DOI: 10.1542/peds.2009-0701 ; originally published online February 1 ...

Poverty and Chronic Illness in Early Childhood: A Comparison Between the United Kingdom and Quebec Béatrice Nikiéma, Nick Spencer and Louise Séguin Pediatrics 2010;125;e499; originally published online February 1, 2010; DOI: 10.1542/peds.2009-0701

The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is located on the World Wide Web at: http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/125/3/e499.full.html

PEDIATRICS is the official journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics. A monthly publication, it has been published continuously since 1948. PEDIATRICS is owned, published, and trademarked by the American Academy of Pediatrics, 141 Northwest Point Boulevard, Elk Grove Village, Illinois, 60007. Copyright © 2010 by the American Academy of Pediatrics. All rights reserved. Print ISSN: 0031-4005. Online ISSN: 1098-4275.

Downloaded from pediatrics.aappublications.org at Indonesia:AAP Sponsored on May 29, 2013

ARTICLES

Poverty and Chronic Illness in Early Childhood: A Comparison Between the United Kingdom and Quebec AUTHORS: Beátrice Nikie´ma, MD, MSc,a Nick Spencer, FRCP, FRCPCH, MPhil,b and Louise Se´guin, MD, MPHa,c aDepartment of Social and Preventive Medicine, University of Montreal, Montreal, Quebec, Canada; bSchool of Health and Social Studies, University of Warwick, Coventry, United Kingdom; and cLea-Roback Research Center on Health Inequalities, Montreal, Quebec, Canada

KEY WORDS poverty, early childhood, chronic illness, asthma, low socioeconomic status ABBREVIATIONS UKMCS—UK Millennium Cohort Study QLSCD—Quebec Longitudinal Study of Child Development IS—income support SW—social welfare OR— odds ratio CI— confidence interval www.pediatrics.org/cgi/doi/10.1542/peds.2009-0701 doi:10.1542/peds.2009-0701 Accepted for publication Sep 28, 2009 Address correspondence to Nick Spencer, FRCP, FRCPCH, MPhil, University of Warwick, School of Health and Social Studies, Coventry CV4 7AL, United Kingdom. E-mail: [email protected] PEDIATRICS (ISSN Numbers: Print, 0031-4005; Online, 1098-4275). Copyright © 2010 by the American Academy of Pediatrics FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE: The authors have indicated they have no financial relationships relevant to this article to disclose.

WHAT’S KNOWN ON THIS SUBJECT: Poverty in early childhood is detrimental to children’s health, but the mechanisms are poorly understood. There is limited evidence on the impact of cumulative poverty in early childhood on chronic illness in childhood. WHAT THIS STUDY ADDS: First-year-of-life and cumulative poverty have similar effects on chronic illness in the United Kingdom and Quebec. Poverty in the fourth year of life only is associated with chronic illness in the United Kingdom but not Quebec.

abstract OBJECTIVES: Our goal was to examine the association between poverty, in the first and fourth years of life and cumulatively in the first and fourth years of life, and the health of children in the fourth year of life in the UK Millennium Cohort Study and in the Quebec Longitudinal Study of Child Development (QLSCD). METHODS: Data from the UK Millennium Cohort Study of 14 556 children and from the QLSCD of 1950 children were analyzed. Comparable measures of poverty were households in receipt of the safety-net benefit: income support in the United Kingdom and social welfare in Quebec. Three parent-reported health indicators were examined: asthma attack, long-standing illness, and limiting long-standing illness by the fourth year of life. Associations were explored with logistic regression modeling controlling for child characteristics and maternal education. RESULTS: Poverty only in the first year of life significantly increased the risk of asthma attacks and limiting long-standing illness in the fourth year of life among UK children; trends were in the expected direction in the QLSCD but did not reach statistical significance. Poverty in the fourth year of life only significantly increased the risk of all 3 outcomes for UK children but not for Quebec children. For children experiencing poverty in both the first and fourth years of life, the risks for all 3 outcomes also increased in the United Kingdom, whereas only the risk of limiting long-standing illness increased in Quebec. Adjustment for confounding had little effect on the increased risks associated with poverty. CONCLUSIONS: These findings suggest that experience of poverty at various times in early childhood increases the risk of asthma attacks and chronic illness in the fourth year of life; however, they also indicate that poverty at different stages of the early childhood life course may have different effects on chronic illness in different country settings. Pediatrics 2010;125:e499–e507

PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 3, March 2010


e499

Although poverty is widely accepted as a major determinant of child health,1–5 the mechanisms by which it impacts child health remain unclear especially in rich countries with relatively well developed social protection systems. Poverty in childhood has been shown to have an adverse effect on adult health,6–8 and there is a new interest in how early “adverse experiences associated with poverty can lead to a lifetime of illness and diminished capacities.”9 There are limited data on the impact of duration of poverty on health in early childhood, but authors suggest that chronic poverty is more detrimental to health in early childhood than transient poverty.2,10–12 Early poverty seems to have an impact on child health at 10 to 11 years,12 and growing up in poverty has been reported to carry a higher risk of chronic illness and asthma in childhood.13–15 However, few authors take into account the dynamics of poverty when studying the health of children, and we know little about the impact of diverse social policies on the health of children.16 The multiple correlates of poverty, such as increased levels of maternal smoking and low maternal education, pose significant methodologic challenges in studying the mechanisms linking poverty to child health. However, a clearer understanding of these mechanisms is key to informing social policies aimed at addressing the social determinants of child health. International comparisons, although methodologically problematic, offer the possibility of comparing the impact of poverty on child health in different countries and social policy settings. Important differences have been reported in child wellbeing when comparing income inequalities in industrialized countries at an ecological level.17 Few authors have compared the impact of long-term poverty during early childhood on child health by use500

NIKIE´MA et al

ing individual data from different countries. On the basis of secondary analysis of longitudinal data from ongoing cohort studies in the United Kingdom and Quebec, we explored the relationship between duration of poverty by using comparable measures collected in the first and fourth years of life, and chronic illness in 2 countries. In addition, we tested whether maternal education, maternal smoking, migrant status, violence since birth, and lone parenthood mediated the association of poverty and chronic illness and whether the association was explained by confounding by child and household characteristics.

METHODS Data from the first (9 months) and second (36 months) sweeps of the UK Millennium Cohort Study (UKMCS) and from the first (5 months) and fourth (41 months) cycles of the Quebec Longitudinal Study of Child Development (QLSCD) were analyzed. The UKMCS, coordinated by the Centre for Longitudinal Studies, Institute of Education, University of London, is specifically designed to follow “the new-century infants” and their families.18 Live births were drawn from the child benefit register after a multistage cluster sampling strategy that selected a random sample of 398 electoral wards, disproportionately stratified to ensure adequate representation of all 4 UK countries, deprived areas, and those with high concentrations of black and ethnic minority families.19 All infants who were alive and living in the selected electoral wards were eligible if they were born between September 1, 2000, and August 31, 2001, in England and Wales, and between November 22, 2000, and January 11, 2002, in Scotland and Northern Ireland, and in receipt of child benefit.18 Of the 20 646 targeted children, data were obtained for

18 819 living infants born to 18 553 participating families at the first sweep. Participating families were resurveyed when their infants were 36 and 60 months old, and will be followed-up every 2 years. The QLSCD is a birth cohort, coordinated by the Direction Sante´ Que´bec of the Institut de la Statistique du Que´bec since 1998. The sample was drawn from the Quebec live birth registry. Sampling followed a 3-step strategy.20 The resulting sample was representative of singleton live births registered in the Quebec live births registry in 1997–1998 with the exception of those on the Cri and Inuit territories, on Indian reservations, or in the northern region of Quebec (2.1% of live births). Infants born before 24 or after 42 weeks’ gestation (0.1%) and those with unknown gestational age (1.3%) were excluded. A random sample of 2940 singleton live-born infants was initially selected. Parents of 2675 children were reachable and 83.1% consented to participate.20 The baseline data collected at 5 months old included 2223 children of whom 2120 children were since resurveyed annually. Our analysis included singleton births only, involving 14 556 children with complete data of 15 596 children followed at 9 months and 36 months by the UKMCS (participation rate of 80% for singletons) and 1893 of 1950 children followed at 5 months and 41 months by the QLSCD (participation rate of 92%). The authors of both studies used structured questionnaires to collect data on children’s health and development, parental characteristics, and on household and community level living conditions. Trained interviewers conducted computer-assisted face-to-face interviews with the person most knowledgeable about the child: the mother in 99% of cases in the UKMCS and in 98% of cases in the QLSCD. Interviews were administrated


ARTICLES

in English in the UKMCS and in English or French in the QLSCD, at respondents’ homes. Respondents also answered paper-based self-administrated questionnaires. Data on birth weight were collected during the interview regarding 9-month-old infants for the UKMCS. Children’s neonatal health data were collected from hospital records in the QLSCD. Poverty was defined as households in receipt of the safety net state benefits: income support (IS) in the United Kingdom and social welfare (SW) in Quebec (see Appendixes 1 and 2 for details of monetary benefits according to family type). These measures were chosen because they were the most comparable across the 2 cohorts. IS in the United Kingdom is offered to families with savings of less than £16 000 and low income in which no member works ⬎16 hours/week. The amount received depends on family size and is below 60% of median income for households with children. In Quebec, families are eligible to receive SW when they have no source of income. For a lone parent with 1 child and a couple with 2 children, the allocated amounts were, 60% and 54%, respectively, of the low income cutoff defined by Statistic Canada.21 Households in receipt of IS when the infant was 9 months old in the United Kingdom and SW when the infant was 5 months old in Quebec were defined as poor in the infant’s first year of life. Those households in receipt of IS or SW when the child was 3 years old in the United Kingdom or 3.5 years old in Quebec were defined as poor in the infant’s fourth year of life. Poverty status was categorized as follows: never poor; poor only in the first year of life; poor only in the fourth year of life; or poor in both the first and fourth year of life (designated as cumulative poverty). Three health indicators, for which comparable data were available in PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 3, March 2010

