Quotients of maximal class of thin lie algebras. the

0 downloads 0 Views 1MB Size Report
Jul 5, 2007 - point of view, using Theorem 2 of [Cur54]: since the elements hl = y, h2 = .... c > b (that implies s, < sb) and Lucas' Theorem, (6) becomes.
This article was downloaded by: [Universita di Trento] On: 19 November 2012, At: 08:56 Publisher: Taylor & Francis Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office: Mortimer House, 37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK

Communications in Algebra Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/lagb20

Quotients of maximal class of thin lie algebras. the case of characteristic two G. Jurman

a

a

Dipartimento di matematica, Povo (trento), 1-38050, Italy E-mail: http://wwwmath.science.unitn.it/-jurman/ Version of record first published: 05 Jul 2007.

To cite this article: G. Jurman (1999): Quotients of maximal class of thin lie algebras. the case of characteristic two, Communications in Algebra, 27:12, 5749-5789 To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00927879908826790

PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE Full terms and conditions of use: http://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-conditions This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden. The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any representation that the contents will be complete or accurate or up to date. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae, and drug doses should be independently verified with primary sources. The publisher shall not be liable for any loss, actions, claims, proceedings, demand, or costs or damages whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with or arising out of the use of this material.

COMMUNICATIONS IN ALGEBRA, 27(12), 5749-5789 (1999)

QUOTIENTS OF MAXIMAL CLASS OF THIN LIE ALGEBRAS. THE CASE OF CHARACTERISTIC TWO G. JURMAN DIPARTIMENTO DI MATEMATICA

UNIVERSITA DEGLI STUDI DI TRENTO

Downloaded by [Universita di Trento] at 08:56 19 November 2012

1-38050 POVO (TRENTO) ITALY E-mail address: [email protected] GRL:http://www-math.science.unitn.it/-jurrnan/

ABSTRACT.In this paper we describe the infinite-dimensional thzn Lie algebras over a field of characteristic two which have non-metabelian factors of maximal class over terms of the lower central series.

Thin infinite-dimensional graded Lie algebras can be considered as generalizations of algebras of niaxiinal class (see [CMNSSG]); the precise definition is given below. Among factors of thin algebras with respect t,o k r m s of the lower central series, there is a greatest one that is of maximal class. In odd characteristic one can prove that this largest quotient is always inetabelian ([CJ97]). In characteristic two it turns out that there are thin algebras where this factor of maximal class is non-metabelian. 4 family of such examples is described here; we show that all thin Lie algebras with such a non-metabelian factor of inaxiinal class are in this family.

1991 Mathematzcs Subject Classzficatzon. 17Bi'O 17B65 17B30 20F40. Key words and phrases. Graded Lie algebras of maximal class, thin Lie algebras. The author is member of GNSAGA, Italy. I am grateful to my advisor A. Caranti for suggesting the problem t o me. and t o M.F. Newman for his kind hospitality at ANU, Canberra, during the preparat,ion of this paper.

Copyright O 1999 by Marcel Dekker, Inc.

JURMAN

As in [CJ97], all commutators are left-normed and the generalized Jacobi identity

is used without mention in its characteristic two signless version:

As usual, wc use [ y r ' ] as a shortcut for [y 3: . . . 3.1. To coill~utcbinoinial coei-

Downloaded by [Universita di Trento] at 08:56 19 November 2012

+

integels a and b are wiltten

111 base

2, that 1s. e =

b,2' mith

u,3', b = 2x0

2=0

a, b, E (0 I ) then

( 1 fi (

(mod 2 ) .

i=O

Note that if a = 29 all i since

-

1 for some natural number g and 0

and then the binomial coefficient

(i)

< b < a,aiis 1 for

is congruent to 1 modulo 2. We will

use this fact 03in several instances without further mention.

Let L = $L, be a Lie algebra over a field F of characteristic 2, which is i=l


1 and for each 0 # z E L, one has [zL1] = Li+l. The covering property implies that the algebra is generated by elements of weight one, and that dim(Li) _< 2, for each i 2 1; a homogeneous component of dimension two of a thin Lie algebra is called a diamond. We say that L is an algebra of maxzmal class (see [CMN97]) if dim(Li) 5 1, for i > 1 and it is generated by L1 as an algebra, i.e. Li = [Li-lL1] for i > 1. If L has finite dimension d, then it has nilpotency class d - 1, otherwise if L is infinite-dimensional, then each finite-dimensional quotient L/Ld has this property, for d > 1. By convention, algebras of maximal class are not considered thin.

