Audiol. 2012;21(1):38-45.
Research Article
Evaluating the results of Persian version of the temporal resolution test in adults Shaghayegh Omidvar1, Zahra Jafari2, Seyed Ali Akbar Tahaei1 1 2
- Department of Audiology, Faculty of Rehabilitation, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Iran - Department of Rehabilitation Basic Sciences, Faculty of Rehabilitation, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Iran
Received: 14 April 2011, accepted: 17 October 2011
Abstract Background and Aim: Temporal resolution refers to the ability of perceiving changes over time. This study was conducted to prepare Persian version of the temporal resolution test, which was first introduced by Phillips (1994) and Stuart (1996), and to obtain its results in 18 to 25 year old normal individuals of both genders. Methods: To construct the Persian version of the temporal resolution test, like the original version, speech stimuli, continuous and interrupted noises were used. Speech stimuli comprised four lists of fifty words-monosyllabic lists, which were presented to the right ears first in quietness and then with continuous and interrupted noises on S/Ns of -20, -10, 0, +10 dB. The test was performed on thirty three right handed healthy individuals (14 male and 19 female with the mean age 21.02, SD=1.7 year old) in written response mode. Results: Significant difference was shown between test scores in quiet with each of the continuous (p @ :; *$ . Q O7P $ D 9 : 8 25 18 M7D I H N" ' 8 $ (1996) Stuart $ (1994) Phillips W '3% D< = . 3'8 TUV7 &" $ 'S &" '3% < = 9 TP F ( 7 SD B @ 9H 8 I F ( A 8 : < A8 G % W 8 -20 $ -10 3\ +10 &" : 7 8 A ( TUV7 $ 'S &" FZ Y OX8 $ > 8 A( S 50 A8 I ' " %b8 # a : 8 1/7 ] ` = $ 21/02 78 2 ( 14 $ 9 19) A8 A8 M7D I 33 $ B @ ]UV F]^ U . " % Z . P $ 9H > 9 ' 2 2 7dSD $ (p@0/0001)TUV7 $ (p$ 3 (p @2 ] ' 8 9H " M7D " 7 9 I 9 D$ % $ B @ 9H P :/ *! =* . &" : 7 8 A ( TUV7 &" 'S &" 9 > @ :/ *48 !>) G$
9> @
9H 8 I F ( F
(90/7/25 :G "i# 90/1/25 : ^ V AI " )
G9 # D " F7 9 V V= g D U@ A8 'I % > \ " 7 '8 9 S! $ ' #< = ( I$ " 7 '8 G9 # 9 " k ] 7 >@9 .A8 'I % Q ]^ U 'S !e; A8 $ B '3% < p8 7 ' > ! $ D MD D SD D $ D9 " 7 > !e; ' 7 \ . p 8H P W Q & '3% k I 7 W = &" "#
!
%$&#
!
& i%& 9 " A8 9 a i% q@
D< = c 3 A" $ " 7 G9 # " "& I D %E"$ 9 ] " # D 3^j \ 9 D %E"$ 2" 2" k 9 " .A8 '( $ > \ > ? < " 9 > @ .(1)A8 ] ; 9 > @ $ 2 9 F3Q$ c" f 7 9:; \ c" 7 > 8 "87 " > \ < 7 G9 # 7 9 D 9H S l " V . > !e; g "9 A8 $B m .(1) "i# on 9 9 = " 7 :
E-mail:
[email protected] 22228051-2 :23 15459-13487 : '(#
40
S! $
