKERTHROUGHTHEORGANISATIONANDANALYSISOF
DISCIPLINEANDMUTUALAIDANDENSURETHAT
INFORMATION THESUPERVISORASFACILITATORMODELS
DIVERGENTVIEWSAREPRESENTED4HEFRAMEWORK
THEDESIREDSKILLSINENGAGINGFAMILIESINRESPECTFUL WAYS3OCIALWORKERSARE
PROVIDESANOPPORTUNITYFOR THESUPERVISORASFACILITATOR TOPOSEQUESTIONSTHATELICIT DETAILEDINFORMATIONABSENTOF INTERPRETATION EMBELLISHMENT ANDSPECULATION&OREXAMPLE ASIMPLELINEOFQUERYMIGHT BE(OWDOYOUKNOWTHIS
$BTFDPOTVMUBUJPOJO UIFDPOUFYUPGHSPVQ TVQFSWJTJPOSFRVJSFTUIBU FBDITPDJBMXPSLFSFYQPTF NBLFUSBOTQBSFOUUIFJS QSBDUJDF
ASKEDFORTHEINFORMATION ANDASKEDWHERETHEYWOULD LIKETHEINFORMATIONTOBE LOCATEDWITHINTHEFRAMEWORK ITISLESSABOUTBITSOF INFORMATIONBEINGLOCATED INTHE£RIGHTPLACE¤ANDMORE
!RETHESETHEWORDSTHAT
ABOUTGETTINGTHEINFORMATION
THEMOTHERUSED 7HAT
RIGHT4HERECORDONTHE WHITEBOARDPROVIDESAREFERENCEPOINTANDA
SPECIFICALLYWASSAID $OESITMAKESENSETO
VISUALACCOUNTOFTHEWORKBEINGDONEANDALLOWS
HAVEANOTHERCONVERSATIONWITHHERTOCLARIFY
FORENGAGEMENTOFTHELARGERGROUP
WHETHERYOUGOTITRIGHT $ESCRIPTIONSAREPUT INBEHAVIOURALTERMS7HENYOUSAYTHATTHE
#ONCLUSION
FATHERHASMENTALHEALTHPROBLEMSWHATDOYOU MEAN )STHEREAFORMALDIAGNOSIS 7HATHAVE
#HILDPROTECTIONPRACTICEISOFTENCARRIEDOUTIN
YOUOBSERVED (OWHASTHEFATHERDESCRIBED
ANANXIOUSANDRISK AVERSIVEENVIRONMENT'ROUP
HISEXPERIENCES %VERYCONVERSATIONWITHIN
SUPERVISIONCANPROVIDEASANCTUARYOFSORTS
THEGROUPISHELDINSUCHAWAYTHATSHOULDA
WHERETIMEISALLOWEDFORTHINKINGANDWORKING
FAMILYMEMBERWALKTHROUGHTHEDOORNOTHING
THROUGHCOMPLEXPRACTICEPATHWAYS)TISAPLACE
WOULDCHANGE0RACTICINGTALKINGINARESPECTFUL
WHEREEMOTIONALSUPPORTISAVAILABLE QUESTIONS
STRAIGHTFORWARD INTERESTEDMANNERSEEMSTO
CANBERESPONDEDTO PROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENT
ASSISTSOCIALWORKERSTOHAVEAPPROPRIATESKILLS
ANDLEADERSHIPSKILLSCANBEHONEDANDWHERE
ANDWORDSTOTALKWITHFAMILIESATTHEIRHOMES
SOCIALWORKKNOWLEDGE RESEARCHANDTOOLS
ANDINANYMEETINGORCONFERENCEFORUM
CANCOMEALIVEANDHAVEMEANINGINTHEFIELD 3TRETCHINGTHEBOUNDARIESBEYONDTRADITIONAL
7HENTHESUPERVISORASFACILITATORENCOURAGES
NOTIONSOFSUPERVISIONCANPROVIDEUSWITH
DISSENTINGVIEWSANDMEMBERSTAKEONTHE
RELEVANTGROUPPROCESSESTHATHAVESYNERGYWITH
TASKOFLOOKINGCRITICALLYATANYDECISION
CHILDPROTECTIONPRACTICE ANDATTHESAMETIME
THEVULNERABILITYANDPRESSUREFORTHEGROUP
BUILDSOCIALWORKCAPACITYANDPRACTICEDEPTH
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
2%&%2%.#%3 'IBBS , 'AMBRILL % #RITICALTHINKINGFOR SOCIALWORKERS%XERCISESFORTHEHELPINGPROFESSION 4HOUSAND/AKS #!0INE&ORGE0UBLICATIONS *ANIS ) 'ROUPTHINK0SYCHOLOGICALSTUDIESOF POLICYDECISIONSANDFIASCOS"OSTON -!(OUGHTON -IFFLIN +ADUSHIN ! 3UPERVISIONINSOCIALWORK 4HIRD %DITION.EW9ORK#OLUMBIA5NIVERSITY0RESS +LEIN ' 3OURCESOFPOWER(OWPEOPLEMAKE DECISIONS#AMBRIDGE -!-)40RESS ,OHRBACH 3 3AWYER 2 #REATINGA CONSTRUCTIVEPRACTICE&AMILYANDPROFESSIONAL PARTNERSHIPINHIGH RISKCHILDPROTECTIONCASE CONFERENCES0ROTECTING#HILDREN PP -UNRO % %FFECTIVECHILDPROTECTION3AGE ,ONDON 3HULMAN , )NTERACTIONALSUPERVISION 7ASHINGTON $#.!370RESS 4URNELL ! %DWARDS 3 3IGNSOF3AFETY .EW9ORK77.ORTON#OMPANY )NC
3UZANNE,OHRBACHISASUPERVISORWITH/LMSTED#OUNTY #HILD&AMILY3ERVICES -INNESOTA 53!ANDISINTERESTED INPARTNERSHIP BASEDCOLLABORATIVEPRACTICE
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
Families, culture and supervision -ARIE#ONNOLLY 9VONNE#RICHTON (ILLAND4ONY7ARD TOWARDPOSITIVECHANGE4HEREISNOQUESTION
)NTRODUCTION
HOWEVER THATCULTURALMISINTERPRETATIONCAN
0EOPLEIDENTIFYWITHMULTIPLECULTURESTHATALSO
CONFOUNDPRACTICE0EOPLEWHOWORKWITH
OVERLAPANDRELATETOEACHOTHER#HILDREN¤S
FAMILIESACROSSCULTURESWILLBEFAMILIARWITH
CULTURESAREIMBEDDEDWITHINTHECOLLECTIVE
THATFEELINGOFBEINGLOST WITHMEANINGBARRIERS
CULTURESOFTHEIRFAMILYGROUPS&AMILIESPROVIDE
MAKINGTHECULTURALSIGNPOSTSTOODIFFICULTTO
USWITHANEARLYSETOFSIGNPOSTS WHICHHELPUS
READ)NTHESESITUATIONS SUPERVISIONCANBEAN
UNDERSTANDOURWORLD,IKEROADSIGNS THEY
IMPORTANTPROCESSTHATOFFERSALTERNATIVEWAYS
TELLUSWHENITISSAFETOPROCEEDANDWHENWE
OFTHINKINGABOUTPRACTICEANDTHEWAYSIN
SHOULDEXERCISECAUTION4HEYSUGGESTWAYSOF
WHICHCULTURALTHINKINGINFLUENCESOURRESPONSES
RESPONDINGTOOTHERSANDINFLUENCETHEWAY
TOFAMILIES)NTHISPAPERWE
WETHINKANDWHATWEDO 4HEYSIGNPOSTOURCULTURAL LANDSCAPE&ROMTHEOUTSIDE THEYCANAPPEARIDIOSYNCRATIC ANDCOMPLEXFROMTHEINSIDE THEYAPPEARNORMALAND
"TVOJRVFBTXFBSFJOPVS WJFXTPGUIFXPSME TPBSF UIFGBNJMJFTGSPNXIJDIXF PSJHJOBUF
LOOKFIRSTATFAMILIES THEIR DIVERSITYANDPATTERNSOF COMMUNICATION7EBEGIN HEREFORTWOREASONSWE THINKKNOWLEDGEABOUTFAMILY DIVERSITYANDCOMMUNICATION
UNDERSTANDABLE!SUNIQUE
PATTERNSISGENERALLYUSEFUL
ASWEAREINOURVIEWSOFTHEWORLD SOARETHE
FORSOCIALWORKERSWITHINTHECONTEXTOFCHILD
FAMILIESFROMWHICHWEORIGINATE#ONNOLLY
WELFAREANDITPROVIDESAPOTENTIALSOURCE
#RICHTON (ILL7ARD
OFKNOWLEDGEFORSUPERVISORSTOEXPLOREIN
7HENWORKINGACROSSCULTURALGROUPS SOMUCH
THECONTEXTOFSUPERVISION7ETHENCONSIDER
DEPENDSONHOWTHESOCIALWORKERCOMESACROSS
CULTURALCOMPONENTSOFPRACTICEANDSOMEOF
TOTHEFAMILYANDWHETHERTHEFAMILYBELIEVES
THEWAYSINWHICHSUPERVISIONCANHELPWORKERS
THATTHEYAREBEINGUNDERSTOOD&AMILIES
NAVIGATETHEIRWAYACROSSCULTURALLANDSCAPES
HAVETHEIROWNCOMMUNICATIONPATTERNS ORGANISATIONALSYSTEMSANDTHEIROWNWAYSOF
&AMILIESANDFAMILYDIVERSITY
RESPONDINGTOTHEWORLD"UILDINGRELATIONSHIPS
#OMPETENTCHILDPROTECTIONPRACTICEWITH
WITHFAMILIESRELIESONTHEWORKER¤SABILITYTO
FAMILIESREQUIRESABROADRANGEOFSKILLSAND
UNDERSTANDCOMPLEXSYSTEMSANDTHEIRCAPACITY
KNOWLEDGE(OWEVER WEWOULDARGUETHATA
TOMOBILISETHEFAMILY¤SCULTURALSTRENGTHS
FUNDAMENTALSTARTINGPOINTISTHERECOGNITION
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
ANDAPPRECIATIONTHATFAMILIESAREDIVERSE4HIS
#ULTURALIDENTITYANDCONTEXTWILLHAVEAN
DIVERSITYISTHERESULTOFCONTEXTUALFACTORS
INFLUENCEONTHEWAYINFORMATIONISTRANSMITTED
INCLUDING BUTNOTLIMITEDTO ETHNICIDENTITY
ANDTHEWAYINWHICHITISRECEIVED!DDITIONALLY
CLASS LANGUAGEOFCHOICE HEALTH GEOGRAPHICAL
¡PASTEXPERIENCEOFASIMILARISSUEMAYSENSITIZE
LOCATION HOUSEHOLDCOMPOSITION ANDSOCIALAND
THEMESSAGERECEIVERTOSUBTLEASPECTSOFIT
COMMUNITYSUPPORTS-UNFORD3ANDERS
OR CONVERSELY REVOKESTRESSFULEMOTIONSAND
&AMILYCONTEXTALSOINCLUDESSOCIETALVALUES
ATENDENCYTODISSOCIATEFROMOR£BLOCKOUT¤
ABOUT¡WHATMAKESAGOODMOTHERORFATHER
EMOTIVEASPECTS¢2EDER$UNCAN
ABOUTHOWSONSANDDAUGHTERSSHOULDBEHAVE
P 4HISADDSTOTHECOMMUNICATIONSTYLE
ANDABOUTWHATKINDSOFRELATIONSHIPSHOULD
OFTHESENDERANDRECEIVER)NENCOUNTERSWITH
EXISTBETWEENHUSBANDSANDWIVES¢-C,ENNAN
FAMILIESTHEREWILLBEANUMBEROFSTYLESOF
2YAN3POONLEY P 4HESEAREALL
COMMUNICATIONPRESENT INCLUDINGTHEPARTICULAR
ASPECTSOFCULTURALTHINKINGTHATSHAPETHEWAY
COMMUNICATIONSTYLEOFTHE
WETHINKABOUTANDBEHAVE
CHILDPROTECTIONWORKER)N
TOWARDFAMILIES&URTHERMORE FAMILIES WITHINTHEMSELVES ARENOTHOMOGENOUSAND THEREFORE¡MULTIPLEDIVERSE CULTURES WITHVARYINGIDEAS ABOUTROLE MEMBERSHIPAND STRUCTURECANEXISTINONE
$VMUVSBMJEFOUJUZBOE DPOUFYUXJMMIBWFBO JOGMVFODFPOUIFXBZ JOGPSNBUJPOJTUSBOTNJUUFE BOEUIFXBZJOXIJDIJUJT SFDFJWFE
FAMILYSYSTEM¢#RICHTON (ILL
ADDITION FAMILIESENTERINGINTO THECHILDPROTECTIONPROCESS AREMOSTLIKELYTOEXPERIENCE ARANGEOFEMOTIONSTHATARE LIKELYTOAFFECTTHEIRABILITY TOCOMMUNICATESUCCESSFULLY -OREOVER THEABILITYOFTHE CHILDPROTECTIONWORKERTO
P !DDITIONALLY ALLFAMILIESWILLHAVE
COMMUNICATEWILLBEAFFECTEDBYARANGEOF
PARTICULARWAYSINWHICHMEANINGISGIVENTO
FACTORSINCLUDINGPERSONALCULTURALIDENTITYAND
EXPERIENCESANDINHOWCOMMUNICATIONWITH
CONTEXT BOTHPERSONALANDPROFESSIONAL)TIS
ONEANOTHEROCCURS4HESEARECOMPLEXAREAS
HARDLYSURPRISING GIVENTHEEMOTIVETOPICOF
TOTACKLEWHENWORKINGTHROUGHISSUESOFCHILD
CHILDABUSE THATTHEPROCESSOFCOMMUNICATION
CAREANDPROTECTION5NDERSTANDINGPROCESSESOF
BETWEENCHILDPROTECTIONPRACTITIONERSAND
FAMILYCOMMUNICATIONCANHELP
FAMILIESCANBEFRAUGHTWITHDIFFICULTY
#OMMUNICATION
(WA &ROELICHAND6IGIL INTHEIR
#OMMUNICATIONHASBEENIDENTIFIEDASTHE
EXAMINATIONOFHOWCOMMUNICATIONIS
PROCESSWHEREAPERSON THROUGHTHEUSE
INFLUENCEDBYCULTURE PROPOSETHREEKEY
OFSIGNSANDSYMBOLS CONVEYSMEANING
AREASWHEREDIFFERENCESINCULTURALTHINKING
+OERNER&ITZPATRICK 2EDER$UNCAN
ANDCOMMUNICATIONMAYOCCURRESPONSIBILITY
4HEPROCESSISRELIANTONTWOABILITIES
RELATIONSHIPSINTERPERSONALRELATIONSHIPS
PRACTICALANDLINGUISTICABILITYTOSENDAND
ANDRISKMANAGEMENT!LTHOUGHTHEYAPPLY
RECEIVEINFORMATIONANDTHEABILITYTO
TOCULTUREMOREGENERALLY THEAREASCAN
ATTRIBUTEMEANINGTOTHEMESSAGE3UCCESSFUL
