Details of a computer cluster built using Pentium 4 processors with a fast ethernet ... from Pentium 4 machines and a 100MBits/second fast ethernet network are.
!#" $% &' ()+* ) , -.0/ %1&,2,"3546378&9 :=?A@B>C3DFEHGJIH:K LM?A?ONFPOQRI>S,;UTVLM?AWYXMZ[G XRZ>E]\;H:_^A?OC C^a` bdc,e_f!gih_jlkmfAnpoqjsrutv3w9xRtYyYhYfAtJzYxRtYyMh_fAtJzR{|xR}~3 MzU
_orqn lj jlvJfah_ jlh_fafAnpjlhYh_orpjsrpYrpf zYgih_jlkmfAnpoqjsrtv3wiYOR h_y>zM{fOf33hy #9hRkRjsnpvhYfahJroqvlkmfAnpo[3npfYnpfaoqfAhRrpfay! hy!3h3l« tM¢oq£¥fy#¤a¦aj§h]¨_©a¦vª_3npjloqvh8rpvdor3hyY3ny]or3fOnpfy8oqvlkmfAn®rpeYfioqe_fAfao$jlo$h_vhM«¬faljlMrpjijlh±rpe_f
YnpfaoqoqMnpf
²_fayrrpeYf
3npjyoqa lf®M{YfAnq« jl3rpfA®Hn¯¹aloq_fOonprpjfO3n± _ YfahYjllOr2eY_oqjl3h_np1µEC×1ÏN¡C3Z_^
POLMD¡ØMC3?aP ; Ë|Ì C!ÐUÍU?aÏ Ì XMPOC|LRÎ¥DFXR?AWMC|POÏ XRD¡C|^OÍU?AZÒÙMC3Ú @dXYÏ Ì N¡ZUC P N¡P¯ÖHC ÚMLYZ>E8^ Ì CXMÖUND¡N^pÚ#LMÎ
@XRZÚ]PO@XRD¡DÛiLY@dÐUÍ^AXR^ON¡LMZ>XMD$ÜD¡ÍUN¡EÞÝ Ú_XRZ>XM@dN¡Ï P ß ÛÜ,Ý2àάXYÏN¡DN^ON¡C P ;=áάXR?dÏ Ì CXRÐ[C3?XMD^AC3?AZ>XJ^ANØYC1NFP^ Ì C#ÍHPC#LRÎÔLM?AÙYÒqP^AXJ^ANLYZ¾ÏD¡Í>P^OC3?aP ; :Í>Ï Ì Î¬XYÏN¡DN^ON¡C PXR?AC¯Ï3LM@dÐU?AN¡POC E1LRÎ$P^AXMZ>EUXR?aEdLRâ8^ Ì C2P Ì C DÎ$EUC POÙ^ALMÐ]ÏLM@dÐUÍU^OC3?aPiDN¡ZUÙMCE Ø_NFX±X±PÔ!N^AÏ Ì CEZ>C^pÔLM?AÙ[;mãäLM?AÙ_ÒP^AXR^ON¡LMZÏ3DÍ>P^OC ?APXM?OCCâÍ^OCE@dC @LY?OÚ Ð>XR?aXRD¡DC DMÏLY@dÐUÍ^OC ?AP I3XMZ>EPLY@dCÔiLY?OÙ¯N¡P¥?AC Õ_ÍUN¡?AC E¯^OL Ï3LMZØMC ?^XP^AXMZ>EUXM?AE±POC3?AN¡XMDRÏLEC^AL @dXMÙMCC3×1ÏN¡C3Z_^iÍ>POCLMÎ9PÍ>Ï Ì XάXMÏN¡D¡N^pÚY;YåqZ^ Ì NFP
Ð>XMÐHC ?iEC3^AXMNDFPLMÎ9XÏD¡Í>P^OC3?|ÏLYZ>P^O?AÍ>Ï^AC E Îæ?OLY@0S,C Z_^ON¡ÍU@èçé@XMÏ Ì N¡ZUC P#XRZ>EêXìë íYíMT°îN^APïJPOC ÏLYZ>EéάXMP^C^ Ì C3?AZUC3^#ZUC3^pÔiLY?OÙXR?AC ÐU?OCPC Z_^OC E;,îLM^ Ì @dCPOPAXRWYCÐ>XYPOPONZ>WÞXRZHE¿EUXR^AXÞÐ>XR?aXRD¡DC D!XRÐUÐU?ALYXYÏ Ì C PXR?AC#Ï3LMZ>PON¡EUC3?AC E XRZ>EN^
N¡PiP Ì LJÔ!Z^ Ì XJ^ÎæLY?
XRZXM?O?aXmÚÖ>XYPCEP^O?AÍ>Ï^OÍU?AC EdÏLEC!Ö[LR^ Ì XRÐUÐ>?OL_XMÏ Ì CP$Ð>?OLJØNFEC XRÐUÐU?ALmÑN@XR^OC3D¡Ú^ Ì CPAXR@dC Ð[C3?OÎæLM?A@XRZ>Ï3CMI_Ô!N^ Ì ^ Ì C2E>XJ^AXÐ>XR?aXRD¡D¡C3DDÚD¡C PAP!ÏLEC@dLENBHÏ3XR^ON¡LMZ; = PÔC3D¡DÍ^OC ?άXMÏ3ND¡N^ON¡C P
^ Ì ?AC3C3ÒEN¡@dC3Z>PON¡LMZ>XMDUÓ>LJÔìPON@ÍUD¡XR^ON¡LMZ1XMD¡POL ?OCÕYÍ>N?AC P C×1ÏN¡C3Z_^2XMZ>E°XYÏ3ÏÍ>?AXR^OCK¯XmØ_N¡C3?OÒp:_^OLYÙMC P!POLMD¡ØMC ?AP ;>åqZ¸?OCÏC3Z_^ ÚYC XM?AP LMZUCLRÎ^ Ì C @LY?OC8Ð[LMÐUÍ>D¡XM?1@dC^ Ì LE>PdÎæLM?^ Ì C°POLMD¡Í^ON¡LMZLRÎ2^ Ì C¸K XmØN¡C3?OÒq:_^ALMÙYC PC Õ_Í>XJ^ANLYZ>PNFPd^ Ì C Îæ?AXYÏ^ON¡LMZHXRDP^OC3Ðð@dC^ Ì LE¥I Ô Ì N¡Ï Ì NFP°XìPN¡ZUWYDC¾P^OC Ð^AN@dC3ÒuN¡Z_^OC3WY?AXR^OLY? I^pÚÐUNFÏ3XRD¡D¡ÚêN¡@Ò ÐUDC @dC3Z_^OCEéN¡ZñPOC ÏLYZ>EÒLM?aEC3?ÎæLM?A@óòëô;
ݯC^aXRN¡D¡PLMαXõZ>LMZÒqPp^aXRWYWMC3?AC E¿K XmØNC ?Òp:_^ALMÙMCP PLYDØYC3?XM?OCÐU?AC POC3Z_^AC EõÖ[C3D¡LJÔöXMZ>E÷N^NFPP Ì LJÔ!Zõ^ Ì XJ^^ Ì CZULYZÒqPp^aXRWMWYC3?AC EäPLYDØYC3?Ð>?OLMÒ Ø_NFECPC Õ_ÍUN¡ØJXRD¡C3Z_^ XMÏ ÏÍU?aXMÏ3ÚXRZHE8C×1ÏN¡C3Z>Ï3Ú^ALXP^AXRZHEUXR?aE8Pp^aXRWMWYC3?AC E#WM?AN¡E#Îæ?aXMÏ^ON¡LMZ>XMD Pp^AC3иÏ3LEUCM;lÛiLMZØMC ?^ANZUWd^ Ì CZ>LMZÒqPp^aXRWYWMC3?AC E]ÏLEC^OL1?AÍUZ°LYZ8^ Ì CÔLM?AÙP^AXR^ON¡LMZ8ÏD¡Í>P^OC3? Í>PN¡ZUWä^ Ì C°EUXJ^aXÞÐHXR?aXRD¡DC D|XMÐUÐU?ALYXYÏ Ì NFPd?OC D¡XR^ON¡ØMC3D¡Ú¾P^O?aXRN¡W Ì ^ÎæLY?OÔ|XR?aE÷XRZ>EøÖ[C3Z>Ï Ì @dXM?OÙ ?OCPÍUD^AP!XM?OC±ÐU?AC POC3Z_^AC E]P Ì LJÔ!N¡ZUW^ Ì XR^CÑUÏC DD¡C3Z_^!?AC POÍUD^aP!XR?ACXMÏ Ì N¡C3ØYC E¥;
~
np±²fay]ùOúûü ý þÿÊÅ iÄ Æ ÞÆ!Ç Ë|Ì C¯K¯XmØ_N¡C3?OÒp:_^OLYÙMC P,CÕ_Í>XJ^ANLYZ>PN¡Z1ZULYZÒEUN@dC3ZHPN¡LMZ>XMDHXMZ>EN¡Z>ÏLY@Ð>?OCPOPONÖ>DC|ÎæLY?O@6XR?AC XYP ÎæLMD¡DLJÔP I ß ëmà ß à "!G Q $# ß)( à %&' í # Ô Ì C3?AC NFPi^ Ì C±ØMC DLÏ3N^pÚYI ^ Ì C±ÐU?AC PAPÍU?AC¯XMZ>+E *-,±NFPi^ Ì C\!C Ú_Z>LMDFEUP
ZÍU@ÖHC ? ; .¯PN¡ZUWdX Îæ?AXYÏ^ON¡LMZH XRDPp^AC3Ð@C3^ Ì LE^ Ì C|@dLM@dC3Z_^AÍU@ C Õ_Í>XR^ON¡LMZ>P,XR?ACBH?AP^N¡Z_^OC WM?aXJ^OCEN¡Z^AN@dCÔ!N^ Ì = EUXM@dPÒqîXYP Ì ÎæLM?O^ Ì ÎæLY?^ Ì CVXMEØYC Ï^ANØYC1^AC3?A@dPdXMZ>EøÛi?aXRZUÙ_ÒqKNFÏLYD¡POLMZõÎæLY?^ Ì C8Ø_NFPAÏLMÍHP ^OC3?A@P3IWYNØN¡ZUW ë ß / 4?> G Aà @ %B2C 4?> EG DAQ ë ß / 4HG G I/ 4 à # ß à /1023/54 ß à 4 : < 9 ; / ( = (= ( *-,F 687 ; Ô!N^ Ì POÍUÐ[C3?aPOÏ3?ON¡ÐK^ J ?OC ÐU?AC POC3Z_^ON¡ZUW÷^ Ì Cä^ON¡@CõD¡LÏ3XJ^ANLYZI|XRZ>E / XRZ>E C ^ Ì CäEUN¡PAÏ?AC^AC ØMC3D¡LÏN^pÚ¿XRZHEéÐ>?OCPOPOÍU?ACMI?AC POÐHCÏ^ON¡ØMC DÚYI = ^ Ì CÞEN¡PAÏ?AC^ACVXMEØYC Ï^ANLYZéLYÐHC ?AXR^OLY? I B ^ Ì C EN¡PAÏ?AC^ACWY?AXYENC Z_^¯XRZ>E F ^ Ì CdENFPOÏ3?OC3^OMC L$XRÐUDFXMÏ3N¡XMZ; Ë|Ì CÐU?AC PAPOÍU?OCNFP¯DLÏ3XR^OCEVNZ°^ON¡@C XJ^±^ Ì NC J Pë O ( D¡C3ØYC3DuI¥LMÖ^aXRN¡ZUC E¸Îæ?OLY@ ^ Ì CÐU?OC ØNLYÍ>P¯^ON¡@C3ÒP^OC ÐÞN¡Z_^OC WM?aXJ^ON¡LMZ9IE Ô!ND¡D ^ Ì C3?AC ÎæLY?OCVZ>LR^#Ö[CÞEUNØYC3?AWMC3ZHÏC8Îæ?AC3C¸XMZ>EN¡P#XRZêXMÐUÐU?ALmÑN@XJ^ANLYZ¿^AL¾^ Ì C¸ÏLY?O?AC /Ï0^ ENØYC3?AWMC Z>ÏCÎæ?OC C G ØMC DLÏ3N^pÚY; Ë|Ì C / 0 B>C3DFEÞN¡P±ÏLY?O?AC Ï^OCE8^OL]ÐU?ALJØ_NFECdXEN¡ØMC ?OWYC3Z>Ï3C Îæ?OC C /?4HG GXMP I / 4HG / 4HG G Q/ 0 6M7 B-RS# Ô!N^ Ì R XÐU?AC PAPÍU?ACÏLY?O?AC Ï^ON¡LMZ1LYÖ^AXMNZUCE#Îæ?OLY@6^ Ì C±ÎæLYDD¡LJÔ!N¡ZUWS,LMNFPOPOLMZ1CÕ_Í>XJ^ANLYZI O 687 # F RTVU/ 0
Ô Ì C3?AC U NFP^ Ì CEN¡PAÏ?AC^ACENØYC3?AWMC Z>ÏCY; Ë|Ì C±ÐU?OCPOPOÍU?AC¯NFP|^ Ì C3Z8ÍUÐ EG DAQ IR XRZ>E^ Ì CN¡Z_^OC WM?aXJ^ON¡LMZ8ÏLYZ_^ON¡Z_Í>C P^OL^ Ì CZUCÑ^!^AN@dCÒqP^OC3Ð9; Ë|Ì CÎæ?AXYÏ^ON¡LMZHXRDPp^AC3Ð@dC^ Ì LEIMXMPECPOÏ3?ON¡Ö[C EXRÖ[LJØMCMI Ì XYP,ÖHC C3ZdP Ì LJÔ!Z^AL2Ö[CPOC ÏLYZ>E LM?aEC3?$NZ^ON¡@CiLMZÖ[LR^ Ì X¯ÏLMZØYC3Z_^ON¡LMZ>XMDMT°= ÛõP^AXMWMWYC3?AC E2WM?AN¡EXRZ>ELYZX!ZULYZÒqPp^aXRWMWYC3?AC E WM?AN¡E¥I¥ò (W çRô;_ÜN¡WMÍU?ACëÏ3LMZ_^AXMNZ>PPOÙMC^aÏ Ì C PLMÎ9^ Ì C±P^AXMWMWYC3?AC EXRZHEZULYZÒqPp^aXRWMWYC3?AC EdWY?ONFEUP I Ô Ì C3?AC
N^NFPPC C3Z^ Ì XJ^LMZ^ Ì CPp^aXRWMWYC3?AC E±WY?ONFE±^ Ì CiØYC3D¡LÏ3N^pÚ±P^OLM?aXRWYCD¡LÏ XJ^ANLYZ>P$XM?OC
LRâ¥PC3^ X Ì XRDÎWM?AN¡E8POÐ>XMÏ3NZUWN¡Z8^ Ì C3N¡? ?AC POÐHCÏ^ON¡ØMCEN¡?AC Ï^ANLYZ>P|Îæ?ALM@ ^ Ì CÐU?OCPOPOÍU?AC±ZULEC P I>Ô Ì N¡D¡C LMZ1^ Ì C±ZULMZUÒP^AXMWMWMC ?OCEWM?ANFE^ Ì C3Ú1XR?AC±ÏLMN¡Z>Ï3N¡EC Z_^ ; Ë|Ì CPp^aXRWYWMC3?AC E1WM?AN¡E#XRÐUÐU?ALYXYÏ Ì1Ì XYP ÖHC C3ZVÔ!NFEC3D¡ÚÍ>POC EVXMZ>E Ì XMP PLY@CXYEØJXRZ_^AXMWMCP|NZ8^ Ì CENFPOÏ3?OC3^ONFPOXR^ON¡LMZ]LRÎ^ Ì CÐU?OCPOPOÍU?AC ÏLM?A?AC Ï^ANLYZCÕYÍHXJ^ON¡LMZ91; XLJÔC3ØMC ?|N^ Ì XYP!XZ_Í>@Ö[C3?LMÎENFPOXYEØJXRZ_^AXMWMCP3IÐ>XM?^AN¡Ï3ÍUD¡XM?OD¡ÚÎæLY? ÏÍU?AØND¡NZ>C XR?9WM?AN¡EUP I3Ô Ì C3?ACZULMZUÒP^AXMWMWMC ?OCE2WM?AN¡EUP9XR?AC
ÏLY@@dLYZUDÚ2Í>POC E1ò YmôP; Z¯ZPp^aXRWMWYC3?AC E WM?AN¡EUPC XMÏ Ì LRÎ^ Ì C@dLM@dC3Z_^AÍU@CÕ_Í>XJ^ANLYZ>P¥XRZ>E2^ Ì C
Ï3LMZ_^ON¡ZÍUN^pÚ¯C Õ_Í>XR^ON¡LMZ±Ô!ND¡D Ì XmØMC^ Ì C N? LJÔ!ZdB>ZUN^OC ØYLMD¡ÍU@dC P IRD¡C XMEUNZUW^OLXDFXR?AWMC ?XRZ>Ed@dLY?OC Ï3LM@dÐUD¡CÑÏLECY;Y=ìZULYZÒqPp^aXRWMWYC3?AC E ÏLEC±N¡PÔ!ND¡D¥^ Ì C3?ACÎæLM?AC2?OCÕYÍ>N?AC±DCPOP|ÔLM?AÙd^OLÐ>XM?AXMDD¡C3D¡NFPCY;
µ¥n llfa3nqnpvojlhyMjl3rpf|kfAnqrpjl "bhgfckmfalvJajsrutlvJrpjlvh_oa®c,e_fijh_yYfAºjiZ>N^AC ØMLYDÍ>@CPÎæLY?^ Ì C£.!Ò XRZ>NE Òu@dLY@C Z_^OÍU@6CÕYÍHXJ^ON¡LMZHP
XRZHEÎæLM?
