Observability ! Existence under Bi-Annual Planning ...

0 downloads 0 Views 165KB Size Report
Incomplete Asset Marketsb. Soumitra K. Mallick. Indian Institute of Social Welfare & Business Management. Management House,College Square West,Kolkata ...
  !#"  $ &%')(*& +" -,.    /1023 4  !57698:*&2;<  =7?> @ A!B CD EGFHIJ KLHNM M DPOQ RTSVU DPH SWRTSVX EGD EGB EGYZAN[\@A O]DPHNM^1YM [HNFGY._a`bB X D S Y XGX KLH S HNc!YCY S E KLH S HNc!YCY S EedeA!B X Y!f ghA!M M Yc!Y.@ iBVHNFGYj^1Y X Ef IjA!M Q?H?EHlk?m!m'mk?n RTSVU DPH X C2HNM M DPOQVoD D Xqpsr C:J Y U B t Y r FGBVHNFGu!f vNm!m!n w `s@ xsy w gbx z{| } ~~ €G\‚ƒ „!…€}\-†ˆ‡‰e~ €GŠ| ‰N‹Z~ƒ ‚‚| ‚Œe€‰‚‰Ž„‡| †Š{‘‹!€€‚?†Tqƒ | …€’‹.ŽZ]Š“ €G†Š} ƒ ” €| † | ‚‰Ž.~ƒ €G†Š€ ‚‹e}T{‰’‡}•†Š{]†7†Š{€ ~!Š‰”ƒ €Ž‰–€G—!| }˜†Š€‚€ ‰– }T}T€G†ŽZ]Š“ €G†•€’™?š| ƒ | ”!Š| šŽ›| ‚}Tšq{ ‚Z€‰‚‰Ž„j| }€’™?š| œƒ €‚?††Š‰e†Š{€~!Š‰”ƒ €Žž‰–7€G—!| }˜†Š€‚€h‰–7€’™?š| ƒ | ”!Š| šŽŸ‡| †Š{'‚Z| Ž.~ €GT–P€G† ‰‚?†Š| ‚Œ€‚?†‰Ž.Ž.‰N‹!| †ˆ„&ŽZ]Š“ €G†| ‚L~!Š€| }T€‘}T€‚}T€'‹!€œ €ƒ ‰~ €’‹:| ‚:†Š{€Z~~ €G’ lz{| }~]T¡ †Š| ƒ ƒ „Z‹‹NŠ€}T}T€}†Š{€| }T}Tš€h‰–7‰”}T€GŠœ”| ƒ | †ˆ„j‰–7}T}T€G†\ŽZ]Š“ €G†€’™?š| ƒ | ”!Š| j¢ ‡| †Š{Z{€G†Š€GŠ‰Œ€‚‰š} ‡€’ƒ †Š{#‹!| }˜†TŠ| ”š!†Š| ‰‚V¢+”?„W'}T‰?| ƒ~ƒ ‚‚€Ge‡{€‚W†Š{€G„W]Š€.| ‚‰Ž.~ƒ €G†Š€¢+}€G—!| }˜†Š€‚€.| } ‚€€}T}Š]T„‰‚‹!| †Š| ‰‚e–P‰‰”}T€GŠœ”| ƒ | †ˆ„?  £hƒ }T‰!¢ | †| }+}T{‰’‡‚†Š{]†+| ‚‰Ž.~ƒ €G†Š€ ŽZ]Š“ €G†Š}7| }–P‰ŠŽ ‰–+| Ž.~ €GT–P€G†\‰Ž.~ €G†Š| †Š| ‰‚'| ‚‘–)G†Š‰hŽZ]Š“ €G†Š} ¤ ¥¦#§ ƒ }T}T| ¨’]†Š| ‰‚&§©Nª¢ «s¬­N¢ ®ª’¯N¢ ¦ª]°'±²q³ ´ µ¶T·¸¹ºP» ¼Šµ½b¾ ¿ ²qÀˆ² ½.Á¶ŠÂ ²qÀ)à ºP½b¾ ² ¶PÄ ² ¼ À ½.Á¶ŠÂ ²qÀ)Ã+Å º)ƈÁ»»ÇÁ¿¾ ¿ Á»»ºP»NÈ ² ¼Šµ» µ½ ³à µ Å ¸ ² ¶qÉÁ Å º)¿ À)³ Á» ·È ² » ² ¶qº¼ ²TÊ ºP¸ Àˆ² » ¼ ²