BEUSEDTOEXPLAINDIFFERENCESINMEANING
COMMUNICATIONENCOUNTERSOCCURWHENTHE
MAKINGANDCOMMUNICATIONINFAMILIESAND
RECEIVERUNDERSTANDSTHEMEANINGOFTHE
HAVETHEPOTENTIALTOCONTRIBUTETOPRACTICE
INFORMATIONINTHEWAYTHESENDERINTENDED
ENHANCEMENT
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
%NHANCINGWORKWITHFAMILIES
HASNORIGHTTOBEINVOLVEDWITHFAMILYBUSINESS 4HEYMAYBEAFFRONTEDATWHATTHEYPERCEIVETO
$ESPITETHEMULTI LAYEREDCOMPLEXITYOFFAMILIES
BEANINTERFERENCEINTHEIRBASICHUMANRIGHTS
ANDTHEIRCULTURALPROCESSES ITISIMPORTANTTO
ANDMAYMOVEQUICKLYTOANADVERSARIALANDOR
NOTETHATITISINDEEDPOSSIBLETOHAVESUCCESSFUL
LITIGIOUSRESPONSE
PRACTICEOUTCOMESTHATREFLECTTHEHARNESSING OFCULTURALSTRENGTHS)FWEUNDERSTANDCULTURAL
)NFAMILIESWITHACOLLECTIVEINTERDEPENDENT
THINKINGANDTHEIRASSOCIATEDPROCESSESOF
ORIENTATION RESPONSIBILITYISVIEWEDASRECIPROCAL
COMMUNICATIONWECANINCORPORATETHESEIDEAS
ANDSOFAMILYMEMBERSARERESPONSIBLEFOREACH
INTOPRACTICESTRATEGIES
OTHER(EREDEFINITIONOFFAMILYISOFTENEXTENDED BEYONDIMMEDIATENUCLEARFAMILYMEMBERSTO
2ESPONSIBILITYRELATIONSHIPS
INCLUDEWIDERFAMILYAUNTS UNCLES COUSINSAND
)DEASABOUTRESPONSIBILITYCANVARYBETWEEN
GRANDPARENTS)MPORTANTCONCEPTSTOFAMILIES
FAMILIESANDAREDEPENDENTONTHEVALUES
WITHTHISORIENTATIONINCLUDEGROUPSOLIDARITY SHARINGOFDUTIESAND
ANDBELIEFSSURROUNDING INTERPERSONALRELATIONSHIPS (OFSTEDE CONCEPTUALISESTHISASA CONTINUUMRANGINGFROM INDIVIDUALRESPONSIBILITY ORIENTATIONTOCOLLECTIVE RESPONSIBILITYORIENTATION &AMILIESWHOIDENTIFY GENERALLYWITHINDIVIDUAL
8IBUJTJNQPSUBOUJT UIBUUIFTPDJBMXPSLFS VOEFSTUBOETUIFQPUFOUJBM GPSSFTQPOTJCJMJUZ SFMBUJPOTIJQTUPJOGMVFODF DVMUVSBMUIJOLJOHBOEIPXJU NBZ PSNBZOPU BQQMZUP UIJTQBSUJDVMBSGBNJMZ
OBLIGATIONS ANDEMOTIONAL DEPENDENCE0ROTECTIVE SERVICESCANSOMETIMESBE FRUSTRATEDWHEN FOREXAMPLE IMMIGRANTFAMILIESSEND RESOURCESBACKTOFAMILYIN THEIRHOMECOUNTRYWHEN THEYMAYBESTRUGGLING THEMSELVESTOMANAGEINTHEIR ADOPTEDHOME)NSIGHTINTO
RESPONSIBILITYMAYBETERMED
CULTURALNOTIONSOFCOLLECTIVE
INDEPENDENTSELF SUPPORTING WHILETHOSESUBSCRIBINGTOCOLLECTIVEDEPENDENT
RESPONSIBILITYCANHELPAWORKERTOWORKWITH
ONOTHERS RESPONSIBILITYMAYBEDESCRIBEDAS
THEFAMILYINTHESECIRCUMSTANCES
INTERDEPENDENT
&AMILIESWITHACOLLECTIVEINTERDEPENDENT
)NFAMILIESWITHANINDIVIDUALINDEPENDENT
ORIENTATIONMAYBEMORERECEPTIVETO
ORIENTATION CHILDRENAREVIEWEDASBEING
INVOLVEMENTOFEXTENDEDFAMILY(OWEVER ITIS
ABLETOTAKECAREOFTHEIROWNNEEDSANDARE
IMPORTANTTOREMEMBERTHATTHESEORIENTATIONS
SOCIALISEDINORDERTOACHIEVETHISOUTCOME
ARENOTHOMOGENOUSCATEGORISATIONS%ACH
0RAISEISMORELIKELYTOBEGIVENFORTASKSTHAT
FAMILYWILLBEDIFFERENT ANDSTEREOTYPINGTHEM
AREACHIEVEDINDIVIDUALLY(WA &ROELICH6IGIL
TOAPARTICULARORIENTATIONHASJUSTASMUCH
#ONCEPTSTHATARECONSIDEREDIMPORTANT
POTENTIALTOCREATEMISCOMMUNICATIONSWHEN
INCLUDEEMOTIONALINDEPENDENCE AUTONOMY
WORKINGACROSSCULTURALGROUPS2ATHER THE
ANDRIGHTSTOPRIVACY&OREXAMPLE AFAMILYWITH
ORIENTATIONSAREPRESENTEDTOILLUSTRATEDIFFERENT
ANINDIVIDUALINDEPENDENTORIENTATIONMAYBE
WAYSOFTHINKINGABOUTTHEWORLDANDHOWTHE
LESSLIKELYTOWANTTOINVOLVEEXTENDEDFAMILY
FAMILYSYSTEMMAYFUNCTIONINRELATIONTOTHAT
MEMBERSINTHECHILDPROTECTIONPROCESSAND
WORLD(ENCE FAMILIESREFLECTINGANINDIVIDUAL
MAYBELIEVETHECHILDPROTECTIONORGANISATION
INDEPENDENTORIENTATIONMAYINDEEDWELCOME
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
EXTENDEDFAMILYSUPPORT WHILEFAMILIESRELATING
BEHAVIOURTOWARDSTHEMINCOMMUNICATIONAND
TOACOLLECTIVEINDEPENDENTORIENTATIONMAY
INOTHERASPECTSOFFAMILYFUNCTIONING0ARENTS
NOT7HATISIMPORTANTISTHATTHESOCIALWORKER
PERCEIVEDASHOLDINGHIGHPOWERDISTANCEIN
UNDERSTANDSTHEPOTENTIALFORRESPONSIBILITY
RELATIONTOOTHERSARELIKELYTOUSEVERYDIRECT
RELATIONSHIPSTOINFLUENCECULTURALTHINKINGAND
ANDEXPLICITCOMMUNICATIONWITHTHEIRCHILDREN
HOWITMAY ORMAYNOT APPLYTOTHISPARTICULAR
#HILDPROTECTIONPRACTITIONERSDEPENDING
FAMILY
ONTHEIROWNCULTURALIDENTITY MAYPERCEIVE PARENTSWITHHIGHPOWERDISTANCERELATIONSHIPS
)NTERPERSONALRELATIONSHIPS
ASAUTHORITARIAN DEMANDINGANDUNLOVING
(OFSTEDE SUGGESTSTHATONEDIMENSIONOF
(OWEVER THINGSARERARELYSOSTRAIGHTFORWARD
SOCIALCULTUREISPOWERDISTANCE4HISREFERS¡TO
4HEREAREDIFFERENCESBETWEENAUTHORITARIAN
THEVERTICALSTRATIFICATIONOFASOCIETYWHERE
ANDAUTHORITATIVEPARENTINGSTYLES!N
INDIVIDUALSAREACCORDEDDIFFERENTLEVELSOF
AUTHORITARIANPARENTINGSTYLECANBEDESCRIBED
IMPORTANCEANDSTATUS¢-ACNAMARA
ASPARENTINGTHATINVOLVESAHIGHLEVELOFCONTROL
P 7ITHINCULTURALGROUPINGS PEOPLE
OVERCHILDRENANDALOWLEVELOFACCEPTANCE
MAYBEASSIGNEDALEVELOF SOCIALSTATUSINFLUENCED BYANUMBEROFVARIABLES SUCHASAGE FINANCIAL WEALTH ACHIEVEMENTSAND EMPLOYMENTROLE3IMILARLY INFAMILYSYSTEMS INDIVIDUALS
!LTERNATIVELY ¡AUTHORITATIVE
'BNJMJFTIBWFEJGGFSFOU TUSBUFHJFTGPSDPQJOHXJUI VODFSUBJOUZBOEDIBMMFOHF BOEXJMMIBWFEJGGFSFOU DVMUVSFTPGSJTLUBLJOH
WILLBEPERCEIVEDASHAVING
PARENTINGISCHARACTERISED BYHIGHLEVELSOFBOTH ACCEPTANCEANDCONTROL¢ 7ISE P 4HIS CAUTIONSUSAGAINSTQUICK ASSUMPTIONSABOUTTHEWAYIN WHICHFAMILIESFUNCTION
STATUSANDTHEREFOREPOWERIN RELATIONTOFAMILYFUNCTIONING
2ISKMANAGEMENT
(WA &ROELICHAND6IGIL SUGGESTTHAT
&AMILIESHAVEDIFFERENTSTRATEGIESFORCOPING
PEOPLEWITHLOWPOWERDISTANCERELATIONSHIPS
WITHUNCERTAINTYANDCHALLENGE ANDWILLHAVE
ARELIKELYTOVIEWSTATUSINEQUALITIESNEGATIVELY
DIFFERENTCULTURESOFRISK TAKING4HISRISK
ANDVIEWTHOSEWITHHIGHSTATUSASBEINGEQUAL
MANAGEMENTAREAISPARTICULARLYRELEVANTTOCHILD
TOTHEMSELVES4HISORIENTATIONLENDSITSELFTO
PROTECTIONPRACTICE THENATUREOFWHICHISBOTH
COMMUNICATIONTHATISDIRECT BUTRESPECTFUL
CHALLENGINGANDANXIETY PROVOKINGFORFAMILIES
ANDINFLUENCEDBYRULESOFPOLITENESSWHICH
(OFSTEDE IDENTIFIEDTHISDIMENSIONOF
MAYRESULTINTHEUSEOF¡INDIRECTDIRECTIONSAND
SOCIALCULTUREASUNCERTAINTYAVOIDANCEAND
QUESTIONS¢(WA &ROELICH6IGIL P
PROPOSEDACONTINUUMOFRESPONSESFROMWEAK UNCERTAINTYAVOIDANCETOSTRONGUNCERTAINTY
!CCORDINGLY THEWRITERSPROPOSE PARENTS
AVOIDANCE0UTSIMPLY SOMEFAMILIESMAYBE
WHOSUBSCRIBETOTHISORIENTATIONARELIKELYTO
MOREPREPAREDTOFOSTERRISK TAKING ANDSOME
COMMUNICATEWITHTHEIRCHILDRENINANEASY
LESSSO0ARENTSWHOEMPLOYTHISKINDOFRESPONSE
ANDINFORMALWAY#ONVERSELY PEOPLEWITHHIGH
ARELIKELYTOSOCIALISECHILDREN¡TOQUESTION TAKE
POWERDISTANCERELATIONSHIPSAREVERYAWARE
RISKS EXPLORE ANDBECREATIVE¢(WA &ROELICH
OFINEQUALITIESINRELATIONSHIPS4HOSEWHO
6IGIL P #ONVERSELY THEORIENTATION
HAVEHIGHPOWERARELIKELYTOEXPECTRESPECTFUL
TOSTRONGUNCERTAINTYAVOIDANCEIERISK AVERSE
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
REPRESENTSFAMILIESWHOFINDUNCERTAINTYAND
DECISION MAKINGWASSTRONGLYINFLUENCEDBY
CHALLENGETHREATENINGANDUNCOMFORTABLE
EVIDENCEGLEANEDFROMVERBALINTERACTIONSWITH
#HILDRENFROMFAMILIESOFTHISORIENTATION
PARENTS(OLLANDFOUNDTHATSOCIALWORKERS
ARESOCIALISEDTODOASTHEYARETOLDWITHOUT
PERCEIVEDPARENTSWHOWEREARTICULATEASBETTER
CHALLENGEANDQUESTIONINGANDTOSTEERCLEAROF
ABLETOPERFORMWELLINASSESSMENTS0ARENTS
MAKINGMISTAKES#HILDRENLEARNTHROUGHTHE
WHOWEREINARTICULATEWEREPERCEIVEDASPASSIVE
PROCESSOFDEMONSTRATIONINTHEHOPETHATBY
ANDUNCO OPERATIVE TRANSLATEDBYTHESOCIAL
THETIMETHECHILDATTEMPTSTHETASKTHEYARELESS
WORKERASREPRESENTINGALACKOFINSIGHT(OLLAND
LIKELYTOMAKEANERROR
IDENTIFIESTHEPOTENTIALFORWORKERSTOBECOME FRUSTRATEDWHENTHEYARE
#HILDPROTECTIONPRACTITIONERS WHOLEANTOWARDSAWEAK UNCERTAINTYAVOIDANCE ORIENTATIONTHEMSELVESARE LIKELYTOBELESSDIRECTIVE ANDEXPLICITINTHEIR COMMUNICATIONWITHFAMILIES 4HEYMAYASKQUESTIONSAND IMPLICITLYMAKESUGGESTIONS &ORFAMILIESWHOHAVESTRONG UNCERTAINTYAVOIDANCEAND
UNABLETOILLICITFROMPARENTS
)PMMBOEJOIFSTUVEZPG DIJMEQSPUFDUJPOBTTFTTNFOU QSBDUJDFT EJTDPWFSFEUIBU BTTFTTNFOUEFDJTJPONBLJOH XBTTUSPOHMZJOGMVFODFE CZFWJEFODFHMFBOFEGSPN WFSCBMJOUFSBDUJPOT XJUIQBSFOUT
INFORMATIONUPONWHICH THEYCAN¡FORMAPLAUSIBLE EXPLANATION¢P FORTHE ABUSEISSUE7HILEITHASLONG BEENAPPRECIATEDTHATWORKERS NEEDTOCHECKCAREFULLYTHE PLAUSIBILITYOFEXPLANATION ITISCLEARLYIMPORTANTTOBE AWAREWHENTHISISINFLUENCED BYPARENTALCOMMUNICATION
PREFEREXPLICITDIRECTION
STYLE
THISAPPROACHMAYWELLBE CONFUSING#ONSIDERTHESITUATIONWHERETHE
0RACTICEENHANCINGTECHNIQUES
CHILDPROTECTIONPRACTITIONERARRANGESAFAMILY
!SKINGFAMILIESWHATTHEYFINDHELPFULINCHILD
MEETINGTODISCUSSTEMPORARYPLACEMENTOFA
CAREANDPROTECTIONWORKISIMPORTANTTOTHE
CHILDWITHEXTENDEDFAMILYMEMBERS4HECHILD
ENHANCEMENTOFCULTURALLYRESPONSIVEPRACTICE
PROTECTIONWORKERWEAKUNCERTAINTYAVOIDANCE
0ARENTSHAVEIDENTIFIEDANUMBEROFCHILD
FACILITATESTHEMEETINGINARELAXEDWAY WITH
PROTECTIONPRACTITIONERCHARACTERISTICSFOUNDTO