both cohorts, were used to examine chronic health problems in the first 4 years of life: the occurrence of asthma attacks at any time up to the child’s fourth year of life; the occurrence of any long-standing illness; and the presence of limiting long-standing illness. In the UKMCS, asthma attack was not specifically defined in the question, “. . . has the child ever had asthma?” Chronic illness was defined as any long-term condition that had been diagnosed by a health professional and had lasted for ⬎3 months or was expected to continue for at least 3 months. These conditions include, among others, vision and hearing problems, asthma, and convulsions. Limiting chronic illness was defined as any long-term condition that limited the child at play or from joining in any activity normal for a child of his or her age. In the QLSCD, the question about asthma attack was, “In the past 12 months did [child’s name] have an asthma attack?” Combining mothers’ reports for the 4 first waves, asthma attack was operationalized as the occurrence of any asthma attack since the child was born. The presence of a chronic illness was established when a mother reported that during the previous 12-month period her child was given a diagnosis by a health professional of allergy, heart disease, bronchitis, kidney disease, mental disability, epilepsy, cerebral palsy, or any other health problem that lasted or might last for 6 months or more. Mothers specified whether the illness limited their child at play or from joining in any activity normal for a child of his or her age. A list of the questions used by the UKMCS and the QLSCD to collect data on the dependent variables is included in Appendix 3. Descriptive analyses were first conducted by using sample weights to account for the complex sampling design

in both cohorts. We explored the associations between poverty and chronic illnesses with logistic regression modeling introducing potential mediators known to be important variables in the pathway from poverty to ill health in childhood. These included maternal smoking, maternal education, lone parenthood, marital violence, and immigration status. Maternal smoking was defined as those smoking daily and subdivided into those who smoked during the child’s first year of life, during the child’s fourth year of life, or during both the first and fourth years of life. In the UKMCS, maternal education represents educational qualification obtained from the age of 16 years (no academic qualification, academic qualification at 16, academic qualification at 18, degree or equivalent) as reported by the mother at the first sweep. In the QLSCD, maternal education represents the highest educational level attained (partial or completed college or university studies; high school, vocational, or trade school diploma; or no high school diploma) at the baseline data collection. Marital violence was established when a mother reported having been physically hurt or threatened by her partner since her child’s birth. A mother was classified as an immigrant if she migrated from a non-European country. Mediation was assessed following the 4 relational criteria established by Baron and Kenny.22 None of the potential mediators fulfilled all 4 conditions. We controlled for potential confounding including child characteristics (gender, age, birth order, and birth weight) and the number of household members at baseline. Because children in both countries have free-attime-of-use access to all levels of health care, health care access was not relevant as a mediator or confounder. Because maternal smoking and education were not shown to act


e501

as mediators, they were treated as potential confounders. We conducted separate but identical analysis for each health outcome and each cohort by using SPSS 13.00 (SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL).

RESULTS Descriptive results are summarized in Table 1. In the UKMCS, asthma was reported in 1688 children (11.6%), longstanding illness in 2300 children (15.8%), and limiting long-standing illness in 422 children (2.9%). In the QLSCD, at least 1 asthma attack since birth was reported in 258 children (13.6%), long-standing illness in 341 children (18.1%), and limiting longstanding illness in 31 children (1.6%). In the UKMCS, 13.5% of children participating at 3 years old were living in families receiving IS during their first year of life, whereas in the QLSCD, 11.0% of children were living in households receiving SW at that age. However, 4.4% in the UKMCS and 5.9% in the QLSCD were living in poor families only during their first year of life, and 3.7% and 2.4%, respectively, only in the fourth year. For cumulative poverty, there were 9.1% of children in the UKMCS and 5.2% of children in the QLSCD who experienced poverty both during their first and fourth years of life (Table 1). In both countries, univariate associations suggest that children living in poverty have a higher risk of having 1 of the 3 chronic conditions: asthma attacks; long-standing illness; and limiting long-standing illness (Table 2). Odds ratios (ORs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) estimated at various steps of the modeling process are presented in Table 3. Model 1 provided unadjusted estimates of the association between poverty indicators and the outcome variables. Model 2 adjusted for maternal smoking, and model 3 additionally adjusted for the child’s and household characteristics. The full e502

NIKIE´MA et al

TABLE 1 Distribution (Weighted) of Children in the Second Sweep of the UKMC (N ⫽ 14 556) and the Fourth Wave of the QLSCD (N ⫽ 1893) According to Their Health Status, Poverty Status, Characteristics, and Mothers’ Characteristics UKMCS