^ Ì C±EN¡ØMC ?OWYC3Z>Ï3C XR?AC¯XMDD[DLÏ XJ^OCE1XJ^ ß #d à;= ( 6 # ( 6 POÐ>XMÏ3C E]ÏC3Z_^AC3?AC E]ENâPCE#ÎæLM?|^ Ì CÐU?OCPOPOÍU?AC¯WY?AXYEN¡C3Z_^AP|XMP I C G G fC > G C #
( 6
G C ~ &> G ( 6 XRZ>E]PN¡@dNDFXR?AD¡ÚÎæLM?|^ Ì C R WY?AXYEN¡C3Z_^!NZ#^ Ì CØYC3D¡LÏN^pÚÏLY?O?AC Ï^ON¡LMZ G G C
C ~ dG
( 6
G
G
#
~ ~ ~ ( 6
XRZ>EÎæLM?!^ Ì CEN¡ØMC ?OWYC3Z>Ï3CMI G G f > G dG G ~ &> G U ß # à : ( 6 ( 6 =ÐUÐUD¡ÚNZ>W1^ Ì CENFPAÏ?AC^OCdEN¡ØMC ?OWYC3Z>Ï3C^OL^ Ì CØMC DLÏN^pÚVÏLY?O?AC Ï^ON¡LMZI[XMP ÎæLM?¯^ Ì CdPp^aXRWMÒ WMC3?AC E]PAÏ Ì C3@dCMIWYNØYC P|XdS,LMNFPOPOLMZ R CÕ_Í>XJ^ANLYZ#LMÎ$^ Ì C±ÎæLM?A@8I R G Q ( R nIR > Q R ~ dG Q ( R ~ ¤R ~ &> Q ç6 Q ç6 Q ë G G G G 0 # ß YYà 6M7
( 6
( 6
Ô Ì C3?AC¸N^]NFP]PC C3Zì^ Ì XJ^]^ Ì C¥L9XMÐUDFXMÏNFXRZìLMÎ R Ì XYPX ( 6 XMZ>E ( 6 POÐ>XMÏ3NZ>W>; Ë|Ì N¡P XRÐUÐU?ALYXYÏ Ì Ô!N¡DD9ÖHCEC ZULR^AC E^ Ì CPOÐ>XM?APOC2PAÏ Ì C @CY; =ZéXMD^AC3?AZ>XJ^ANØYC^OLÞLMÖ^aXRN¡ZUN¡ZUW°^ Ì C C Õ_Í>XJ^ANLYZ¾ØN¡XÞXÞEUN?AC Ï^XRÐ>ÐUDNFÏ3XR^ON¡LMZ¾LMÎ^ Ì C EN¡PAÏ?AC^ACENØYC3?AWMC Z>ÏC¯^OLd^ Ì CØMC DLÏN^pÚÏ3LMR ?A?OCÏ^ON¡LMZ#N¡P!^OLEC3?AN¡ØMC2^ Ì C R C Õ_Í>XR^ON¡LMZ#B>?aPp^N¡Z
¥µ n llfaP!ÎæLY?O@ XRZ>EV^ Ì C Z¸ENFPOÏ3?OC3^ONFPCN^¯ÍHPN¡ZUWX1Ï3LM@dÐ>XYÏ^ 6 # 6 PÐ>XYÏN¡ZUWdÎæLM?¯^ Ì C L9XRÐ>D¡XYÏNFXRZIXMPÎæLYDD¡LJÔP I R G G ( R nIR > G R ~ dG G ( R ~ nR ~ &> G 6 Q 6 Q ë G G G G 0 # ß~§ à 687
( 6
( 6
Ô Ì N¡Ï Ì Ô!ND¡D,ÖHCEC3ZULM^OCEV^ Ì CÏLY@dÐ>XMÏ^2PAÏ Ì C3@dCM; Ë|Ì NFP¯XMÐUÐU?ALYXYÏ Ì NZ_^O?ALEÍ>Ï3C P XMZ¸XME>ENÒ ^ON¡LMZ>XMDHENFPOÏ3?OC3^ONFPOXR^ON¡LMZC ?O?ALM?N¡Z_^OL^ Ì C¯Ï3LM?A?OCÏ^OCEØMC3D¡LÏN^pÚXYP
XEUNØYC3?AWMC3ZHÏC!C3?A?ALM?Ô Ì NFÏ Ì Ì XMP^ Ì C±ÎæLMD¡DLJÔ!N¡ZUWÎæLM?A@8I Q ç G § ç G Q ¨e©P©aªP© 687 9 6 Q R G R G n R R > IR > ç 6 « ~ dG Q ç R ~ dG G § R f ç R &> G IR &> Q R ß ¬ à 6 Q @ # ç6 « Ô Ì N¡Ï Ì NFP^OL1POC Ï3LMZ>E#LM?aEC3?I 687¤®¯6 Q R } 6 Q R &&&}° ¨e©P©aªP© = P R±¥C4G EG DAQ C4?> dG DAQ 6M7 ^ Ì C!Ï3LM@dÐ>XMÏ^EN¡ØMC ?OWYC3Z>Ï3C
C ?O?ALM?N¡PC3ÑÐ[C Ï^OCE^AL¯Ö[C Ì XmØYC XMP I 687 Q ß 6 Q # 6 Q à ¨e©P©PªP© Ë|Ì ÍHP,ÎæLM?
^ Ì CZ>LMZÒqPp^aXRWYWMC3?AC EPOÏ Ì C3@dCMI_XMP,ÎæLY?^ Ì C2Pp^aXR WYWMC3?AC EPAÏ Ì C3@dCMIYXRD¡DU^ Ì CÐU?AC PÒ PÍU?ACWY?AXYEN¡C3Z_^2XMZ>E°EN¡ØMC ?OWYC3Z>Ï3C^OC ?O@P±XR?ACENFPAÏ?AC^ONFPOC EVÍ>PON¡ZUW#POC Ï3LMZ>EVLY?AEUC3?±ÏC3Z_^AC3?AC E POÏ Ì C @dC P ; uvhu
²-a
?}³´P
TµK³ az1¶
= PP Ì LJÔ!Z1XMÖHLJØYC|^ Ì C¯Í>POC LRÎXZ>LMZÒqPp^aXRWYWMC3?AC EWY?ONFEdDCXMEUP^OLC N^ Ì C3?|XPOÐ>XR?aPOC!ÐU?OCPOPOÍU?AC ÏLM?A?AC Ï^ANLYZ#CÕ_Í>XJ^ANLYZIULM?|^AL1XdÐU?AC PAPÍU?ACÏLY?O?AC Ï^ON¡LMZ#C Õ_Í>XJ^ANLYZ]^ Ì XR^ N¡PZULR^ EC ?ON¡ØMCE8ENÒ ?OCÏ^OD¡Ú¯Îæ?OLY@^ Ì CiEUN¡PAÏ?AC^ACÎæLM?A@PLRÎ^ Ì CiØYC3D¡LÏN^pÚ¯ÏLY?O?AC Ï^ON¡LMZXRZHEEN¡ØMC3?AWMC Z>ÏCLYÐHC ?AXR^OLY?AP ; Ë|Ì CCâE]ÖHC Ì XmØNLYÍU?!LRÎ^ Ì CÐU?AC PAPÍU?AC±N¡PNZØMCPp^ANW_XJ^AC E Ö_ÚEC ?ON¡ØNZ>W^ Ì C N¡@Ð>DN¡C EÐU?OCPOPOÍU?ACC Õ_Í>XR^ON¡LMZ; Ë|Ì C¯ÐU?OCPOPOÍU?ACC Õ_Í>XR^ON¡LMZ1NFPiLMÖ^aXRN¡ZUC EÖÚ ^AXRÙN¡ZUW^ Ì CEUNØYC3?AWMC3ZHÏC2LRÎ^ Ì C@dLM@dC ZY^AÍU@áCÕ_Í>XJ^ANLYZ>P3I ë ë /?4HG G 3/?4 ·9&;( = ß / 4 à ( = ß / 4?> G ¸à @ ¹B2C 4G EG DAQ ( *-, F ß / 4HG G / 4 à 6M7 687 ~ß º à ( *-, F B-R Ë|Ì N¡PdNFPd^ Ì CVC Õ_Í>XR^ON¡LMZ¾^ Ì XJ^1NFPPAXJ^ONFPB>C EéÖÚ¾^ Ì C G]XMZ>E EG DAQ]LMÖ^aXRN¡ZUC EéÍ>PONZ>W ^ Ì C±Îæ?aXMÏ^ON¡LMZ>XMDPp^AC3Ð8@dC^ Ì LE;>= PÏ XRZ]ÖHCPOC3C Z8N^N¡/?Z>4HÏGD¡Í>ECPXRZ8CXM4HE>G EN^ANLYZ>XRDXM?OCE÷^ALÞ^ Ì CVENFPOÏ3?OC3^ONFPCE¾@dLM@dC3Z_^AÍU@ CÕYÍHXJ^ON¡LMZ ß àXMÖHLJØYCMI,Ô Ì NFÏ Ì ?AC3ÐU?AC POC3Z_^aP ^ Ì C]C3?A?OLY??AC POÍUD^ON¡ZUWVÎæ?ALM@ ^ Ì C#Í>POCLMÎ X°Îæ?aXMÏ^ON¡LMZ>XMDiP^OC п; @dC^ Ì LE¥;= P R 687 ^ Ì N¡P
np±²fay]ùOúûü 3C ?A?OLY?N¡PPCÏLYZ>EõLM?aEC3?NZ÷^AN@dCYI,XYP Ì XYPÖ[C3C Z¿P Ì LJÔ!ZäÐ>?OC Ø_N¡LMÍHPD¡Úøò (W çRô;´»2N¡ØMC3Z¾^ Ì XR^ PCÏLMZHE¾LM?aEC ?PAÏ Ì C3@dCPXM?OC]Í>POC E¾ÎæLM?d^ Ì C8XYEØMCÏ^ANLYZ¾LMÐ[C3?aXJ^ALM? = XMZ>E÷^ Ì C8Ø_NFPAÏLMÍHP L9XRÐ>D¡XYÏNFXRZ I[XRZ>EV^ Ì XR^ ^ Ì CØYC3D¡LÏ3N^pÚ G±NFP2ENØYC3?AWMC Z>ÏC±Îæ?AC3C^OL#POC Ï3LMZ>E8LY?AEUC3?IU^ Ì C LJØMC3?aXRD¡D_Îæ?AXYÏF ^ANLYZ>XRDUP^OC Ð@dC^ Ì LEXMPECPO/?Ï34H?OGN¡Ö[C E Ì C3?AC|Ô!ND¡D^ Ì C3?ACÎæLY?OC|ÐU?ALEÍ>ÏC!X±ØYC3D¡LÏ3N^pÚ B>C3DFE#^ Ì XR^N¡P!POC Ï3LMZ>E#LM?aEC3?XYÏ3Ï3ÍU?AXR^OC2NZVPOÐ>XMÏ3CXRZ>E^ON¡@dCM; x{z1
5a
5Ka|~ Ë|Ì CÐ>?OCPOPOÍU?AC±ÎæLM?¯^ Ì CdPp^aXRWYWMC3?AC E8PAÏ Ì C3@dCÔ!N¡D¡D,PAXJ^AN¡PÎæÚ#^ Ì CC Õ_Í>XRÒ ^ON¡LMZI ë ß / 4?> G à 687 B-R à EDAQ %U ß ; ß / 4 à G ß~¼ à 4 G C ( = ( = ( *-, F F Ë|Ì C¸BH?AP^8XMZ>EñPOC Ï3LMZ>E^AC3?A@P#LYZì^ Ì Cä?AN¡W Ì ^ Ì XMZ>EêPONFEC¸LMÎ^ Ì NFP]C Õ_Í>XR^ON¡LMZñ@XmÚìÖ[C ?OC ÐU?OCPC Z_^OC E#XMP I ë ß / 4?> G àOà U ß ß / 4HG GEDAQ àà ¢½ ß 687 Q à U ß ; ß/ 4 à ( =
( =
=
Ë|Ì C^ Ì N¡?AE¾^OC3?A@ LMZ¿^ Ì C]?ON¡W Ì ^ Ì XRZ>E¿PNFECMI Q ¾ "! F B-R INFPXRZ¿LY?AEUC3? 687 Q#C3?A?OLY?^AC3?A@]I XMP R 687 ; Ë|Ì CÐU?AC PAPÍ>?OC±LMÖU^AXRN¡ZUCE8Í>PN¡ZUW^ Ì CÎæ?aXMÏ^ON¡LMZ>XMD9Pp^AC3ÐV@dC^ Ì LE8N¡P^ Ì C ?OC3ÎæLM?AC PCÏLMZHELY?AEC ?!XMÏ3Ï3ÍU?aXJ^OC±N¡Z^AN@dCXMZ>E]PÐ>XYÏCY; ¡qx"{}z1
a
?¿KP|) Ë|Ì C¾Ð>?OCPOPOÍU?ACäCÕ_Í>XJ^ANLYZÎæLY?°^ Ì C¿POÐ>XR?aPCõZULYZÒqPp^aXRWMWYC3?AC E POÏ Ì C @dC2NFPXYPÎæLMD¡DLJÔP I ß C G Q ( C ~ nTC > Q à ß C dG Q ( C ~ ÀC ~ &> Qmà ç6 Q ç6 Q 687 ë ß ë í_à U ß ;( = ß / 4 à ( = ß / 4> G à ( *Á, F B-R à # Ô Ì C3?AC^ Ì C ( 6 # ( 6 PÐHXMÏCE±EN¡PAÏ?AC^AN¡PAXJ^ANLYZLRÎ^ Ì C
ÐU?AC PAPÍ>?OCWY?AXYENC Z_^9XRZ>EEN¡ØMC ?OWYC3Z>Ï3C LMÐ[C3?aXJ^OLY?