FEWDIRECTQUESTIONS INANATTEMPTTOENGAGE
MAKEINTERVENTIONMOREHELPFUL$ALE )N
THEFAMILYINCOLLABORATIVEDECISION MAKING
RELATIONTOPRACTITIONERSTYLE $ALEFOUNDTHAT
4HEFAMILYSTRONGUNCERTAINTYAVOIDANCE MAY
VALUEDCHARACTERISTICSWERESUPPORTIVENESS
NOTBESUREOFHOWTHEYSHOULDRESPONDASTHEY
LISTENINGSKILLS SKILLSINENCOURAGING
AREUNAWAREOFTHEWORKER¤SEXPECTATIONS4HE
COLLABORATION BEING¡MATTEROFFACT¢AND¡BEING
RESULTISAFAMILYWHOSEAWKWARDNESSESCALATES
HUMAN¢P INESSENCETHEWORKER¤S
ASTHEYFEARMAKINGAMISTAKE RESULTINGINLOWER
CAPACITYTOBEEMPATHIC%MPATHYHASLONG
LEVELSOFVERBALANDNON VERBALINTERACTIONAND
BEENCONSIDEREDTOBEAPRIMARYANDNECESSARY
ULTIMATELYNOINFORMATIONCOMMUNICATEDASTO
FEATUREOFSUCCESSFULSOCIALWORKPRACTICE.OT
THEFAMILY¤SOPINIONS4HEWORKERMAYSEETHISAS
SURPRISINGLY FAMILIESWISHALSOTOBERESPECTED
THEFAMILYABDICATINGTHEIRRESPONSIBILITIES
ANDTOBEVALUEDASPEOPLERATHERTHANBE
(OLLAND INHERSTUDYOFCHILDPROTECTION
LABELLEDASDYSFUNCTIONALORASADIAGNOSIS
ASSESSMENTPRACTICES DISCOVEREDTHATASSESSMENT
"LUE "ANNING 3UMMERS &RANKLAND .ELSON
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
"EEGLE )NORDERTOHEARTHEFAMILY THE
ASPIRATIONS¢4HISISPARTICULARLYRELEVANTWHEN
WORKERNEEDSTOBEABLETOLISTEN/NEWAYOF
WORKINGACROSSDIVERSECULTURALGROUPSASIT
DEVELOPINGLISTENINGSKILLSISTOTALKLESSAND
SUPPORTSTHENOTIONTHATCULTURALCONSTRUCTSCAN
FOCUSONLEARNINGTHROUGHDISCUSSION
ALSOBEHARNESSEDASASTRENGTHRATHERTHANBEING PERCEIVEDASAPROBLEM
$ALE ALSOFOUNDTHATPARENTSWANTEDTO KNOWHOWDECISIONSINCHILDPROTECTIONCASES
#ULTUREANDPRACTICEINSUPERVISION
WEREMADE!S$ALESTATES ¡PARENTSREQUIRE
"ECAUSEOFTHEDEMANDINGNATUREOFCHILDCARE
GREATERCLARITY CONSISTENCYANDTRANSPARENCY
ANDPROTECTIONWORKANDTHEDOMINATIONOF
INTHESEAREASOFDECISION MAKING¢P
RISKANDSAFETYDISCOURSES ISSUESOFCULTURECAN
4HECHILDPROTECTIONWORKERTHEREFOREHAS
BECOMEANAFTERTHOUGHTINCHILDPROTECTION
ANOBLIGATIONTOBEHONESTANDCLEARINTHEIR
SUPERVISION4HECHILDPROTECTIONENVIRONMENT
DISCUSSIONSWITHFAMILIES
ISCHARACTERISEDBYMANYPRESSURES AND
0REPARINGWELLFORTHEIRINTERACTIONSWITHFAMILIES
INTHISCONTEXTAFOCUSONADMINISTRATIVE
ALSOENHANCESPRACTICE4HISINCLUDESIDENTIFYING
ASPECTSOFCHILDPROTECTIONWORKCANBECOME
ASMUCHINFORMATIONASPOSSIBLEABOUTTHE
AREALITYFORBUSYSOCIALWORKERSANDTHEIR
CULTURALIDENTITYOFTHEFAMILY(WA &ROELICHAND
SUPERVISORS(OWEVER IFWORKERSDONOTHAVE
6IGIL SUGGESTTHATPRACTITIONERSSHOULD
THEOPPORTUNITYTOCONSIDERTHEIMPACTOF CULTURALTHINKINGANDBIASES
HAVEDISCUSSIONSWITHTHE FAMILYPRIORTOCARRYINGOUT AFORMALASSESSMENTPROCESS "EFOREANASSESSMENTCANBE DONE THEWORKERNEEDSTO KNOWMOREABOUTTHEFAMILY¤S
$VMUVSBMDPMMJTJPOTDBOPDDVS FBSMZPOJOBSFMBUJPOTIJQPS XIFOBSFMBUJPOTIJQJTXFMM FTUBCMJTIFE
INPRACTICE THEREISADANGER THATFAMILIESWILLNOTBE WELLSERVEDBYTHEPRACTICE SYSTEM3UPERVISIONPROVIDES AKEYMECHANISMTHROUGH WHICHPRACTICEPATHWAYS
CULTURALCONSTRUCTS4HISTHEN ENABLESASSESSMENTDISCUSSIONSWITHTHEFAMILY
CANBEEXPLORED ANDGROUPSUPERVISIONOFFERS
TOBEBALANCEDALONGSIDEOTHERINFORMATIONTHAT
THEADDITIONALRICHNESSOFMULTIPLECULTURAL
HASBEENGATHERED(OLLAND 4HISAPPROACH
EXPERIENCEANDCRITIQUE
REDUCESTHELIKELIHOODOFNEGATIVELYANDUNFAIRLY
7HENCONSIDERINGCULTURALMISCOMMUNICATION
LABELLINGASARESULTOFVERBALCOMMUNICATION
ANDMISUNDERSTANDINGITISCLEARTHATTHEYCAN
ALONE
BEFOUNDINDIFFERENTSITUATIONSWITHINTHE
/THERAUTHORSPROMOTETHEUSEOFASTRENGTHS
FAMILY BETWEENTHEFAMILYANDTHEWORKER
APPROACHWITHFAMILIES,EE 3ALEEBEY
WITHINTHEWORKER ORBETWEENTHEWORKERAND
7EICK3ALEEBEY 4HESTRENGTHS
THEPRACTICESYSTEM#ULTURALCOLLISIONSCANOCCUR
APPROACHESSENTIALLYATTEMPTSTOVIEWFAMILIES
EARLYONINARELATIONSHIPORWHENARELATIONSHIP
ASHAVINGSTRENGTHSANDPOTENTIALTHATCANBE
ISWELLESTABLISHED3OMETIMESTHETENDENCY
USEDTODEALWITHTHEISSUESTHATCONFRONTTHEM
FORAWORKERTOBELIEVETHATTHEYKNOWTHE
!S7EICKAND3ALEEBEY P APTLYSTATE
FAMILYBETTERTHANTHEYKNOWTHEMSELVESCAN
¡7ECANNOTKNOW ATTHEOUTSET THEUPPER
PRESENTBARRIERSTOUNDERSTANDINGMORECOMPLEX
LIMITSOFANYFAMILY¤SPOTENTIAL7ECANNOT
LEVELSOFDIFFERENCE3TRENGTHENINGTHECALLFOR
DENYTHEREALITYANDPOSSIBILITYOFANYFAMILY¤S
GROUPSUPERVISION ONEOFTHEDISADVANTAGES
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
OFINDIVIDUALSUPERVISIONISTHATWORKERSAND
ENGAGEMENTWITHFAMILIESANDTHEWORKER¤S
SUPERVISORSWHOKNOWEACHOTHERWELLMAYHAVE
CAPACITYTOHARNESSTHEFAMILY¤SCULTURAL
COMMONASSUMPTIONSABOUTTHEWORKANDBE
STRENGTHS)TISIMPORTANTTONOTEHERETHATPOWER
UNUSEDTOCRITICALLYEXAMININGTHEUNDERPINNING
DOESN¤TONLYOPERATEONEWAYPROFESSIONAL
CULTURALASSUMPTIONSOFTHEOTHER
POWEROVERFAMILYPOWER)FAWORKERFEELS CULTURALLYILL AT EASEANDPOWERLESSINTHEFACEOF
)NFLUENCEDBYTHELITERATURE WECONSIDER
ACLOSELYKNITANDPOWERFULFAMILYGROUP THEY
THERETOBEFOURUSEFULAREASTOCONSIDERWHEN
MAYFEELRELUCTANTTOGIVEEFFECTTOTHEIRCHILD
EXPLORINGCULTURALINFLUENCESINPRACTICE
PROTECTIONSTATUTORYPOWERS)TISIMPORTANTTHAT
DIFFERENCEPOWERCONNECTEDNESSANDMEANING
WEUNDERSTANDTHESEDYNAMICSANDHOWPOWER MAYBEINFLUENCINGTHEPROCESSESOFTHEWORKAND
%XPLORINGTHENATUREOFDIFFERENCE
THEWAYSINWHICHDECISIONSAREBEINGMADE
)NPRACTICE WHENWEFEELANAFFINITYWITH ANOTHERPERSONITINVARIABLYINFLUENCESTHEWAY
4HEIMPORTANCEOFCONNECTEDNESS
INWHICHWERESPONDTOTHEM3IMILARITIESIN
4HEELEMENTSOFRAPPORTANDRESPECTARE
EXPERIENCECANPROVIDEINSIGHTANDEMPATHY BUT
IMPORTANTWHENCONSIDERINGISSUESOF
CANALSOCREATEBLINDSPOTS#ONVERSELY WHENWE
CONNECTEDNESS5NDERSTANDINGHOWDEPENDENCE
MEETPEOPLEWHOAREDIFFERENTFROMOURSELVES
INTERDEPENDENCE ANDSEPARATENESSARE
WECANMAKEASSUMPTIONS ABOUTTHEOTHER)TCANBE USEFULTHEREFORETOEXPLORE THENATUREOFDIFFERENCE ANDSAMENESSANDHOWTHIS OPERATESINTHERELATIONSHIP
PERCEIVEDISIMPORTANT
4JNJMBSJUJFTJOFYQFSJFODF DBOQSPWJEFJOTJHIUBOE FNQBUIZ CVUDBOBMTP DSFBUFCMJOETQPUT
DYNAMIC(OWDOTHEWORKERS
WHENWORKINGWITHDIVERSE CULTURALGROUPS(OWDO RELATIONSHIPRESPONSIBILITIES WORKACROSSTHERELATIONSHIP CONFIGURATIONS (OWDOES CONNECTEDNESSRESONATE
SEETHEMSELVESASDIFFERENT
WITHNOTIONSOFFAMILIALDUTYANDLOYALTY (OW
FROMTHEFAMILY ANDHOWDOTHEYUNDERSTAND SIMILARITIES (OWDOEXPERIENCESOFOPPRESSION
DOESTHEFAMILYDEMONSTRATECONNECTEDNESS
RESONATEACROSSTHERELATIONSHIPCONFIGURATIONS
ORSEPARATENESSINFAMILYRELATIONSHIPS (OW
FOREXAMPLERACISM SEXISM AGEISMANDSOFORTH
DOESTHECONCEPTOFCONNECTEDNESSHELPIN
!NDHOWMAYTHISBERESPONDEDTOINPRACTICE
THEUNDERSTANDINGOFCULTURALDIFFERENCE AND ISCONNECTEDNESSLIMITEDORENHANCEDINTHE CONTEXTOFPOWERANDDIFFERENCE
%XPLORINGTHENATUREOFPOWER
0OWERISNOTONLYANINHERENTCOMPONENTOF
5NDERSTANDINGMEANING
CHILDPROTECTIONPRACTICEBUTISINEXTRICABLY LINKEDTOTHEWAYSINWHICHRELATIONSHIPSARE
7HENITCOMESDOWNTOACTUALLYUNDERSTANDING
PERCEIVEDACROSSCULTURES0RACTITIONERSHAVE
WHATPEOPLEMEAN ITISOFTENMUCH MUCH
POWERINRELATIONTOTHEIR¡KNOWLEDGEAND
HARDERTHANWETHINKITWILLBE7HEN
EXPERTISEACCESSTORESOURCESSTATUTORYPOWERS
COMMUNICATIONCROSSESCULTURALBOUNDARIES
ANDINFLUENCEOVERINDIVIDUALS AGENCIESAND
THINGSCANBECOMECOMPLICATEDAND
SOON¢4HOMPSON P 0OWERCANBE
MISUNDERSTANDINGSARELIKELYTOOCCUR4HIS
EMPLOYEDINPRACTICEINWAYSTHATUNDERMINE
SUPPORTSTHENOTIONTHATMEANINGBARRIERS
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
#RICHTON (ILL 9 !SSESSMENTWITHFAMILIES )N*-AIDMENTAND2%AGEN%DS 0RACTICESKILLSIN SOCIALWORKANDWELFARE-ORETHANJUSTCOMMON SENSEPP #ROWS.EST!LLEN5NWIN
EXISTBETWEENALLPEOPLEANDWORKINGOURWAY THROUGHTHEMISADAILYTASK (OWPEOPLEASCRIBEMEANINGTOTHEIREXPERIENCES
$ALE 0 ¡,IKEAFISHINABOWL¢0ARENTS¤ PERCEPTIONSOFCHILDPROTECTIONSERVICES#HILD!BUSE 2EVIEW
WILLDEPENDONHOWTHEYSEETHEMSELVESRELATING TOTHEWORLDAROUNDTHEM-EANINGTHEREFORE CANNOTBEDISCONNECTEDFROMTHESETSOFBELIEFS
(OFSTEDE ' #ULTURE¤SCONSEQUENCES )NTERNATIONALDIFFERENCESINWORK RELATEDVALUES .EWBURY0ARK3AGE
ANDVALUESTHATWEALLHOLDANDTHATDRIVETHE WAYWETHINKANDACT(OWDOESMEANING MAKINGHELPTHISPARTICULARFAMILYCONFRONTTHE
(OLLAND 3 4HEASSESSMENTRELATIONSHIP )NTERACTIONSBETWEENSOCIALWORKERSANDPARENTSIN CHILDPROTECTIONASSESSMENTS"RITISH*OURNALOF3OCIAL 7ORK
DIFFICULTIESAHEADOFTHEM (OWDOTHEYMAKE SENSEOFWHATHASHAPPENED )STHISDIFFERENT FROMTHEWAYINWHICHTHESOCIALWORKERMAKES
(WA &ROELICH $! 6IGIL $# 4HREE ASPECTSOFCULTURALINFLUENCEONCOMMUNICATION !LITERATUREREVIEW#OMMUNICATION$ISORDERS
SENSEOFIT !NDHOWDOTHEMEANINGSWEASCRIBE INFLUENCEOURATTITUDESTOWARDDIFFERENCE POWER ANDCONNECTEDNESS
+OERNER !& &ITZPATRICK - 4OWARDA THEORYOFFAMILYCOMMUNICATION#OMMUNICATION 4HEORY
#ONCLUSION 3UPERVISIONPROVIDESANOPPORTUNITYTOEXPLORE