THIN LIE ALGEBRAS AND CHARACTERISTIC TWO

575 1

Finally, let L be infinite-dimensional of maximal class and define, for i > 1, the two-step centralizer Ci of the component Lias the subspace CL,(Li) of L1. (In the following, we refer to [CMN97] for the facts about algebras of nlaxinial class mentioned without proof.) Choose 0 # y E C2, SO that C2 = F y . If all two-step centralizers coincide with F y , then the algebra is metabelian; otherwise, let F x be the first two-step centralizer C, distinct from Fy: then it can proved that m = 2h+1, for some positive integer h: we call q = 2h the parameter of L. If, for some i and 1, we have

tile11 1 can only assume the values 2q and 2 q 2 S . for 0 k

L can be viewed as a two-generated non-split extension of M by A. Note that the top right hand k x k minors of the above matrices x and y are just the generators of A, whilst the choice of is needed to have a non-trivial action of A over the copies of M contained in L. This can be verified looking a t the element ,$ = [ y ~ 2 ~ - 1 y ~ 2 ~ - 2 ( y ~ 2 ~ - 1 ) 2 n y Z ]

6

in class k + 1, i.e. the first element of the first occurrence of M : the only non zero entry of its matrix is the element ,$(k+1,2) = 1 (the top right hand k x k minor vanishes because it is actually in the abelian ideal), and so the action is non-trivial.

THIN LIE ALGEBRAS AND CHARACTERISTIC TWO

5753

Downloaded by [Universita di Trento] at 08:56 19 November 2012

The representation of the above family can also be obtained, from another point of view, using Theorem 2 of [Cur54]: since the elements hl = y, h2 = X , h~ = [ y x ]h4 , = [ Y X X ] , . . . , hk+l = [y~2q-1yx2q-2(yx2~~1)2ny] form a regular basis for the nilpotent Lie algebra of maximal class L/L< if we take the irreducible polynomials f l = f:! = . . . = f k = Y, fk+l = Y - t (with t as above) in F [ Y ] ,then there exists an irreducible representation of L such that the minimuin polynomial of every matrix attached to hi is a power of f,;furthermore, this representation is unique up to equivalence since the fi are linear. Now, if we write down the matrices C Y , p, [CY, p],. . . of hi as elemerits of EndFrtl(M) and we calculate their minimum polynomial, we find that these polynomials are just powers of the f, as required, giving us another way to see the representation In the remaining part of the paper we will prove the following T h e o r e m . Let L be an znjnzte-dzi~?eriszoiznlthzn Lze algebia o w 7 u jeld of C h a ~ a C t e r two ~~t~~ Suppose the second dzarnond occurs zn wezght k If L/L%s not metabelzan, then L zs zsomorphzc to an algebra zn the famzly constructed zn thzs sectzon

Let L be a thin Lie algebra with the second diamond in class k . Thus L / L k is an algebras of maximal class of dimension k . Let q = 2h be its parameter and let x and y be its generators. We suppose that this quotient is non-metabelian, that is it has a t least 2 two-step centralizers and that its last constituent has h. Call v the element of L just length t = 29 - 2n - 1 for some 0 5 n before the diamond, u a non-zero element of weight k - t - 3 and write v-j as a shortcut for [uxyxt-j],SO that [v-jxj] = v. Then the following relations hold:


0; 3. t = 29 - 2. Some of the computations performed in [CJ97] turn out to be independent of the characteristic of the field of definition of the algebra, so they can be used here, too: this happens when the last constituent before the second diamond has length 29, where the arguments of the odd characteristic case can be

JURM AN

5754

Downloaded by [Universita di Trento] at 08:56 19 November 2012

integrally applied, while when the same constituent has length 2q -pS we have to check that the inequality 2q - pS + 1 < 2q - 1 still holds. As q = 2h and p = 2, this happens when s > 1: this implies that all cases are covered but the one with s = 1. As regards the last case t = 2q - 2 , although the lemma still holds, the entire argument cannot be applied, since the coefficient that appears in it is even and thus vanishes in characteristic two. This leaves us with two cases to consider: 1. t = 29 - 2 and 2 . t = 29 - 3. These ones need to be studied from a slightly different point of view, not 10oliiilg a t the last constituent only, but considering the entire structure of the invol~edLie algebras.