LYZ^ Ì C2ZULYZÒP^AXMWMWYC3?AC EdWM?ANFE¥IYWYNØYC PiXPOÐ>XR?aPC¯ÐU?AC PAPÍU?AC L$XRÐUDFXMÏ3C LMÐ[C3?aXJ^ALM?IYXYP ÎæLM?^ Ì C R Ð>?OCPOPOÍU?AC#ÏLY?O?AC Ï^ON¡LMZ÷CÕYÍHXJ^ON¡LMZøXRÖ[LJØMC#NZéC Õ_Í>XJ^ANLYZ ß YMà; Ë|Ì C8?ANW Ì ^ Ì XMZ>E PNFECNFPXRWYXMNZ9I U ß = ß /54G EG DAQmàà¯^AL8POC Ï3LMZ>EÞLM?aEC ?NZä^ON¡@dC1XRZ>E¸^ Ì CÐU?OCPOPOÍU?ACdN¡PXMWYXRN¡Z PCÏLMZHE8LM?aEC3?2XMÏ3Ï3ÍU?aXJ^OCNZ¸POÐ>XYÏCXMZ>E8^ON¡@dCM; XLJÔC3ØYC3?!^ Ì CPOÐ>XM?APOC ( 6 # ( 6 POÐ>XMÏ3C E EN¡PAÏ?AC^AN¡PAXJ^ANLYZ¿LMÎ ^ Ì CVÐU?OCPOPOÍU?AC L$XRÐUDFXMÏ3N¡XMZ¿@dC XMZ>P^ Ì XR^^ Ì C8WY?ONFEéPAÏ3XMDC]ÐU?AC PAPÍ>?OC]N¡P ÍUZÒqÏLMÍ>ÐUDCE¥I>XMZ>E1^ Ì CENFPAÏ?AC^OC±LYÐHC ?AXR^OLM?|NFP!ZULYZÒuC DD¡N¡Ð^ONFÏò § I ¬ ôu; Ë|Ì N¡P!@dCXRZ>P|^ Ì XJ^WY?ONFE POÏ XRD¡CC3?A?OLY?NZ1^ Ì C¯ÐU?OCPOPOÍU?AC|B>C3DFE1Ï XRZ1XMÏ ÏÍU@ÍUDFXJ^OC Ô!N^ Ì LMÍ^ÖHLYÍUZ>E¥IYDCXMEN¡ZUW^ALXWY?ONFE POÏ XRD¡C2L_POÏ3ND¡DFXJ^ON¡LMZ^ Ì XR^@XmÚÏ3XMÍ>PC2^ Ì CPLYDÍU^ON¡LMZ#^OLÖU?AC XMÙ1ELJÔ!Z]Ï3LM@dÐUD¡C^AC3D¡ÚM; Ë|Ì CZULYZÒP^AXMWMWYC3?AC E2POÏ Ì C @dCÔ!N^ Ì ÏLY@dÐ>XMÏ^S,LMNFPAPLYZ R CÕYÍHXJ^ON¡LMZ Ì XMP¥^ Ì CÎæLYDD¡LJÔ!N¡ZUW ÐU?OCPOPOÍU?AC¯CÕ_Í>XJ^ANLYZI ß C G Q ( C ~ TC > Q à ß C dG Q ( C ~ ÀC ~ &> Q à ç6 Q ç6 Q 6M7 ë U ß ;( = ß / 4 à ( = ß / 4?> G à ( *Á, F B-R à ë ß 687 Q ® 6 Q C } 6 Q C &Â& ° à h *-, F ß 687 Q ® 6 Q C } 6 Q C && ° à ?OCWY?AXYENC Z_^¥XMZ>E±EN¡ØMC3?AWMC Z>ÏCXMWYXRN¡Z WMN¡ØMC PX2PÐ># XM?APOCn L$XRÐUDFXMÏ3C
LYÐHC ?AXR^OLM?$ÎæLM? C ; Ë|Ì CXYEUEN^ON¡LMZ>XMD_?AN¡W Ì ^ Ì XMZ>EPNFECi^OC3?A@P3ImÔ Ì C Z ÏLM@dÐ>XM?OCE¾^ALõC Õ_Í>XJ^ANLYZ ß ë í_àdXRÖ[LJØMCMIXM?ONFPC]Îæ?ALM@^ Ì C°ÏLY@dÐ>XMÏ^PAÏ Ì C @CVEN¡ØMC ?OWYC3Z>Ï3C C3?A?OLY? ; Ë|Ì CPC2^OC ?O@P!XM?OC±XRD¡DLRÎ$^ Ì C±ÎæLY?O@ ß 687 Q 6 Q # 6M7 Q 6 Qà|XRZ>E^ Ì Í>P!^ Ì CÏ3LM@dÐ>XMÏ^ POÏ Ì C @dCÐU?AC PAPÍ>?OCÔ!ND¡DPp^AND¡D,ÖHCdPCÏLYZ>EVLM?aEC ?2XYÏ3ÏÍ>?AXR^OCMI[XRD^ Ì LYÍUW Ì ^ Ì C@XRWMZ>N^AÍ>ECLRÎ ^ Ì CdC3?A?ALM?2@dXmÚ Ì XmØMCÖHC C3ZäNZ>Ï3?OCXMPOC E¥; X LJÔiC ØMC3?¯^ Ì C POCdXYEUEN^ON¡LMZ>XMD,C3?A?OLY? ^AC3?A@dP Ì XmØYC ^ Ì C±Câ?OCPOPOÍU?ACB>C D¡E¥IXYP
^ Ì C2ÎæLM?A@6LRÎ^ Ì C2ÐU?OCPOPOÍU?AC ÎæLMÍU?O^ Ì EC3?ANØJXR^ON¡ØMC P¯NFPXMP¯WMN¡ØMC3ZäXRÖ[LJØMCC Õ_Í>XJ^ANLYZ ß ¬ àI¥Ô Ì NFÏ Ì XM?OCC3D¡DN¡Ð^AN¡ÏdXJ^2^ Ì CWY?ONFE POÏ XRD¡CM;
ã Ì C3ZÏ3LM@dÐ>XM?OCEø^OL¾^ Ì CÞPOÐ>XM?APOC¸PAÏ Ì C3@dCÞXMÖHLJØYC8^ Ì CõÏLY@dÐ>XMÏ^#POÏ Ì C3@dC¸Ô!N¡DD ^ Ì C ?OC3ÎæLM?AC Ì XmØMC]^ Ì C°XYEØJXRZ_^AXMWMC8LRαZULM^XRD¡DLJÔ!N¡ZUWÞ^ Ì C°WY?ONFEøPOÏ XRD¡C]Ð>?OCPOPOÍU?AC]C ?O?ALM?^AL WM?ALJÔìÔ!N^ Ì LMÍ^!Ö[LMÍUZHE¥I>XRZHE^ Ì N¡P|NFP^ Ì C±?AC XYPLYZÎæLM?|Í>PONZ>WdPOÍ>Ï Ì XRZ8XRÐUÐU?ALYXYÏ Ì I_NZ8PÐ>N^AC LRÎ^ Ì CXYEUEN^ON¡LMZ>XMD¥C3?A?OLY?
^ Ì XJ^NFP!N¡ZY^A?OLEÍHÏC E; Ä )~|y${}|)¢ÅÂ{}
5Py )z{}|) =áÎæÍ>?^ Ì C3?@dLENBHÏ3XR^ON¡LMZ Ì XMPÎæ?AC Õ_ÍUC3Z_^ADÚ÷Ö[C3C ZøÍHPCE¾ÎæLY? ZULMZÒqP^AXRWYWMC ?OCE]PAÏ Ì C @CP!^ALÐU?AC3ØYC3Z_^ ^ Ì CWY?ONFE°PAÏ3XRD¡CÐU?AC PAPOÍU?OCC3?A?OLY? ZULM^OC E¸XRÖ[LJØMCM;HåqZ ^ Ì NFPXRÐ>ÐU?OL_XMÏ Ì ^ Ì CEN¡ØMC ?OWYC3Z>Ï3C¯NFP!EC3B>ZUC E8XYP3I dG EG DAQ ~ &> dG DAQ G EG DAQ 2 > dG DAQ # U ß # à 6 6 Ô!N^ Ì ^ Ì CN¡ZY^AC3?OÒuZ>LEUC±Ï3C3D¡D¥Î¬XMÏ3C±ØMC3D¡LÏN^ON¡C P|LYÖ^AXMNZUCEØNFXNZ_^OC ?OÐ[LMDFXJ^ANLYZ]XYP3I ~ dG EG DAQ ÇÆÈ´ÉhÊ Ë)Ì?Í G È"ÉÊ Ë Q Î 687fÏ ÆÐ ÉhÊ Ë)ÌÑ > Ð ÉhÊ Ë Æ1Ð ÉÊ Ë)Ì5Í > Ð ÉÊ ËÒ5Í Æ1Ð ÉÊ ËÌ5Í > Ð ÉhÊ Ë # Q¾ Î Q¾ Î ÎÓ ¾ XRZ>E G dG DAQ £ ÆÔÉÕÌ?Í¸Ê Ë G ÔÉhÊ Ë Q Î 687 Ï ÆÐ ÉÕÌÑEÊ Ë > Ð ÉhÊ Ë ÖÆ1Ð É_Ì5ÍAÊ Ë > Ð ÉÒ5Í¸Ê Ë Æ1Ð É_Ì5ÍAÊ Ë > Ð ÉhÊ Ë Q¾ Î Q¾ Î ÎÓ ¾ Ë|Ì N¡PXRÐUÐU?ALYXYÏ Ì¸Ì XYP±ÖHC C3ZõÍ>POC EäN¡ZäCÕ_ÍUNØJXMDC ZY^±ÎæLY?O@PN¡Z÷X#ZÍU@ÖHC ?LRÎ!POÏ Ì C3@dC PXMZ>E Ì XMP2Ö[C3C3Z÷EC3B>ZUCEÞXYP¯C DD¡N¡Ð^ONFÏdNZ_^AC3?AÐHLYD¡XR^ON¡LMZÞXYP2N^ Ì XYP2CâW^ Ì CWY?ONFE POÏ XRD¡CÐU?AC PAPÍU?ACC DD¡NÐU^ONFÏN^pÚ]LMÎ^ Ì CÏLYZY^ANZ>LMÍ>P C Õ_Í>XJ^ANLYZ>Pò § I ¬ ôu; Ë|Ì CÍ>POCLMÎC3D¡DN¡Ð^AN¡ÏNZÒ ^OC3?AÐ[LMDFXJ^ON¡LMZ8XME>EUP!XdENØYC3?AWMC Z>ÏC2C3?A?OLY?|LRÎ^ Ì C±ÎæLY?O@8I 687 ® 6 Q C } 6 Q C &Â& ° # Ô Ì N¡Ï Ì N¡PdC3ÑÐHCÏ^OCE÷^ALäÖ[C Ì XmØMC#XYP ß 687E6 Q # 687E6 Qmà; Ë|Ì CVÏ3LM?A?OCPÐ[LMZ>EUNZUW¸ÐU?OCPOPOÍU?AC C Õ_Í>XJ^ANLYZ#Ô!N¡D¡DÖHCYI ß C G G ( C ~ nTC > G à ß C dG G ( C ~ ÀC ~ &> G à 6 Q 6 Q 6M7 ë U ß ;( = ß / 4 à ( = ß / 4?> G à ( *Á, F B-R à ë ß 687 Q ®Õ6 Q C } 6 Q C &Â& ° à h *-, F ß 687 Q ®Õ6 Q C } 6 Q C && ° à ë ßë( à ß ® 6 Q C } 6 Q C && ° à *-, F ß 687 ® 6 Q C } 6 Q C &&& ° à
np±²fay]ùOúûü ã Ì C3Z¾Ï3LM@dÐ>XR?AC E¸^OL8^ Ì C1ÐU?AC PAPOÍU?OCdCÕYÍHXJ^ON¡LMZÞÎæLM?^ Ì CÏ3LM@dÐ>XYÏ^S,LMNFPAPLYZ R C Õ_Í>XR^ON¡LMZ POÏ Ì C @dCMICÕYÍHXJ^ON¡LMZ ß ëMëmàÏ3CiXÏ3LM@dÐ>XMÏ^ENFPAÏ?AC^OCiÐU?AC PAPÍU?A C L9XMÐUDFXMÏC
LMÐ[C3?aXJ^OLY? ; Ë|Ì NFP9@dC XMZ>P9^ Ì XR^ ^ Ì C]WM?AN¡EéPOÏ XRD¡CÐU?AC PAPOÍU?OC#N¡PÎæÍUD¡D¡Ú¾ÏLMÍ>ÐUDCE¥I Ì LJÔC3ØMC ?XYEUEN^ON¡LMZ>XMDC ?O?ALM?LRÎ^ Ì C#ÎæLM?A@]I 6 Q 6 Q # 687E6 Q # 687E6 Q Ì XYP|ÖHC C3Z8N¡ZY^A?OLEÍHÏC E; îiLM^ Ì ^ Ì CiÏ3LM@dÐ>XYÏ^XMZ>EC DD¡NÐU^ONFÏ
N¡Z_^OC3?AÐ[LMDFXJ^ON¡LMZZ>LMZÒqPp^aXRWYWMC3?AC E±PAÏ Ì C3@dCPCâÐUDC^ Ì C#WM?AN¡E÷PAÏ3XMDCÐU?OCPOPOÍU?AC1N¡ZY^ALV^ Ì C]POLMD¡Í^ON¡LMZ9I Ì LJÔC3ØYC3?^ Ì C3?ACNFPX¸ENâXMDD¡ÚìEC3ØYC3D¡LMÐ[C EìÎæLY?#ÍHPCõÔ!N^ Ì N^OC ?Ò XJ^ON¡ØMCVPOLMD¡ØMC ?AP I,?AXR^ Ì C ?d^ Ì XMZøZ>LMZÒN^AC3?aXJ^ANØYCÎæ?aXMÏ^ON¡LMZ>XMDPp^AC3ÐPLYDØYC3?aP3;,åqZø^ Ì C°Ï3LMZ_^OC3Ñ^ LRÎ2^ Ì C°Ð>?OCPC ZY^PAÏ Ì C @C°XMZN^AC3?aXJ^ON¡ØMC°POLMD¡ØMC ?dÔiLYÍUD¡Eø?AC3Ð[C XR^^ Ì C°@dLY@C Z_^OÍU@ C Õ_Í>XRÒ ^ON¡LMZ[ïJÐU?OCPOPOÍU?AC ÏLY?O?AC Ï^ON¡LMZdC Õ_Í>XR^ON¡LMZÏ3ÚÏD¡C¯XJ^C XYÏ Ì ^ON¡@dC2P^OC ÐÍUZ_^ON¡DH^ Ì C±EN¡ØMC3?AWMC Z>ÏC LRÎ ^ Ì C /10 BHC3DFE8ÔXYP|DCPOP|^ Ì XRZ°XdÐ>?OCPC3^ ÏLMZØYC3?AWMC3ZHÏC±Ï?AN^AC3?ANLYZ; Ë|Ì NFP!CâP ^ Ì XR^$^ Ì C