,EE - !SOLUTION FOCUSEDAPPROACHTO CROSS CULTURALCLINICALSOCIALWORKPRACTICE5TILIZING CULTURALSTRENGTHS&AMILIESIN3OCIETY
ALTERNATIVEEXPLANATIONSANDINTERVENTIONS FORCHILDPROTECTIONPRACTICE"YPROACTIVELY CONSIDERINGCULTURALCOMPONENTSINPRACTICE
-ACNAMARA *2 4HECRUCIALROLEOFRESEARCH INMULTICULTURALANDCROSS CULTURALCOMMUNICATION *OURNALOF#OMMUNICATION-ANAGEMENT
WEHAVEANOPPORTUNITYTODEVELOPMORE COMPLEXUNDERSTANDINGOFHOWCULTUREAND
-C,ENNAN ' 2YAN ! 3POONLEY 0 %XPLORINGSOCIETY3OCIOLOGYFOR.EW:EALAND STUDENTS 3ECOND%DITION!UCKLAND0EARSON0RENTICE (ALL
DIVERSITYINFLUENCERELATIONSHIPDYNAMICS WITHINANDACROSSSYSTEMS'ROUPSUPERVISIONIN PARTICULARHASTHEPOTENTIALTOENHANCECULTURAL PRACTICEBYEXPLORINGCULTURALEXPERIENCEFROM
-UNFORD 23ANDERS * 3UPPORTINGFAMILIES 0ALMERSTON.ORTH$UNMORE0RESS
MULTIPLEPERSPECTIVES)NTHESHARINGOFCULTURAL EXPERIENCEWECANMOREREADILYGAININSIGHTINTO ALTERNATIVECULTURALLANDSCAPES
2EDER 0 $UNCAN 3 5NDERSTANDING COMMUNICATIONINCHILDPROTECTIONNETWORKS#HILD !BUSE2EVIEW
2%&%2%.#%3
3ALEEBEY $ 4HESTRENGTHSPERSPECTIVEIN SOCIALWORKPRACTICE.EW9ORK,ONGMAN
"LUE "ANNING - 3UMMERS *! &RANKLAND ( .ELSON ,"EEGLE ' $IMENSIONSOF FAMILYANDPROFESSIONALPARTNERSHIPS#ONSTRUCTIVE GUIDELINESFORCOLLABORATION%XCEPTIONAL#HILDREN
4HOMPSON . "RITISH!SSOCIATIONOF3OCIAL 7ORKERS !NTI DISCRIMINATORYPRACTICE 4HIRD %DITION"ASINGSTOKE0ALGRAVE 7EICK ! 3ALEEBEY $ 3UPPORTINGFAMILY STRENGTHS/RIENTINGPOLICYANDPRACTICETOWARDTHE STCENTURY&AMILIESIN3OCIETY
#ONNOLLY - #RICHTON (ILL 9 7ARD 4 #ULTUREANDCHILDPROTECTION2EFLEXIVERESPONSES ,ONDON*ESSICA+INGSLEY0UBLISHERS
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
7ISE 3 &AMILYSTRUCTURE CHILDOUTCOMES ANDENVIRONMENTALMEDIATORS!NOVERVIEWOFTHE DEVELOPMENTINDIVERSEFAMILIESSTUDY-ELBOURNE !USTRALIAN)NSTITUTEOF&AMILY3TUDIES
$R-ARIE#ONNOLLYISTHE#HIEF3OCIAL7ORKERATTHE -INISTRYOF3OCIAL$EVELOPMENT 9VONNE#RICHTON (ILLHASBEENA3ENIOR,ECTURERWITH THE3CHOOLOF3OCIAL7ORKAND(UMAN3ERVICESATTHE 5NIVERSITYOF#ANTERBURYSINCE3HEIS$EPUTY#HAIR OF0ACIFIC4RUST#ANTERBURYANDISAMEMBEROFTHE3OCIAL 7ORKERS¥2EGISTRATION"OARD 4ONY7ARDIS0ROFESSOROF#LINICAL0SYCHOLOGYAT6ICTORIA 5NIVERSITYOF7ELLINGTON(EHASWORKEDASACLINICAL PSYCHOLOGISTANDANACADEMICINANUMBEROFSETTINGS AND HASASMALLPRIVATEPRACTICE
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
Revitalising supervision education through stories of confirmation and difference: The case for interprofessional learning ,IZ"EDDOEAND!LLYSON$AVYS )NTRODUCTION
ANDLEARNINGAPPROACHESFORNEWSUPERVISORS ACROSSARANGEOFPROFESSIONS
3UPERVISIONHASLONGBEENANIMPORTANT COMPONENTOFONGOINGLEARNINGAND
)NRECENTYEARSWEHAVEFACILITATEDMANYHOURS
DEVELOPMENTFORSOCIALWORKERS'RAUEL
OFSUPERVISIONEDUCATIONFORMIXEDGROUPSOF
/VERTHEPASTYEARSWEHAVESEENTHE
PROFESSIONALS ALLOFWHOMSHAREDAPURPOSETO
DEVELOPMENTOFAMOREFOCUSEDAPPROACHTO
LEARNTOBECOMEEFFECTIVESUPERVISORS)NOUR
BESTPRACTICEINTHEHEALTH SERVICES0ARTOFTHATFOCUS HASBEENTHEINCLUSIONOF SUPERVISIONINTOPRACTICE ACCOUNTABILITYFORMANY OTHERPROFESSIONS¡HELPING PROFESSIONS¢(AWKINS
REFLECTIONONTHESETEACHING
0WFSUIFQBTUZFBSTXF IBWFTFFOUIFEFWFMPQNFOU PGBNPSFGPDVTFEBQQSPBDI UPCFTUQSBDUJDFJOUIF IFBMUITFSWJDFT
3HOHET NURSING
ANDLEARNINGEXPERIENCES WEFORMEDTHEVIEWTHAT INTERPROFESSIONALLEARNING CANSTRENGTHENAREFLECTIVE APPROACHBYENABLING PARTICIPANTSTOQUESTION TAKEN FOR GRANTEDPROFESSIONAL
"OND(OLLAND
ASSUMPTIONS THROUGH
MENTALHEALTH3CAIFE HEALTH3POUSE
DISCUSSIONANDEXPLORATIONOFMATERIALFROM
2EDFERN PHYSIOTHERAPY3ELLARS 4HE
DIVERSEPRACTICECONTEXTS
SEARCHTOEXPLOREBESTMETHODSFORSUPERVISOR DEVELOPMENTHASOFTENLEDHEALTHANDSOCIAL
,EARNINGTHESKILLSOFSUPERVISIONTOGETHER
CAREORGANISATIONSTODEVELOPTRAININGWITH
INANINTERACTIVELEARNINGENVIRONMENT
SUPERVISIONEDUCATORSWHOHAVESOCIALWORK
PROVIDESANEXCELLENTOPPORTUNITYTODEVELOP
BACKGROUNDS3INCETHES THEAUTHORS BOTH
THEINTERPROFESSIONALRESPECTANDCOLLEGIALITY
SOCIALWORKERS HAVEBEENDEVELOPINGTEACHING
ESSENTIALTOEFFECTIVESERVICEDELIVERYINHEALTH
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
ANDSOCIALCARE4HISARTICLEIDENTIFIESASETOF
"EDDOE 7ETHENPRESENTANEXAMPLEFROM
POSSIBILITIESANDCHALLENGESFORCONSIDERATIONIN
TEACHINGTHATILLUSTRATESTHEUSEFULNESSOFTHIS
TEACHINGANDLEARNINGABOUTSUPERVISIONPRACTICE
LEARNINGENVIRONMENT
WITHINAMULTIDISCIPLINARYLEARNINGSETTING
7ORKINGTOGETHERMESSAGESFROMRESEARCH
4HEACCEPTEDWISDOMISTHATSOCIALWORK SUPERVISIONINCLUDESTHEPRIMARYFUNCTIONOF
)NTHEFIRSTEDITIONOFTHEIREXCELLENTTEXTFOR
EDUCATION SUPPORTANDADMINISTRATION)NHERENT
SUPERVISIONINTHEHELPINGPROFESSIONS (AWKINS
INFUNCTIONALISTMODELSOFSUPERVISIONISA
AND3HOHET IDENTIFIEDTHEWAYSINWHICH
TENDENCYTOMINIMISETHETENSIONSTHATARISE
INTERPROFESSIONALANDINTERAGENCYDYNAMICS
BETWEENTHESEFUNCTIONSINTHEORGANISATIONAL
COULDHINDEREFFECTIVESERVICESTOCLIENTSOF
CONTEXTSINWHICHSOCIALWORKERSPRACTICE
HEALTHANDSOCIALCARESERVICES7ITHREFERENCE
(UGHESAND0ENGELLY¤S£TRIANGLE¤OFSUPERVISORY
TOASERIESOFCASESTUDIES THEYILLUSTRATEDTHE
FUNCTIONSPRACTITIONERWORK SERVICEDELIVERY
DIFFICULTIESTHATCANARISEWHEN¡PROFESSIONALSARE
ANDPROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENT APTLYREPRESENTS
NOTONLYFAILINGTOWORKTOGETHERBUTAREALSO
THESETENSIONSANDPROVIDESAFRAMEWORKFOR
ENACTINGSOMEOFTHETYPICALINTERPROFESSIONAL RIVALRIESENDEMICWITHIN
IDENTIFICATIONANDSUPPORTIVE EXPLORATIONOFPRACTICE DILEMMAS(UGHES0ENGELLY )NSOMEFIELDSOFSOCIAL WORK PARTICULARLYCHILD PROTECTIONANDMENTALHEALTH THECURRENTPRACTICEAND
*OSFDFOUEFDBEFT IFBMUI BOETPDJBMTFSWJDFTIBWF NPWFEUPXBSETSFEVDJOH UIFQSPCMFNTBUUFOEBOUPO SJHJEQSPGFTTJPOBMUFSSJUPSJFT
ANDBETWEENTHEIRROLES¢ (AWKINS3HOHET P )NSOCIALWORKWEDO NOTNEEDMUCHREMINDINGOF HOWOFTENINTERPROFESSIONAL ANDINTERAGENCYISSUESCAN
SOCIALCLIMATEHASENCOURAGED
CAUSEPROBLEMSINCAREAND
ATENDENCYFORRISK
PROTECTION JUSTICEANDMENTAL
MANAGEMENTANDPOLICYCOMPLIANCETODOMINATE
HEALTH3TANLEY-ANTHORPE 2IVALRY
SUPERVISION ATTHEEXPENSEOFCRITICALLYREFLECTIVE
STATUSGAMESANDASSUMPTIONSCANALLIMPACTON
PRACTICEANDLEARNING)NADDITION AFOCUSON
HOWPEOPLEWORKTOGETHER
IN HOUSEPROCEDUREANDDECISION MAKINGMAY
5NDERPINNINGTHISCONFLICTANDRIVALRYIS
LEAVELITTLESPACEFORSOCIALWORKERSTOCONSIDER
THEHISTORYOFTHEDEVELOPMENTOFDIFFERENT
THEPOTENTIALFORGREATERPARTNERSHIPWORKING
PROFESSIONS(ALL DESCRIBINGTHEEVOLUTIONOFTHE
WITHOTHERPROFESSIONALS3UPERVISIONPROVIDESAN
HEALTHPROFESSIONS SUGGESTS¡EACHPROFESSION
OPPORTUNITYFORSUPERVISORSTOBRINGACONSCIOUS
HASSTRUGGLEDTODEFINEITSIDENTITY VALUES
CONSIDERATIONOFPROFESSIONALPERSPECTIVESAND
SPHEREOFPRACTICEANDROLEINPATIENTCARE4HIS
ASSUMPTIONSTOCRITICALREFLECTIONANDDECISION
HASLEDTOEACHHEALTHCAREPROFESSIONWORKING
MAKING
WITHINITSOWNSILOTOENSUREITSMEMBERSHAVE
4HISARTICLEPROVIDESABRIEFREVIEWOF
COMMONEXPERIENCES VALUES APPROACHESTO
INTERPROFESSIONALLEARNINGFORSUPERVISION
PROBLEM SOLVINGANDLANGUAGEFORPROFESSIONAL
ANDTHENGOESONTOSHAREPARTICIPANTS¤
TOOLS¢ P $URINGTHEIRPRE SERVICE
EXPERIENCESOFLEARNINGABOUTSUPERVISIONINAN
EDUCATION EACHGROUPNOTONLYLEARNSTHE
INTERPROFESSIONALGROUP3UBSTANTIVEFINDINGS
ESSENTIALKNOWLEDGEANDSKILLSFORTHEPRACTICEOF
FROMTHISSTUDYCANBEFOUNDIN$AVYS
THEIRPROFESSIONBUTTHEYALSOBECOMESOCIALISED
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
INTOTHEVALUESANDNORMSOFTHEIRVOCATION
BETWEENMEMBERSOFDIFFERENTPROFESSIONAL
(ALLAND7EAVERSUGGESTTHATEACHPROFESSION
GROUPS¢/WENS 'OBLE 'RAY P
MIGHT¡ATTRACTAPREDOMINANCEOFINDIVIDUALS
4HISDEFINITIONISUSEFULINTHISCONTEXTASIT
WITHAPARTICULARSETOFCOGNITIVELEARNINGSKILLS
EMPHASISESTHENATUREOFTHELEARNINGPROCESS
ANDSTYLES¢AGAININFLUENCINGTHETHINKINGAND
RATHERTHANJUSTTHELEARNINGOUTCOMES
PROBLEMSOLVINGSTYLESOFDIFFERENTDISCIPLINES
)NTERPROFESSIONALEDUCATIONFORTHESUPERVISOR
P
ROLEISANATTRACTIVEOPTIONFORBOTHEMPLOYERS
)NRECENTDECADES HEALTHANDSOCIALSERVICES
ANDEDUCATIONPROVIDERS)TENABLESSTAFFTO
HAVEMOVEDTOWARDSREDUCINGTHEPROBLEMS
RECEIVETRAININGINMORECOSTEFFECTIVEGROUPS
ATTENDANTONRIGIDPROFESSIONALTERRITORIES3MITH
ANDPROVIDESOPPORTUNITIESFORORGANISATIONS
AND!NDERSON ATTRIBUTETHISFOCUSTOA
TODEVELOPCOHERENTPOLICIESANDCONSISTENT
NUMBEROFFACTORSTHE¡INCREASINGSENSEOF
PRACTICESINSUPERVISIONACROSSPROFESSIONAL
INTERDEPENDENCYARISINGFROMTHERECOGNITION
GROUPS
OFTHEHOLISTICNATUREOF NEEDS¢THECHALLENGESOF WORKINGINCOMPLEXSYSTEMS THEINFLUENCEOFSYSTEMS ANDECOLOGICALPERSPECTIVES ANDTHERECOGNITIONOF THERIGHTSOFSERVICEUSERS WHICH¡WHETHERDRIVEN BYCONSUMERISTIDEASOR
2ECENTRESEARCHIN.EW