Befbre discussing the remaining cases, we state and prove some results about t,he classification of Lie algebras of nlaximal class that we need later. For the complete classification, see [CN98] and [Jur98]. 02

P r o p o s i t i o n . Let L = $Libe a graded Lie algebra of maaimal class over a i=O

field F of characteristic 2 . Let q = 2 h be the parameter of L, and let zts second constituent length be b. Then b cannot be 2q - 1. If b is not q - 1, then all other constituents of the algebra have length b or 2q - 1. Furthermore, if the third constituent has also length b, then the fourth cannot have length 2q - 1. Proof. The proof has various steps tjhat deal with the different possible values of the constituents: in every step we suppose the lengths are not the ones specified in the thesis and we prove that the algebra has finite dimension. Note that, for the lemma in [CJ97], we must consider the possibility of the occurrence of a third (or higher) centralizer only when short constituents other that the second are involved in the proof. 0

b cannot be 29 - 1

To prove the assumption, apply the generalized Jacobi identity t o the element [yx2q-' [yx29-'11:

THIN LIE ALGEBRAS AND CHARACTERISTIC TWO

so b cannot assume the value 29 - 1 The length of the third constituent can only be b or 29

-

1

Write b as 29 - 2% - 1 and call c = 29 - 2'< - 1 the length of the third constituent. Now let n be a natural number less or equal than b, and apply the generalized Jacobi identity to the element [ y x 2 ~ - 1 y x n [ y x 2 q - 1 y x n ] ] :

Downloaded by [Universita di Trento] at 08:56 19 November 2012

0 = [yx29-lyxn[yx2q-1yxn]]

+ +

The elements of the first sum are always zero except for n i j = b and 29 - 1 - j = c, while the only non-zero term of the second sum has n i = b aiid j = c, so that equation ( 2 ) reduces to

+

To show that the algebra has finite dimension under the initial hypothesis we have to find a natural number n such that the coefficient of the element in (3) is odd (ie. it is non-zero as an element of F) and such that 2 n + 29 - ( b+ c + 1 ) cannot be an admissible length for the fourth constituent (it will be sufficient that 2 n 29 - ( b + c + 1 ) 5 q - 1 ) . The first case occurs when b = 29 - 2 (i.e. s b = 0), that is the only even possible value for a constituent. Since by hypothesis c # 29 - 1 , 2 q - 2 , the sum b c is odd, so the number n = - q is a positive integer less than b; furthermore 2 n - b < 0 because c < 29 - 2 and 2 n + 29 - ( b + c + 1) =

+

+

JURMAN

bi c

T

1 - 24

+ 2q

-

(b

+ c + 1) = 0 , so that

(3) becomes

and the algebra must be finite-dimensional by definition of constituent. Simmetrically, the situation t,urns out to he ident,ical when c = 2q - 2 , bccause in that case b (wliicli for the previous proof cannot be 29 - 1) cannot e w i be 3q - 2. so if we t,alte 12 defined as above the same argument applies. The general case occurs wlieli bot11 0 and c are less than 2q - 2 or. equivalc~litly..it,allif s, arc 110th I~iggertlim 0 and tlipn 11 + c is ~ v c l i .Co~isidrrthe

Downloaded by [Universita di Trento] at 08:56 19 November 2012

illlll1l)l'l~

- q i i1 I f 1 i f ' 2 f i n 2 t q = 2 I except tiit. 1 1 J two dlff'rrr~itpowers %""-I and 2"cp1:so. if ~e p u t [ = min { s b -- 1;,, --- 1 ) : tllc nuinbcr 17 = --- q + $ vi.ill be the right choice i11 (3), b e c a , ~ ~

as

b (that implies s, < sb) and Lucas' Theorem, ( 6 ) becomes

if 2Sc# 0, t h a t is c # 29 - 1; moreover, as b # q - 1 we have t h a t s, < sb < h, and hence 2sb 2SC 2h-1 2h-2 + . . . 2' = q - 1: therefore the thesis.

+
2) 0 = [ ~ - ~ [ y z ~ (remember y]] = ["XYXYI,

show that [vxyx]is central, against the covering property again 7.2. b = q - 1. Here f has no limitation on its length, so we will consider the cases f not short and f short.

JURMAN

5762

'7.2.1. f # q - 1. Take an element k exactly q + 1 places before the last constituent (this is possible if its length 2q - 29 - 1 is a t least q 1 , i.e. if q # 2) and coiiipute:

+

Downloaded by [Universita di Trento] at 08:56 19 November 2012

Thc only p l i r ( 1 . , I ) wl~ichgives a nonzero telm in tlw previolls sllill is ( q . 1). autl for such a value the above ecluatioii reduces t,o

and so this subcase is completed, too '7.2.2. f = q - 1. Suppose q > 2 (for q = 2 it is just b = f = 2q k three elements before the last constituent:

-

3) and take

0 = [B[yx2Q-'yxq]]

= [kxxyx2Q-3yx~] = [uyxQ] 2:

[~xyxq-~x].