ÐU?AC PAPOÍU?OCiÏLM?A?AC Ï^ANLYZ R ÖHCÏLY@CP9ØYC3?AÚ2PO@XRD¡DImXRZHE^ Ì CiXME>EN^ANLYZ>XRD_C3?A?ALM?¥^AC3?A@dP NZ^ Ì C Ï3LM@dÐ>XMÏ^iPAÏ Ì C3@dCÖ[C Ï3LM@dCZUC WMD¡NWYNÖUD¡CM;Y= PiN^
NFP^ Ì C POC^AC3?A@P^ Ì XJ^iXYÏ^^ALÏLYÍUÐUD¡C ^ Ì C!WY?ONFEPAÏ3XMDCÐU?AC PAPÍ>?OC|N¡ZY^AL2^ Ì CPOLMD¡Í^ON¡LMZ9Im^ Ì C!WY?ONFEPAÏ3XMDC!ÏLYÍUÐUD¡NZ>W2Ô!N¡D¡DUÖHC!D¡LYP^ ;M:Í>Ï Ì XPAÏ Ì C @C±NFP|^ Ì C3?ACÎæLM?AC±ZULR^POÍUN^AXRÖ>DC±ÎæLY?XRZ]N^AC3?aXJ^ON¡ØMCXMÐUÐU?ALYXMÏ Ì ; ²-P
?}³´a
ÙØ8³´$$zP¶3Ú8$´|~{}|)$ Ü>LM?^ Ì C!P^AXMWMWMC ?OCEPAÏ Ì C3@dCZUL¯C3ÑÐUDNFÏN^ÖHLYÍUZ>EÒ XR?AÚ#ÏLYZ>EN^ON¡LMZ>P¯XR?AC?OCÕ_ÍUN?AC EI>XRZ>EV^ Ì NFPNFPLYZUCLRÎ,^ Ì CXYEØJXRZ_^AXMWMC P|LMÎ,^ Ì NFP¯XMÐUÐU?ALYXYÏ Ì ; ÜULM?2^ Ì CdZULMZÒqP^AXRWYWMC ?OCE°POÏ Ì C3@dCX#Ö[LMÍUZ>E>XR?AÚ°ÏLMZHEN^ANLYZÞNFP±?AC Õ_ÍUN¡?OCE8^OL8ÐU?ALJØN¡EC^ Ì C ÐU?OCPOPOÍU?ACXJ^^ Ì C]ÖHLYÍUZ>EUXM?OÚäCÑ^AC3?ANLY?ÐHLYNZ_^IXMZ>Eõ^ Ì N¡PN¡PLMÖU^AXRN¡ZUCE÷ÖÚ¸ÎæLYÍU?^ Ì LM?aEC ? CÑ^O?aXRÐ[LMDFXJ^ANLYZõÎæ?OLY@ ^ Ì C]NZ_^OC ?ON¡LM?;,ÜULM?^ Ì C#ÐU?AC PAPOÍU?OC#ÏLM?A?AC Ï^ANLYZ R N¡ZéXRD¡D|Ï3XMPOC P^ Ì C ÖHLYÍUZ>EUXM?OÚÏ3LMZ>EUN^ANLYZ#NFP!LMÖU^AXRN¡ZUCE#EN¡?AC Ï^ADÚ1Îæ?OLY@·^ Ì CØMC3D¡LÏN^pÚÖHLYÍUZ>EUXM?OÚ#ÏLMZHEN^ANLYZ; Û ÜQ È Ýp1Ä Ë|Ì C!XMÏ3Ï3ÍU?aXMÏÚXMZ>EC3×1ÏN¡C3Z>Ï3ÚLRÎH^ Ì C!PAÏ Ì C3@dC P,ECPOÏ3?ON¡Ö[C EXRÖ[LJØMCiXM?OC|ÏLY@dÐ>XR?AC EÎæLM?,^ Ì C PLYDÍ^ANLYZ¸LMÎP^AXR?O^ÒÍUÐäZ>XJ^AÍU?aXRDÏLYZ_ØYC Ï^ON¡LMZVÓ>LJÔ NZ÷X]POÕ_Í>XM?OCdÏ3XmØN^pÚM; Ë|Ì CPN¡@Í>D¡XR^ON¡LMZ LRίZHXJ^OÍ>?AXMD|Ï3LMZØMCÏ^ANLYZ÷Ó>LJÔ·?AC Õ_ÍUN¡?OCP^ Ì CVPOLMD¡Í^ON¡LMZéLRÎ2X¸^OC @dÐHC ?AXR^OÍU?AC8C Õ_Í>XJ^ANLYZ¿N¡Z XMEUEN^ON¡LMZ^OL^ Ì C¯@dLM@dC ZY^AÍU@áXMZ>ES,LYN¡PAPLYZ1ÐU?AC PAPÍ>?OC2ÏLM?A?AC Ï^ANLYZ1C Õ_Í>XR^ON¡LMZ>PECPOÏ3?ON¡ÖHCE XRÖ[LJØMCMI3^OLYWMC^ Ì C3?$Ô!N^ Ì XÖ>ÍULJÚYXMZ>ÏÚ ^OC3?A@ XMEUEUC E±^AL!^ Ì CØMC ?^AN¡Ï XRDR@dLY@C Z_^OÍU@ CÕYÍHXJ^ON¡LMZ9; Ë|Ì C ^AC3@dÐ[C3?aXJ^OÍ>?OC¯C Õ_Í>XJ^ANLYZ1NFPEUN¡PAÏ?AC^AN¡POC EÍHPN¡ZUW^ Ì C±POXM@C ^ON¡@dC2XMZ>EPOÐ>XMÏ3C¯PAÏ Ì C3@dCP XMPi^ Ì C2@dLM@dC3Z_^AÍU@6C Õ_Í>XR^ON¡LMZ>P IXRZ>EN¡P|POLMD¡ØMC E1ÐU?ON¡LM?i^OL^ Ì C¯@dLM@dC ZY^AÍU@·CÕYÍHXJ^ON¡LMZHPiXR^ C XMÏ Ì ^ON¡@dC±P^OC Ð; Ë|Ì CXMEUØMC Ï^ON¡ØMC¯LMÐ[C3?aXJ^OLY? = Í>POC P|X^ Ì N¡?AE#LM?aEC f? ÞÁ. åO¤Û ß ENFPOÏ3?OC3^ONFPOXRÒ ^ON¡LMZIMXMZ>E^ Ì CEUNâPONLYÙZ L$XRÐUDFXMÏ3C|LMÐ[C3?aXJ^OLY? F ÍHPCPX±Pp^aXRZ>EUXM?AEPOC ÏLYZ>ELM?aEC3?Ï3LM@dÐ>XMÏ^ EN¡PAÏ?AC^AN¡PAXJ^ANLYZ;>Ü>LM? Ö[LR^ Ì ^ Ì CPp^aXRWYWMC3?AC E8XMZ>E8ZULMZUÒP^AXMWMWMC ?OCEPAÏ Ì C3@dCP!^ Ì C^OC @dÐHC ?AXRÒ ^OÍU?AC!ØJXRD¡ÍUC PiXR?AC|P^OLY?OCEdXJ^^ Ì CÐU?AC PAPÍU?AC|ZULEC!D¡LÏ XJ^ANLYZ>P3; Ë|Ì C ÏLYZ_^O?ALMDÐ>XM?AXM@C3^OC ?APÎæLY? ^ Ì C2Z>XJ^AÍU?aXRDLJÔñXR?AC^ Ì C±S?aXRZ>E^ADHZÍU@ÖHC ? © áà OHâ#XRZ>E1^ Ì C±\XmÚD¡C3N¡W Ì Z_Í>@Ö[C3£? *-ã áäå 68æ = }` O à â9I>Ô!N^ Ì ä WM?aXmØN^pÚYI å ^ Ì CÏ3LC×1ÏN¡C3Z_^ LMÎ^ Ì C3?A@XRD$CÑÐ>XRZUÒ PN¡LMZI = ^ Ì C Ì C NW Ì ^LRÎ|^ Ì C]Ï3XmØN^pÚMI à ^ Ì C#Ù_N¡ZUC @dXR^ONFÏØN¡PAÏL_PN^pÚõXRZ>IE â÷^ Ì C^ Ì C ?O@XRD ENâPONØN^pÚ¸; åqZUN^AN¡XMDD¡ÚV^ Ì CÓ>ÍUNFE¸N¡Z¸^ Ì C1PAÕYÍHXR?ACÏ3XmØN^pÚVN¡PP^AXR^ON¡LMZ>XM?OÚVXMZ>E¸NFPOLR^ Ì C3?A@dXMDXJ^±^OC @Ò ÐHC ?AXR^OÍU?AC æ íU;R=^^AN@dC 7 í¯^ Ì C!D¡CÎ ^XRZ>E?ON¡W Ì ^Ô|XRD¡D¡P,XR?AC|NZHPp^aXRZ_^AXMZUC3LYÍ>PD¡Ú Ì CXJ^OCE XRZ>E8ÏLLYDCE1^AL 6Mæ O ( XMZ>E 68æ O ( ?AC POÐHCÏ^ON¡ØMC DÚYIÔ!N^ Ì ^ Ì C±^ALMÐVXRZ>E]Ö[LR^O^OLM@ ÖHLYÍUZ>EÒ ×
COLD
HOT
COLD
HOT
µ¥n llfaXR^ONFÏR;U= DD$ÖHLYÍUZ>EUXM?ON¡C P!XM?OC±ZULMÒPODN¡Ð; Ë|Ì C?AC POÍUD^AP!Ð>?OCPC ZY^AC E#ÔiC ?OC±LYÖ^AXMNZUCE Ô!N^ Ì *-ã §Ùè ë íé±XMZ>E © ¬ Y; Ë L¸^OC P^^ Ì C]ÖHC Ì XmØNLYÍU?LMÎ^ Ì C#@dC^ Ì LEUP^ Ì C#Ó>LJÔ6Ô|XMPNZ_^AC3WM?aXJ^AC EäÎæ?ALM@ 7 í ^OL 7 ( ÎæLM?X8POC3?ANCP LMÎiWM?ANFE°XRZ>E¸^ON¡@dCPp^AC3Ð>P±POÕN ê C P±XMP¯ÎæLMD¡D¡LJeÔ ë,ò ( í èì( í # 687 í ëôI ò ç_í è ç_í # 687 í íYJôuIò º í è-º í # 687 í í ( YJôUXRZ>E]òë § í è ë § í # 687 í íUë ( YmôWM?ANFEUP3; Ë|Ì C í C ?O?ALM?îÏCÖ[C^pÔC3C Zõ^ Ì Cd^AC P^PLYDÍU^ON¡LMZ LMÖ^aXRN¡ZUC E]XJ^XWMN¡ØMC3Z 687 XMZ>EF WY?ONFEXMZ>E]XÖ[C3ZHÏ Ì @XR?AÙ1PLYDÍ^ANLYZ#XMD¡POLN¡Z_^OC WM?aXJ^OCEÎæ?ALM@ 7 í¾^AL 7 ( LMZêX § ç_í è§ çYí¾WM?AN¡EìÔ!N^ Ì 687 ë ( Y è ëí `J; Ë N@dC P Ì XmØYC ÖHC C3ZdZULMZUÒEN¡@dC3Z>PON¡LMZ>XMDNFPCEÍHPN¡ZUW2^ Ì C ÖHLYÍUZ>EUXM?OÚDFXmÚMC ?Pp^a; XR ?O^ÒÍUÐ^AN@dC|> ÎæLY?^ Ì C!ZHXJ^OÍ>?AXMD ÏLMZØYC Ï^ANLYZ1Ï3XmØN^pÚM; Ë|Ì C ^AN@dC3ÒP^OC Ð#POC3D¡C Ï^AC EN¡ZCXMÏ Ì Ï XMPOC NFPi^ Ì C2D¡XM?OWYC P^^ON¡@dC2P^OC Ð#XR^ Ô Ì N¡Ï Ì ^ Ì C1PÐHXJ^ONFXRDC ?O?ALM?¯^OLM^AXMDD¡Ú¸ELY@N¡Z>XR^OC P^ Ì Cd^AC3@dÐHLY?AXMDC3?A?OLY? IH^ Ì XJ^NFPX#ÎæÍU?^ Ì C3? ?OCEÍ>Ï^ANLYZN¡Z^ON¡@C3ÒP^OC ÐLYZX BUÑC EWM?ANFED¡C XYEUP$^OL±ZULÏ Ì XRZ>WMCNZ^ Ì C|C ?O?ALM?I Ô Ì N¡Ï Ì WMN¡ØMCP XÛiLMÍU?aXRZ_^|Z_Í>@Ö[C3?LMÎ,XMÐUÐU?ALmÑN¡@XJ^AC3D¡Ú1íU;¡ëM;UîLR^ Ì ^ Ì CP^AXRWYWMC ?OCEXRZHEZULYZÒqPp^aXRWMWYC3?AC E POÏ Ì C @dC P Ì XmØMC2Ö[C3C3Z]ÐU?AC3ØN¡LMÍ>PODÚ1P Ì LJÔ!Z^OL Ì XmØMC2PCÏLYZ>ELY?AEUC3?|XMÏ3Ï3ÍU?aXMÏÚdN¡Z^AN@dCYI9ò (PW çRô; Ë|Ì C?AC POÍUD^aPP Ì LJÔ!Z#Ö[C3D¡LJÔ¹Ô!ND¡DÖ[CÍ>POC E#^OLØJXRD¡NFEUXJ^AC±^ Ì CPOÐ>XR^ONFXRDXMÏ ÏÍU?aXMÏ3ÚLRÎ,^ Ì C POÏ Ì C @dC P ;