0VSFYQFSJFODFJO UFBDIJOHNJYFEHSPVQTPG QSPGFTTJPOBMTJTUIBUXIFO QBSUJDJQBOUTXPSLUPHFUIFS UIFJSEJGGFSFODFTJOFWJUBCMZ DSFBUFUIFOFFEGPS FYQMBOBUJPOBOEFYQMPSBUJPO
:EALANDEXAMINEDEVIDENCE FROMASMALLQUALITATIVESTUDY OFPARTICIPANTS¤VIEWSON LEARNINGININTERPROFESSIONAL SUPERVISIONPROGRAMMES $AVYS"EDDOE 4HESTUDYFOUNDTHATTHE INTERPROFESSIONALLEARNING
PRINCIPLESOFSOCIALJUSTICE
ENVIRONMENTDEEPENED
REQUIREDTHEDEVELOPMENTOF
THEEXPLORATIONANDLEVEL
RESPONSESWHICHCROSSEDARBITRARYORGANISATIONAL
OFUNDERSTANDINGABOUTSUPERVISIONAND
BOUNDARIES¢3MITH!NDERSON PP
ENCOURAGEDPARTICIPANTSTOQUESTIONTAKEN
)NTERPROFESSIONALLEARNINGISONEMAJORSTRATEGY
FOR GRANTEDPROFESSIONALASSUMPTIONS4HE
ADOPTEDBYSOMEGOVERNMENTAGENCIESTOMEET
IDENTIFICATIONOFDIFFERENCEBETWEENPARTICIPANTS
THESECHALLENGES
WASSEENTOENHANCETHEBREADTHOFLEARNINGAND PARTICIPANTSWERECHALLENGEDTOCLARIFYIDEASAND
7HILEINTERPROFESSIONALLEARNINGISAMAJOR
LANGUAGE)NSUMMARY
TOPICOFSCHOLARSHIP RESEARCHANDCURRICULUM DEVELOPMENTINTHE5NITED+INGDOM ITISNOT
¢2ESPONDENTSTHOUGHTTHATSAME PROFESSION
PARTICULARLYCOMMONIN.EW:EALANDBEYOND
LEARNINGCONTEXTSWOULDENCOURAGELESS
THEHEALTHSECTOR INWHICHITOCCURSMAINLY
DIVERSITYOFOPINION MOREASSUMPTIONSWOULD
AMONGSTTHEMEDICALANDPHYSICALTHERAPIES
BEMADE THEREWOULDBEAGREATERTENDENCY
)NTERPROFESSIONALLEARNINGMAYINCLUDE
TOLOSEFOCUS MOREADVICEGIVINGANDLESS
UNDERGRADUATETEACHINGOFPRE SERVICESTUDENTS
REFLECTION3OMEEXPRESSEDANOPINIONTHAT
INHEALTHANDSOCIALCAREFIELDSANDPROFESSIONAL
SAME PROFESSIONGROUPSWOULDINCREASE
DEVELOPMENTFORQUALIFIEDPROFESSIONALS)N
COMPETITIVENESSANDREINFORCEHIERARCHIES
THISARTICLEITISDEFINEDASMEANING¡THOSE
4HERECOULDBEMORECAUTIONABOUTREVEALING
OCCASIONSWHEREINTERACTIVELEARNINGTAKESPLACE
INADEQUACIES£$AVYS"EDDOE P
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
/UREXPERIENCEINTEACHINGMIXEDGROUPSOF
)TISOUREXPERIENCETHATMULTIDISCIPLINARY
PROFESSIONALSISTHATWHENPARTICIPANTSWORK
EXPLORATIONOFPRACTITIONERSTORIESCANLEADTO
TOGETHERTHEIRDIFFERENCESINEVITABLYCREATETHE
THEENRICHMENTOFSUPERVISION0ARTICIPANTSARE
NEEDFOREXPLANATIONANDEXPLORATION OFTEN
ENCOURAGEDTOSHAREIDEAS EXPERIENCESAND
ADDINGDEPTHTOTHELEARNINGEXPERIENCEITSELF
VALUESINRELATIONTOPRACTICESCENARIOSFROM
4HISISILLUSTRATEDBYONETHEPARTICIPANTSINOUR
HEALTHANDSOCIALCARE WHICHINTURNALLOWS
STUDY
SIMILARITIESANDDIFFERENCESTOEMERGEANDTOBE CONSIDERED4HEDISCOVERYOFSIMILARITIESASMUCH
)TWASBROADERTHANJUSTLEARNINGABOUT
ASDIFFERENCEDEVELOPSRESPECTANDCOLLEGIALITY
CLINICALSUPERVISIONWITHOTHERDISCIPLINES)
7HILESUPERVISIONMUSTHAVECONSIDERABLE
THINKIT¥SSEEINGHOWOTHERDISCIPLINESTHINK
ALIGNMENTWITHPROFESSIONALPRACTICEGUIDELINES
AROUNDSUPPORTINGORHELPINGOTHERS;NURSE=
ETHICSANDAGENCYREQUIREMENTS THEBROADER
$IRKX 'ILLEYAND'ILLEY P SUGGEST
FOCUSOFSUPERVISIONALLOWSITTOTRANSCEND
THATFOREDUCATORSTOBEABLETOPROVIDE
PROFESSIONALBOUNDARIES7HENSUPERVISIONIS
PROFESSIONALSWITHLEARNINGEXPERIENCESTHAT
FREEDFROMTHEMINUTIAEOFCLINICALCONTENTAND
GIVETHEM¡SOMETHING)CAN USEON-ONDAYMORNING¢ THEREMUSTBEOPPORTUNITYTO BALANCECONTENTORTECHNICAL KNOWLEDGEWITH£STORIES¤THAT ENABLEPEOPLETOMAKESENSE OFNEWIDEAS4HISASSISTS PRACTITIONERSTO¡TRANSFORM THESEGENERALITIESINTOUSEFUL PRACTICALKNOWLEDGE BUT
PROCEDURE THEGENERICNATURE
8IFOTVQFSWJTJPOJT GSFFEGSPNUIFNJOVUJBF PGDMJOJDBMDPOUFOUBOE QSPDFEVSF UIFHFOFSJD OBUVSFPGQSPGFTTJPOBM TVQFSWJTJPOQSBDUJDF DPNFTUPUIFGPSF
OFPROFESSIONALSUPERVISION PRACTICECOMESTOTHEFORE )TISHERETHATBEGINNINGAND EXPERIENCEDSUPERVISORSFIND THAT REGARDLESSOFPROFESSION PRACTITIONERSOFTENBRINGTHE SAMETHINGSTOSUPERVISION STRESS ANXIETY CONFLICT ETHICALANDMORALDILEMMAS
INSTRUGGLINGWITHTHEIR
£STUCKNESS¤ANDSOFORTH
APPLICATION THEIREXPERIENCEOFPRACTICEISALSO
)TISHERETHATINTERPROFESSIONALGROUPS INAN
TRANSFORMED!SONESEEKSTOMAKESENSEOF
INTERACTIVELEARNINGENVIRONMENT AREABLETO
NEWINFORMATIONORTECHNICALSKILLSWITHINTHE
SHARETHEIRKNOWLEDGEANDEXPERIENCE4HIS
CONCRETENESSOFPRACTICE THEMEANINGOFBOTHIS
CONFIRMATIONOFCOMMONPURPOSEANDOFTEN
RECONSTRUCTED¢$IRKXETAL P 4HISCANLEAD
SHAREDVALUESABOUTWORKINGWITHPEOPLECREATES
TOADEEPERUNDERSTANDINGOFONE¤SPROFESSIONAL
AGOODMEDIUMFORDEEPERLEARNING
£LENS¤WITHWHICHWESEEPRACTICE ASEXPRESSED AGAINBYONEOFOURPARTICIPANTS
3MALLGROUPWORKUSINGSCENARIOSCANPROVIDE OPPORTUNITIESFORSTORIESOFCONFIRMATIONAND
.URSINGBASICALLYIS;DOING=SUCHINTIMATE WORKWITHPEOPLETHATWESTILLTENDTOWANT
DIFFERENCETOEMERGE4HEREISPEDAGOGICAL
TODOFOROTHERSANDFIXITANDIFANYTHING)
SUPPORTFORTHEUSEOFSCENARIOMATERIAL
HEARFROMOTHERPROFESSIONSABOUTTHEHANDS
INLEARNINGFORREFLECTIVEPRACTICEINTHE
OFFANDLETTINGPEOPLEDOFORTHEMSELVES
PROFESSIONS&ROMTEACHEREDUCATION 3ANTORO
ANDENABLING THATWORD)HEARWHEN)¥M
AND!LLARD P SUGGESTANUMBEROF
LISTENINGTOOTHERPROFESSIONSAND)LEARN
CHARACTERISTICSOFUSEFULSCENARIOSFORUSEIN
FROMTHAT;NURSE=
LEARNINGCONTEXTS
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
4HECASEOF4IMOTHY
3CENARIOS¡SHOULDBE£REALISTIC¤ANDREFLECTIVE OFSITUATIONSTHATPRACTITIONERSARELIKELYTO ENCOUNTERINTHEIRPARTICULARFIELDS¢
9OURSUPERVISEE 4IMOTHY WHOWORKSINA COMMUNITYHEALTHSETTING COMESTOSUPERVISION
3CENARIOS¡BASEDONCOMMONTHEMESTHAT EMERGEFROMSTORIESOFPRACTICE¢PROVIDE FAMILIARCONTENT
WITHTHEFOLLOWINGSITUATION(EISPROVIDINGPOST OPERATIVEWOUNDCAREFOR-ELISSA WHOHAS MULTIPLE CHRONICHEALTHPROBLEMS4HETREATMENT
!LTHOUGHUSINGCOMMONTHEMATICMATERIALS SCENARIOSMUSTALSOBESUFFICIENTLY DISTINGUISHEDFROMTHEPARTICIPANTS¤EVERYDAY PROFESSIONALCONTEXTS¡SOTHATTHEYHAVE THEOPTIONOFVOLUNTARILYIDENTIFYINGWITH THESCENARIO)NTHISWAY THEYCANREFLECT UPONANDINTERROGATETHEIROWNBELIEFSAND PRACTICESWITHMINIMUMTHREATTOTHEIR PERSONALINTEGRITY¢
PLANWASPROVIDEDBYTHESURGICALREGISTRARAT THEHOSPITALAND-ELISSAISDUETOGOBACKINFOR ACHECK UPNEXTWEEK4HEPARENTSOFTHECHILD AREALSOENGAGINGTHESERVICESOFANALTERNATIVE HEALER4HEALTERNATIVEHEALERDOESNOTSUPPORT THEMEDICALTREATMENTANDTHEPARENTSARE FOLLOWINGTHEHEALER¥SREGIME4HEALTERNATIVE TREATMENTISVERYEXPENSIVE AND4IMOTHYKNOWS
&ORTHESCENARIOS¡TORESONATEWITHARANGE OFPARTICIPANTSONANINDIVIDUALLEVEL THEY MUSTINCORPORATEMULTIPLEPERSPECTIVESWHICH PARTICIPANTSCANDRAWUPONINRELATIONTO THEMSELVES¢
THATTHEFAMILYISONAVERYLIMITEDBUDGETANDIS ALREADYINDEBT(EHASHADCONVERSATIONSWITH THEPARENTSANDTHEHEALERTONOAVAIL4IMOTHY HASTALKEDTOTHEFAMILY¥S'0WHOADVISED
¡3CENARIOSDONOTHAVETOFOCUSONFINDING SOLUTIONSTOPROBLEMS¢3TORIESOFSUCCESS CANPROVIDERICHOPPORTUNITIESFORDISCUSSION ANDDEBATETHROUGHTHEPRESENTATIONOFBOTH CONFIRMINGANDALTERNATIVEVIEWS
SEEKINGANEARLIERCHECK UPAPPOINTMENTIFTHE FAMILYWON¥TBRING-ELISSAINTOHERSURGERY 4HEALTERNATIVETREATMENTISNOTWORKINGAND THEWOUNDISNOWINFECTED ANDATTODAY¥SHOME VISIT-ELISSACOMPLAINEDOFCONSIDERABLEPAIN
4HEFOLLOWINGEXAMPLEISPROVIDEDINORDERTO
4HECOMMUNITYHEALTHSOCIALWORKERANGRILY
ILLUSTRATETHEPOTENTIALOFINTERPROFESSIONAL
TOLD4IMOTHYINTHESTAFFROOMTHATTHISIS
SUPERVISIONLEARNINGCONTEXTS!GROUPOF
BORDERINGONACHILDPROTECTIONISSUEANDHEHAS
LEARNERSFROMSEVERALPROFESSIONS ANDINCLUDING
TODOSOMETHINGSOON4IMOTHYISFEELINGTORN
SOCIALWORKERSFROMBOTHHEALTHANDCHILD
BETWEENHISCONCERNFOR-ELISSAANDHISDESIRETO
PROTECTIONCONTEXTS ISPRESENTEDWITHTHIS
MAINTAINARELATIONSHIPWITHTHEPARENTS
SCENARIOINASUPERVISIONCOURSE)NTHISCASE ITISAPROBLEM BASEDSCENARIO BUTITISUSEFUL
4HETASKFORTHEGROUPWASTOIDENTIFYTHEMAIN
BECAUSEITHASHIGHLYEMOTIONALCONTENT
ISSUESFORSUPERVISION)NEVITABLY SUPERVISION
CONTAINSTHESEEDSOFINTERPROFESSIONALDIFFERENCE
ISSUESWERELEFTTOONESIDEWHILETHISGROUP
ANDCONFLICT ANDISHIGHLYREALISTICASTHEKIND
OFCONFIDENTANDEXPRESSIVEPROFESSIONALS
OF£WORRY¤ACLINICALPRACTITIONERMIGHTBRING
RESPONDEDTOTHECONTENT7E¤LLLETTHEREADER
TOSUPERVISION WHERECLINICALINTHISCASE
DECIDEWHOMIGHTHAVESAIDWHATINTHISLISTOF
MEDICAL KNOWLEDGEISNOTTHEMAINDIMENSION
COMMENTS
OFTHEPROBLEM4HISEXAMPLEISFICTIONAL AND WHILEITHASBEENUSEDINTEACHINGSETTINGSON
"ORDERINGONCHILDPROTECTION ITISABUSE
MANYOCCASIONS THEDISCUSSIONTHATFOLLOWSAND
4HERE¥SACLEARDUTYOFCAREHERE
THEVIEWSEXPRESSEDBYTHEPROFESSIONALSARE
7HATABOUTFAMILYRIGHTSANDEMPOWERING
FICTIONALISEDANDACOMPOSITEOFMANYDIFFERENT
PEOPLE
DISCUSSIONS
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
4HEPARAMOUNTRIGHTSOFTHECHILD
THERETOHELP)THINKBACKTOWHEN)WASA
7HATABOUTTHEVIEWSOFTHERESTOFTHE
STUDENTANDINMYEARLYDAYSOFNURSING )
WHiNAU
KNEWNOTHINGOFOTHERDISCIPLINES ABSOLUTELY NOTHING;NURSE=
(ASANYONETALKEDTO-ELISSA )T¥SASIMPLETHING THEYHAVETOBETOLD