&" A ( TUV7 &" q@ M7D " 7 7! Phillips $ Stuart .(10) G &% f ]B TUV7 a 7 # 9 ' 8 9 3'8 " 7 '8 uV 9 > @ f]B a 77 O ]7 (> 8 D $ 7]") .(6)A8 9 3'8 P x" ; 2" 9 9>@ 8 &" on CM78 $ 9H < = 7! '3% < = 7 9 89 ]Q $ "9 r" H< $ A SD '3% < 9 > @ f]B on 8 2 9 > @ 9H A SD P . ' ' H 8 A SD $ & " 7 G9 # D 9H ! SM " ) &" q@ E"$ '3% D< = 2 7dSD $ (A8 P Q D 9H B @ F^ V x" ; 2" 9 > 2" "9 8 I F ( G &% $ 9>@ 9H 8 I F ( A 8 a = y .9 # M7D P I 9 D$ % H N" ' < 9H A 8 \ C $ W B @ ]UV F]^ U : 8 25 18 P I 9 D$ % $ H P $ 9 > @ . D w$ W < = t 8 9 9H A 8 F @ $ 'S &" . 3'8 TUV7 &" $ 'S &" " MDc 100 ( I a $ = ) 3; ' 8 9 TUV7 $ D. >$ 3' 9 D %E"$ 9 (& D 8000 . ' 8 & D 48000 % S A! 8 9 3'8 &" O I 9 W 8 c" a $ = 'S T 8$ &" f ; DA8 &" W TUV7 T 8$ &" . & D 8000 100 $ o 95 5 ?' G " H2 > 8 D $ $ % TUV7 &" 9 ' 8. W U'( H G # $ ' AD '3% '8 H D @ $ z ' . \ 50 H r8 :? 9 > A(
.(2) 7 '8 r8 9 >@ 9 H 8 A8 'I F\I f ^ .(3)A8 1947 : 8 A8 $ . I ] Garner r8 " 7 $ A8 A8 T .(1) " S " 8 7 H
i%& a = k I % > \ "9 > ]^ U " 7 ' $ = & 7 ^ F 7P 2 ^$ (gap detection) 9 9>@ " 8 &" $ W < = ^ 2" 2 > 8 \I " 9 F3Q$ 9 8s$ : V' (Temporal modulation transfer 9 > @ "9 A8 " G$ function) ? t Q$ 9 8s$ . 3'8 " 7 " 7 9H 2" . 9 :; $ 3' 8s$ DA! 8 ) 7 8 78> 8 " .D u A 7 " : 7 8 c" 9 vU8 ( 8s$ F '8H) 7 8s$ & WQ @ f .(4) k8 8s$ O I 9 ] 7! " P G$ SD $ Phillips 1994 : 8 9 > @ 9H .(4) I] 9> @ 8 9 ] > \ w$ u S! I] H TUV7 $ 'S T 8$ &" $ q@ &" :7 8A( " " 7! D w $ u 9 ' >$ 3 $ "9 (3 TUV7 &" 9 ' 8 9 3'8 I 8 ]' > ]^ U 9H 2" 9 .(5) H 9> @ " % : S'@ ! se' 98 " 7 k W A P$ (simulated O I " 7 k &" 9 " 7 k hearing loss) $ 7S^ 8 ]' 9$ 8 e' I I ;c" s I > ]^ U 2" N" ' .(4-9) 3'8 9 'S &" A ( TUV7 &" q@ M7D " 7 2 7dSD .(C # 9 " D a " #) ' S! I ;c" s O I " 7 k &" 9 " 7 k 9 P I (" V 7S^ 8 $ ]' 9$ 8
1391 1
21
41
$ %
! " #
$ $ ~ kD &" $ '3% : $ p8 7 &" :7 8 9H " W" I OX8 . 7'I % Q : c" DVD $ . } 19) M7D I 33 $ 9H P F @ 28 2 : 8 25 18 78 a $ = ( 14 $ 9 87 " 7 c7 : 8 1/7 ] ` = $ 21/02 P 8 ; &# ! a M7D " 7 (1 9 I $ B @ ]UV F]^ U . 2 2 W 8 10 9 'S `e' ) G % $ 7" Q $ '3% 8 7 9 9 ' (2 (G % $ u^ 62 D '8H r ( (4 $ 2' A8 A8 (3 G % $ M7D > \ .AI % M ( ) :$ 9 7! 8 I 9 8 B t \ ' 7 $ :e' % D FV 8 P$ "$ % $ D$ ` m ` m / '! &? @ P $ 8 . ' i% 7 ]^ U 9 I W ^ ` m 7 2 SD C8 # 9 } A" ! A $ ] •e F' S "n CD$E# . 3'8 .AI % > \ &# ! D$E# p( 9 O# ]^ U $$ D ] 9 I X 8 F7" ] ' . A 8 A" B G$ '3% 8 7 9 9H $ u^ 2 ' " OX8 $ $ G % A e8 8 2 7dSD . M 8 O ' S" ' " C" 9H ^ S'@ p 8H % D D M7D " 7 A ]B$ 9 H 9 O# . M I F I D W\ @ 7 S; ]^ U I 9 c" : Z "9 > = B H P a = $ 9H H ` D $ A8 U le $ 8 B @ 9H .A8 &" q@ $ > 8 '3% 8 7 9 " "9 $ D G % AQ D w $ A8 I 9 c" D FZ 7D 7 2" \ m F% " 7 d H OX8 . (" 7 S F@ $ 9>@ 9H D< =