cHfafAn3rpMnpfiAvhJrpvMnpoqb fOw¡rdc3hyorqnpf ±w¡_h_Orpjv hAvhJrpvMnpoqbFnpj eJrdc9wFv3n,rpe_fih3rpMn A\ v]_hR^ kmª}faï>Aª rpjlv hðv Ü$N¡WMÍ>?OC ( P Ì LJÔP$^ Ì CPp^A?OCXR@ÎæÍUZ>Ï^ON¡LMZdXRZ>E^OC @dÐHC ?AXR^OÍU?AC!ÏLMZ_^ALMÍU?aP?OCPÐ[C Ï^ON¡ØMC3D¡ÚÎæLY? ^ Ì C!Z>XR^OÍU?aXRDUÏ3LMZØMCÏ^ANLYZÓ>LJÔøXJ^^ON¡@dC 7 ( ; Ë|Ì CPp^A?OCXR@ÎæÍUZ>Ï^ON¡LMZÏLYZY^ALMÍU?aP,P Ì LJÔ¾^ Ì C ?OCÏN¡?AÏ3ÍUD¡XR^ON¡LMZ>P^ Ì XR^|XM?OC XYPOPOLÏNFXJ^AC EdÔ!N^ Ì CXMÏ Ì LMÎ¥^ Ì C ^ Ì C ?O@XRD[Ö[LMÍUZ>E>XR?AÚDFXmÚMC ?AP^ Ì XR^ ÎæLM?A@ LMZä^ Ì C Ì CXJ^OCEõXRZ>EõÏLLYDCE¸Ô|XRD¡D¡P ; Ë|Ì CdÓHLJÔ Ï3LMZ_^ON¡ZÍUC P2^AL°EC3ØYC3D¡LMÐäÎæ?OLY@ ^ Ì N¡P Pp^aXRWMCÔ!N^ ÌõÌ LR^XMZ>EÞÏ3LMDFE°N¡Z_^O?AÍ>PN¡LMZHP±C ñpC Ï^OCE°Îæ?ALM@ ^ Ì CdÖHLYÍUZ>EUXM?OÚ¸D¡XmÚYC3?aP^A?AXmØYC3D¡DN¡ZUW XMÏ?ALYPAP
^ Ì C Ì LY?O_N ê3LYZY^aXRD[ÖHLYÍUZ>EUXM?ON¡C P|XMZ>E#P^O?aXJ^ANÎæÚN¡ZUW^ Ì C±N¡ZY^AC3?ANLY?|LRÎ9^ Ì CELM@XMNZIXMZ>E ^ Ì C±^pÔLd?OCÏN¡?AÏ3ÍUD¡XR^ON¡LMZ>P|Ï3LYXRD¡C PAÏN¡ZUW^OLÎæLM?A@áXPONZ>WMD¡C±Ï XmØN^pÚ1PAÏ3XMDC±?AC ÏN¡?aÏÍUDFXJ^ANLYZ; Ü$N¡WMÍ>?OC P Ì LJÔP?OCPOPOÍU?ACMI^AC3@dÐHC ?AXR^OÍU?AC
XMZ>eE .¿XMZ>-E ¿ØYC3D¡LÏ3N^pÚ¯C3?A?OLY?AP[ÎæLY?9CXMÏ Ì LRÎ^ Ì CPAÏ Ì C3; @dC P IU^ALMWYC^ Ì C3?Ô!N^ Ì ^ Ì CEUNâÏ3CÖ[C^pÔC3C Z8^ Ì CPp^aXRWMWYC3?AC E8PAÏ Ì C3@dCXMZ>E ^ Ì CdZULYZÒP^AXMWMWYC3?AC EVÏLY@dÐ>XMÏ^±PAÏ Ì C3@dCY;LM?2^ Ì CÐU?AC PAPOÍU?OCXRD¡DÖUÍ^±^ Ì CZULYZÒqPp^aXRWMWYC3?AC E PÐ>XM?APOC!POÏ Ì C3@dC P Ì LJÔøPOC Ï3LMZ>ELY?AEC ?ÏLYZ_ØYC3?AWMC Z>ÏCY; Ë|Ì CZULYZÒP^AXMWMWYC3?AC EPOÐ>XM?APOC!POÏ Ì C @dC P Ì LJÔPXD¡LJÔìLM?aEC ?Ï3LMZØMC ?OWYC3Z>Ï3C!Ô Ì N¡Ï Ì N¡PXMPAPOÍU@dC E^ALÖ[C2X?AC POÍUD^LRÎ^ Ì C±XMÏ3Ï3ÍU@Í>D¡XRÒ ^ON¡LMZdLRÎP^O?aXJ^ANZ>W¯^ Ì CÐ[LLM?Ð[C3?OÎæLM?A@dXMZ>ÏC|LMÎ[^ Ì NFPPOÏ Ì C3@dCM; Ë|Ì C ^OC3@dÐ[C3?aXJ^AÍU?OC]?AC POÍUD^aPdXRWYXMNZøP Ì LJÔö^ Ì XR^XMDD|ÖUÍU^^ Ì C8ZULMZUÒP^AXMWMWMC ?OCE÷PÐHXR?aPC]POÏ Ì C @dC XR?ACCÑ Ì N¡ÖUN^ANZ>WPCÏLYZ>E]LM?aEC3?Ö[C Ì XmØ_N¡LMÍ>? ; Ë|Ì CZULMZÒqP^AXRWYWMC ?OCE#POÐ>XR?aPOC±PAÏ Ì C @CYI>Ô Ì N¡D¡C
np±²fay]ùOúûü Ì XmØNZUW]XRÐUÐ>?OLmÑN¡@dXR^OC DÚ#^ Ì CdPAXR@dCC ?O?ALM?I>NFP±P Ì LJÔ!N¡ZUW#NZ>Ï3LMZ>PONFPp^AC3Z_^¯Ö[C Ì XmØN¡LMÍU?±XJ^2^ Ì C B>ZUC P^iWY?ONFEPOÕN ê CM; Ë|Ì £C .ÒuØYC3D¡LÏ3N^pÚ?OCPÍ>D^aP3IP Ì LJÔXMDD[POÏ Ì C3@dC P
CÑ Ì N¡ÖUN^ANZ>WPOC ÏLYZ>EdLM?aEC ? ÖHC Ì XmØNLYÍU? ImÔ Ì N¡D¡Ci^ Ì 2C ÒØMC DLÏN^pÚ?AC POÍUD^aP,XRWYXMNZP Ì LJÔ¾NZHÏLMZHPNFPp^AC3Z_^ÖHC Ì XmØNLYÍU?$ÎæLM?,^ Ì C ZULMZÒqP^AXRWYWMC ?OCEVPÐ>XM?APOCPAÏ Ì C3@dCYI[Ô Ì ND¡CXMDD,LM^ Ì C ?2PAÏ Ì C3@dCP¯XM?OCÏLMZØYC3?AWMN¡ZUWXJ^POC ÏLYZ>E LM?aEC3?; ò
Temperature Staggered Non-staggered, compact Non-staggered, sparse Non-staggered, elliptic Difference 2 Order h
Pressure Staggered Non-staggered, compact Non-staggered, sparse Non-staggered, elliptic 0.01Difference 2 Order h
1
0.01
Error
Error
0.1
0.001
0.0001 0.0001
1e-05 0.001
0.01
1e-06 0.001
0.1
Grid size
0.01
0.1
Grid size
U-Velocity
V-Velocity
Staggered
Staggered
0.1 Non-staggered,
compact Non-staggered, sparse Non-staggered, elliptic Difference 2 Order h
0.1 Non-staggered,
compact Non-staggered, sparse Non-staggered, elliptic Difference 0.01 2 Order h Error
Error
0.01
0.001
0.001
0.0001
0.0001 0.001
1e-05 0.001
µ¥npfaoqoqYnpf| aaMn AtbFrpv lfAw¡rdcOzRrpfafOn3rpYnpf aAYn OtbFrpv npjl eRrdcOzMg
«kfalvJajsrut AaY« n\ 3]_A^ tª}bó> ª v rqrpv lfAwrdc hyMgi«¬kmfalvJajsrt3aaMn Atb v rqrpv ðnpjleJrdc 0.01
Grid size
0.1
0.01
0.1
Grid size
Ü$N¡WMÍ>?OC¯çÏLYZ_^AXRN¡Z>P
^ Ì C±XmØMC ?AXMWMC!C ?O?ALM?Ð>DLM^^OCEXMWYXRN¡Z>P^Ï3LM@dÐUÍ^AC ^AN@dC¯ÎæLM?C XMÏ Ì LRÎ ^ Ì CdPOÏ Ì C3@dC P I¥XRD¡DLJÔ!N¡ZUW^ Ì CC3×1ÏN¡C3Z>Ï3Ú8^OL]ÖHCdÏLY@ÐHXR?AC E¥; Ë|Ì CZULMZÒqP^AXRWYWMC ?OCE]POÐ>XM?APOC POÏ Ì C @dCN¡P!Ï3DCXR?ADÚ^ Ì CD¡C XYPp^!C×1Ï3NC ZY^LMÎ$^ Ì LYPOC±^OCPp^AC E¥I>Ô Ì ND¡CXRD¡DLM^ Ì C ?AP!XM?OCXRÐ>ÐU?OLmÑNÒ @dXR^OC DÚ2C Õ_Í>XMDa; Z¯ØMC3?aXRD¡Dm^ Ì C3?ACÎæLM?AC^ Ì CZULYZÒP^AXMWMWYC3?AC E2POÏ Ì C @dC P Ì XmØMCÐ[C3?OÎæLM?A@CE±C Õ_ÍUN¡Ø_Ò XRD¡C3Z_^OD¡Ú^AL1^ Ì CP^AXMWMWMC ?OCE#PAÏ Ì C @CYIHÔ!N^ Ì ØMC3?AÚ#PON¡@N¡DFXR? C3×1ÏN¡C3Z>Ï3Ú]XMZ>E°XMÏ ÏÍU?aXMÏ3ÚM; Ë|Ì C ZULMZÒqP^AXRWYWMC ?OCEäPAÏ Ì C @CÔ!N^ Ì C3D¡D¡NÐ^AN¡ÏNZ_^AC3?AÐHLYD¡XR^ON¡LMZ¾Ð[C3?OÎæLM?A@dC E÷XRÐ>ÐU?OLmÑN¡@XJ^OC DÚÞ^ Ì C POXM@CXMP ^ Ì CZULMZÒqP^AXRWYWMC ?OCE]Ï3LM@dÐ>XYÏ^¯PAÏ Ì C3@dCYI[EC @dLMZ>P^O?aXJ^ANZUW1^ Ì XR^ ^ Ì CXYEUEN^ON¡LMZ>XMD C3?A?OLY?|^OC3?A@P ENFEVZULM^¯PONWYZUNB[Ï3XRZ_^ADÚ]XJâWLRÎ[^ Ì C!C DD¡NÐU^ONFÏ|NZ_^OC ?OÐ[LMDFXJ^ANLYZNFPZULM^ZUC Ï3C PAPOXM?OÚY; Ë|Ì CÐHLLY?ÐHC ?ÎæLY?O@XMZ>ÏCLMÎi^ Ì C1ZULYZÒP^AXMWMWYC3?AC E¸POÐ>XM?APOC1POÏ Ì C3@dCN¡PXJ^^A?ON¡ÖUÍ^AC Eä^AL ^ Ì CDFXMÏaÙLRÎ¥WM?ANFEPOÏ XRD¡C!ÐU?OCPOPOÍU?ACÏLYÍUÐUD¡NZUWH;MÜNWYÍU?A£C Y±P Ì LJÔP,^ Ì C ÐU?OCPOPOÍU?ACÏLYZY^ALMÍU?aP,ÎæLY? PÐ>XM?APOCXRZHE]Ï3LM@dÐ>XYÏ^ ZULYZÒqPp^aXRWMWYC3?AC E#POÏ Ì C @dC PXR^^ON¡@dC 7 ( I[XRZ>E]N^¯NFPÏD¡C XM?OD¡Ú#POC3C Z ^ Ì XR^ XWY?ONFE]POÏ XRD¡C2C ?O?ALM?|ÏLY@dÐHLYZUC3Z_^NFP|ÐU?OCPC Z_^|N¡Z]^ Ì CPOÐ>XM ?APOC2PAÏ Ì C @CY;
µ¥n llfaXYÏ^
ÐU?AC PAPOÍU?OCÏ3LM?A?OCÏ^ANLYZCÕ_Í>XJ^ANLYZ1POÏ Ì C @dC ÐU?OLJØNFEC P#C Õ_ÍUN¡ØJXRD¡C3Z_^VXMÏ3Ï3ÍU?aXMÏÚXRZHEñC×1Ï3NC Z>ÏÚ^AL¿^ Ì C÷Pp^aXRWMWYC3?AC EìÏ3LEUCM; Ë|Ì CäZULMZÒ Pp^aXRWMWYC3?AC EñPOÐ>XM?APOC¸ÐU?AC PAPOÍU?OCõÏLY?O?AC Ï^ON¡LMZñCÕ_Í>XJ^ANLYZPAÏ Ì C3@dCõDCXMEUP#^ALXMZêN¡Z>XMÏ ÏÍU?aXJ^AC LYPAÏN¡DDFXJ^ALM?AÚäÐ>?OCPOPOÍU?AC]XMZ>E¿N¡Z>Ï3LMZ>PON¡P^OC Z_^dWY?ONFEøÏLMZØYC3?AWMC3ZHÏC1ÎæLY?d^OC @Ð[C3?aXJ^AÍU?AC8XMZ>E¢ ØMC3D¡LÏN^pÚMIXRZ>E¾P Ì LYÍUD¡E¾ZULR^ÖHC#Í>PCE¥; Ë|Ì C#ÍHPC1LMÎC3D¡DN¡Ð^AN¡Ï#NZ_^AC3?AÐHLYD¡XR^ON¡LMZõÎæLM?^ Ì C#ÏC DD άXMÏCØYC3D¡LÏN^ON¡C P!ELC PZULR^ PONWYZUNBHÏ3XMZY^ADÚ#EC^A?AXYÏ^|Îæ?OLY@·^ Ì CXMÏ ÏÍU?aXMÏ3Ú1XRZ>E]C×1Ï3NC Z>ÏÚ#LRÎ ^ Ì CZ>LMZÒqPp^aXRWYWMC3?AC EÏLY@ÐHXMÏ^