Note tha~t [kxq[yx2q-'y]] is zero because [kxx] mus~tbe centralized by x , as the next constituent is not short. Furthermore 0 = [v-("-')[yx2~-2y]] = [v-(~-l)[y229-2]y]

=[v~~xq-~~],

and so [ ~ x y x q - ~is]central and the algebra has finite dimension.

THIN LIE ALGEBRAS AND CHARACTERISTIC TWO

5763

7.3. T h e q = 2 r e m a i n i n g cases. Here the algebra starts out with constituents 3 and 1, has t = 1 and f may assume the values 3, 2 or 1. If f is 3, take d as the element before the constituent of length f and compute:

0 = [d[yxxxyxx]]

= =

[dxxxyxry] [72Y/].

+

a i d so every elcnicnt of weight bigger than k 2 is zero. If f is 2 , the above equation gives jvxyrr] = 0;that. together ~ i t h

Downloaded by [Universita di Trento] at 08:56 19 November 2012

0= [ ~ ~ - ' [ ~ : c s ~ j j

+

= jv-l [ y r z ] y ] [ ~ - ~ ~ [ ~ x x ] j

=

[2!-1xxyy]

=

[~xYYI,

shows the centrality of [ v x y ]and so the assumption. If f is 1 we may also consider the possibility of the presence of a different centralizer p after the centralizer f ;but then take d as above and expand.

0=[~[~xxxx]] = [dxxxxy] = [Wcp- ~ Y ) X X Y I [dxyxxy]

--

So we may assume that f is centralized by x and use ( 8 ) to obtain [wxyxx]= 0 and [ u [ y x y ] = ] 0 t o obtain [uxyy] = 0. Thus, if [ v x y x ] is zero, we find a central element [ u x y ] ,otherwise the conclusion depends on the study of the whole structure of the algebra. First of all, note that in the case of two short constituents before the diamonds, if we consider the maximal class branch of the thin algebra raising from the element [ v x y ] ,we see that this algebra has really a constituent of length 2 and if this branch ends, the entire thin Lie algebra has t o be finite-dimensional. So we start studying the behaviour of a constituent of length 2 in a Lie algebra of maximal class that begins with constituent sequence ( 3 , 1 , .. .). It can be shown t h a t , if the first non short constituent after the top one is long, then 2 cannot appear as an admissible constituent length, so we can never

5764

JURMAN

Downloaded by [Universita di Trento] at 08:56 19 November 2012

have the situation we are studying, whilst if such a constituent is short the Lie algebra of inaxinla1 class that rises is periodic, so we cannot have a second diamond in this case, too. In fact, when the algebra starts out with constituent length sequence (3,19,3), first of all we can see using just one deflation that, g = 2' - 3 for some power s 2 2: in fact if we write explicitly down the top part of the constituent sequences of the original and the deflated algebra we get

and so y + 3 - 2 has to be of the forill 2q - 2 , and so the thesis. Then. if we suppose there is a constituent of length 2 somewhere in the algebra we call consider its first occurrence and call n z the element just before the beginning of the constituent iinmediately before this one; but now

= [mxxxyxxy],

and this implies that before the constituent of length 2 there must be a t least a short one. So we are in the situation (3,19,3,.. . , 3 , 1 " 2 . . . ) . Now call r the element just before the branch of sequence (. . .3,1" 2, . . . ); then there are two possibilities, depending on k : if k 2 g expanding we obtain that the algebra has finite dimension (if g > I), whilst if k < g we obtain the same result applying 0 = [r[yxxx(yx)kyxx]]

for k odd and for k even, where r = [cyx]. When g = 1 we can see that there are two possibilities, depending on the constituent after the second long one. First of all, expanding 0 = [yxxxyxyxy[yxxxyxx]]

we note that this constituent cannot be intermediate. If this is a short one, the algebra goes on periodic with constituents sequence ( 3 , l ) " (this facts