ˊÌÍ Î Ï+Ð?ÑÐNҊӝÍ?ÑÏÔNÒŠÕ ÒTÖ ×׈ҊØj٠ӈڒÛÜØ Î ÏˆÝŠÞ ÏˆÏˆÎ Ú’Õ Ï+ߝΠ׈ÍψҊÛsÎ Õ?ÑÓ+Ð?ÑÓ׈Π݊ΠÐ?ÑÕ]×ˆÏ ÑG××ˆÍ Òhàáàâlã ψΠÑÕ ÛsҊÒT×ˆÎ Õ ä#ÚÙ×ˆÍ Ò&â7ÝŠÚ’Õ Ú’ÛsÒT׈ӈΠÝ:àÚ݊ΠÒT×)åÜæ’ç’ç’æèeé ÑÍ Ú’ÓˆÒ’èeê)Õ Ø Î Ñ՛à]טÑG׈ΠÏ׈ΠÝqÑëeê)Õ Ï׈Π׈Þ׈Ғèì Ҋë Í Îeá í ڒë îÑGטÑè•ê)Õ Ø Î ÑÕlê)Õ Ï׈Π׈Þ׈ҏÚِàÚ݊ΠÑë+ï‘ÒŠë ÙPÑӈҏáŸð•Þ ÏˆÎ Õ ÒŠÏˆÏ-ñ.ÑÕ?Ñä’ÒŠÛsҊÕ]×qè í ڒë îÑGטÑèÑÕ Ø×ˆÍ Òê)Õò Ø Î ÑÕZê)Õ Ï׈Π׈Þ׈Ò-ÚÙ•Ì ÒŠÝ˜Í Õ Ú’ë ڒäå]è í Í?ÑӘÑä’Ð Þ Óqó ÌÍ Ò-ÑÞ×ˆÍ Ú’ÓhÑë ψÚÑݘîÕ Úqߝë ÒŠØ ä’ÒŠÏhÒqÑӈë Î ÒŠÓ ÝŠÚ’Õ]ô]ҊӈϘÑG×ˆÎ Ú’Õ Ï ßÎ ×ˆÍõó ö ڒë ҊÛeÑӈݘÍ?ÑîÎ Ïqè÷+ó õ ÑÍ Õè?øhó é ÑӈÚùÞ Ò’è ú ó ñjÚڒӈҒè ïûó éÚ××qèNú ó ð•ÒŠÕ Í?ÑÔ Î Ôèübó ýåÑӈî’Ú è ú ó ì Þ×טÑè ö ó àÎ ÝŠÚ’Õ Ú’ë ÖèàNó ñjÞ Ó׈Í]å]èàNó ú]ÑGþ!ӈÒTå]è ãhó ÿ!ÑÛeÑÕ.ÑÕ Ø×)ß+ÚeÒqÑӈë Î ÒŠÓ ÓˆÒTÙ ÒŠÓˆÒŠÒŠÏÙ Ú’ÓÍ ÒŠë ÐÙ Þ ë ݊ڒÛsÛsҊÕ]׈ÏqóÌÍ Ò Þ ÏˆÞ?ÑëØ Î ÏˆÝŠë ÑÎ ÛsҊÓÑÐ Ð ë ΠҊÏqó

  !#"  $ &%')(*& +" -,.    /1023 4  !57698:*&;<  =7 J R xsy jgbx R   ^  Y S HNc!Y S E X HNFGY  Y]EGYFGA!c!Y S A!B X f S H S O]DPHNMC2HNFGQ!Y]E X OH S r YûYD E  YFWO]A!C M Y]EGY A!F2D S O]A! C  M Y]EGYûH SVU E  D X YVHNB X E X HNM M7A XGX D r D M D EGD Y X J•YO’EGD !YM uO]A!C M Y]EGY S H S O]DPHNM\C2HNFGQ!Y]E X HNFGY S ANE7A XGX D r M Y p  Y S9U D •YFGY S EZHNc!Y S E X [H!O]Y U D •YFGY S E.QD SVU X AN[bFGD X Q  YH S A!Q! A  M A X H SV U  A!M YC2HNFO VHNQD X  "!#$&%'% J KLHNFGQ!Y]E‘D S O]A!C M Y]EGY S Y XGX C2H u1HNFGD X Y2YD E  YFZ[FGA!C(VHNFqEGDPO]D VH?EGD A S O]A SVX EGFHND S E X DˆJ Y!J p  Y S HNc!Y S E X HNFGYO]A SVX EGFHND S Y U [FGA!C)VHNFqEGDPO]D VH?EGD S c p D E .FGY X 7YO’EEGA U D •YFGY S E* S H S O]DPHNM X YO]B FGD EGD Y X  yeH U S YF  "! kNv %'% X YiB Y S EGDPHNMO]A SVU D EGD A S A!F[FGA!C E  Y'MPH!OQ:AN[bH+?HND MPH r D M D EŠu AN[ S H S O]DPHNM X YO]B FGD EGD Y X VH uD S clA, D S O]YFqEHND SLX EH?EGY X  YH S A!Q!A M A X Y]EJ HNMˆJ  "!#$&%'%  X VH S S D S c2O]A SVU D EGD A S J ^  Y S E  Y X YO]B FGD EGD Y X HNFGY S ANE- B FGYM u. S H S O]DPHNM r B E:O]A S EGD S c!Y S E&O]A!CCA U D EGD Y X E  Y/?HNM B YZAN[ X YO]B FGD EGD Y X H+?HND MPH r M Y[A!FsEGFH SVX [YFGFGD S c2O]A SVX B C EGD A S#r Y]E p YY SLX EH?EGY X H?E H S u X Y]ElAN[  FGDPO]Y Xr u›H S uÜHNc!Y S EfhD X Y SVU A!c!Y S A!B X EGA1E  Y#YO]A S A!C‘u U Y07Y SVU D S c A S E  Y‘EGFH U Y X AN[ E  Y‘AN E  YFjHNc!Y S E X J RTSûX BVO ûH&OH X YZE  Y U D X EGD S O’EGD A Sûr Y]E p YY S E  Y‘E p A EŠ1u 7Y X AN[hD S O]A! C  M Y]EGY S Y XGX O]A!M MP,H  X Y X D S EGAWA S Y!J w S ANEGD A S AN[hD C7YFq[YO’EZO]A!C7Y]EGD EGD A S A!FhC2HNFGQ!Y]Eh E  D S S Y XGX D S S H S O]DPHNM•O,H  D EHNM7C2HNFGQ!Y]E X D SWX BVO &H X D EGBVH?EGD A S D X32 D C7YFq[YO’E  S H S O]DPHNM % C2HNFGQ!Y]E X 2 J KLHNM M DPOQ  "!! n % VH X B X Y U H U Y S D EGD A S AN[•D S O]A!C  M Y]EGY-C2HNFGQ!Y]E X p  DPO ‘D X FGYMPH?EGY U EGA E  Y U Y S D EGD A S AN[7D S O]A!C  M Y]EGYbC2HNFGQ!Y]E X AN[ E  D X V,H 7YFY  O]0Y  E E VH?E  FGDPO]Y X HNFGY Y  A!c!Y S A!B X E  YFGY!J `bY X D U Y X f! E  Y U D X EGD S O’EGD A S&r Y]E p YY S D S O]A!C  M Y]EGYC2HNFGQ!Y]E X H X H2[YH?EGB FGY‘AN[ S H S O]DPHNM C2HNFGQ!Y]E X H SVU D S O]A!C  M Y]EGY‘C2HNFGQ!Y]E X H X H[YH?EGB FGY‘AN[  FGYHNM % O]A S EGD S c!Y S EO]A!CCA U D EŠu C2HNFGQ!Y]E XZp  DPO  p H X‘S ANE U D X O]B XGX Y U D S E  YFGYWD XU D X O]B XGX Y U  YFGY!J RTS E  4Y  FGY X Y S O]Y‘AN[ E  Y S AWHNF r D EGFHNc!Y‘O]A SVU D EGD A S HNM 5M S H S O]DPHNM X YO]FGD EGD Y X OH Sûr Y Y  FGY XGX Y U H X /H 7A!FqEq[A!M D A‘AN*[  FGD C2HNFGu w FGFGA p X YO]B FGD EGD Y X J 3x  D XhX EGFGBVO’EGB FHNMVYiB D ?HNM Y S O]Y  D X Y  M A!D EGY U D S E  D X V,H 7YFD S E  Y#O]A S EGY EAN[D S O]A!C  M Y]EGYWC2HNFGQ!Y]E X J 3x  D X FGYiB D FGY X u VH u!,A  C2H?EGFGD  p  DPO  D X H S Y EGY SVX D A S AN[j E  Y X 7YO]D [uD S c9 E  Y S ANEGD A S AN[  FGD C2HNFG. w FGFGA p S ANEGD A S D S C2H?EGFGD Ü[A!FGC:J 3x  Y U D CY SVX D A S HNM D EŠ6 u  FGA r M YC D X H X D C 7A!FqEH S ElH X E VH?EeAN[ E  YZHNM M A OH?EGD A SVX D S E  Y X EGB U u&AN[D S O]A!C  M Y]EGYjC2HNFGQ!Y]E X J