PAÏ Ì C @CYI Ì LJÔC3ØYC3?,N^iN¡PZ>LR^
ZUCÏCPOPAXR?AÚ±ÎæLM?^ Ì C!Îæ?aXMÏ^ON¡LMZ>XMD Pp^AC3Ð8@dC^ Ì LE]Í>POC E Ì C ?OCY; ö
Þn Æ ÷ùø2È!Ä úÅ 3Ý£È Y?Ä 9Å û v)w
x
5P|)z1¤²
5aüaýIz1$
|Ë Ì C!ÏD¡Í>Pp^AC3?,NFP,Ö>XMPOC ELMZdS,C3Z_^ON¡ÍU@ çëM; § » Ì ê|S
?OLÏ3C PAPC ?$ÔLM?AÙPp^aXJ^ON¡LMZHP3I Ô!N^ Ì ^ Ì C|åqZ_^OC3D º YRí#Ï Ì N¡Ð>PC3^ I¥ç_íMí#@ Ì êdÜ>?OLYZ_^:NFECîÍ>PXRZHE3YMíMíMT¸îiÚ_^AC P2SÛ
Ò º íMí\ݯ\ = T÷; Ë|Ì C POC ÔiLY?OÙP^AXJ^ANLYZ>PÏ3LYP^$XRÐUÐ>?OLmÑN¡@dXR^OC DÚÁ.¯:þ ¬ íMí|CXMÏ Ì N¡ZT°XM?AÏ Ì I ( íYí ( I XRZ>E±ÐU?ALJØN¡EUC
XRZC3ÑÒ ÏC3D¡D¡C3Z_^Ö>XMPOCÎæLM?^ Ì CÏ3LMZ>P^O?AÍ>Ï^ON¡LMZLMÎ[X2ÔLM?AÙPp^aXJ^ON¡LMZÏD¡Í>P^OC3?EUC ENFÏ3XR^OC E^OL±DFXR?AWMC|POÏ XRD¡C
~ np±²fay]ùOúûü ÏLM@dÐUÍU^AXJ^ANLYZ>XRD9Ó>ÍUNFE¸EÚZ>XM@dN¡Ï P3; Ë|Ì Cç_íMíM@ Ì êÎæ?OLYZ_^2PON¡ECÖUÍ>P¯NZÞÏLM@ÖUN¡Z>XJ^ANLYZVÔ!N^ Ì ^ Ì CS|Û
Ò º íMí@dC3@dLM?AÚÐU?ALJØN¡EUC P!XÐ[C XMÙ@dC3@dLM?AÚÖHXRZ>EÔ!NFE^ Ì LRÎ ; ; ( »±îiÚ_^AC PïJPOC ÏLYZ>E Í>PN¡ZUW1XEÍHXRD9Ï Ì XMZUZUC D9XR?aÏ Ì N^OC Ï^OÍU?ACÔ!N^ Ì PON@ÍUD^aXRZUC LMÍ>P±ëY; § »2ÖÚY^ACmïRPCÏLMZHE?AC XYE#XMZ>E ëM; § »2ÖÚ_^OC PïJPOC Ï3LMZ>E°Ô!?ON^OCY; Ë|Ì C Ì NW Ì @XMNZä@dC3@dLM?AÚVÖ>XRZHEÔ!N¡E^ Ì LRÎi^ Ì CPCd@XMÏ Ì N¡ZUCP ÐU?OLJØNFEC PWYL_LE#ÐHC ?ÎæLY?O@XMZ>ÏC¯ÎæLM?!DFXR?AWMC±XR?A?AXmÁÚ ñpLYÖ>P|^ Ì XJ^!?OÍ>Z]Ð>?ON¡@XR?AND¡ÚLMÍ^!LMÎ,Ï XMÏ Ì CY; Ë|Ì C POC3?AN¡XMD>Ð[C3?OÎæLM?A@dXMZ>ÏC!NFPEC3@dLMZHPp^A?AXR^OC EdÍHPN¡ZUW^ Ì CÎæLYDD¡LJÔ!NZ>WÖHC Z>Ï Ì @XR?AÙD¡LLMÐI $~ß ÿ à ã ß ÿ à ~ß ÿ ëà ß ÿ à $~ß ÿ à ß ÿ à ß ÿ ëmà XMÏ Ì N^OC ?AXR^ON¡LMZLRÎL_XJ^ANZUWÐHLYNZ_^
LYÐHC ?AXR^ON¡LMZ>P IRÔ!N^ Ì B>ØYC?AC XME>P XRZ>EVLYZUCÔ!?ON^OCY; Ë|Ì CS,C3Z_^ON¡ÍU@ Aå NZäPN¡ZUWMD¡CÐ>?OCÏNFPN¡LMZ¸Ï XRZ¸PON¡@ÍUD^AXMZUC3LYÍ>PD¡Ú8ÐHC ?ÎæLY?O@ çYíMí¯TVãäLM?aEUPaïRPCÏLYZ>E?AC XYEXRZHEçYíYí¯T°ãÞLY?AEUPïJPOC Ï3LMZ>EÔ!?ON^OCY; Ë|Ì CLYÍ^LRÎL_XJ^OÒ NZUWÞÐHLYNZ_^dÐHC ?ÎæLY?O@XMZ>ÏC#Ô!ND¡D
^ Ì C3?ACÎæLY?OC#ÖHC]D¡N@dN^OC E¿ÖÚõ^ Ì C]?OCXMEä^ALäXMÐUÐU?ALmÑN¡@XJ^AC3D¡Ú çYíMíYT°ÜDLYÐ>PïJPOC ÏLYZ>E¥; Ü$N¡WMÍ>?OC § ÐU?OCPC Z_^AP|^ Ì C?AC POÍUD^APLYÖ^AXMNZ>C E]ÎæLM? ^ Ì NFP¯ÖHC Z>Ï Ì @XR?AÙ#D¡LLMÐ8ÎæLY?^ Ì CS,C3ZUÒ ^ON¡ÍU@ çÏLY@ÐHXR?AC E#^OLXS,C3Z_^ON¡ÍU@ ; ?OÍ>ZUZUN¡ZUWXJ^ëM; ( » Ì êXMZ>EVX#ÛiLY@ÐHXMÕݱ:PONZ>W^ Ì CiåqZ_^OC DÜULM?O^O?aXRZÏ3LM@dÐUN¡DC ? ImØYC3?aPN¡LMMZ YU; í>I ?OÍUZ>ZUNZ>WLMZ8^ Ì C\!C E Ì XJ£^ L9NZÍÑ ¬ ; ( LMÐ[C3?aXJ^ANZUW1POÚPp^AC3@8I>Ô Ì ND¡C±^ Ì XR^ÎæLM? ^ Ì CdÛiLM@dÐ>XMÕ Í>PCE#^ Ì CÛiLY@ÐHXMÕÜULY?^A?AXMKZ -Y; çÏLM@dÐUN¡D¡C3?!?AÍUZUZUN¡ZUWdÍUZ>EC ?¯ÛiLM@dÐ>XYKÕ Z±:ÜïëY; ò
1500
P3 1.2Ghz Compaq DS10 P4 1.6Ghz 850chipset
MFLOPS
1000
500
0 100
1000
10000
1e+05
1e+06
1e+07
ª >ª xMfOnpj3[fAnqw¡v np3h_af|w¡v niµPp^A?AXR^OCi^ Ì C|C3â[CÏ^LRÎÏ3CiXRZHE^AL EC^AC3?A@N¡ZUCi^ Ì C|XMPOÚ@dÐ^OLM^ONFÏ
DFXR?AWMCXR?A?AXmÚ¯ÐHC ?ÎæLY?O@XRZHÏCM;mÜULY?XRD¡DM^ Ì C|@dXYÏ Ì N¡ZUC P$N^,NFPPOC3C Z ^ Ì XR^!^ Ì CÖ[C P^ Ð[C3?OÎæLM?A@dXMZ>ÏC2NFP!LMÖ^aXRN¡ZUC EÎæLM?¯P@XRD¡DXR?A?aXmÚ1P_N ê3CP3; Ë|Ì CÏ3DCXR?ADÚ1EUC3@dLMZÒ Pp^A?AXR^OC P^ Ì C#CâEUP^OLäX°ØMCÏ^ALM?D¡C3Z>WR^ Ì LRÎë ( I º íMíVÎæLM?^ Ì NFPD¡LLMÐ; å^N¡P#PC C3Z^ Ì XJ^1ÎæLY?XR?A?aXmÚPD¡C PAP^ Ì XRZ ë ( I º íMíÞ^ Ì C¸S,C3Z_^ANÍU@èç¾NFP1ÐU?ALJØN¡EN¡ZUW÷XRÖ[LMÍU^ ëM; ( »±ÜDLYÐ>PïJPOC ÏLYZ>EñÐ[C3?OÎæLM?A@XRZ>Ï3CMIÔ Ì ND¡C÷ÎæLM?VDFXR?AWMC ?°XR?A?AXmÚñPO_N ê3C PV^ Ì C¾Ð[C3?OÎæLM?A@XRZ>Ï3C N¡PXRÐUÐ>?OLmÑN¡@dXR^OC DÚÞçYíMíYT°ÜDLYÐ>PïJPOC ÏLYZ>E¥IXYPÐU?AC ENFÏ^AC EõÖ>XYPCE÷LMZõ^ Ì C@XMNZ¾@dC @LY?OÚ Ö>XRZ>EÒuÔ!NFE^ Ì ; Ë|Ì C#S,C3Z_^ANÍU@ ; P Ì LJÔPX¸PON¡@N¡DFXR?dÏ3XMÏ Ì Cmïm@XMNZ÷@dC3@dLY?OÚäØJXR?AN¡XR^ON¡LMZ¾N¡Z ÐHC ?ÎæLY?O@XRZHÏCMIXRD^ Ì LYÍUW Ì Ô!N^ Ì ^ Ì C]XMPOÚ_@dÐ[LR^ALR^ONFÏDFXR?AWMC1XM?O?aXmÚ¸Ð[C3?OÎæLM?A@XRZ>Ï3C?OCEÍ>ÏCE \ ]_^
Array size
¥µ n llfaPïJPOC Ï3LMZ>EI$ÏLY?O?AC POÐ[LMZ>EN¡ZUWÞ^OLõ^ Ì CV@dC3@dLM?AÚ÷Ö>XRZHEÔ!N¡E^ Ì ÎæLM?d^ Ì XJ^1@XRÒ Ï Ì NZ>CM; Ë|Ì C1ÛiLM@dÐ>XYÕVÝ2:E¥I9XMWYXRN¡Z ÏLM?A?AC POÐHLYZ>EN¡ZUW^ALdN^aP!@XRN¡Z#@dC3@dLY?OÚ1ÖHXRZ>EÔ!NFE^ Ì ; å^ N¡P¯ÏD¡C XM?!Îæ?OLY@á^ Ì NFP¯PON@dÐUD¡CÖ[C3Z>Ï Ì @dXM?OÙ#^ Ì XJ^ @XRN¡ZV@dC3@dLM?AÚ]Ö>XRZ>EUÔ!N¡E^ Ì NFP!^ Ì C EC^AC3?A@N¡ZUN¡ZUW¯Î¬XMÏ^ALM?NZ^ Ì CLMÍU^LMÎ>Ï3XMÏ Ì C
Ð[C3?OÎæLM?A@dXMZ>ÏC
ÎæLM?$^ Ì CPC?AC3ÐU?AC POC3Z_^AXR^ON¡ØMCÔLM?AÙ_Ò Pp^aXJ^ON¡LMZHP3;5L9XR?AWMCPAÏ3XMDC|^ Ì ?AC3CÒqEN¡@dC3Z>PONLYZ>XRDUÓ>ÍUNFE1PN¡@Í>D¡XR^ON¡LMZ>PiXR?AC!ØMC3?AÚ@dC @LY?OÚN¡ZY^AC3ZÒ PN¡ØMC
XMZ>E±Ö[LR^ Ì NZPOC3?AN¡XMDJÎæLM?A@ðXRZ>E±LYZ@LEC ?AXR^OC
PO_N ê3C E±ÔLM?AÙ¯P^AXR^ON¡LMZÏ3DÍ>P^OC ?AP^ Ì CiÏLEC P Ô!ND¡DÖ[C?OÍUZ>ZUNZ>WÐ>?ON¡@XR?AND¡ÚLMÍ^!LMÎ,Ï XMÏ Ì CY; Ë|Ì CØMC3?AÚ Ì N¡W Ì @XRN¡ZÒu@dC @LY?OÚÖHXRZ>EÔ!NFE^ Ì XRZ>EõÏLY?O?AC POÐ[LMZ>EN¡ZUW]LMÍ^LRÎ!Ï3XMÏ Ì CÐ[C3?OÎæLM?A@XRZ>Ï3CdLRÎ|^ Ì C1S,C Z_^ON¡ÍU@ ç°Ï3DCXR?ADÚ°@XMÙMCN^ XRZVCÑUÏ3C3D¡DC ZY^¯@dXYÏ Ì N¡ZUCLMZVÔ Ì N¡Ï Ì ^AL1Ö>XMPOCX1Ï3LM@dÐUÍ^aXJ^ANLYZ>XRD9Ó>ÍUNFEVEÚZ>XR@dNFÏ3PÐHXR?aXRD¡DC D ÏD¡Í>Pp^AC3?; û vhu
²£zaz1~)
5¤²
5aü¸aýIz´