Downloaded by [Universita di Trento] at 08:56 19 November 2012

THIN LIE ALGEBRAS AND CHARACTERISTIC TWO

5765

can be seen using the two zero relations [yxxxyxyxy]and [ y x x y x x ] ) .Finally, suppose it is long and suppose further that there is a constituent of length 2 somewhere in an upper class of the grading; then take the first occurrence of such a constituent: from above, we know that it follows a short constituent and, using the relations just seen for the previous cases, we show that there can be only one short constituent between the intermediate one we are considering and the previous non short one (that in view of our assumption is long). So we are in the situation (3; 1 , 3 , 3 , . . , 3 , 1 , 2 ) ,but also this can be shown t o be a finite-dimensional Lie algebra: call x t,he element just before the sequence ( 3 , 1 , 2 ,. . . ) and expand 0 = [ x s ~ [ ~ x z z y z y xand y ] ]0 = [ x x x x y [ y x x x y x x ]to] see that; if we call a the weight of the elements at the end of the sequence (. . . 3 , 1 :2). every commutator of weight a t 2 is zero. When the first non short constituent is an intermediate one (with g short constituents hefore it) we can prove. using essentially r~lationssimilar to those used for the previous case? that when the algebra is infinite-dime~lsiollalit is periodic with period (after the top 3) of kind (19,a l , . . . , lg,a,) where a, can be 2 or 3: also this result implies that every element of the grading is onedimensional, so there is no diamonds other than the top one.

8. THECASE

f,

= 2q

-

2

Also in this case, first of all suppose [uxx]# 0 and compute as above 0 = [u[yx2Q]]

so there is not a diamond after the element v , against the hypothesis. So we can assume [uxx]= 0 and compute

+

= [uxyxZq] [ux24+ly] = [vxx].

Then [vxx]= 0 and (by the covering property) [vxy]and [vyx]are linearly dependent. Furthermore, we can apply the same calculation used in [CJ97], obtaining [ v x y x j y ]= 0 for 0 j q - 2.

<
1,

I

r = terms of order > 2d-"

+ 2 d - b 1 terms of order < 2d-0 1.

Downloaded by [Universita di Trento] at 08:56 19 November 2012

Then s - r = 2d-B and S becomes

The elements of this sum are non-zero only for c = 2d-P+ 1 and for all values of c whose 2-adic summands are 2-adic summands of 2r (i.e. they appears also as summands in the numerator of the last binomial coefficient above): they are therefore 1+ (2* - I ) , where n is the number of summands of such a numerator: this number is always even (and so the sum is zero) as we are in the case n # 0. In the second case (remember that s is not a power of 2, so p > 1) r = rl

s, 2, and the sum becomes u,=d-fl+1

But the 2-adic summands of c are less than 2d-P+2, SO every term of the above sum is zero, and so S = 0. Note that in every case the difference k - a turns out t o be bigger than 2d-P + 1 and so bigger than 2e - 1 satisfying the condition on R required a t page 24. So the algebra can be infinite-dimensional only if k is of the form 29 - 1 for some exponent g. Now we want to prove that in this case the resulting algebra is periodic, so it cannot evolve as thin. To prove the periodicity, we have to show that every elements of type = [yx2~-lyx2~-2((yx2~-1)kYx2q-2 )n(yx2q-1)kyx2q"-1]

JURMAN

and


0 vanish or are central, while we have already seen the case n = 0. As regards [ p ( , , ~ ) x ' q - ~ y ]there , is nothing to prove, because it follows irnmediately from (12); furthermore, also the centrality of [p(,,,)x2q-2y] when 1 5 a 5 k - 1 follows from equation (15) above substituting [ P ( ~ , = )with ] [ P ( ~ - I , ~ ) ]Both . [ p ( , , k ) ~ ~ ~and - ~ ] [ p ( , , k ) ~ ~ q - ~ y x ~ 9can - ' ] be shown to lie in the second center expanding a Jacobi relation with the same zero element [ x ~ z=]

[y~29-1y~2q-2(y~2q-1)kY~29-2~]

JURMAN

where

Downloaded by [Universita di Trento] at 08:56 19 November 2012

=0

(mod 2).

as k is even. Further, previous general considerations about constituents lengths show that the elements [p(n,k)x2q-1x], [ p ( n , k ) ~ 2 q -y1y] , [ ~ ( Q . ) X ~ ~ - ~ ~ Xand ~ ~ - ~ X ] [ p ( n , k ) ~ 2 q -yx2q-1 2 y y ] are zero. So we have proved that every algebra that starts out with constituent lengths sequence ( 2 q - 1 , 2 q - 2 ) goes on either as the limit (29 - 1 , 2 q - 2 , ( 2 9 or periodically as the algebra ( 2 9 - 1 , 2 q - 2, ( ( 2 9 - 1 ) 2 9 - 1 ,( 2 9 - 2))-) or as the algebra ( 2 9 - 1 , 2 q - 2 , ( ( 2 q - 1 ) 2 g - 2 ,( 2 9 - 2)')*) for any exponent g . Now we want to discuss the possibility of having another diamond starting after a 29 - 2 constituent, with element v. So, first of all we must show when such a situation cannot take place.