RTS E  Y'B M EGD C2H?EGY2H S HNM u X D X E  Y B F 7A X Y‘AN[hE  D X V H,7YFjD X GE A X  A p E  Y'[A!M M A p D S c D S E  Y r D  H S S BVHNM  MPH S S D S c2YO]A S A!C‘u  J R C7YFq[YO’EO]A S EGD S c!Y S E-O]A!CCA U D EŠulC2HNFGQ!Y]E D S O]A!C M Y]EGY X YO]B FGD EGD Y X C2HNFGQ!Y]EJ v J R C7YFq[YO’EO]A S EGD S c!Y S EeO]A!CCA U D EŠu&C2HNFGQ!Y]E C2HNFGQ!Y]Eb[HND M B FGYZH J X J n J RTS O]A!C M Y]EGY X YO]B FGD EGD Y X C2HNFGQ!Y]E C2HNFGQ!Y]E-[HND M B FGY.H J X J x A r YsA rVX YF ?H r M YhYiB D M D r FGDPHC‘B X E\Y D X Ef?E  D X D X A S Y-AN[VE  Y S YO]Y XGX HNFGuZO]A SVU D EGD A SVX [A!FsA rVX YF ?H r D M D EŠu!J t A!FeH4 MPH S S YFsE  Y.D S [A!FGC2H?EGD A S:X Y]EeA!B cE-EGAlO]A S EHND S H S H XGX Y XGX CY S EZAN[b E  Y2M D Q!YM D  AA U AN[sH U YO]Y S EGFHNM D Y U YiB D M D r FGD B C Y D X EGD S c#D S E  Y[B EGB FGY&H X HNM X AZ E  Y X VH U A p  FGDPO]Ye[B S O’EGD A S HNM7E VH?E p D M M•FGY X B M E-O]A!FGFGY X 7A SVU D S c.EGA4?HNFGD A!B X FGY U D X EGFGD r B EGD A S 7A!M DPO]D Y X J3x  D X V,H 7YFH S HNM uY X A SûX BVO LH 7A!M DPO]u FGA!c!FHNC:J ReX  A p E VH?E p D E l[B M M+CYH X B FGYC2HNFGQ!Y]E Xhp D M M7[HND M p D E :H S D S O]A!C  M Y]EGYC2HNFGQ!Y]E X EGFGBVO’EGB FGY r B E-[A!F FGYH X A SVXjp  DPO ÜHNFGY U D •YFGY S E‘[FGA!C E VH?E‘D S !Y X EGD cH?EGY U FGYO]Y S EGM u1D S x HNQ!Y X  D  vNm!m +% J x  YFGYH X A S D S E  D X V,H 7YF VH X EGA U A p D E  D C 7YFq[YO’EZO]A!C 7Y]EGD EGD A S FGY X B M EGD S c&[FGA!C 3 C 7Y]EGD EGD A S ?HNFGuD S c p D E 6 FGDPO]Y X B SVU YFZD S O]A!C  M Y]EGYlC2HNFGQ!Y]E X D S HWE p A U Yc!FGYYAN[eO]A! 7YFGD A U  MPH S S Y U YO]A S A!C‘u p  DPO lC2HNQ!Y X E  YFGY X EbAN[+ E  YEGD CY 7YFGD A U X Y  A!c!Y S A!B X EGA E  Y.C2HNFGQ!Y]E-CA U YMˆJ  E  Y#CA U YMˆf X YO’EGD A S n O]A S EHND SVX E  Y#FGY X B M E X f X YO’EGD A S  TR S X YO’EGD A S v RX Y]ElB  U D X O]B XGX Y X H S Y HNC M Y!J

v J K v J





 

g hyx w R x 

    %'%  ! %  #"  '$% %  #"  % &

'

x3 YFGYWHNFGY(' & HNc!Y S E X D S E  YWYO]A S A!C‘u!J AN['E  YD * F )\A S   YB C2H S S K#A!FGc!Y SVX EGYF S B EGD M D EGD Y X $  % x  YFGY.HNFGYE p A U H?EGY X mH SVU J   J 3 v