Characteristic Health status Ever had asthma attack Long-standing illness at 3 y of age Limiting long-standing illness at 3 y of age Poverty status SW or IS in the child’s first year of life No Yes Cumulative poverty Never been in receipt of SW or IS SW or IS only in the first year of life SW or IS only in the fourth year of life SW or IS in both the first and fourth y of life Child’s characteristic Gender Girl Boy Age, mo 36–39 40 41 42–44 ⬎44 Birth rank First born Second born Third born or over Birth weight, g ⬍2500 2500–2999 3000–3499 ⱖ3500 Maternal characteristic Smoking status Nonsmoker or occasional smoker Daily smoker Education level Partial or completed college or university studies High school, vocational, or trade school diploma No high school diploma No academic qualification Academic qualification at age 16 y Academic qualification at age 18 y Degree or equivalent Mean (SD) No. of household members

model 4 controlled for all covariates by adding maternal education. In the UKMCS, unadjusted estimates show that experience of poverty only in the first year of life significantly increased the risk of asthma attacks

QLSCD

%

Count

%

Count

11.6 15.8 2.9

1688 2300 422

13.6 18.1 1.6

258 341 31

86.5 13.5

12 591 1965

89.0 11.0

1682 209

82.8 4.4 3.7 9.1

12 052 640 538 1326

86.5 5.9 2.4 5.2

1636 111 46 98

49.1 50.9

7147 7409

49.4 50.6

935 956

88.7 3.0 1.7 2.1 4.5

12 911 437 248 306 654

— 44.8 50.3 4.8 —

— 847 952 91 —

42.4 36.7 20.9

6172 5342 3042

44.1 38.8 17.0

834 734 322

6.0 14.8 36.1 43.1

873 2154 5255 6274

4.0 16.5 36.9 42.5

76 312 698 804

72.8 27.2

10 597 3959

75.3 24.7

1424 467

—

—

60.4

1143

—

—

22.1

417

— 12.7 47.0 10.2 30.1 4.12

— 1849 6841 1485 4381 (1.16)

17.5 — — — — 3.87

331 — — — — (0.98)

(OR: 2.04 [CI: 1.70 –2.44]) and limiting long-standing illness (OR: 1.49 [95% CI: 1.02–2.17]) in the fourth year of life. Adjustment for maternal smoking status, the child’s characteristics, and maternal education changed very little


ARTICLES

TABLE 2 Prevalence (Weighted) of Asthma, Long-Standing Illness, and Limiting Long-Standing Illness Among 3-Year-Old Children in the QLSCD and the UKMCS, According to Poverty Status UKMCS, n (%)

QLSCD, n (%)

Ever Had Asthma Long-Standing Illness Limiting Long-Standing Ever Had Asthma Long-Standing Illness Limiting Long-Standing Since Birth at 3 y of Age Illness at 3 y of Age Since Birth at 3 y of Age Illness at 3 y of Age Periods with income support or social welfare None First year of life only Fourth year of life only First and fourth y of life a

P ⫽ .001a

P ⫽ .001a

P ⫽ .001a

P ⫽ .007a

P ⫽ .289

P ⫽ .001a

1247 (10.2) 130 (20.3) 100 (18.0) 244 (18.1)

1853 (15.1) 108 (16.9) 111 (19.9) 255 (18.9)

302 (2.5) 21 (3.3) 38 (6.8) 64 (4.8)

208 (12.7) 19 (17.3) 6 (13.0) 24 (24.5)

284 (17.4) 23 (20.7) 11 (24.4) 23 (23.5)

20 (1.2) 4 (3.6) 1 (2.2) 6 (6.1)

P value for ␹2 statistic.

the strength of the association between asthma and first-year poverty, which remained statistically significant at the 5% level. In the QLSCD, none of the 3 health indicators were significantly associated with poverty in the child’s first year of life, although trends were in the expected direction. Table 3 also shows that in the United Kingdom but not in Quebec, exposure to poverty in the fourth year of life only is associated with higher risk for all 3 indicators of ill health before and after adjustment. The adjusted odds of asthma attacks, long-standing illness, and limiting long-standing illness remained significantly higher for UK children in cumulative poverty compared with the reference group. Only limiting longstanding illness was significantly associated with cumulative poverty for children in the QLSCD cohort.