|Ë Ì C±ÔiLY?OÙP^AXJ^ANLYZ#Ï3DÍ>P^OC ?!ÏLMZHPNFPp^aP|LRÎë § S,C3Z_^ON¡ÍU@·çd@XMÏ Ì N¡ZUCP3IUXYPEUC PAÏ?ANÖ[C E]XRÖ[LJØMCYI ÏLMZ>ZUC Ï^OC EÖÚ1X1ë íYíT°îN^APïJPOC Ï3LMZ>EdάXYPp^|C^ Ì C3?AZUC3^|POÔ!N^aÏ Ì ; Ë|Ì C±PÔ!N^AÏ Ì ÏLYP^!XRÐUÐU?ALmÑÒ N@XJ^AC3D¡ÚK.2:þ ( íMíXRZ>E^ Ì Í>P|^ Ì CÏL_Pp^!LMÎ9^ Ì CC3Z_^ON¡?OCÏ3LMZBHWMÍU?aXJ^ANLYZ1N¡PÁþëMëYI ç_íMí>; Ë L8?AÍUZäX8Ï3LEUCNZõÐ>XM?AXMDD¡C3D,LMZõX]ÔiLY?OÙP^AXR^ON¡LMZÞÏ3DÍHPp^AC3?N^N¡PWYC3ZUC ?AXMDD¡ÚVZUCÏC PAPAXR?AÚ ^OLø@dXMÙMCäPLY@Cä@dLENB[Ï3XJ^ANLYZ>P ;|SXM?AXMDD¡C3D¡NFPOXR^ON¡LMZ@XmÚìÖHCõÏ3XM?O?ANCEìLMÍU^]Í>PON¡ZUWéC N^ Ì C3? @CPOPAXRWYCdÐ>XMPAPN¡ZUW]LM?E>XJ^AX]Ð>XM?AXMDD¡C3DÐHXR?aXMEN¡WM@P ;Pp^AC3?IÔ!N^ Ì ^ Ì C#T°SåO¤Û XöD¡NÖ>?AXM?OÚ¿ò º I ¼ ôIPOC E¸ÎæLM?¯^ Ì Cd@dC PAPAXRWMCÐ>XMPAPN¡ZUW]ÏLECdXRZ>E°^ Ì CS,LM?O^ODFXRZH±E »2?OLYÍUÐ XN¡W Ì S,C3?OÎæLM?A@XRZ>Ï3C¯ÜULY?^A?AXMZ#Ï3LM@dÐUN¡DC ?|ÎæLM?|^ Ì CEUXJ^aXÐHXR?aXRD¡DC DÏLECòëíJô; Ë|Ì CÏ3DÍHPp^AC3?,ÔXYP$^OC P^OCEÎæLY?,X ÝøBHZUN^AC|ØMLMD¡ÍU@dC|EN¡PAÏ?AC^AN¡PAXJ^ANLYZLRÎ L9XMÐUD¡XYÏC î P$C Õ_Í>XRÒ ^ON¡LMZ°ÍUÐ[LMZÞXP^O?AÍ>Ï^AÍU?OCE8@dC P Ì Ô!; N^ Ì Ý¯N?ANFÏ Ì DC3^¯Ö[LMÍUZHEUXR?AÚ]Ï3LMZ>EUN^ANLYZ>P3I[XRZ>E°Ô!N^ Ì ^ Ì C C Õ_Í>XJ^ANLYZ>P,XRZ>EPOLMD¡Í^ON¡LMZB>C3DFEÖ[C3N¡ZUWP^OLM?AC ENZ^ Ì ?OC C|EUN@dC3ZHPN¡LMZ>XMDXR?A?AXmÚP9Ï3LM?A?OCPÐ[LMZHEÒ NZUW ^OL ^ Ì CZULEC P$LRÎ^ Ì C@CP Ì ; Ë|Ì CXR?A?AXmÚP¥ÔC3?ACÐ>XM?^AN^ANLYZUC EXMÏ?ALYPAP?OLÏCPOPOLM?aP¥N¡Z ^ Ì C N?^ Ì N?aEXRÑNFP ; Ë|Ì C|ENFPOÏ3?OC3^ONFPCEC Õ_Í>XR^ON¡LMZ>PÔC3?AC
POLMD¡ØMC EÍ>PN¡ZUW±XRZÍ>ZUÐU?AC ÏLYZ>EN^ON¡LMZUCE ÏLMHZ ñpÍUWYXR^OC±WM?aXMEN¡C3Z_^!PLYDØYC3?I¥òëYëôqòë ( ô; Ë L!ÐU?ALJØN¡EUC,X!Ï3LM@dÐ>XM?ONFPLYZ¯LMÎY^ Ì C
ENâE Ü$N¡WMÍ>?OC º ÎæLM?^ Ì C¯T¸Så,N@dÐUD¡C3@dC ZY^aXJ^ANLYZ;_=¯PiÏ XRZÖ[C¯POC3C Zd^ Ì C¯N@dÐUD¡C3@dC3Z_^aXJ^ON¡LMZLRÎ¥^ Ì C @dXR^O?ANÑVØYC Ï^ALM?2@ÍUD^ON¡ÐUD¡ÚVN¡P±P^O?aXRN¡W Ì ^ ÎæLY?OÔ|XR?aE8Í>PONZ>KW X SiÜ;[ãìN^ Ì ^ Ì CT°S
å ÏLEC^ Ì C @dXR^O?ANÑÒØMCÏ^OLY?LMÐ[C3?aXJ^ANLYZdÏ XRZÖ[CN¡@Ð>DC @C Z_^OC E1NZd^ Ì C¯PAXR@dC|ÎæLM?A@öXMP,^ Ì £C X¯S
ÜäÏLECMI Ô!N^ Ì ^ Ì CXYEUEN^ON¡LMZ>XMD>Pp^AC3ÐdLRÎXPOÔXMÐLYÐHC ?AXR^ON¡LMZÖHC3^pÔiC C3ZdZUC NW Ì Ö[LMÍ>?ON¡ZUW±ÐU?ALÏ3C PAPLY?AP$^AL P Ì XM?OC¯C3D¡C3@dC3Z_^aPiXR^i^ Ì C2XM?O?aXmÚÖHLYÍUZ>EUXM?ON¡C P ; Ë|Ì C2Ï3LEUC¯NFPiPON¡@Ð>DCPp^|Ô Ì C3Z#Ô!?ON^^AC3Z#Ô!N^ Ì XEÍ>@@Ú1C3D¡C3@dC ZY^!XJ^^ Ì C2Ö[LMÍ>Z>EUXR?AN¡C Pi^ Ì XR^NFP|Í>POC ENZ#^ Ì CPC±POÔXMÐ>P3; Ë|Ì C±ZUC NW Ì Ö[LMÍ>? PÔ|XRаLYÐHC ?AXR^ON¡LMZ°Ï XRZ°Ö[CN¡@dÐUD¡C3@dC3Z_^OCE°N¡ZÞXZ_Í>@Ö[C3?±LRÎÔ|XmÚP W ^ Ì CÏ3LEC Ì C ?OCÍ>POC P2X ÐHC ?APON¡P^OC Z_^|Ï3LM@d@ÍUZ>N¡Ï XJ^ON¡LMZ?OCÕYÍ>C P^ I_LM?!X Ì XRDÎ$Ï Ì XMZUZUC3D UI_Ô!N^ Ì ^ Ì CÏLY@@ÍUZUNFÏ3XR^ON¡LMZ Ð>XJ^O^OC3?AZ8ÖHC NZ>WNZUN^ONFXRD¡NFPCE8Ô!N^ Ì ^ Ì C 1Ï3XMDDFP I>XRZ>E#^ Ì C3ZVC3ÑCÏÍ^AC E]Ô!N^ Ì ^ Ì C "!!XMZ># E $" "!!dÏ3XRD¡DFP3; Ë|Ì C#Ï3LEUC]POÕN ê C PÎæLM?^ Ì CPC8ÏLECÎæ?AXMWM@dC3Z_^aPXM?OC1?AC3Ð>?OCPC ZY^aXJ^ANØYC1LRÎ^ Ì LYPOCLMÎ^ Ì C ÏLM@dÐUD¡C^ACÏ3LMaZ ñpÍ>WYXJ^ACWY?AXYEN¡C3Z_^2Ï3LEUC P2Ô!N^ Ì ^ Ì C@CPOPAXRWYCÐ>XYPOPON¡ZUW]Ï3LEC P¯D¡XM?OWYC3?¯^ Ì XMZ
ò
¶
np±²fay]ùOúûü
%'&)( *,+ * -/.)0213.)413.)5217681:9;1=;13.A@)6CB - *)D E1GFA%CH*&AI% JK&L3.0213.)421=.)5MON NQPR13S1?T U1:TKV21:TK.1:TPR1:T B21?TKW1:TKS XZY S)[,\]FA% I ( -%'^ _,( *`L7aR1:aR13WA>@b'E1^ALdNZUN^ONFXRD¡NFPC2^ Ì C @ÍUD^ON¡ÐUD¡CÐU?OLÏ3C PAPCP W ^aXMPOÙP|Ô Ì N¡Ï Ì XR?AC±ELMZUC±^A?AXMZ>POÐ>XR?AC3Z_^OD¡ÚÖ+Ú X SiÜ; Ë|Ì CiÐ[C3?OÎæLM?A@XRZ>Ï3CLRÎHC XMÏ Ì LRÎU^ Ì CÏ3LMaZ ñpÍ>WYXJ^AC
WY?AXYENC Z_^$N¡@Ð>DC @C Z>XJ^ANLYZ>P,XR?ACiP Ì LJÔ!Z NZ÷ÜNWYÍU?AC ¼ ÎæLY?XÞëíMíY`Ð>?OLYÖUDC @ POÕN ê CM;= PÏ3XRZäÖ[C1PC C3ZäÖHLM^ Ì ^ Ì C@dCPOPAXRWYCÐ>XYPOPON¡ZUW XRZ>EdEUXR^AX2Ð>XR?aXRD¡D¡C3DUÏLECP,ÐU?ALJØ_NFEC|WMLLEÐ>XR?aXRD¡DC DUPÐ[C3CEÍUÐ>P IRÔ!N^ Ì XMÐUÐU?ALmÑN¡@XJ^AC3D¡Ú § í Ð>XR?aXRD¡DC D>C3×Ï3NC Z>ÏÚÎæLY?iÍUÐ1^OL^AC3Z1Ð>?OLÏCPOPOLM?aP ;Rã Ì N¡DC2ÖHLM^ Ì XMÐUÐU?ALYXYÏ Ì C PXM?OC ÐU?OLJØNFEN¡ZUW \ ]_^ K
¥µ n llfaW Pp^A?OÍ>Ï^OÍU?AC EøÜULY?^A?AXMZ ¼ íäÏ3LEC EøK XmØN¡C3?OÒq:_^ALMÙYC PPLYDØYC3?dÔ!ND¡D!Ö[CV@Í>Ï Ì PN¡@dÐUD¡C3?Í>PONZ>W X S
ÜIUXMZ>E^ Ì N¡P!XMÐUÐU?ALYXYÏ Ì ÔXYP|Ï Ì LYPOC3Z;å^!NFP Ì LJÔiC ØMC3?ZULM^OC E1^ Ì XR ^ X S
ܾN¡P|D¡N@dN^OCE1^AL Pp^A?OÍ>Ï^OÍU?AC E¸XR?A?AXmÚ#Ö>XMPOC EVÏ3LEUC P I[T°S
å Ì XMP¯@ÍHÏ Ì WM?AC XR^OC3?Ó>CÑN¡ÖUND¡N^pÚ]Ô!N^ Ì ?OCPÐ[C Ï^ ^AL EUXJ^aXEUN¡P^O?ANÖ>Í^ON¡LMZ>P ; 1000
6
MPI HPF Speedup
MFLOPS
800
8
600
400
200 0
4 HPF Linear
2
0 0
H _3aféf R_3rpjlvh oqv lkmfAnõ_3n3lfa \ ]_^ ªa`,Hª µ¥3n llfa{|kRjlfAnq«uxRrpv mfao avRyYffAnq« oq\ ]_fA^ fª y>ª jsrpe1dµ h_y½|µ9 ¡w v np3h_af8v hQ[ ´ hrpYn av hRkmfaArpjlvh ðv jsrped½µ$Vav npfyrpv±ljlh_fa3n
oqfafyM_ û v
2
4 6 No. Processors
8
²£zaz1~)
5)|~z{}|)ü£ÚGf
10
ÚM ´
5
10 No. Processors
15
20
|Ë Ì C
K XmØN¡C3?OÒq:^OLMÙYC PPONZUW¯ÜULM?O^O?aXRZ ¼ í!XM?O?aXmÚ!LMÐ[C3?aXJ^ANLYZ>P¥XRZHE2ÎæLM?aXRD¡D Pp^A?OÍ>Ï^OÍU?AC P ;mSXR?aXRD¡DC DNFPOXR^ON¡LMZ±LRÎ[PÍ>Ï Ì X P^O?AÍ>Ï^AÍU?AC EÏ3LECiÍHPN¡ZUW£X NW Ì S,C ?ÎæLY?O@XRZHÏC
Ü>LM?OÒ ^O?aXRZVNFP ØYC3?AÚ]P^O?aXRN¡W Ì ^ÎæLY?OÔ|XR?aE¥ILYZUDÚ8?AC Õ_ÍUN¡?ON¡ZUWd^ Ì CN¡Z>Ï3DÍ>PON¡LMZVLRÎ^ Ì CÏ3LM@dÐUN¡DC ?2EUN?AC ÏÒ ^ON¡ØMC P
PÐ[C Ï3NÎæÚN¡ZUW±^ Ì C!DFXmÚMLYÍ^LRÎ[^ Ì CXM?O?aXmÚP9LYZ^ Ì CÐ>?OLÏCPOPOLM?aP I ZUL@dLENBHÏ3XR^ON¡LMZdLRÎ[^ Ì C ÏLEC!N^APOC3DÎ[NFP?AC Õ_ÍUN¡?OCE¥; Ë|Ì C Ï3LEUCÔ|XMPXMWYXMNZ^OCPp^AC EdLMZ^ Ì CZ>XJ^AÍU?aXRDUÏLYZØMC Ï^ON¡LMZdPp^aXR?O^ ÍUÐ#Ð>?OLYÖUDC @·N¡Z^ Ì ?OC CÒqEN¡@C Z>PONLYZ>XRD[ÎæLM?A@·LYZ]X]ë íYíM`¯WM?AN¡E; Ë|Ì C2ÐHXR?aXRD¡DC D[Ð[C3?OÎæLM?A@XRZ>Ï3C LMZ÷ÍUп^OLVÎæLYÍU?^AC3C Z¾ÐU?ALÏ3C PAPLY?AP±NFPP Ì LJÔ!Z÷N¡Z¿ÜN¡WMÍU?AC°ë í>I9Ô Ì C ?OC#PÐ[C3CEÍUоNFPÐ>DLM^^OCE XRWYXMNZHPp^ZÍU@Ö[C3?