 +%

w c!Y S E XU D •YF47A XGX D r M u D S EGYFGC X   C YSEX     %'% ! H SVU Y SVU A p 

hH!O  VHNFqEGDPO]D VH S EjDD X O VHNFH!O’EGYFGD Y U#r uûH U D X O]FGY]EGY X B Vr X Y]E  GE A p  DPO   YlH?E  EH!O  Y X 7A X D EGD !Y  FGA r H r D M D EŠu 

  v         %       v          X A!CY    A OO]B F X H?E       

t B FqE  YFf



   %  

v 

 !#"$%$   '& )( +*    % 

n

 ,

 A OO]B F X H?E      & m.- /





%





%

%

v J v2gbd  R g b@ x  YFGYD X A S YjO]A!CCA U D EŠu2D S E  YjYO]A S A!C‘u!JhghA SVX B C EGD A S&r u VHNFqEGDPO]D VH S -E D+H?E-E 3  m‘D X-U Y S ANEGY U&r u102 H SVU ]O A S EGD S c!Y S E-O]A SVX B C EGD A S D S:X EH?EGY X H?EbE  D X-U Y S ANEGY U r u30  J w S u VHNFqEGDPO]B MPHNFFGYHNM D H?EGD A S AN[ VHNFqEGDPO]D VH S ED54 X Y SVU A p CY S EjH?EE  mlD X $ 2 H SVU D S:X EH?EGY X H?E    $ 7 6 $  % 98;?> _ D XA@ CYH X B FH r M Y!f p  YFGY @ D X E  Y Y r Y X iB Y CYH X B FGY  A !YFb E  YZ`bA!FGYM X B rVX Y]E X % AN[ 8;?>

J x  Y  FGDPO]YlAN[-E  YWO]A!CCA U D EŠu ?H EZE  m#D X‘U Y S ANEGY UCB  m E% D m p  D M YlD E X'X EH?EGY  3 ]O A S EGD S c!Y S E  FGDPO]YjD S#X EH?EGY X H?EsE  D XFB  %GD m J HNFqEGDPO]D VH S ED54 X B EGD M D EŠu'[B S O’EGD A Slp D E lFGY X 7YO’EEGA X EH?EGY X D X    %     % D Xhr A!B VS U Y U f D S O]FGYH X D S cH SVUWX EGFGDPO’EGM uWO]A S OH+!Y!Jx3 YjFH?EGYjAN[ EGD CY U D X O]A!B S EsD XIH  m  H    HNFqEGDPO]D VH S E-5D 4 X O  A!DPO]Y X H?EsE  m'D XeU Y X O]FGD r Y U&r u  

n

C2H 

:  :  > >

  0 2 %



>

H     %   0  %

    B  m % 0 2 B  %  0   % $  % B  m % $ 2 m > 0   $  [A!F  &   D [   %   

 %

X  mO]A!FGFGY X 7A SVU X EGA'E  m % J v J n R K  hy t -gbx K w yeIhxe@ B S D EhAN[•E  YO]A!CCA U D EŠu'D SlX EH?EGY  FGD C2HNFGu X YO]B FGD EŠu X D X HZO]A S EGFH!O’E p  DPO  VH u X X H SVU m'B S D E X D S HNM M+AN E  YF X EH?EGY X f H?EsE  J 

Y]Ef 0  ' B  

U Y S NA EGYE  Y U YC2H SVU [A!FO]A S EGD S c!Y S E O]A SVX B C EGD A SZr u VHNFqEGDPO]D VH S E D•[A!F X EH?EGY X H?EsE  c!D !Y S E  Y FGDPO]Y !YO’EGA!F  B  %'% D S EGYFGC X AN[  % J %'%'%

x  Y2O]A S EGD S c!Y S EjO]A!CCA U D EŠu#C2HNFGQ!Y]ED X2 D C7YFq[YO’E.H?EE  mWH?E  FGDPO]Y X  B   %'% 2 3 D WH?EsM YH X E X A!CYjDˆf X  r B Ef [A!FeHNM M *    

0  ' B   %'%'%

$%   m

0 (  ' B   %'%'%

$ (  m  $&%

x3 Y.O]A S EGD S c!Y S E-O]A!CCA U D EŠu2C2HNFGQ!Y]E-D X32 D C7YFq[YO’EeH?EbE  m 2 D LD EsD X D C7YFq[YO’E D S E  Y.M D CD Es[A!F X A!CY.O]A S !YFGc!Y S E  FGDPO]Y X YiB Y S O]Y  X % D S 8; >  k % J

x3 D XeU Y S D EGD A S AN[D C7YFq[YO’EO]A S EGD S c!Y S EsO]A!CCA U D EŠu&C2HNFGQ!Y]E X Y  H S EGYD X CANEGD  ?H?EGY Ujr uE  Y\[A!M M A p D S c-EŠu17YAN[ X O]Y S YFGD AVJ ^1Y X H ueE VH?E HeO]A S EGD S c!Y S EO]A!CCA U D EŠuC2HNF  Q!Y]E\D X D S O]A! C  M Y]EGY-D [•H S u/VHNFqEGDPO]D VH S E U AY XS ANE SVU H XGX Y]E X D S E  Y-C2HNFGQ!Y]E EGAEGFH SVX [YF 