DISCUSSION These analyses show that, in both countries, relative poverty during early childhood has health consequences for the child later on. In both countries, a comparable percentage of children in their first and fourth years of life were living in families receiving IS or SW. However, there was a higher percentage of cumulatively poor in the UKMCS than in the QLSCD. These differences remained even after applying the sampling weights that account for oversampling of low-income families in the UK sample. PEDIATRICS Volume 125, Number 3, March 2010

Our results demonstrate that in the UK poverty only in the first year of life was associated with an increased risk of asthma attacks and limiting longstanding illness in children in the fourth year of life. Trends for asthma and limiting long-standing illness were in the expected direction for Quebec children but failed to reach statistical significance as a result of small numbers. Poverty in the fourth year of life had very different effects in the 2 cohorts: in the United Kingdom, the odds for all 3 outcomes were higher than those for poverty in the first year only, but, in Quebec, there was no association between fourth-year-only poverty and any of the outcomes. Cumulative poverty was associated with higher risks for all 3 health problems in the UKMCS but only for limiting longstanding illness in the QLSCD, although the ORs for asthma and long-standing illness were in the expected direction. In the UKMCS, the higher risks remained significant for all 3 health outcomes after adjustment for confounding as did limiting long-standing illness in the QLSCD cohort. In addition, the findings indicate that poverty at different stages of the early childhood life course may have different effects on chronic illness in different country settings. The increased risk of chronic illness associated with poverty only in the fourth year among UK children but not among Quebec children may result from the known tendency for UK households with disabled children to

become increasingly disadvantaged as the children get older.23 In both cohorts, ORs for limiting longstanding illness were higher and more consistently significant than for the other 2 outcomes. Children whose long-standing illness is activity-limiting are more likely to be more severely affected by their illness than those with no activity limitation, suggesting that poverty may be causally related to increased severity of long-standing illness or activity limitation may be differently reported by poor compared with nonpoor parents. Comparison With Published Literature We are not aware of authors of published articles who compared individual level data on the relationship of early and cumulative poverty to chronic illness in early childhood. Social disparities in chronic illness in childhood have been reported from authors of various countries24–26; however, the specific role of early and cumulative poverty has received less attention.2,3 Our findings, particularly the UKMCS data, suggest that poor children are at higher risk of experiencing asthma attacks. Some authors suggest that disparities are related more to difference in management leading to more frequent and more severe attacks.2,27–33 Our findings that early and cumulative poverty are related to chronic health


e503

TABLE 3 Risk of Chronic Illness Among Children Aged 3 to 3.5 Years of the UKMCS and the QLSCD Birth Cohorts, as a Function of Cumulative Exposure to Poverty During the First and Third Years of Life Model by Outcome

UKMCS, OR (95% CI)

Household in receipt of SW or IS in the first year of life exclusively (reference ⫽ not in receipt of SW or IS) Asthma Model 1 Model 2 Model 3 Model 4 Long-standing illness Model 1 Model 2 Model 3 Model 4 Limiting long-standing illness Model 1 Model 2 Model 3 Model 4 Household in receipt of SW or IS in the fourth year of life exclusively (reference ⫽ not in receipt of SW or IS) Asthma Model 1 Model 2 Model 3 Model 4 Long-standing illness Model 1 Model 2 Model 3 Model 4 Limiting long-standing illness Model 1 Model 2 Model 3 Model 4 Household in receipt of SW or IS in the first and fourth y of life of the child (reference ⫽ never been in receipt of SW or IS) Asthma Model 1 Model 2 Model 3 Model 4 Long-standing illness Model 1 Model 2 Model 3 Model 4 Limiting long-standing illness Model 1 Model 2 Model 3 Model 4

QLSCD, OR (95% CI)

Limitations 2.04 (1.70–2.44) 1.82 (1.51–2.19) 1.76 (1.46–2.13) 1.67 (1.39–2.02)

1.55 (0.88–2.71) 1.59 (0.90–2.80) 1.51 (0.85–2.70) 1.52 (0.84–2.75)

1.15 (0.95–1.39) 1.09 (0.90–1.32) 1.08 (0.89–1.31) 1.10 (0.91–1.34)

1.25 (0.77–2.01) 1.20 (0.74–1.95) 1.17 (0.72–1.90) 1.13 (0.69–1.86)

1.49 (1.02–2.17) 1.40 (0.95–2.05) 1.37 (0.93–2.01) 1.39 (0.94–2.06)

2.82 (0.92–8.64) 3.04 (0.98–9.50) 2.67 (0.83–8.62) 3.16 (0.93–10.70)

1.93 (1.56–2.38) 1.73 (1.39–2.14) 1.66 (1.32–2.03) 1.55 (1.24–1.93)

1.13 (0.47–2.71) 1.15 (0.48–2.77) 1.17 (0.48–2.84) 1.17 (0.48–2.85)

1.64 (1.35–2.00) 1.55 (1.27–1.89) 1.50 (1.23–1.83) 1.52 (1.24–1.87)

1.55 (0.78–3.08) 1.51 (0.76–3.00) 1.46 (0.73–2.93) 1.43 (0.71–2.86)

3.29 (2.41–4.51) 3.02 (2.19–4.17) 3.02 (2.18–4.18) 3.11 (2.23–4.34)

1.20 (0.10–13.94) 1.25 (0.11–14.75) 1.21 (0.10–14.45) 1.48 (0.12–18.05)