LRÎÐ?AXR^ON¡L2NFPXMÐUÐU?ALmÑN¡@XJ^AC3D¡Ú ÏLMZHPp^aXRZ_^ÍUÐd^OLdë í±Ð>?OLÏCPOPOLM?aP I Ô Ì C ZjX Y; Y^AN@dCPPÐ[C3CEÍUÐNFPLMÖU^AXRN¡ZUCE¥IRXRZdC×1Ï3NC Z>ÏÚ LR Î YY; Ë|Ì CPOÐHC C EÍ>Ð]?aXJ^ANL^ Ì C3ZV?AC EÍ>Ï3C PÔ!N^ Ì X § ^ON¡@CP!PÐ[C3CEÍUÐ8LMÖU^AXRN¡ZUCE#LYZÞë ç ÐU?OLÏ3C PAPLY?AP I_XMZ8C×1ÏN¡C3Z>Ï3Ú1LRÎ,ç ; ; ñdÊ É¥ È ?ÊpÆ
à ÿÃ Ç ÞÆiÃ É Ý£È ÊpÆ
£Ã Ë|Ì CÎæ?aXMÏ^ANLYZ>XRDRP^OC ÐZULMZUÒP^AXMWMWMC ?OCE PAÏ Ì C3@dCÔ!N^ Ì Ï3LM@dÐ>XYÏ^ÐU?AC PAPÍ>?OCÏLY?O?AC Ï^ON¡LMZ2C Õ_Í>XRÒ ^ON¡LMZN¡PPOC Ï3LMZ>EéLM?aEC ?Ô!N^ Ì CÕYÍ>NØJXRD¡C3Z_^XYÏ3ÏÍ>?AXYÏÚ÷XRZ>EøC3×Ï3NC Z>ÏÚéXMP^ Ì C°Pp^aXRWMWYC3?AC E POÏ Ì C @dCM; Ë|Ì C|ZULYZÒP^AXMWMWYC3?AC EPAÏ Ì C3@dC|Ô!N^ Ì PÐHXR?aPCÐU?AC PAPÍU?AC|ÏLM?A?AC Ï^ANLYZCÕYÍHXJ^ON¡LMZÐHC ?Ò ÎæLM?A@dPÐHLLM?AD¡ÚXRZHEdÐU?OLJØNFEC P,N¡Z>Ï3LMZ>PON¡P^OC Z_^
ÏLMZØYC3?AWMC3ZHÏCM; DD¡N¡Ð^ONFÏ|NZ_^AC3?AÐHLYD¡XR^ON¡LMZdLRÎÏC DD άXMÏC]ØMC DLÏ3N^ANCPNFPdZULM^d?AC Õ_ÍUN¡?AC E÷Ô!N^ Ì ^ Ì C]Z>LMZÒqPp^aXRWYWMC3?AC EäÎæ?aXMÏ^ON¡LMZ>XMD!Pp^AC3п@dC3^ Ì LE¥I Ì LJÔiC ØMC ?Í>POCLMÎC3D¡DN¡Ð^ONFÏNZ_^OC ?OÐ[LMDFXJ^ANLYZ°ELC P¯ZULR^EC WM?aXMECXYÏ3Ï3ÍU?AXYÏÚY; Ë|Ì NFP¯NFP¯NZäÏLMZUÒ ^O?aXMP^
^OLN^AC3?aXJ^ANØYC!^ON¡@dC¯N¡Z_^OC3WY?AXR^ON¡LMZ1PAÏ Ì C3@dCPÔ Ì C ?OC ^ Ì C¯ÐU?OCPOPOÍU?AC ÏLY?O?AC Ï^ON¡LMZWYL_CP^AL
np±²fay]ùOúûü ê3C3?ALÔ!N^ Ì ^ Ì CN^OC3?aXJ^ANLYZVXRZ>E8C DD¡NÐU^ONFÏNZ_^AC3?AÐHLYD¡XR^ON¡LMZ8N¡P^ Ì C ZV?OCÕ_ÍUN?AC E#^ALÏLYZY^A?OLYD¥^ Ì C WM?ALJÔ|^ Ì LMÎWY?ONFE]POÏ XRD¡C2Ð>?OCPOPOÍU?AC¯C ?O?ALM?±ò § I ¬ ô Ë|Ì C Ì N¡W Ì @dXMNZ@dC3@dLM?AÚ¯ÖHXRZ>EÔ!NFE^ Ì LRÎ>^ Ì C|S,C3Z_^ON¡ÍU@ðç Ô!N^ Ì ^ Ì C º YMíÏ Ì N¡Ð>POC^$Ð>?OLMÒ Ø_NFECPiC3ÑUÏC3D¡D¡C3Z_^|Ó>LYXR^ON¡ZUWÐ[LMN¡Z_^!ÐHC ?ÎæLY?O@XRZHÏC¯XMZ>E#N¡P|ÔC3D¡D¥PÍUN^OCE1ÎæLY?|D¡XM?OWYC2PAÏ3XMDC Ó>ÍUNFE @CÏ Ì XRZ>N¡Ï PPON@ÍUDFXJ^ON¡LMZHP3;,îLR^ Ì @CPOPAXRWYC1Ð>XYPOPONZ>W ß T¸SåàXMZ>E¿E>XJ^AX¸Ð>XR?aXRD¡D¡C3D ß X SiÜ,à ÏLEC PÔC3?AC ^AC P^OCELYZ]XSçdÏD¡Í>P^OC3?|^ALEC3@dLMZHPp^A?AXR^OC¯^ Ì C±Ð>XM?AXMDD¡C3DXRÖUN¡D¡N^pÚ1LMÎ$POÍ>Ï Ì XάXMÏ3ND¡N^pÚM;[åqZ°Ð>XR?O^ONFÏÍ>D¡XM? N^¯Ô|XMP!ÎæLYÍUZ>E°^ Ì XR^¯Ö[LR^ Ì XRÐUÐ>?OL_XMÏ Ì CP|WYXmØMCC Õ_ÍUN¡ØmXMDC Z_^ ÐHC ?Ò ÎæLM?A@dXMZ>ÏCYI_XMZ>EWYNØYC3Z^ Ì C¯?AC3DFXJ^ANØYCC XYPC¯LRÎ$XMÐUÐUD¡ÚNZUW X Siܸ^ALXMZ1CÑNFPp^ANZ>WP^O?AÍ>Ï^AÍU?OCE K XmØNC ?Òp:_^ALMÙMCP|PLYDØYC3?!Ô!?AN^O^OC3ZVN¡Z°ÜULY?^A?AXMZ ¼ íUIU^ Ì NFP XMÐUÐU?ALYXMÏ Ì Ô|XMP!Ï Ì L_PC Z; Ë|Ì CÐHXR?OÒ XRD¡DC D>ÏLEC!Ô|XMPÎæLYÍUZ>E^OL Ì XmØMC|WMLLEÐHXR?aXRD¡DC DUPÐ[C3CEÍUÐdÎæLM?Í>Ðd^OL±^OC ZÐU?ALÏ3C PAPLY?AP IÔ!N^ Ì C×1ÏN¡C3Z>Ï3NCP
XMÐUÐU?ALmÑN¡@XJ^AC3D¡Ú^ Ì C¯PAXR@dC XMP^ Ì C¯ÖHC Z>Ï Ì @XR?AÙdÏLMHZ ñpÍUWYXR^OCWY?AXYENC Z_^iPLYDØYC3?; ÜULM?!@dLY?OC2^ Ì XRZõë íÐU?ALÏC PAPOLM?aP^ Ì CÐ>XR?aXRD¡D¡C3D¥C×1Ï3NC Z>ÏÚEU?OLYÐUÐHCE¥I>XMZ>EN^NFPÏD¡C XM?|^ Ì XR^ ÎæLM?Xäë íYí ` WM?AN¡EäÏLY@@ÍUZUNFÏ3XR^ON¡LMZ¸LJØYC3? Ì C XYEUP2XR?AC^ Ì C3ZõÖ[C Ï3LM@dNZ>W8EULM@dNZHXRZ_^ ;¥åqZä^ Ì C ÎæÍ^OÍU?ACXάXMP^OC3Á? »2NW_XRÖUN^ ZUC3^pÔiLY?OÙ#Ô!ND¡D$Ö[C^AC P^OC E°Ô Ì N¡Ï Ì Ô!N¡D¡DXMDD¡LJÔ@dLY?OCÐU?ALÏCPOPOLM?aP ^OL1Ö[CC×1Ï3NC ZY^ADÚ#Í^ON¡D¡N¡POC EVÖ[CÎæLY?OCÏ3LM@d@Í>ZUN¡Ï XJ^ANLYZ>P!LJØMC ? Ì C XME>PiÖ[C3WYNZ8^AL1EC3WY?AXYEC±^ Ì C ÐHC ?ÎæLY?O@XRZHÏCM; Ü$N¡Z>XMDD¡Ú±N^,N¡P,Ï3DCXR?$^ Ì XR^?AC3DFXJ^ANØYC3D¡Ú¯N¡ZUCÑÐ[C3Z>PON¡ØMCLRâd^ Ì C|P Ì C3DÎ>ÔLM?AÙ2P^AXR^ON¡LMZÏ3DÍHPp^AC3?aP Ï3XRZ]ÐU?ALJØN¡EjC »¯Ó>LYÐ[ïJPOC Ï3LMZ>E#PÐ[C3CEUPXR^!Ï3LYP^AP|D¡C PAP^ Ì XMTZ .¯: þë íU; íMíïJTVC WYXRÓ>LMÐ; µ+ "´N)
5$
5ý
5{A Ë|Ì CXRÍ^ Ì LM?aP|Ô!N¡P Ì ^OL#XMÏaÙZULJÔ!D¡C EWYC ^ Ì CPOÍUÐUÐ[LM?O^ LRÎ,^ Ì C Z ×Ï3C#LMÎ K XmØJXRD!\!CPCXR?aÏ Ì »2?AXMZ_^K íYíMí>ë3çRÒ ¼¼ ÒAë3ÒíMç>ë I[K2:Ü »2?aXRZ_^= Ë TVÒíYí ¬ ¼ YI =Í>P^O?aXRD¡N¡XMZø\C POC XR?aÏ Ì ÛiLYÍUZ>Ï3N£D »2?aXRZ_^1= íYíMíYíMí ¬¬¬ XR; Z>E¿^ Ì ÀC . ZUN¡ØMC3?aPON^pÚ¾LMÎ:Ú;EU; ZUC3Ú T°aX ñpLY? Õ_ÍUNÐ>@C Z_^ ÜUÍUZ>E; Üs91Å 9Ã É ´ ±²_¢YfazUyxv jl® }øhµo ®Yïµ9 eJz z tMò oqÃ3jlÙbaò o ç}b `?ç ç`aò ç3cOô a¶ ® z c òq× b ò çç P¶ c inpv _Hz¥jlh_>_oqz¥3hy8
hR`?rp`aeYô vhJt8ò xM¼òfall_d ¤¯R°7±²)³Q´µ©¶·µ¹¸ ºú¬û »aüªù µ û º¼ × ®|}÷jllj3® ûüFüùA;ü µ½º?¸7³ ºq û ¾¿¾¬±²)³À±FÂú Á]Âú Á_ªù ´]ù °7°O'û ³Jù ÃCµ û °7°7±²,³¶Ä²_úù ºÂÅaû ÆùOT® b¬uc¹µ¥npfaoqoaz ,32 YnpjyMfz d oqop3OeR_oqfOrqrpoaz ò ç}ç ¶M® c çR® d3npxRh_jsnzYxRrpfAkmfÈÇirqrpvMzYxRrpfakfah½_oqo«>fyYfAnp3hHz ´ kRjy±}V3fAnzM h_yG¢m3O ´ v h_3nqnM® ´µ©¶ÃÉRÁ_Ë ù ʸ ¾ÍÌüùOú¹ù Î
ù Åaù ºpù ²"Æ'ù ·¹Ï¸ü Ð,¾¡ù ÑKÒÓÉRÁ_§ù ´GµÔ¶ÕʸKºpùO´® b¬cäµ¥npfaoqoaz ,32 YnpjyMfz MË® d e_oq3opnp3lfaOoeR_½ oqfO2® rqrp !oavJzfaoqlfa afav hz yfayYkMjsjrpy¸jlvhHiz ®9ò Hç}vç km× fA® c hHz ¦iv fAnqrx®$xMeYnpfajl fAn©z Mt°9®$xJrpfafaldf ¢ nz ò h_y÷d3nqtõ®Uv oqfa ®Ö´ ÉRÁ_ùd×ر¥³CÁµiùºÂŸ ºÄ¾û ²ÆùdÙ;¸ ºúZºqû ²×ûK²"Ú»7¸'¸CÛ3®%b¬xRajlfahJrpjl²_1 h_y ® 9¦hY®3,jlh_fAnqfAnpnpfAjlrqh_rzJ# ®v fA_nqYnqtJrz3rpcjlv®h1 ® xR fAnpejlfa3oahH® z ¢Y® u´c¾faµnpfaoqfaoa "z Cz ,¢Y® ´¯v Yhnpj3yYrp vMf z z¢Yd® ´ 3voqoph_ 3eRnq_noqRfAz rqg rpoa®3z 9ò j ç¼Rç3eY¶Yv® c Yrz ò}ò ¡ ¦ ®µ