]O A SVX B C EGD A SWr Y]E p YY S H S u2E p A X EH?EGY X A !YF p  DPO  Y U Y X D FGY X EGA X  FGYH U O]A SVX B C  EGD A S J x3B X f p  YFGY#HNc!Y S E X HNFGYWFH?EGD A S HNMsH SVU O  AA X Y&EGA6VHNFqEGDPO]D VH?EGYWD S O]A S EGD S c!Y S E EGFH U Y X Y SVU A!c!Y S A!B X M u!f  Y]EGYFGA!c!Y S YD EŠu&HNCA S clD SVU D D U BVHNM X FGY X B M E X D S E  Y 2 VHNFqEGDPO]D VH  EGD A S FH?EGY X 2r YD S c U D !YF X Y!J deY S O]Y!f?E  YFGY-Y D X E X H?E\M YH X E\A S Y3VHNFqEGDPO]D VH S E p  AZOH S S ANE SVU H VHNFqE S YF\EGAjEGFH U YsO]A S EGD S c!Y S EhO]A SVX B C EGD A Sp D E f p D E FGY X 7YO’E\EGA X A!CY X EH?EGY A!F X EH?EGY!J  3x  D XeU Y S D EGD A S H SVU E  YjCANEGD ?H?EGD A S D X EHNQ!Y S [FGA!C KLHNM M DPOQ  "!! n %'% J x3 Y X EGFGBVO’EGB FHNM X 7YO]D 7OH?EGD A S AN[VHNFqEGDPO]D VH S E X *    O]A SVX B CD S cLE  YD F'Y SVU A p3 CY S E X D S E  Y 2 O]FGD EGDPOHNM X EH?EGY 2 X OH Sr Y#O]A S EGFH X EGY UÜp D E  H r A!B SVU Y U FH?EGD A S HNM D EŠu X O]Y S YFGD A p  YFGYE  Yu&O]A SVX B CYjH!OO]A!F U D S c‘EGA X A!CY  D X EGA!FGDPOHNM7FGB M Y p  DPO WD X-S ANEsA  EGD CD D S c1D S›S H?EGB FGY  X YY:KLHNM M DPOQ  "!! n %'% J deA p Y0!YF.HNB EHNFGQu9OH S HNM X A r Y:HLFGB M Y!J RTS E  D X V,H 7YF‘ E  Y VHNFqEGDPO]B MPHNF‘CANEGD ?H?EGD A S D X'U YFGD !Y U [FGA!CHLCD  Y U YO]A S A!C‘u p  YFGY HNc!Y S E X A  EGD CD Y p D E  D S E  Y&O]Y S EGFHNM M u X 7YO]D VY U r D  H S S BVHNM  MPH S S D S c X EGFGBVO’EGB FGY X A E VH?E VHNFqEGDPO]D VH S E X A  EGD CD Y p D E FGY X 7YO’E\EGAjE p A U H?EGY X H?EHEGD CY!f  A p 0Y !YFYH!O  U Y  O]D X D A S  A!FGD A S D XhU YFGD !Y U [FGA!C X A!CYeD SVU D D U BVHNMVA  EGD CD D S c‘CA U YM p D E lFGY X 7YO’EEGA X A!CY ?HNFGDPH r M YD S [A!FGC2H?EGD A S O]A X EsAN[ VHNFqEGDPO]D VH?EGD A S  X YY.KLHNM M DPOQ  vNm!mvNH % [A!Fh E  Y.CA  EGD ?H?EGD A S AN[ X BVO LD SVU D D U BVHNMA  EGD CD H?EGD A SLp D E 1H U D X O]FGY]EGY ?HNM B Y U EGYO  S A!M A!c!u:H SVU M A!cHNFGD E  CDPO  FGY][YFGY S O]Y X H SVU KLHNM M DPOQ  vNm!mv r % [A!Fs E  Y‘C2H? E  YC2H?EGDPOHNM O VHNFH!O’EGYFGD H  EGD A S % J w M EGYF S H?EGD !Y U u S HNCDPO VHNFqEGDPO]D VH?EGD A S CA U YM X HNFGY&O]YFqEHND S M u9O]A S O]YD ?H r M Y!J 3x  D X V, H 7YFZH XGX B CY X H p H uW E  Y2CDPO]FGAYO]A S A!CDP/O VHNFqEGDPO]D VH?EGD A S D XGX B Y X H SVU O]A SVX D U YF X HNc  c!FGYcH?EGY U u S HNCDPO X f  A p 0Y !YF.D SVU D D U BVHNM p YHNM E 6 Y]EGYFGA!c!Y S YD EŠuLD X'X EGD M M[H!O’EGA!FGY U D S E  FGA!B c :O]A S EGD S B D EŠu  FGA 7YFqEGD Y X AN[D SVU D D U BVHNMY  O]Y XGX-U YC2H SVU Xsp D E  p YHNM E J x VH?ED SVU D D U BVHNM VHNFqEGDPO]D VH?EGD A S FH?EGY X ?HNFGD Y X H!O]FGA XGXsU H?EGY X H SVU ?HNFGD A!B X EŠu17Y X AN[ 3 X VHNFGY X VH X+r YY S A rVX YF !Y U D S E  YhO]A S EGYEAN[E  Y RTSVU DPH S @EGA OQjKLHNFGQ!Y]E+[A!F+E  Y 7YFGD A U r Y]E p YY S "! k?m  vNm!m!mlD S @ HNFGQ?HNFf\ysA?u!f\KLHNM M DPOQ•fB EqEHg VHNB U B FGDˆf_ g VHNQFH r A!FqEŠu  vNm!m +% J ^ VH?ED X HNM X A&EGFGB Y'D X E VH?EjE  YVH?EqEGYF S AN[hE  YD S !Y X EGCY S E 7A!FqEq[A!M D A-?HNFGD Y X A !Y*F  MPH S 7YFGD A U X J 3x B XS Y X EGY U FGYc!FGY XGX D A S CA U YM X Y  D r D E X D c S D 7OH S E U D !YFGc!Y S O]YD S  FGDPO]D S c‘[B S O’EGD A SVX H!O]FGA XGXbX YO’EGA!F X  FG Y VYO’EGD S c U D •YFGY S EeO]A S EGD S c!Y S O]D Y X % HNM E  A!B c l E  Y FGY X B M E X D S E  Y&HNc!c!FGYcH?EGYHNFGY  D c  M u X YFGDPHNM M uûO]A!FGFGYMPH?EGY U A !YF  MPH S 7YFGD A U X J ^  D M Y FGYc!FGY XGX D A SVX A S EGFH U D S /c !A!M B CY Xhp A!B M U2r YHZCA!FGY U Y S D EGD !YeEGY X Eb[A! F VHNFqEGDPO]D VH?EGD A S 