2.02 (1.77–2.31) 1.74 (1.52–2.01) 1.66 (1.43–1.92) 1.52 (1.30–1.76)

1.73 (0.95–3.15) 1.77 (0.96–3.25) 1.70 (0.91–3.19) 1.71 (0.89–3.27)

1.32 (1.16–1.50) 1.22 (1.07–1.40) 1.17 (1.02–1.35) 1.20 (1.04–1.39)

1.44 (0.88–2.34) 1.37 (0.84–2.25) 1.38 (0.83–2.28) 1.32 (0.78–2.23)

1.83 (1.42–2.36) 1.68 (1.29–2.19) 1.67 (1.27–2.19) 1.69 (1.26–2.25)

5.56 (2.22–13.91) 6.77 (2.62–17.47) 6.90 (2.58–18.46) 8.01 (2.83–22.66)

e504

NIKIE´MA et al

Our study has a number of limitations that need to be taken into account when interpreting the results. The measures of poverty used are likely to have limited our capacity to demonstrate health differences between poor children and children classified as nonpoor in this study. Using safety net benefits to classify poverty excludes children of working poor families. For example, in the QLSCD, 50% of those children living below Statistics Canada’s low income cutoff are in working households that are not reliant on SW.15 Therefore, our results might underestimate the relationship between poverty and child health. The outcomes measured in the 2 cohorts are not identical and no information on the severity of asthma attacks or longstanding illnesses was available. The small numbers in the QLSCD resulted in unstable findings with wide CIs in some of the regression models. However, the direction of the effects was similar to that of the UK data lending support to the overall conclusions. The main strength of the study is the comparison between longitudinal cohort studies in the United Kingdom and Quebec at about the same period of time with high participation rates and with comparable data. Social Policy Implications

Results are from logistic regressions. Model 1, nonadjusted; model 2, adjusted for maternal smoking; model 3, adjusted for maternal smoking, child’s gender, age, birth order, and birth weight, and for household size; model 4, adjusted for maternal smoking, child’s gender, age, birth order, and birth weight, household size, and mother’s education.

problems in the fourth year of life support Chen et al’s12 conclusions that the effect of poverty on child health is cu-

and cumulative poverty are likely to exert negative influences on health across the life course.4,16

mulative rather than latent. In addition to their adverse effects on children’s health in the fourth year of life, early

Despite differences, for example in maternity benefits and child care, both countries have protective social policies for families and children. However, poor children are still more at risk of ill health. We suggest that policies aimed at more effectively reducing child poverty, particularly in early childhood, may reduce the burden of chronic illness in childhood.


ARTICLES

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The UKMCS was supported by the Economic and Social Research Council, the Office of National Statistics, and various government departments. The study was led by the Centre for Longi-

tudinal Studies at the Institute of Education of the University of London. We thank the Economic and Social Data Service and the United Kingdom Data Archive for permission to access the study data. The QLSCD was supported

by Canadian Institutes of Health Research grants 200309MOP-123079 and 200609MOP-165867 and by the Institut de la Statistique du Que´bec, Direction Sante´ Que´bec, which was responsible for data collection and validation.

dren’s lifetime predict health. Pediatrics. 2007;120(2). Available at: www.pediatrics.org/ cgi/content/full/120/2/e297 Newacheck PW, Rising JP. Children at risk for special health care needs. Pediatrics. 2006;118(1):334 –342 Rona RJ. Asthma and poverty. Thorax. 2000; 55(3):239 –244 Se´guin L, Xu Q, Potvin L, Dumas C, Frohlich KL. Socioeconomic Conditions and Health, Part 1: Poverty and Health in Que´bećois Children in the Que´bec Longitudinal Study of Child Development (QLSCD 1998–2002), From Birth to 29 Months. Volume 2, No. 3. Quebec City, Quebec, Canada: Institut de la Statistique du Que´bec; 2003 Mackenbach JP, Howden-Chapman P. New perspectives on socioeconomic inequalities in health. Perspect Biol Med. 2003;46(3): 428 – 444 Pickett KE, Wilkinson RG. Child well-being and income inequality in rich societies: ecological cross sectional study. BMJ. 2007; 335(7629):1080 Dex S, Joshi H. Millennium Cohort Study First Survey: A User’s Guide to Initial Findings. London, United Kingdom: London Centre for Longitudinal Studies, Bedford Group for Lifecourse and Statistical Studies, Institute of Education, University of London; 2004 Plewis I, Calderwood L, Hawkes D, Hughes G, Joshi H. Millennium Cohort Study First Survey: Technical Report on Sampling. 4th ed. London, United Kingdom: Centre for Longitudinal Studies, Institute of Education, University of London; 2007 Jette´ M, Desgroseillers L. Survey Description and Methodology in the Longitudinal Study of Child Development in Quebec (QLSCD 1998 –2002). Volume 1, No. 1. Quebec City, Quebec, Canada: Institut de la Statistique du Que´bec; 2000 National Council of Welfare. National Council of Welfare: welfare incomes 2005. Report volume 125. Ottawa, Ontario, Canada; Minister of Public Works and Government Services, 2006 Baron NM, Kenny DA. The moderatormediator variable distinction in social psychological research: conceptual, strategic,