1391 1
21
8s$ 9 2 S S $ "9 < % D9 % P &" 9 : 7 8 c 3 $ W\ @ 7 # $ \ Q9 9 ' 9 (sound level meter) f" : c" $ &" < = . 7 ( " r B '3% D< = t$ 9 C # o $ S S 2" H FZ 9 O# o $ $ t$ " : . A! 8 c" l " V 9H P 9s 9 .AI " F! SM 9 S 50 A8 I W '3% D< = CD$E# " MDc D w $ 9 " MD c D w $ % > S z ' . z ' (11) SD $ v m $ A" ! A8 I 2 P$ 9 @ P 7 . % z 7'P D w$ 9 2 7dSD { $ 29 9 c" D t Q$ O I DA8 I 2 P $ 9 ] CD$E# 7'8 ( SD 23 $ $ C W ) 8 I 9 . A" ! A8 I 2 $u (11) SD $ v m >S $ 'I % o D w$ 2 > 8 F \ I c" '3% AI " F '8H 9 s W 8 30 | (@ vU8 TUV7 $ 'S &" FZ Y OX8 $ > 8 a $ > \ W 8 -20$ -10 3\ +10 &" :7 8 A( 2 ^$ 9 W Q o 10 . Z (A8 G %) %c & D 1000 O I 8 7 8 > \ c" A8 I D 9 S . Z > k 7 AP Cool &I 9 9H f ' DC A 8 9H A8 I D D w $ 2 $ 3'8 Edit Pro 2.1 &" . 'I % ' " %b8 # a o . }s " D %E"$ & TUV7 $ 'S &" kD $ D w $ A8 I kD 9 OX8 A ( M" 9 O# $ AI % > \ % P > \ TUV7 / 'S
42
O#
EF
-20
-10
0 "
EF
? "
"
? "
C* % 0 / @7
+10
% 9
C* @7
# % 9
#
$% &
$' $ * ) *1 ;) A ) B*C * D1 )# ?
(33=#) 1H)
. 'I % I 9> @ H &I 9 D HW = ]^ U 2" . 3'8 p \ OX8 > \ w$ u S! 1 S . k 8 7 # 2" .A8 &" :7 8 A( 9 ]
vU8 $ ' " 9 3'8 H 9H A 8 OX8 $ > 8 A( @ ; W 8 30 | (@ W 8 -20 $ -10 3\ +10 &" :7 8A( &" $ FZ a . Z A8 G % TUV7 $ 'S &" $ A8 I FZ p z$ 7' I TUV7 $ 'S P . I m &" : 7 8 >$ 3' DA ( $ D w $ ; 9H P $ D w $ A8 I 9 8 A8 I c" $ "i# z 7'P DA8 I @ ; 9 z 7'P . $ DA8 I " 8 $ 2 A@ '8 D $ 9 9H I r8 D w $ X8 @ 2 9H P F \ I C" &I 2 7dSD $ @ D D9 ' . 3'8 ( " '8 I 'S &" (" V TUV7 &" FZ 7D w $ u I " a 7D &" : 7 8 DA ( 9 c" D @ D9 ' AI $ TUV7 a 7 # 9 ' 8 9 3'8 9 ' >$ 3 7]") C # 9 " D & . $ 9 " 7! ( 'S $ TUV7 &" q@ D w $ u
1391 1
21
43
$ %
! " #
(33=#) 1H)
#
" "
-20
-10
C* @7
Q: #
'@ #
0O
10 A g &" :7 8 A( 9 > @ 9 ' $ 28 2 D 7] h W 8 .(r=-0/065 p=0/721) A( H A8 9 > @ " V 1 :$ P .A8 8 &" :7 8 PA 7 9 &" q@ "9 A8 8 $ D 2" A( .A8 7S 9 s '! 9 9$ % 9 ; I TUV7 &" " 89 . $H kD I 9 7 7 ? "$ 9 9 @ 7 < .(12)A8 &" : 7 8 DA ( B @ F]^ U . ' D w$ u S! 'S (" V TUV7 2" (1994) SD $ Phillips Stuart f ' > ]^ U 7 # > \ c" on .(12$4-9 2)A8 'I " f; '3% : 7 8 A ( H > vU8 '3% 9 $ 9 .A8 '( $ 9 $ $ '8 H T" 8 " ( Hh ) M" \ I 7 # 7]" . " CD oj C # M" H on ( .7 M (C # 9 " D ) A"& c" 7
1391 1
21
D1
2
C* @7 +10
31/52 (11/10) 23/82 (12/04) 9/40 (10/24) 7/70 (9/11)
" $ z$ 7 > vU8 9 W^ $ '3% u S! TUV7 &" 'S &" (" V U" &" 8 "9 .A8 . ' AD A8 P H > @ D 7P 9 " "9 $ " > vU8 \ I M" C # 9 "D " A"& '3% &P c 3 $ "
$% & #
$ % & ( *1 ;) A )) B*C *