CA U YM X fY X EGD C2H?EGD A S AN[3 FGDPO]D S cW[B S O’EGD A SVXZp  DPO  X  A p X D c S D 7OH S E U Y07Y SVU H S O]Y2A S p YHNM E f•O]YFqEHND S M u-7A!D S E X EGA p HNF U X E  Y p YHNM E  U Y07Y SVU H S O]Y‘AN[Y O]Y XGXU YC2H SVU H SVU X B   M u2[B S O’EGD A SVX D S#X EGA OQlC2HNFGQ!Y]E X H SVUWX D S O]YjE  D X ?HNFGD Y X H!O]FGA XGX D SVU B X EGFGDPHNMc!FGA!B   D S c X fN E  Y  Y]EGYFGA!c!Y S YD EŠu‘H X 7YO’EhD X HNM X AjCYH X B FH r M YsD S H  FGA O]Y XGXX BVO 2H X D X A!B EGM D S Y U E  YFGY!J e[ O]A!B F X YD S:X BVO WH X D EGBVH?EGD A S Y  O]Y XGX !A!MPH?EGD M D EŠu2H X VH Xbr YY S A rVX YF !Y U D S E  Y H r A !Y X EGB U uW[A!FGC X E  Y‘CYH X B FGYZAN[\ E  Y‘Y EGY S EAN[ U D X YiB D M D r FGD B C:J 3x  D X VHNFHNc!FH,  D X CYH S E-EGA'CANEGD ?H?EGY E  YjFGY X B M E X AN[ E  D X V,H 7YF-D S H'O]A S O]FGY]EGYYC  D FGDPOHNM+OH X Y!J  3x  Y U Y]EHND M X AN[ E  D XeX EGB U ulC2H u r Y.A r EHND S Y U [FGA!C E  YZHNB

E  A!F % J v J R g  K  5 hx   K w yeIhxe@ @B  7A X Y 2H?EE  m‘H FGY  H+?HND MPH r M Y3!YO’EGA!FhAN[  FGD C2HNFGu X YO]B FGD EGD Y Xp  DPO  V H u'A, H?E-E  f p D E :FGA p FH S Q C2H   J C H   f E  Y X YO]B FGD EŠu&C2HNFGQ!Y]EsD X D S O]A!C M Y]EGY % Jbx3 Y r B U c!Y]E R [O]A!M B C S FH S Q  2 ]O A SVX EGFHND S E-D X GF Y p FGD EqEGY S D S  % H X 

B  m % 0 2     B  m % $ 2 B  % 0  B  % $% B  %     %  





p  YFGY!f  G     %'%  D X E  Y U YC2H SVU [A!F X YO]B FGD EGD Y Xr u#D\H SVU i:D X E  Y X YO]B FGD EŠu  98  FGDPO]Y !YO’EGA!FJ C H?EGFGD +f   %    % 98 < -     %'%  98
  % B C   %  % -    



 %

H SVU›r uÜO]A S EGD S B D EŠu E  D X O]A SVU D EGD A S  A!M U X D S E  Y:M D CD EJ w M X AVf p  Y S HNc!Y S E X HNFGY  Y]EGYFGA!c!Y S YA!B X-X YO]B FGD EGD Y X C2HNFGQ!Y]EeOH S YD E  YF r ‘ Y O]A!C M Y]EGY.A!FsD S O]A!C M Y]EGY  YVHNB X EGD !Y % J deY S O]Y!f [FGA!C  D D D % H SVU  D  %

  m % B C  m %  0 2  C

!

 % m t FGA!C S A STX H?EGDPH?EGD A S  % H VS U 7YFq[YO’E U D D X D r D M D EŠu9E  Y r B U c!Y]ElO]A VS X EGFHND S E X NH FGY X H?EGD X VY U&p D E :YiBVHNM D EŠu&H?EsYiB D M D r FGD B C:f [A!F   -  J





$ 2 %





  %  0   C



$%

%



R [E  Y w FGFGA p3 Y r FGYBlC2HNFGQ!Y]EbD X D C7YFq[YO’EeH?E-E  m r u  k % E  Y S [A!F X A!CYjO]A S !YFGc!Y S E X YiB Y S O]Y    X %'% H SVU [A!F X A!CY2D  C2H =( (     0   C $  %1  m !       0 (   C $ (  %  mL[A!F *    [FGA!C  % J›x3 D X H,  M D Y X D S E  Y:M D CD E X D S O]Y 0   C ' B C  %'%'% $  D X O]A S EGD S B A!B X D S  B C  % r ue E  YhKLH  D C‘B Cžx3 YA!FGYC  ysB U D S  "! k $&%'% f p  YFGY!f B C  %'% E  B  %'% J !