and statistical considerations. J Pers Soc Psychol. 1986;51(6):1173–1182 Burchardt T. Being and Becoming: Social Exclusion and the Onset of Disability. Case Report 21. London, United Kingdom: Economic and Social Research Council Centre for Analysis of Social Exclusion, London School of Economics; 2003 Gordon D, Parker R, Loughran F, Heslop P. Disabled Children in Britain: A Re-analysis of the OPCS Disability Surveys. London, United Kingdom: Stationery Office; 2000 Newacheck PW, Stein REK, Bauman L, Hung YY; Research Consortium on Children With Chronic Conditions. Disparities in the prevalence of disability between black and white children. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2003; 157:244 –248 Berntsson L, Kohler L. Long-term illness and psychosomatic complaints in children aged 2–17 years in the five Nordic countries: comparison between 1984 and 1996. Eur J Public Health. 2001;11(1):35– 42 Garner R, Kohen D. Changes in the prevalence of asthma among Canadian children. Health Rep. 2008;19(2):45–50 Brooks-Gunn J, Duncan GJ. The effects of poverty on children. Future Child. 1997;7(2): 55–71 Chen E. Why socioeconomic status affects the health of children. Am Psychol. 2004; 13(3):112–115 Chen E, Fisher E, Bacharier L, Strunk R. Socioeconomic status, stress, and immune markers in adolescents with asthma. Psychosom Med. 2003;65(6):984 –992 Gruchalla RS, Pongracic J, Plaut M, et al. Inner city asthma: relationships among sensitivity, allergen exposure, and asthma morbidity. J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2005;115(3): 478 – 485 Newacheck PW, Halfon N. Prevalence, impact, and trends in childhood disability due to asthma. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2000; 154(3):287–293 Smith LA, Hatcher-Ross JL, Wertheimer R, Kahn RS. Rethinking race/ethnicity, income, and childhood asthma: racial/ethnic disparities concentrated among very poor. Public Health Rep. 2005;120:109 –116

REFERENCES 1. Phipps S. The Impact of Poverty on Health. Ottawa, Ontario, Canada: Canadian Population Health Initiative and Canadian Institute for Health Information; 2003 2. Se´guin L, Nikie´ma B, Gauvin L, Zunzunegui MV, Xu Q. Duration of poverty and child health in the Quebec Longitudinal Study of Child Development: longitudinal analysis of a birth cohort. Pediatrics. 2007;119(5). Available at: www.pediatrics.org/cgi/ content/full/119/5/e1063 3. Se´guin L, Xu Q, Gauvin L, Zunzunegui MV, Potvin L, Frohlich KL. Understanding the dimensions of socioeconomic status that influence toddlers’ health: unique impact of lack of money for basic needs in Quebec ’s birth cohort. J Epidemiol Community Health. 2005;59(1):42– 48 4. Spencer N. Poverty and Child Health. 2nd ed. Oxon, United Kingdom: Radcliffe Medical Press; 2000 5. Wood D. Effect of child and family poverty on child health in the United States. Pediatrics. 2003;112(3 pt 2):707–711 6. Luo Y, Waite LJ. The impact of childhood and adult SES on physical, mental, and cognitive well-being in later life. J Gerontol. 2005; 60B(2):S93–S101 7. Lynch J, Davey Smith G. A life course approach to chronic disease epidemiology. Annu Rev Public Health. 2005;26:1–35 8. Van de Mheen HD, Stronks K, Mackenbach JP. A lifecourse perspective on socioeconomic inequalities in health: the influence of childhood socio-economic conditions and selection processes. Sociol Health Illn. 1998;20(5):754 –777 9. Shonkoff JP. A promising opportunity for developmental and behavioral pediatrics at the interface of neuroscience, psychology, and social policy: remarks on receiving the 2005 C. Anderson Aldrich award. Pediatrics. 2006;118(5):2187–2191 10. Lethbridge LN, Phipps SA. Chronic poverty and childhood asthma in the Maritimes versus the rest of Canada. Can J Public Health. 2005;96(1):18 –23 11. Logan S. Research and equity in child health. Pediatrics. 2003;112(3 pt 2):759 –762 12. Chen E, Martin AD, Matthews KA. Trajectories of socioeconomic status across chil-


13.

14. 15.

16.

17.

18.

19.

20.

21.

22.

23.

24.

25.

26.

27.

28.

29.

30.

31.

32.