u D9 ' U8 &" : 7 8 DA ( S $ 'S r $ p TUV7 $ 'S &" $ '8 D w $ D ; SD .A8 C" S TUV7 ) \ 94/3 ( 7=7 $ |Y ) > 8 D9 ' 2 : 7 8 A ( CD . H A8 ( \ 100 86 a $ = TUV7 $ 'S 7=7 $ D D9 ' 2 &" TUV7 $ 'S &" $ p ; AI " CD A( \ 85/64 $ 77/94 +10 &" :7 8 A( :7 8A( \ 75/03 $ 66/24 3\ &" :7 8 : 7 8 A ( $ \ 56/61 $ 33/03 -10 &" ; SD . 8 \ 33/15 $ 2/85 W 8 -20 &" +10 9 &" : 7 8 A ( CD D 1 S 9 " D & ) TUV7 $ 'S &" $ 2 9 ' `e' -20 DA ( FSD .AI " C" &I ( 9 > @ 9 ' " C # $ 'S &" 9 s TUV7 &" S &" :7 8 . 'S p D w$ u 9 ' 2 2 HW = -10 3\ +10 &" :7 8A( 9 c" D > 8 W 8 -20 $ (p@0/0001)TUV7 $ (p$ 3 P$ 7] >$ 3 TUV7 $ 'S &" FZ A ]B$ $ > 8 D w$ u 9 ' 2 2 .(p@ " 8 |8 CD$E# x U 'I " 2" . 8 W ƒ ^8 ^8 & # C 7 $ (2005) Stuart $ F]^ U .(2) (" V : (% & $ % $ M ( s (% & 9>@ " ^ 8 12 28 2" SD $ Stuart r8 ]^ U | 8 . c" & f 9H 9 3'8 (2008) SD $ Werner $ 9H ' 9> @ " 8 M \I 2" " > ! .(13) ^$& OX8 $ ]\ $ c" $ 'I " N" ^ (% & a$ 9 " .D AI 7S^ 8 a $ 28 ' C" &I DA ( O7P $ 2 7] >$ 3 a D ! 2" D 'I " " 9 TUV7 $ 'S &" : 7 8 >$ 3' (2008) Schochat $ Samelli D 'I " CD$E# O7P on Q > ]^ U ; .(14)A xI $ A8 'I Q P 7 9 >@ " H ^ S'@ W ! $ O7P $ 2 >$ 3 $ = > ]^ U > ]^ U 2" A (7P on 2 >$ 3 .(15) ' # 9 H 9 & $ 8 I ] >$ 3 9 . 3'8 9H t " O7P / *! =* 9> @ " "9 $ = 7 ^ & P$ r" ) '3% D< = 9 3'8 9H 9 $ > 2" ' (7 9 89 7 TQ $ "9 8 I F ( A 8 S'D \ W ! " S 8 9 > @ 9H (1996) Stuart $ (1994) Phillips G$ 9 I 9 D$ % $ B @ 9H P FM ' . 9> @2 ] $ %9 9H " M7D " 7 2" MH 9 . '3% D< = 9 3'8 & " 7 G9 # Dp 8H 9 '(% f ; " 2" 9 on' ' 7 $ pm! >se' $
" a 7D TUV7 &" q@ '3% y B$ "9 > ! .A8 '3% &P c 3 " 7 '8 9 P '3% &" W\ I 2 A8 Q " 7 '8 " € w$ u 7 OX8 $ ' ^ SP .(2) " S Wm' kD > !e; c" 9 > @ f \ 3'8 ^ ls S] & D' I9 W @ U '8 " 9 a M7# ( Q D ' I : ) U ~ :$ F @ $ .A8 %k Sm & c" $ 9 a 77 x 3 pm! 9 O# ] y U8 n 7 $ D • " 7 $& @ '8 @ 2" 9 ! D< = .A8 " 7 SD 2" $ 8 & %k Sm ‚3@ '(DH > 8 $ `i@ T" 8 > 8 ; on' W@ 2" 9 " r8 A8 2 S 9> @. .(2) &" S!6 T p ]^ U 2" : 7 8 2 " # DA ( 2 7dSD . TUV7 9 ' 'S & ( ' ) s &" : 7 8 DA ( | Q &" ' TUV7 $ 'S &" 2 w $ u D9 ' >$ 3 SD SD $ Phillips Stuart > ]^ U D 'I " TUV7 $ 'S &" D9 ' 2 `e' .(12$5-9 2) q@ .A8 >$ 3' D 7" I A^ W ^ ls S'@ D&" 2 > 8 W\ I 9 7 TUV7 &" :7 8 z U DA ( %.7 3'8 M3 " S G$ A"& 2" P $ C # A8 2 S &" &" : 7 8 DA ( M3 D&" 2 W\ I 9 TUV7 $ 'S &" $ 2" P . P$ ' D9 ' 7 $ 3' 9 9 $ ( " l " V 3; ' 8 9 3'8 I " a 7D TUV7 &" q@ .A8 &" 9 9 > @ "9 9 ' $ 28 2 B @ 8 2" .A P$ 7] h +10 &" :7 8A(
1391 1
21
45
$ %
! " #
Dennis Philips '
$ Andrew Stuart ' 9 A 8 A P 9s D SD $ 7S 9 D " S7D FZ Q ' v m S= QH z 7P 9H 8 I F ( & F c^ 8 QH z 7P %w $ A8 I . % ]^ U 77 A I F $ &I A 8
$
# >
9> @ " uV u Q on C" # 2 7dSD $ @ P/
9H &# . S 3'8
/ )"C R
REFERENCES 1. 1. Sbinn
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
1391 1