deY S O]Y!f X D S O]Y    % B  %& m  X YY t M A!FGY S H S AY]EJ HNM  "!!  % YCC2H +% H?EeYiB D  M D r FGD B C [A!F  C2H       % OH Slr YjH S u S B C r YFbD S   % [A!F    [A!F *    H SVU X H?EGD X [u  D  % r B E S ANE X A[A!FD[A!F p  DPO ‘D E\D X H VHNFqEGDPO]B MPHNF FGYHNM S B C r YF\H?E\YiB D M D r FGD B C  t M A!FGY S H S A'Y]EJHNMˆJ  "!!  % YCC2H2v % [A!F X BVO   B  %'% J deY S O]Y!f E  Y.B S DPiB Y S Y XGX AN[    % -  D X  D A!MPH?EGY U [A!F X BVO   B  %'% J deY S O]Y!f  k %  D S O]A!C M Y]EGYjC2HNFGQ!Y]E X-p D E :FGY X 7YO’E-EGA2C2H?EGFGD  w J x A  FGA !YjE  Y‘O]A S ! YF X Y!Js@B  7A X Y p J MˆJ AVJ cVJ-A S M u-VHNFqEGDPO]D VH S E eD XU D •YFGY S Ee[FGA!C E  Y.FGY X EJ

Y]Ef    1 % 

(   % [ A!F  



EGD A SVX HNFGY X EGFGDPO’EGM uD S O]FGYH X D S cVf  r M Y!J x3 YFGY][A!FGY!f 



 m % B  m %  0 2  

H?EeYiB D M D r FGD B C:J



 m %B

!

$ (2 %





  % B  %  0 



(   % B  %  0 ( 





!

>



( 

 %









%'%

B





% 

0 (





$  %  m 

(





 %









m

(    % B    %  0 ( 



 ! < > w EeYiB D M D r FGD B C X B CCD S c2A !YF-HNM MD X 



B





 %

 m



$%(  %

$  %  m

(   % B  % & m !  

%'%

$% 0 ( 

" 

$ ( %  m

  % B  %  0 



$%(  %



$% %  m

&  x3 Y S f  H % H SVU  r %  

$ (2 %

  % B  %  0 ( 





>

 ( D 

m %  0 2 0 ( 2 $ 2 



!

$ 2 %

> D SVU DPOH?EGY X YiB D M D r FGD B C ? HNM B Y X %



Y]Ef p J MˆJ AVJ cVJ ( &  H SVU 

%



(  m % B , m %  0 (2

f[A!F.H S u VHNFqEGDPO]B MPHNF E  * Jlx3 YB EGD M D EŠuL[B S O   A!M U X H SVU E  Y1O]A!CCA U D Š E uD X 7YFq[YO’EGM u U D D X D  



C2H  (

%

 %





0 (

$ (  %  m JdeY S O]Y!fC2HNFGQ!Y]E X O H S S NA E r YD C7YFq[YO’Ef X D S O]Y



M D CD EeAN[ X A!CY.O]A S ! YFGc!Y S E  FGDPO]Y X YiB Y S O]YjD S E  Y7A X D EGD !YjFGYHNM X VH!O]Y!J



B   %'% D X E  Y

deY S O]YjE  Y  GF A7A X D EGD A S J 

FGA !Y U

xsd 3yhK Q  ,$ +2/ GH$%&*BAN/0$ GH! !# -&*$% !#/0$#&F1&*!? /0,0/HG0$ "/0I &  &0&*I ! - /1.@$ /'&F1$ P AN0/ @/0&3GH   ?J

y

 

t

ghA SVX D U YF-E  Y X H U U M Y[B S O’EGD A S   ' 0  %  $% %   B  %'%'%  ! !   0 2 % H    %   0  %  5 B  m % $ 2 0 2 % B  % $%

> Y S YjE  YZHNc!c!FGYcH?EGYA r ŠYO’EGD !Y[B S O’EGD A S 



"





  

 $ 

Y]Ef E  Y.A r ŠYO’EGD !Y r Y.C2H





0 

>



0  %76    9 8
>  8 ?>  8   $ >>  C  $>  C  $>  C  & m p D E   FGA r H r D M D EŠu  >C    >>  C & m  >  C & m  >  C  m 

RTSVU D D U BVHNM7v VH X\p YHNM E  U D X EGFGD r B EGD A S $    $ >  $   $   & m p D E        >      m    m  H SVU sEGD M D EŠul[B S O’EGD A S $,M   % [ A!FeHNM M X EH?EGY X [A!FeHNM M+D SVU D D U BVHNM X J B > C B  C B  C %  FGDPO]Y X    O]A SVX B C EGD A S  0 C>   0 >>  C  0 >  C  0 >  C %  0 C   0 >  C  0   C  0   C % 

RTSVU D D U BVHNMM54 X  FGA r M YC  >  C M S 0 >>  C    C M S 0 >  C  :   2      2 >    B >  C  0 >>  C $ >>  C % B   C  0 >  C $ >  C % m 0   C  $  C C2H 

RTSVU D D U BVHNM v 4 X  FGA r M YC 

>

>

C2H  M S 0 >  C :   2 >

n

   B >  C  0 >  C 

$j>

0   $ 



%

m

0   $ 

hiB D M D r FGD B C D X H 

B   B >  B " %  0 >   0 > >  0  > %  0    0 >   0   %     >  0  > $  >  m     0   $   m 



x3 YY O]Y XGXU YC2H SVU [B S O’EGD A S [A!F X EH?EGYbvsO]A S EGD S c!Y S E O]A SVX B C EGD A S [A!FE  D X YO]A S A!C‘u D X H X [A!M M A p  RTSVU D D U BVHNM  