33.


e505

APPENDIX 1 Value of IS and SW for Different Family Types With US Dollar Equivalents: IS Rates According to Family Type in the United Kingdom, 2003 Family Type

Single parent with 1 child ⬍11 y old Couple with 1 child ⬍11 y old Couple with 2 children ⬍11 y old or 2 children aged 12–16 y

£/wk

US $ Equivalent (Exchange Rate as of November 8, 2009)

Percentage of Average Earnings

108.90 140.00 178.50

179.23 230.38 293.78

22 28.7 36.6

Source: Department of Work and Pensions. The Abstract of Statistics for Benefits, National Insurance Contributions, and Indices of Prices and Earnings. 2007 ed. London, United Kingdom: Department of Work and Pensions; 2007.

APPENDIX 2 Value of IS and SW for Different Family Types With US Dollar Equivalents: SW Rates According to Family Type in Quebec, 2001 Family Type

Total Welfare Income Per Year in Canadian $a

US $ Equivalent (Exchange Rate as of November 8, 2009)

Total Welfare Income as % of Poverty Line

Employable adult Person with a disability Single parent with 1 child ⬍18 y old Couple with 2 children ⬍18 y old

6415 9314 13 318

5919.57 8594.68 12 289.45

34 49 57

16 919

15 612.35

48

a “Total welfare income” includes all income from basic social assistance, additional benefits, Canada Child Tax Benefit, Provincial/Territorial child benefits, the federal Goods and Services Tax credit, and Provincial/Territorial tax credits. Prepared by the Canadian Council on Social Development using: National Council of Welfare. Welfare incomes 2000 –2001, spring 2002. Available at: www.ccsd.ca/factsheets/fs㛭ncwpl01.htm.

e506

NIKIE´MA et al


ARTICLES

APPENDIX 3 Questions About Asthma, Long-Standing Illness, and Limiting Long-Standing Illness in the UKMCS and the QLSCD UKMCSa Asthma

Has Jack ever had asthma? 1 Yes 2 No 3 Don’t know

Long-standing illness

Does Jack have long-term conditions that have been diagnosed by a health professional? By long-term I mean anything that Jack has had for at least 3 months or is expected to continue for at least the next 3 months. 1 Yes 2 No

Limiting long-standing illness

If Jack has a long-term condition (CLSI ⫽ 1)

What is this? Write in the words of the main respondent Does this limit him or her at play or from joining in any other activity normal for a child his or her age? 1 Yes 2 No

QLSCDb The following questions are about asthma. In the past 12 months, did (child’s name) have an attack of asthma? Yes . . . (go to HLT-Q43D) 1 No 2 Don’t know ⫺2 Refusal ⫺1 In the following questions, long-term conditions refer to conditions that have lasted or are expected to last 6 months or more and have been diagnosed by a health professional (a doctor). Does (child’s name) have any of the following longterm conditions: (Read list. Mark all that apply) Allergies? 1 Bronchitis?. 2 Heart condition or disease? 3 Epilepsy? 4 Cerebral Palsy? 5 Kidney condition or disease? 6 Mental handicap? 7 Any other long-term condition (specify)? 8 None 9 Don’t know ⫺2 Refusal ⫺1 Does (child’s name) have any long-term conditions or health problems that prevent or limit his or her participation in school, at play, sports, or in any other activity for a child of his or her age? Yes 1 No 2 Don’t know ⫺2 Refusal ⫺1

a Adapted with permission from Londra M, Calderwood L; the Millennium Cohort Team. Millennium Cohort Study second survey: CAPI questionnaire documentation. 2006. Available at: www.cls.ioe.ac.uk/studies.asp?section⫽00010002000100040002. b Adapted with permission from Institut de la Statistique du Québec. In 2002 . . . I’ll be 5 years old: interviewer completed computerized questionnaire (ICCQ). 2001. Available at: www.jesuisjeserai.stat.gouv.qc.ca/pdf/questionnaires/E4-Questionnaire-informatique (Anglais).pdf.



e507

Poverty and Chronic Illness in Early Childhood: A Comparison Between the United Kingdom and Quebec Béatrice Nikiéma, Nick Spencer and Louise Séguin Pediatrics 2010;125;e499; originally published online February 1, 2010; DOI: 10.1542/peds.2009-0701 Updated Information & Services

including high resolution figures, can be found at: http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/125/3/e499.full.h tml

References

This article cites 22 articles, 7 of which can be accessed free at: http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/125/3/e499.full.h tml#ref-list-1

Permissions & Licensing

Information about reproducing this article in parts (figures, tables) or in its entirety can be found online at: http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/site/misc/Permissions.xht ml

Reprints

Information about ordering reprints can be found online: http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/site/misc/reprints.xhtml

PEDIATRICS is the official journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics. A monthly publication, it has been published continuously since 1948. PEDIATRICS is owned, published, and trademarked by the American Academy of Pediatrics, 141 Northwest Point Boulevard, Elk Grove Village, Illinois, 60007. Copyright © 2010 by the American Academy of Pediatrics. All rights reserved. Print ISSN: 0031-4005. Online ISSN: 1098-4275.