(ALL CITING0ETRIE SUGGESTS
THEY¥LLLOSEHERIFTHEYDON¥TCOMPLYWITH
THATPRACTITIONERSDEVELOPACOGNITIVEMAP
TREATMENT
WHERE ALONGSIDEEACHINDIVIDUAL¤SPERSONAL
(E¥SGOTTOREFERHERTO#HILD 9OUTHAND
CHARACTERISTICSANDEXPERIENCE THEIRVALUES
&AMILY
ANDBELIEFSDETERMINESOMEKEYASPECTOFTHEIR PRACTICE(ALL P 0ROFESSIONALVALUES
.OHE¥SRIGHT HEHASTOMAINTAINTHE
ALSOEMPHASISEASPECTSOFWORKINGWITHSERVICE
RELATIONSHIP SHE¥SALONG TERMCLIENT
USERSDIFFERENTLY&ORSOMEPROFESSIONS SCIENCE
9ES BUTSHECOULDDIEIFSHEGETSBLOOD
RULESDECISION MAKINGANDINTERACTIONWITH
POISONING
SERVICEUSERSFOROTHERS LISTENINGTOCLIENT
4HEFAMILYLOVESHERTHEY¥RETRYINGTODOTHE
STORIESISWHATISVALUED,ANGUAGEISOFTEN
RIGHTTHING
ANIMPORTANTMEANSOFDIFFERENTIATION AND DISCUSSIONSLIKETHATABOVEWHILEABOUTA
!FTERSOMEANIMATED DISCUSSION THEGROUPWAS ABLETOFOCUSMOREONTHE SUPERVISIONISSUES4HEYCAME UPWITHAVERYSENSIBLEPLAN TOSUPPORTTHESUPERVISEE 4HEIREXPLORATIONOFTHE ISSUESINTHESCENARIOENABLED THEMTODEBATETHEIRVARIOUS PERSPECTIVESONTHISCASE AND FREEDFROMTHEUSUALPOWER
SPECIFICASPECTOFSUPERVISION
5IFJSFYQMPSBUJPOPGUIF JTTVFTJOUIFTDFOBSJP FOBCMFEUIFNUPEFCBUF UIFJSWBSJPVTQFSTQFDUJWFT POUIJTDBTF BOEGSFFEGSPN UIFVTVBMQPXFSEZOBNJDT UIFEJTDVTTJPOXBTSPCVTU BOEQBTTJPOBUF
OFTENHIGHLIGHTTHEDIFFERENT WAYSOFDESCRIBINGWHATWE DO )PROBABLYDIDPICKITUPIN THESUPERVISIONTRAINING IS OFTENYOUTHINKINYOUROWN PROFESSION ¤WHYDON¥TPEOPLE UNDERSTANDME ¥7ELLBECAUSE THEYDON¥TSPEAKTHESAME LANGUAGEFORASTART THAT¥S
DYNAMICS THEDISCUSSION WASROBUSTANDPASSIONATE4HELEARNERSENJOYED
WHYTHEYDON¥TUNDERSTANDYOU4HEYDON¥T
THEOPPORTUNITYTOHAVETHISDISCUSSION AND
KNOWTHESAMETHINGSTHATYOUKNOW4HEY
WEREQUICKLYABLETORETURNTHEIRFOCUSON
DON¥TSEETHEWORLDINTHESAMEWAYTHAT
THESUPERVISIONISSUESWHILEREALISINGTHAT
YOUDOAND)THINK;FOR=THECOMMUNICATION
THEYHADTHINGSTOLEARNFROMTHEDIFFERENCES
WITHOTHERPROFESSIONALGROUPS IT¥SREALLY
INTHEIRAPPROACHESTOTHESAMESITUATION
IMPORTANT;SOCIALWORKER STUDYPARTICIPANT=
/NEPARTICIPANTRECALLEDHERINITIALTRAINING
-ARSH ARGUESTHATTHEREISASUBSTANTIAL
WHENREFLECTINGONLEARNINGALONGSIDEOTHER
AGENDAOFWORKFORPRIMARYCAREANDSOCIAL
PROFESSIONALS
WORKTOPROVIDEBETTERHEALTHCAREANDCHILD PROTECTION BUTASKSFORGREATERCONCEPTUAL
)THINKTHEMORETHATWECANLEARNAND
CLARITYANDRESEARCHTOPROVIDEEVIDENCEOF
DEVELOPSIDEBYSIDE THEMOREWECANWORK
WHATWORKS-ARSHSUGGESTSKEYELEMENTSMAY
ASATEAMTOHELPTHECLIENTSTHATWE¥RE
INCLUDEKNOWINGABOUTTHEOTHERPROFESSIONALS¤
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
PRACTICES BEINGABLETOCOMMUNICATEWELL
IDENTIFYPERSISTENTISSUESOFSTATUSAND
ACROSSDISCIPLINES ANDDIRECTLYWORKING
POWERASBARRIERS BUTNEVERTHELESSCONCLUDE
TOGETHER"ARBOURETAL¤SSTUDYFOUNDTHAT
THATTHEREISMUCHTOBEOPTIMISTICABOUT
DIFFICULTIESBETWEENCHILDPROTECTIONANDMENTAL
)N.EW:EALANDWENEEDANAPPLICATIONOF
HEALTHSERVICESOFTENFOCUSEDONTHEDIFFERENT
ENERGYANDNEWIDEASTOTHEDEVELOPMENTOF
THRESHOLDSANDCODESOFPRACTICEADOPTEDBY
INTERPROFESSIONALLEARNINGFORSOCIALWORKAND
EACHPROFESSIONANDLEDTOCONFLICTAROUNDRISK
THEHEALTHPROFESSIONS7HILETHEREARESOME
ASSESSMENT"ARBOUR 3TANLEY 0ENHALE(OLDEN
SMALLFORAYSINTOINTERPROFESSIONALLEARNINGIN
PP )NTHESEANDOTHERSITUATIONS
THEHEALTHSECTOR THISISLIMITEDTOPRACTICEIN
WHERECONFLICT ROLEANDBOUNDARYISSUES
NARROWCLINICALSETTINGSANDARECENTSEARCH
MAYPUTCLIENTANDWORKEROUTCOMESATRISK
FOUNDLITTLEMENTIONOFSOCIALWORK)TISOUR
SUPERVISORSHAVEAKEYROLETOPLAY
VIEWTHATOPPORTUNITIESFORINTERPROFESSIONAL LEARNINGSHOULDBEEMBRACED ASTHEYPROVIDE
#HALLENGES 2ECENTEMPHASISON INTERPROFESSIONALWORKIS UNDERPINNEDBYTHEIDEALSOF COLLABORATIONANDINSOME COUNTRIES THEPRAGMATIC CONSIDERATIONOFDIRECTIVES INGOVERNMENTPOLICY
CONFIRMATIONOFTHETHINGS
'PSTPNFQSPGFTTJPOT TDJFODFSVMFTEFDJTJPO NBLJOHBOEJOUFSBDUJPO XJUITFSWJDFVTFST GPS PUIFST MJTUFOJOHUPDMJFOU TUPSJFTJTXIBUJTWBMVFE
HELDINCOMMONAMONGST DISCIPLINES ANDBUILDRESPECT FORTHEDIFFERENCESTHATMAKE EACHPROFESSIONALCONTRIBUTION UNIQUE7HILEPERHAPSONLY ASMALLCONTRIBUTIONTOAN INTERPROFESSIONALPROGRAMME
0OLICYMAKERSHOPETHAT
FORHEALTHANDSOCIALCARE
IMPROVEDCOLLABORATION
PROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENTIN
WILLLEADTOMOREEFFECTIVEANDEFFICIENT
PRACTICETEACHING SUPERVISION LEADERSHIPAND
SERVICES)SSUESOFPOWERANDORGANISATIONAL
MANAGEMENTMAYPROVIDERICHOPPORTUNITIES
CULTUREARENOTUSUALLYAFFORDEDMUCH
FORIMPROVINGTHECULTURE,EARNINGTOFOCUS
ATTENTIONINTHEPOLICYREALM2ATHER THEREIS
ONRELATIONSHIPSANDMUTUALITYRATHERTHAN
ANEXPECTATIONTHATBYDECREEINGTHATITWILL
KNOWLEDGEFROMANDFORSPECIFICCLINICALDOMAINS
BESO COLLABORATIONWILLHAPPEN3MITHAND
ISPOTENTIALLYTRANSFORMATIVE4HEFINALWORD
!NDERSON P POINTOUTTHATTHERE
GOESTOONEOFOURPARTICIPANTSWHOFOUND
IS HOWEVER AFAIRLYBROADCONSENSUSTHAT
INTERPROFESSIONALLEARNINGLEDTOA
POWERISAPRESENTANDPOTENTISSUEINBOTHTHE RELATIONSHIPSBETWEENPROFESSIONALANDSERVICE
2ICHINTERCHANGEOFIDEAS EXPOSEDTOOTHER
USERS ANDTHEPROFESSIONALSTHEMSELVES!MONGST
WAYSOFTHINKINGOTHERSASKQUESTIONSTHAT
THEPROFESSIONALSTHEREAREISSUESOFSTATUSAND
CHALLENGEOWNDISCIPLINE¥SWISDOM)ALSOLIKE
POWERTHATSTILL¡REPRESENTSIGNIFICANTCHALLENGES
TOUNDERSTANDHOWOTHERDISCIPLINESTHINK
TOEFFECTIVEINTERPROFESSIONALWORKING¢3MITH
ANDCONCEPTUALISEISSUES
P
!CKNOWLEDGEMENTS #ONCLUSION
4HEAUTHORSWISHTOACKNOWLEDGETHEVERYMANY
2EVIEWSOFPROGRESSININTERPROFESSIONALLEARNING
WONDERFULSUPERVISIONCOURSEPARTICIPANTSWHO
BY3MITHAND!NDERSON AND(UDSON
HAVECONTRIBUTEDTOTHEIDEASINTHISARTICLE
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
-ARSH 0 0ROMOTING#HILDRENS7ELFAREBY )NTER PROFESSIONAL0RACTICEAND,EARNINGIN3OCIAL 7ORKAND0RIMARY#ARE3OCIAL7ORK%DUCATION
4HERESEARCHWASSUPPORTEDBYTHE5NIVERSITYOF !UCKLAND3TAFF2ESEARCH&UND
2 % & % 2 % . # % 3 "ARBOUR 23 3TANLEY . 0ENHALE " (OLDEN 3 !SSESSINGRISK0ROFESSIONALPERSPECTIVESON WORKINVOLVINGMENTALHEALTHANDCHILDCARESERVICES *OURNALOF)NTERPROFESSIONAL#ARE
/WENS # 'OBLE 2 'RAY $0 )NVOLVEMENTINMULTIPROFESSIONALCONTINUING EDUCATION!LOCALSURVEYOFHEALTHCARE PROFESSIONS*OURNALOF)NTERPROFESSIONAL#ARE
"OND - (OLLAND 3 3KILLSOFCLINICAL SUPERVISIONFORNURSES"UCKINGHAM/PEN5NIVERSITY 0RESS
3ANTORO . !LLARD ! 3CENARIOSAS SPRINGBOARDSFORREFLECTIONONPRACTICE3TIMULATING DISCUSSION2EFLECTIVE0RACTICE
$AVYS ! "EDDOE , 5NPUBLISHEDPAPER £)NTERPROFESSIONALLEARNINGFORSUPERVISION£4AKING THEBLINKERSOFF¤¤3CHOOLOF3OCIAL$EVELOPMENT 7AIKATO)NSTITUTEOF4ECHNOLOGY (AMILTON.EW :EALAND
3CAIFE * 3UPERVISIONINMENTALHEALTH PROFESSIONS%AST%SSEX"RUNNER2OUTLEDGE 3ELLARS * ,EARNINGFROMCONTEMPORARY PRACTICE!NEXPLORATIONOFCLINICALSUPERVISIONIN PHYSIOTHERAPY,EARNINGIN(EALTHAND3OCIAL#ARE
$IRKX *- 'ILLEY *7 'ILLEY !- #HANGETHEORYIN#0%AND(2$4OWARDSAHOLISTIC VIEWOFLEARNINGANDCHANGEINWORK!DVANCESIN $EVELOPING(UMAN2ESOURCES
3MITH 2 3OCIALWORKANDPOWER"ASINGSTOKE 0ALGRAVE-ACMILLAN 3MITH 2 !NDERSON %3 )NTERPROFESSIONAL ,EARNING!SPIRATIONORACHIEVEMENT 3OCIAL7ORK %DUCATION ACCESSED*UNEFROM WWWINFORMAWORLDCOM
'RAUEL 4 0ROFESSIONAL/VERSIGHT4HE NEGLECTEDHISTORIESOFSUPERVISION)N--C-AHON 70ATTON%DS 3UPERVISIONINTHE(ELPING 0ROFESSIONS!PRACTICALAPPROACH&RENCHS&OREST .370RENTICE(ALL
3POUSE * 2EDFERN ,%DS 3UCCESSFUL SUPERVISIONINHEALTHCAREPRACTICE,ONDON"LACKWELL 3CIENCE
(ALL 0 )NTERPROFESSIONALTEAMWORK 0ROFESSIONALCULTURESASBARRIERS*OURNALOF )NTERPROFESSIONAL#ARE SUPPLEMENT
3TANLEY . -ANTHORPE *%DS 4HE!GE OFTHE)NQUIRY,EARNINGANDBLAMINGINHEALTHAND SOCIALCARE,ONDON2OUTLEDGE
(ALL 0 7EAVER , )NTERDISCIPLINARY EDUCATIONANDTEAMWORK!LONGANDWINDINGROAD -EDICAL%DUCATION (AWKINS 0 3HOHET 2 3UPERVISIONINTHE HELPINGPROFESSIONS-AIDENHEAD "ERKSHIRE/PEN 5NIVERSITY0RESS
,IZ"EDDOEISTHE(EADOFTHE3CHOOLOF#OUNSELLING (UMAN3ERVICESAND3OCIAL7ORKATTHE5NIVERSITYOF !UCKLAND .EW:EALAND3HETEACHESUNDERGRADUATEAND POSTGRADUATEPAPERSINSOCIALWORK HEALTHPRACTICEAND PROFESSIONALSUPERVISION
(AWKINS 0 3HOHET 2 3UPERVISIONINTHE HELPINGPROFESSIONS 4HIRD%DITION-AIDENHEAD/PEN 5NIVERSITY0RESS (UDSON " )NTERPROFESSIONALITYINHEALTHAND SOCIALCARE4HE!CHILLESHEELOFPARTNERSHIP *OURNAL OF)NTERPROFESSIONAL#ARE
!LLYSON$AVYSISTHE(EADOF3CHOOLOF3OCIAL$EVELOPMENT AT7INTEC3HEHASPRESENTEDAT.EW:EALANDAND !USTRALIANCONFERENCESANDHADWORKPUBLISHEDIN .EW:EALANDANDIN"RITAINONMANYASPECTSOF PROFESSIONALSUPERVISION
(UDSON " 0ESSIMISMANDOPTIMISMININTER PROFESSIONALWORKING4HE3EDGEFIELD)NTEGRATED 4EAM*OURNALOF)NTERPROFESSIONAL#ARE (UGHES , 0ENGELLY 0 3TAFFSUPERVISION INATURBULENTENVIRONMENT-ANAGINGPROCESSAND TASKINFRONT LINESERVICES,ONDON*ESSICA+INGSLEY