JB. Temporal processing and temporal patterning tests. In: Chermak G, Musiek F, editors. Handbook of central auditory processing disorder. 1st ed. San Diego: Plural Publishing; 2007. p. 231-56. Stuart A. Development of auditory temporal resolution in school-age children revealed by word recognition in continuous and interrupted noise. Ear Hear. 2005;26(1):7888. Sbinn JB. Temporal processing and temporal patterning tests. In: Chermak G, Musiek F, editors. Handbook of central auditory processing disorder. 1st ed. San Diego: Plural Publishing; 2007. p. 231-56. Phillips DP, Rappaport JM, Gulliver JM. Impaired word recognition in noise by patients with noise-induced cochlear hearing loss: contribution of temporal resolution defect. Am J Otol. 1994;15(5):679-86. Stuart A, Phillips DP. Word recognition in continuous and interrupted broadband noise by young normal-hearing, older normalhearing, and presbycusic listeners. Ear Hear. 1996;17(6):478–89. Stuart A, Phillips DP, Green WB. Word recognition performance in continuous and interrupted broad-band noise by normalhearing and simulated hearing-impaired listeners. Am J Otol. 1995;16(5):658-63. Stuart A, Carpenter M. Unilateral auditory temporal resolution deficit: a case study. J Commun Disord. 1999;32(5):317-24; quiz 324-5.
21
8. Rappaport JM, Gulliver JM, Phillips DP, Van Dorpe RA, Maxner CE, Bhan V. Auditory temporal resolution in multiple sclerosis. J Otolaryngol. 1994;23(5):307-24. 9. Stuart A, Givens GD, Walker LJ, Elangovan S. Auditory temporal resolution in normalhearing preschool children revealed by word recognition in continuous and interrupted noise. J Acoust Soc Am. 2006;119(4):19469. 10. Scott T, Green WB, Stuart A. Interactive effects of low-pass filtering and masking noise on word recognition. J Am Acad Audiol. 2001;12(9):437-44. 11. Mosleh M. Development and evaluation of a speech recognition test for Persian speaking adults. Audiol. 2001;9(1-2):72-6. Persian. 12. Stuart A. Reception thresholds for sentences in quiet, continuous noise, and interrupted noise in school-age children. J Am Acad Audiol. 2008;19(2):135-46. 13. Werner LA, Marean GC, Halpin CF, Spetner NB, Gillenwater JM. Infant auditory temporal acuity: gap detection. Child Dev. 1992;63(2):260-72. 14. Samelli AG, Schochat E. The gaps-in-noise test: gap detection thresholds in normalhearing young adults. Int J Audiol. 2008;47(5):238-45. 15. Zaidan E, Garcia AP, Tedesco ML, Baran JA. Performance of normal young adults in two temporal resolution tests. PrKo Fono. 2008;20(1):19-24. Portuguese.