C >>   



RTSVU D D U BVHNM v   > >  m

C  >> 

> B > C



C >  

>C $ >>  C %   > 





C  > 





> B   CC >B 

hiB D M D r FGD B C D S:X EH?EGY‘v‘FGYiB D FGY X 

 

> B > C  C $ >>  C >B >

$>  C

%

m

  









C >  



C  > 

> B  C



$>  C  m

`bu4 A!CA!c!Y S YD EŠu'AN[ U Yc!FGYYm.AN[+E  Y r B U c!Y]E-O]A SVX EGFHND S E p YeFGY X EGFGDPO’E B >  C B   C   R O]A SVX D U YF- E  YZOH X Y  B >  C    B   C    M  J gbH X Y R   >  m 

 

C >   m 

[A!FeH S u B   C E B  D m p  DPO :D X D S O]!A CVH?EGD r M Y p D E :YiB D M D r FGD B C p D E 7A X D EGD !Y p YHNM E J gbH X Y qR R   >  m 

[A!FH S u B   C E B  D m   >   M D C C  p D E  r A!B SVU Y UWp YHNM E J gbH X Y RqRqR  m   > m [A!FH S u B   C E B  D m   >  M D C C  p D E  r A!B SVU Y UWp YNH M E J



C >     p  DPO ÜD X D S O]A!CVH?EGD r M Y





>  C   p  DPO ÜD X D S O]A!CVH?EGD r M Y

gbH X Y R )  m    >  



C >   m  B   C  

C  >  > $ >  C

@D S O]Y!f $  C   $>  C      C   'm [A!FH S u B   C           C HNFGD X Y X [FGA!C X A!M D S c

  % [A!FeD SVU D D U BVHNM v

X A!CY p YNH M E WFGYHNM D H?EGD A S $     C    $ >  C JbdeY S O]Y!fVH S YiB D M D r FGD B C U AY XS ANE.Y D X E.D S  H J X J X D S O]Y @ $  C  $>  C %  ml[FG!A C E  Y FGA7YFqEGD Y X AN[ E  Y Y r Y X iB YjCYH X B FGY!J gbH X Y )   > 

    C  m[A!FjH S u B   C E B  & m f p  DPO LD X D S O]A!CVH?EGD r M Y p D E LYiB D M D r FGD B C p D E 7A X D EGD !Y p YHNM E J y t h y  g b@ J w B X MPH SVU YFf J f+_ y.J eJ KLH!OQ!Y S  D Y2f "! k!kf RTS GE FGA U BVO’EGD A S EGA-D •YFGY S EGDPHNM C2H S D  [A!M U X f7v SVU J\Y U D EGD A S f A !YF  B r M DPOH?EGD A SVX f  Y p  A!FGQ•J v JgbH GX X f ‘J f "!#  Nf ghA!C7Y]EGD EGD !YhYiB D M D r GF D B C p D E  S H S O]DPHNM!D S O]A!C M Y]EGYhC2HNFGQ!Y]E X f  S D !YF X D EŠulAN[  Y S SVX uM ?H S DPH p A!FGQD S c VH,7YFf "!#  J n J B2Y!f ‘J f "!# kf@EGA O VH X EGDPO2YiB D M D r FGDPH p D E  S H S O]DPHNMhD S O]A!C M Y]EGYlC2HNFGQ!Y]E X f  A!B F S HNM•AN[hO]A S A!CDPOx3 YA!FGu!f  f  m    "$ J  B2Y!f ‘J!_ ^ J @1VH?[YFf J 

f hiB D M D r FGD B C D 'S RTS O]A!C M Y]EGYsKLHNFGQ!Y]E XR f  !A B F S HNM AN[\KLH?E  YC2H?EGDPOHNM*hO]A S A!CDPO X f  f "#   n!m!m J "!# 



J t M A!FGY S H S AVf K9J_  J  A!B F U YMˆf "!!  f\x  7 YFGD A U Y O]A S A!CD Y XZp D E D S O]A!C M Y]EGY C2HNFGQ!Y]E X f hO]A S A!CDPOM Y]EqEGYF X f   f !  ! kJ 

J  Y H S A!Q!A M A X f  Je_ dZJ K9J  A!M YC2HNFO VHNQD X f "!#$ f D X EGY S O]Y!f.FGYc!B MPHNFGD EŠu H SVU O]A SVX EGFHND S Y U&X B r A EGD C2HNM D EŠu2AN[O]A!C7Y]EGD EGD !Y.HNM M A OH?EGD A SVXhp  Y S E  Y.H XGX Y]E-C2HNF  Q!Y]ED X D S O]A!C M Y]EGY!f•D S y.J+@EHNFGFf7^ J•deYM M YFjH SVU ‘J@EHNFGY]EqE  Y U X J %  XGX H u X D S  A S A!FsAN[IJ  J w FGFGA p f)\A!MˆJ RqRqR f•gbHNC r FGD U c!Y S D !YF X D EŠu  FGY XGX J $

kJ  Y H S A!Q!A M A X f  J f "!! m f w SÜRTS EGFGA U BVO’EGD A S EGA  Y S YFHNM hiB D M D r FGD B C p D E  RTS O]A!C M Y]EGY w XGX Y]EeKLHNFGQ!Y]E X f  A!B F S HNM•AN[\KLH?E  YC2H?EGDPOHNM*hO]A S A!CDPO X f "! f  n # J JsdHNFqEf ‘J ‘f "! k  f& S E  YeA EGD C2HNM D EŠu‘AN[*hiB D M D r FGD B C p  Y S E  YeC2HNFGQ!Y]E X EGFGBVO  EGB FGY.D X D S O]A!C M Y]EGY!f  A!B F S HNM•AN[hO]A S A!CDPOx3 YA!FGu!f  f  "#    n J #

JsKLHNc!D M Mˆf K9JV_