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
Practice note: Launching the supervision triggers .OVA3ALOMEN $EVELOPINGTHESUPERVISIONPRACTICETRIGGERS
¢4HISYEAR#HILD 9OUTHAND&AMILYINTRODUCED SUPERVISIONTRIGGERSASENHANCEMENTSTO
7EHELDTHREEFOCUSGROUPSAROUNDTHECOUNTRY
THE.EW:EALANDPRACTICEFRAMEWORKS£
INVOLVINGSTAFFFROMRESIDENCES ADOPTIONS CARE
#ONNOLLY
ANDPROTECTIONANDYOUTHJUSTICE4HESEGROUPS
7ITHINTHE.EW:EALANDCONTEXT PRACTICE
WEREORGANISEDACCORDINGTOROLES TOALLOW
TRIGGERSPROVIDEREMINDERSTHATSUPPORTGOOD
PRACTITIONERSTOEXPRESSTHEMSELVESWITHINTHEIR
PRACTICE!SANEXTENSIONOFTHEPRACTICE
PEERGROUP4HEFOCUSGROUPSWEREASKEDTO
FRAMEWORKS SUPERVISIONTRIGGERSHAVEBEEN
DESCRIBETHEFOLLOWING
DESIGNEDTOPROVIDESUPERVISORSWITHREMINDERS
POSITIVEEXAMPLESOFHOWASANINDIVIDUALYOU DEMONSTRATEVALUINGSUPERVISION
THATSUPPORTGOODSUPERVISIONPRACTICE 4HETRIGGERSWEREINITIATED TOSTRENGTHENPROFESSIONAL SUPERVISIONANDSUPPORTTHE DEVELOPMENTOFACULTURE THATENABLESPROFESSIONAL PRACTICETODELIVERQUALITY SERVICESTOCHILDREN YOUNG
4VQFSWJTJPOUSJHHFSTIBWF CFFOEFTJHOFEUPQSPWJEF TVQFSWJTPSTXJUISFNJOEFST UIBUTVQQPSUHPPE TVQFSWJTJPOQSBDUJDF
PEOPLEANDTHEIRFAMILIES
P OSITIVEEXAMPLESOFHOW MANAGEMENTVALUEAND SUPPORTSUPERVISION H OWBARRIERSORBLOCKSTO SUPERVISIONAREMANAGED H OWTHEPRACTICE FRAMEWORKSRELATETOTHE PRACTICEOFSUPERVISION
5SINGTHESTORIESGATHEREDFROMTHEFOCUSGROUPS
-ORRISON STATES¡T HEFACTTHAT
ANEXPERTGROUPOFPRACTITIONERSCOMPRISING
SUPERVISIONTAKESPLACEISNOGUARANTEEIN
REPRESENTATIVESFROMALLAREASOFPRACTICE
ITSELFTHATSERVICEUSERSWILLBEBENEFICIARIES
DEVELOPEDANUMBEROFTRIGGERSORPROMPTS
)TALLDEPENDSONTHEQUALITYANDFOCUSOF
DESIGNEDTOSUPPORTSUPERVISIONPRACTICE
SUPERVISION¢#HILD 9OUTHAND&AMILYHASA
WITHINTHEORGANISATION4HESEWEREGROUPED
DEPTHOFPRACTICEKNOWLEDGEANDEXPERIENCEIN
INTOSIGNIFICANTAREASFOREXAMPLE WORKER
THEAREAOFCHILDWELFARESUPERVISION7ITHTHIS
WELLBEINGSUPPORT RELEVANTTHEORIES ANDCLINICAL
INMIND WEWANTEDTOCAPTUREANDPROMULGATE
QUESTIONS4HEEXPERTGROUPAGREEDTOUSESOME
ASPECTSOFTHISEXPERTISETOENHANCESUPERVISION
OFTHETRIGGERSINTHEIRSUPERVISIONPRACTICE
PRACTICEACROSSTHEORGANISATION
TOASSESSTHEIRIMPACTANDUSABILITYINTHE SUPERVISIONSESSION
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
0RACTICETRIGGERSASENHANCEMENTSTOTHE PRACTICEFRAMEWORKS
!REVIEWOFTHELITERATUREANDINSIGHTSGAINED FROMPRACTICEREVIEWSALSOADDEDTOTHE KNOWLEDGEBASE4HEREVIEWSPROVIDEDEVIDENCE
!CCORDINGTO#ONNOLLYAND(EALYINPRESS
THATHIGHLIGHTEDCERTAINPRACTICEISSUESFOR
PRACTICEFRAMEWORKSINTEGRATE
SUPERVISORSANDPRACTITIONERSTOCONSIDERWHEN DISCUSSINGCASES4HESEISSUESINCLUDEDVIOLENCE
¢%MPIRICALRESEARCH PRACTICETHEORIES ETHICAL
ORINTIMIDATIONAGAINSTPRACTITIONERS ENGAGING
PRINCIPLESANDEXPERIENTIALKNOWLEDGEINA
WITHCHILDRENANDYOUNGPEOPLE ANDTHE
COMPACTANDCONVENIENTFORMATTHATHELP
IMPORTANCEOFAVOIDINGEPISODICPRACTICE
PRACTITIONERSTOUSETHEKNOWLEDGEAND PRINCIPLESTOINFORMTHEIREVERYDAYWORK
!FTERCONSULTATIONANDTESTING THETRIGGERSWERE
"ASEDONRESEARCHFINDINGS ¤GOODPRACTICE¥
NARROWEDDOWNTOTHREEKEYAREASCONTAININGA
PRINCIPLESANDNATURALJUSTICEFORCLIENTS THEY
TOTALOFEIGHTTRIGGERS4HETRIGGERSARE
PROVIDECLARITYWITHRESPECTTOUNDERSTANDING THECRITICALASPECTSOFTHESOCIALWORKTASK
#HILD YOUNGPERSONANDFAMILYFOCUSED
ANDTHEMEANSTHROUGHWHICHKNOWLEDGECAN
(OWISSUPERVISIONENCOURAGING ENGAGEMENTWITHTHECHILDORYOUNG PERSONANDTHEIRFAMILYTOBRINGABOUT CHANGE (OWISSUPERVISION STRENGTHENING PARTICIPATIONOFTHE CHILD YOUNGPERSONAND THEIRFAMILYWHiNAUIN SAFEDECISION MAKING 3TRENGTHENINGPRACTICE
INFLUENCEINTERVENTIONPATHWAYS£ 0RACTICETRIGGERSARETHE
5IFUSJHHFSTQSPWJEFB GPDVTBOEFOBCMFSFGMFDUJWF QSBDUJDF CPUICFGPSF EVSJOH BOEIPQFGVMMZBGUFS UIFTVQFSWJTJPOTFTTJPO
KEYMECHANISMSUSEDIN THE0RACTICE&RAMEWORKS TOINTEGRATERESEARCHAND KNOWLEDGEINTOPRACTICE #ONNOLLY "ASEDON EVIDENCEANDBESTPRACTICE LITERATURE THEYAREDESIGNED
(OWISHISTORICALCASE MATERIALBEINGCONSIDEREDTOENSUREWEARE SEEINGTHEWHOLEPICTURE
TOBRINGKNOWLEDGEABOUT WHATWORKSINTOPRACTICE ANDTOPROVIDEA QUICKANDSIMPLEREMINDERFORPRACTITIONERSIN
(OWARETHEPRACTICEFRAMEWORKSBEING USEDTOGUIDECASEWORKANALYSISAND DECISION MAKING
KEYAREASOFPRACTICE)N3EPTEMBER THE VULNERABLEINFANTPRACTICETRIGGERSWERERELEASED TOPROMPTAWARENESSABOUT ANDREFLECTIONON
/NASCALEOFTO HOWISYOUR WORKLIFEBALANCE (OWISTHISINFLUENCING PRACTICE
KEYISSUESRELATINGTOOURWORKWITHCHILDREN UNDERTWOYEARSOFAGE#ONNOLLY 7ELLS&IELD &EEDBACKFROMACROSSTHECOUNTRYON
7ORKERSAFETYANDONGOINGDEVELOPMENT
THEUSABILITYANDSTRAIGHTFORWARDNESSOFTHE
(OWISSUPERVISIONBUILDINGONPRACTICE STRENGTHSANDENCOURAGINGONGOING PROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENTANDLEARNING
VULNERABLEINFANTTRIGGERSWASOVERWHELMINGLY POSITIVE4HEDEVELOPMENTOFTHESUPERVISION
(OWAREWORKERSAFETYISSUESBEING IDENTIFIEDANDEXPLORED (OWISTHEIMPACT OFINTIMIDATIONORTHREATENINGBEHAVIOUR BEINGADDRESSED
TRIGGERSHASMIRROREDTHEPROCESSANDBOTHSETS
(OWISSUPERVISIONADDRESSINGANY DANGEROUSDYNAMICSINPRACTICE
4HESUPERVISIONTRIGGERSAREGROUPEDINTOTHREE
OFTRIGGERSAREREGARDEDASENHANCEMENTSTOTHE PRACTICEFRAMEWORKS
KEYAREASTOSTRENGTHENTHEIRMEANINGANDTO
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
REINFORCETHEIRRELATIONTOASPECIFICFUNCTION
2%&%2%.#%3
OFTHESUPERVISIONPROCESS FOREXAMPLESUPPORT
#ONNOLLY - 0RACTICEFRAMEWORKS #ONCEPTUALMAPSTOGUIDEPRACTICEINCHILDWELFARE "RITISH*OURNALOF3OCIAL7ORK
ANDEDUCATION4HETRIGGERSPROVIDEAFOCUSAND ENABLEREFLECTIVEPRACTICE BOTHBEFORE DURING
#ONNOLLY - (EALY + 3OCIALWORKPRACTICE THEORIESANDFRAMEWORKS)N-#ONNOLLYAND, (ARMS%DS 3OCIAL7ORK#ONTEXTSANDPRACTICE 3ECOND%DITION#HAPTER-ELBOURNE/XFORD 5NIVERSITY0RESS
ANDHOPEFULLYAFTER THESUPERVISIONSESSION 4HEYCANALSOBEUSEDDURINGCASECONSULTATIONS ORDEBRIEFINGSWHENCONSIDERINGACERTAIN ACTIONORRESPONSEBYAWORKER4HEYPROVIDE
#ONNOLLY - 7ELLS 0 AND&IELD * 7ORKING WITHVULNERABLEINFANTS3OCIAL7ORK.OW
THEOPPORTUNITYFORCHALLENGEANDTODISCUSS DIFFERINGPRACTICEPOSITIONSANDDECISIONS4HEY
-ORRISON 4 3TAFF3UPERVISIONIN3OCIAL#ARE "RIGHTON 5+0AVILION
CANBEUSEDINANYWORKPRACTICECONTEXTASWELL ASPEERANDGROUPSUPERVISIONSETTINGS 4HESIMPLICITYOFTHETRIGGERSASSISTSPRACTITIONERS TOCONSIDERCERTAINTHEMESTHEYMAYNOTBE AWAREOFORTHINKINGABOUT&OREXAMPLE BY
.OVA3ALOMENISA3ENIOR!DVISORINTHE/FFICEOFTHE#HIEF 3OCIAL7ORKER WITHAPARTICULARINTERESTINTHEAREAOF STAFFWELLBEINGANDSUPERVISION
HIGHLIGHTINGTHATVIOLENCEORINTIMIDATIONOCCURS ALLOWSPRACTITIONERSTOBRINGITOUTINTOTHE OPEN RATHERTHANTHINKING¡ITISJUSTPARTOFTHE JOB¢ PARTICULARLYINARESIDENTIALSETTINGWHERE AWORKERMAYBEREPEATEDLYTHREATENEDBYA YOUNGPERSON4HISISNOTACCEPTABLE ANDTHE TRIGGERALLOWSTHEPRACTITIONER THESUPERVISOR ANDTHEMANAGERTOADDRESSTHECONCERNAND SUPPORTTHEWORKER 4HETRIGGERSWEREDISTRIBUTEDTOPRACTITIONERS IN*ULY ALONGWITHARESOURCEPACKTHAT CONTAINSRELEVANTARTICLESONTHESUBJECTOF SUPERVISIONANDINFORMATIONSHEETSONHOWTO USETHETRIGGERS4HEYEASILYSLIPINTOTHE#$CASE ANDCANALSOBETRANSPORTEDINADIARYORVISITING BOOKFORQUICKANDEASYREFERENCE4RAININGIS ANINTEGRALPARTOFIMPLEMENTINGTHETRIGGERS ANDSITESHAVEBEENPROVIDEDWITHMATERIALTO SUPPORTTHIS
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
Book reviews 0ASSIONATESUPERVISION
!PASSIONATESUPERVISORSEESTHEBIGGER PICTURE3UPERVISEESOFTENGETCAUGHTUPIN THEIRCLIENT¤SSTORIESANDCAN¤TSEEBEYOND THEMSUPERVISORSNEEDTOHELPTHEIR SUPERVISEESSEETHATTHESESTORIES HOWEVER POWERFULANDMOVING AREJUSTSTORIESAND THATLIFEEXISTSOUTSIDEOFTHEM
&EJUFECZ3PCJO4IPIFU 1VCMJTIFEJOCZ+FTTJDB,JOHTMFZ1VCMJTIFST -POEPO 2EVIEWEDBY*ONELLE#RAWFORD
!PASSIONATESUPERVISORISFULLYPRESENT ATEACHSUPERVISIONSESSION7HENTHE SUPERVISIONSESSIONSTARTS THESUPERVISOR¤S MIND BODYANDSPIRITARECOMPLETELYENGAGED ANDTUNEDINTOTHESUPERVISEE
2OBIN3HOHET APRACTISINGPSYCHOTHERAPISTAND ORGANISATIONALCONSULTANT HASBEENPROVIDING SUPERVISIONTRAININGFORORGANISATIONSINTHE HELPINGPROFESSIONSINTHE5NITED+INGDOM
!PASSIONATESUPERVISORLOVESTHEIRWORKAND ISDEEPLYINTERESTEDANDCURIOUSINTHEWORK OFTHEIRSUPERVISEES
SINCE3HOHETISWIDELYPUBLISHED ANDIS BESTKNOWNFORCO AUTHORING3UPERVISIONINTHE HELPINGPROFESSIONSFIRSTPUBLISHEDIN
!PASSIONATESUPERVISORISAROLEMODEL4HEY MODELCOURAGE OPENNESS STEADFASTNESSAND OPTIMISMABOUTTHEPOSSIBILITYFORCHANGE ANDTHEYALSOMODELAGOODWORKLIFE BALANCE
WHICHISREGARDEDASGROUND BREAKINGINTHE DEVELOPMENTOFSUPERVISIONANDSUPERVISION TRAINING )NHISLATESTBOOK 3HOHETHASASKEDSUPERVISORS