THIN LIE ALGEBRAS AND CHARACTERISTIC TWO

5781

First of all, it can be noted that the diamond must lie before the end of the first period, otherwise if a t least the sequence

(with k,j as above) takes place in the algebra before the diamond, the algebra can go on only as a periodic one of maximal class, as the above calculations show. So we can reduce to consider the element v before the diamond to be

Downloaded by [Universita di Trento] at 08:56 19 November 2012

where i can be 1 or 2, studying separately what happens if d is even or odd

is central. In fact, if we call d the element [ y s 2 9 - 1 y x 2 ~ - 2 ( y z 2 ~ - 1 ) ~ ] and p the elenlent [yx2q-1ys2q-2(yx2q-1 ) 1 , we obtain

0 = [dS]

and

5782

JURMAN

i = 1,d odd. As above, we will show that there exists a central element, against ~ q -using ~ ] : the covering property: here this element is [ u ~ ~ x ~ q - ~ ~in xfact,

we show that after the diamond must be an intermediate constituent and, if we write d as 217, - 1 and put

Downloaded by [Universita di Trento] at 08:56 19 November 2012

and

we can show that:

THIN LIE ALGEBRAS AND CHARACTERISTIC TWO

and

Downloaded by [Universita di Trento] at 08:56 19 November 2012

0 = [2919]

So there cannot be a diamond in such a situation but in the cases n odd, i.e. d = 1 (mod 4). Repeating the computation (18) increasing the number of constituents of the involved elements) it can be shown that the algebra has a t least three more long constituents (and, in general, exactly Using this fact, we can improve the previous bound showing that n can assume only some very special kind of values: call as usual v the element just before the diamond

[$I).

and let

+

+

with 2n 1 < 7 < 3n 1 (bounds required to obtain a non vanishing part up to the last element) and

JURMAN

Downloaded by [Universita di Trento] at 08:56 19 November 2012

Then expand

so the algebra is finite-dimensional if there exists a t least a value of r ] that satisfies the above bounds which makes the last binomial coefficient odd. This coefficient is congruent to

(2n+i)

modulo 2, so the problem reduces to check

+

the existence of a t least a value of 77 in the range 2n + 1 < r ] < 3n 1. Now we claim the such an 77 always exists but in the case n of the form 2k - 1 for any k strictly bigger than 1. This can be proved using the 2-adic expansion together with Lucas' theorem. First of all, we look a t what happens when n is of the just cited form: we have that the above coefficient vanishes for every value of r]. It can be easily seen that if 77 is odd, the binomial coefficient is always zero (this really happens

THIN LIE ALGEBRAS AND CHARACTERISTIC TWO

5785

for any value of n), so assume 7 = 2s; you obtain the following equivalences: ( "4n I ) .- 7

(

4(2k - 1) - 2s

h-1

If s is even, say s = 2r (with r 2-adically written as

aiZZ)we obtain

Downloaded by [Universita di Trento] at 08:56 19 November 2012

z=o

that is congruent to zero (mod 2) unless a, = 1 for all i, i.e. 11 = 4n, but that is iinpossible in view of the above bounds. If s is odd, say s = 2r 1 we have

+

and again distinguishing the cases r even and r odd we fall in the above solved cases, and so we have our thesis. This means that in case n + 1 is a power of 2, the Jacobi expansion (19) is just an identity and does not give us information about the structure of the algebra. k+2

b,2i-2

On the contrary, if n is not of such a kind, writing 2-adically n = i=?

k+2

(letting bo = bl = 0) and 7 = ):ai2i (letting a. = 0 ) we obtain

and it can be seen that, given the sequence of the ai (which cannot be all equal t o 1 as n is different from 2" I), it can always be found a t least a valid (in the sense of the bounds) sequence of bi that makes the above product to be non-zero, and thus a value of for which equation (19) is meaningful, forcing the algebra t o be finite-dimensional for every value of n not of the kind 2" 1,

JURMAN

5786

because it can always be shown that [LY]va~lislles. In fact, take the element = [yz2~-lyz2q-2(yx2q-1 ) 217 - 1- L'1 with 1 k 4n t o be specified, and expand:

<