!PASSIONATESUPERVISORHELPSTHESUPERVISEE SEETHEWORLDTHROUGHNEWEYES2ATHER THANSUPERVISIONJUSTBEINGAPLACEFORTHE SUPERVISEETOREFLECTONTHEIRPRACTICE THEY AREENCOURAGEDTOGETTOKNOWNEWASPECTS OFTHEMSELVESANDMOVEOUTOFTHEIRCOMFORT ZONE
FROMTHEFIELDSOFEDUCATION PSYCHOTHERAPY COACHING YOUTHWORK ANDHOMEOPATHYTO EXPLAINWHATMAKESTHEM£PASSIONATE¤ABOUT THEIRROLEANDABOUTSUPERVISIONINGENERAL 3HOHETALSOCONTRIBUTESHISOWNCHAPTERTOTHE BOOK
4HEABOVEVIEWSARENOTNECESSARILYNEWOR
4HECONTRIBUTORSSPEAKOPENLYANDHONESTLY
ENLIGHTENING BUTTHEYSERVETOREMINDUSOF
ABOUTTHEIREXPERIENCESBOTHASSUPERVISEESAND
WHATISKNOWNBUTMAYNOTALWAYSBEPUTINTO
SUPERVISORS ANDPROVIDECASEEXAMPLESAND
PRACTICE
SHORTSTORIESTOILLUSTRATETHEIRPERSPECTIVES
4HEREWERETWOCHAPTERSINPARTICULARTHAT
)NTERESTINGLY DESPITETHEDIFFERINGFIELDS
STOODOUTFORME4HEFIRSTISBY*OE7ILMOT A
WITHINWHICHTHESESUPERVISORSWORKANDTHEIR
SUPERVISORWITHEXPERIENCEWORKINGWITHYOUNG
VARYINGDEGREESOFSUPERVISORYEXPERIENCE THEY
PEOPLEINSCHOOLS(ISCANDIDACCOUNTOFHIS
EXPRESSVERYSIMILARVIEWSABOUTWHATMAKESA
FEARSONEMBARKINGONTHESUPERVISORROLEIS
£PASSIONATE¤SUPERVISOR
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
REFRESHING ANDHISSTYLEOFWRITINGISENGAGING ANDDOWN TO EARTH4HEOTHERISWRITTENBY*ULIE (EWSON ASUPERVISORWITHABACKGROUNDIN TEACHING3HEMAKESTHEPOINTTHATSUPERVISORS NOTONLYCAREFORTHEIRSUPERVISEES BUTTHEYARE ALSO¡ENGAGEDINTHETEACHINGANDDEVELOPMENT PROCESSOFTHEINDIVIDUALPROFESSIONAL¢P 4HISCOMMENTPERFECTLYILLUSTRATESTHE IMPORTANCEOFTHESUPERVISORROLE 4HEBOOKALSOCONTAINSSOMEIDEASTHATCOULDBE UTILISEDINASUPERVISORYRELATIONSHIP4HEIDEA OFINCORPORATINGCREATIVITYINTOTHERELATIONSHIP THROUGHROLEPLAY DRAWING ORUSINGITEMSTO REPRESENTORSYMBOLISEFEELINGSORBELIEFSIS PROMOTEDBYSEVERALOFTHESUPERVISORS4WOOF THECONTRIBUTORSINCLUDEQUESTIONSTHATCOULD BEUSEDTOENCOURAGEOPENDIALOGUEBETWEEN THESUPERVISORANDSUPERVISEEABOUTTHEIR RELATIONSHIPANDPRACTICE3OMEALSOPROVIDE ALISTOFADDITIONALRESOURCESANDINFORMATION ABOUTSUPERVISION 0ASSIONATE3UPERVISIONHASAFOCUSONSPIRITUALITY THATMAYNOTAPPEALTOEVERYONE(OWEVER THEBOOKISPOSITIVE AFFIRMING ANDOFFERS USEFULINSIGHTSINTOTHEWORLDOFSUPERVISION PARTICULARLYINTERMSOFHOWSUPERVISIONLOOKSIN DIFFERENTFIELDSOFWORK ANDITWOULDBERELEVANT FORALLSUPERVISORSANDSUPERVISEES *ONELLE#RAWFORDISTHE1UALITY!DVISORFOR#HILD 9OUTHAND &AMILY¥S"AYOF0LENTY3ERVICE#ENTRE
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
Social Work Now */'03."5*0/ '03 $0/53*#65034 #HILD 9OUTHAND&AMILY ASERVICEOFTHE
)FYOUWOULDLIKETOSUBMITANARTICLEORREVIEW
-INISTRYOF3OCIAL$EVELOPMENT WELCOMES
TO3OCIAL7ORK.OW ORIFYOUHAVEANYQUERIES
SUBMISSIONSFOR3OCIAL7ORK.OWONTOPICS
PLEASECONTACT*O&IELD -ANAGER0ROFESSIONAL
RELEVANTTOSOCIALWORKPRACTITIONERSANDSOCIAL
0RACTICE /FFICEOFTHE#HIEF3OCIAL7ORKER ON
WORK ANDWHICHAIMTOPROMOTEPROFESSIONALISM
OREMAILJOANNFIELD CYFGOVTNZ
ANDPRACTICEEXCELLENCE3OCIAL7ORK.OWISA PUBLICLYFUNDEDJOURNALTHATISAVAILABLEFREEOF
3UBMISSIONSMAYBESENTBYEMAILTO
CHARGE3UBMISSIONSPUBLISHEDINTHEJOURNALARE
SOCIALWORKNOW CYFGOVTNZ
MADEAVAILABLEONTHE#HILD 9OUTHAND&AMILY WEBSITEWWWCYFGOVTNZ3OCIAL7ORK.OWHTM
%DITORIALREQUIREMENTS
ANDTHROUGHELECTRONICLIBRARYDATABASES
4HEGUIDELINESLISTEDBELOWAREASUMMARYOFTHE 3OCIAL7ORK.OWEDITORIALREQUIREMENTS)FYOU
3UBMISSIONS
WOULDLIKETODISCUSSANYASPECTOFTHEM PLEASE
3UBMISSIONSMAYINCLUDE
GETINTOUCH
3UBSTANTIVEARTICLESSUBSTANTIVEARTICLESOF AROUND WORDSFOCUSINGONA THEMEAREGENERALLYREQUESTEDBYSPECIFIC INVITATIONTOTHEAUTHOR)FYOUWOULDLIKE TOSUBMITANARTICLE PLEASEEMAILJOANN FIELD CYFGOVTNZ
!LLWORKMUSTBETHEORIGINALWORKOFTHE AUTHORS HAVEALTEREDNAMESANDOTHERDETAILS TOPROTECTCLIENTCONFIDENTIALITY ANDSHOW WHERERELEVANT THATTHECASEHASBEENFOLLOWED UPOVERASPECIFIEDPERIOD
0RACTICEARTICLESCONTRIBUTIONSFORPRACTICE ARTICLESAREWELCOMEDFROMSOCIALWORKERS OTHER#HILD 9OUTHAND&AMILYSTAFF AND PROFESSIONALSWORKINGWITHINTHEWIDERFIELD !RTICLESCANINCLUDEACCOUNTSOFINNOVATIVE WORKPLACEPRACTICE CASEREPORTS RESEARCH EDUCATION REVIEWARTICLES CONFERENCEAND WORKSHOPREPORTS ANDSHOULDBEAROUND WORDS
3UBMISSIONSSHOULDNOTHAVEBEENPUBLISHED BEFOREORBEUNDERCONSIDERATIONFORPUBLICATION ELSEWHERESHOULDNOTCONTRAVENEANYLAWS INCLUDINGTHOSEOFDEFAMATIONANDPRIVACY SHOULDDISCLOSEANYCONFLICTOFINTERESTAND SHOULDMEETANYAPPLICABLEETHICALORRESEARCH STANDARDS3UBMISSIONSSHOULDNOTVIOLATEA
2EVIEWSWEALSOWELCOMEBOOKREVIEWSAND THESESHOULDBEAROUNDWORDS
THIRDPARTY¤SINTELLECTUALPROPERTYRIGHTSAND
7EAPPRECIATEAUTHORSMAYBEATVARYINGLEVELS
SHOULDTHESEBEREQUIREDFORMATERIALSOURCED
OFFAMILIARITYWITHPROFESSIONALJOURNALWRITING
FROMOTHERCOPYRIGHTEDPUBLICATIONS ETC
7EAREAVAILABLETOTALKTHROUGHIDEASANDTO
-3$RESERVESTHERIGHTTOCONSIDERPUBLISHING
DISCUSSHOWBESTTOPRESENTYOURINFORMATION
ANYSUBMISSIONIN3OCIAL7ORK.OWTHATHAS
THEAUTHORSWILLHAVEOBTAINEDANYPERMISSIONS
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
BEENPUBLISHEDELSEWHERE WHERETHEREQUIRED
AGREETOLICENCE-3$TOPUBLISHYOURSUBMISSION
PERMISSIONSHAVEBEENOBTAINED BUTPREFERENCE
ONTHEFOLLOWINGTERMS
WILLBEGIVENTOORIGINALSUBMISSIONS
9OUAGREETOCOMPLYWITHTHESEGUIDELINES
0LEASEKEEPNOTESTOAMINIMUMANDFOLLOW
9OUWARRANTTHATYOUHAVETHERIGHT ORHAVE OBTAINEDSUCHAUTHORISATIONORTHERELEVANT LICENCES ASMAYBEREQUIRED INCLUDINGFROM ANYCO AUTHORSOFTHESUBMISSION
THEREFERENCINGFORMATINTHISISSUE2EFERENCES SHOULDONLYINCLUDEPUBLICATIONSDIRECTLY REFERREDTOINTHETEXTANDNOTBEACOMPLETE
9OUGRANTANON EXCLUSIVEANDPERPETUAL LICENCETO-3$INORDERFOR-3$TO
REVIEWOFTHELITERATUREUNLESSTHATISTHE PURPOSEOFTHEARTICLE 0HOTOGRAPHSAND
REPRODUCE PUBLISH COMMUNICATEOR DISSEMINATEYOURSUBMISSIONINANYMEDIA FORMATINCLUDINGINHARDCOPY ONTHE #HILD 9OUTHAND&AMILYWEBSITE ELECTRONIC LIBRARYDATABASES ORVIAINFORMATION SERVICEPROVIDERS ASPARTOF3OCIAL7ORK .OW
ILLUSTRATIONSAREALWAYSWELCOMEBLACKAND WHITEORCOLOUR !LLARTICLESWILLBECONSIDEREDBYSTAFFINTHE #HIEF3OCIAL7ORKER¤S/FFICE -3$WILLNOTMAKEANYPAYMENTFORCONTRIBUTIONS
REPRODUCEYOURSUBMISSIONFREEOF CHARGEFORTHENON COMMERCIALPURPOSES OFEDUCATION STUDYANDORRESEARCH WITHOUTREQUIRINGSPECIFICPERMISSION FROMYOUNOTETHATSUCHREPRODUCTION WILLBECONDITIONALONYOURSUBMISSION BEINGREPRODUCEDACCURATELY INCLUDING ACKNOWLEDGEMENTOFYOURAUTHORSHIP AND NOTBEINGUSEDINAMISLEADINGCONTEXT
TO3OCIAL7ORK.OWANDDOESNOTHOLDITSELF RESPONSIBLEFORSTATEMENTSMADEBYAUTHORS
#OPYRIGHT )NMOSTINSTANCES COPYRIGHTINASUBMISSION MADETO3OCIAL7ORK.OWWILLBEOWNEDBY -3$7HENYOUARETHEAUTHORANDCOPYRIGHT
ALLOWYOURSUBMISSIONTOBEDISSEMINATED ASAWHOLEORPARTOFTHETEXT IMAGE ANDOTHERCONTENTCONTAINEDWITHIN YOURSUBMISSIONINTEXT IMAGE OTHER ELECTRONICFORMATORSUCHOTHERFORMAT ORONSUCHOTHERMEDIUMASMAYNOW EXISTORHEREAFTERBEDISCOVERED ASPART OFELECTRONICPRODUCTSDISTRIBUTEDBY INFORMATIONSERVICEPROVIDERS
OWNEROFYOURSUBMISSION YOURETAINCOPYRIGHT INYOURSUBMISSION BUTINORDERTOPUBLISH YOURSUBMISSION-3$NEEDSTOOBTAINALICENCE FROMYOUAND IFRELEVANT ANYOTHERAUTHORS BEFOREWECANPUBLISHIN3OCIAL7ORK.OW-3$ ACKNOWLEDGESYOURMORALRIGHTTOBEIDENTIFIED ASTHEAUTHOROFTHESUBMISSION 7HEREYOUDONOTOWNTHECOPYRIGHTINYOUR
0LEASENOTETHAT-3$WILLNOTPAYYOUFORTHE
SUBMISSION FOREXAMPLEWHEREYOUREMPLOYER
LICENCEORRIGHTTOPUBLISHYOURSUBMISSION
OWNSTHECOPYRIGHT YOUMUSTENSURETHATTHE
-3$WILLNOTBENEFITFROMANYFINANCIALGAIN
COPYRIGHTOWNERHASAUTHORISEDYOUTOLICENCE
WHATSOEVERASARESULTOFYOUGRANTINGSUCHA
THESUBMISSIONUNDERTHETERMSSETOUTINTHESE
LICENCE
GUIDELINES "YPUTTINGFORWARDYOURSUBMISSIONTO-3$FOR PUBLICATIONIN3OCIAL7ORK.OW YOUANDANY OTHERAUTHORSOFYOURSUBMISSIONIFAPPLICABLE
3/#)!, 7/2+ ./7 !5'534
40$*"-803,/08
!IMS
.. . 4OPROVIDEDISCUSSIONOFSOCIALWORK
PRACTICEIN#HILD 9OUTHAND&AMILY .. . 4OENCOURAGEREFLECTIVEANDINNOVATIVE
SOCIALWORKPRACTICE .. . 4OEXTENDPRACTICEKNOWLEDGEINANYASPECT
OFADOPTION CAREANDPROTECTION RESIDENTIALCAREANDYOUTHJUSTICEPRACTICE .. . 4OEXTENDKNOWLEDGEINANYCHILD FAMILY
ORRELATEDSERVICE ONANYASPECTOF ADMINISTRATION SUPERVISION CASEWORK GROUPWORK COMMUNITYORGANISATION TEACHING RESEARCH INTERPRETATION INTER DISCIPLINARYWORK ORSOCIALPOLICYTHEORY ASITRELATESTOPROFESSIONALPRACTICE RELEVANTTO#HILD 9OUTHAND&AMILY ANDTHEWIDERSOCIALWORKSECTOR
"GPDVTPOTVQFSWJTJPO )MPROVINGREASONINGINSUPERVISION 2ETHINKINGSUPERVISIONANDSHAPINGFUTUREPRACTICE 'ROUPSUPERVISIONINCHILDPROTECTIONPRACTICE &AMILIES CULTUREANDSUPERVISION 2EVITALISINGSUPERVISIONEDUCATIONTHROUGHSTORIESOF CONFIRMATIONANDDIFFERENCE4HECASEFORINTERPROFESSIONAL LEARNING ,AUNCHINGTHE£SUPERVISIONTRIGGERS¤
