The most important parameter which affected the SST anomalies in annual and ... The upper part of the seas varying between 1 mm to 20 m are called sea .... to the standard deviation values calculated in order to determine the ... 0,63:%69,77sy ... maximum values were recorded (Brochier & Ramieri, 2001); and the results ...
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
ScienceDirect Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 476 – 486
,:7D6 !@F7D@3F;A@3> 7A9D3B:K+K?BAE;G? '%
+73EGD8357F7?B7D3FGD7 3@A?3>;7E3FF:7 %76;F7DD3@73@ 5A3EFA8,GD=7K(7D;A6A8 1V=E7> VP>V +->5=B80.>-+=387/9+;=6/7=80%8-3+5%=>.3/-+=387%+4+;B+'73?/;;4/B
! ! ,:7BGDBAE7A8F:7EFG6K;EFAD7H;7IF:7E73EGD8357F7?B7D3FGD7++,3@A?3>;7E3FF:7%76;F7DD3@73@5A3EFA8,GD=7K6GD;@9 F:7 B7D;A6 47FI77@ 3@6 ,:7 ++, 63F3 A8 F:7 ?7F7ADA>A9K EF3F;A@E ;@ 7F:;K7 ;@;=7 @F3>K3 >3@K3 @3?GD %7DE;@3@6!E=7@67DG@3D7GE768ADF:7EFG6K 55AD6;@9FAF:;E:3H7F:7++,3@A?3>;7EBD7E7@F76E;9@;8;53@F5:3@97E;@3@@G3> 3@6E73EA@3>F7D?E6GD;@9F:7D7H;7I76B7D;A6 ,:7?AEF;?BADF3@FB3D3?7F7DI:;5:38875F76F:7++,3@A?3>;7E;@3@@G3>3@6 E73EA@3>F7D?E;EF:7I73F:7DF7?B7D3FGD7 !F53@47E3;6F:3F3>EAF:75:3@97E;@F:7&(:3E3@;@8>G7@573F3678;@;F7679D77 6GD;@9 F:7 I;@F7D 3@6 EBD;@9 E73EA@E ;@ 3@@G3> F7D?E GF &' &+' EG@EBAFE 3@6 BD75;B;F3F;A@ 3D7 @AF ?G5: 6;D75F 67F7D?;@3@FE 8AD ++, 3@A?3>;7E ,:7 ++, 3@A?3>K H3>G7E :3H7 BD7E7@F76 3 EK??7FD;5 6;EFD;4GF;A@ ;@ 7F:;K7 @F3>K3 3@6 @3?GD EF3F;A@E 3@63@3EK??7FD;56;EFD;4GF;A@3FF:7AF:7D EF3F;A@E;@F7D?E3H7D39767H;3F;A@3@63EK??7FD;56;EFD;4GF;A@;@ @F3>K3 EF3F;A@ 3@6 3@ 3EK??7FD;5 6;EFD;4GF;A@ 3F F:7 AF:7D EF3F;A@E ;@ F7D?E EF3@63D6 67H;3F;A@ ,:7 3@@G3> 3H7D397 ++, 3@A?3>;7E :3H7 E:AI@ 3@ ;@5D73E7 8AD 3>> EF3F;A@E 6GD;@9 F:7 D7H;7I76 B7D;A6 !@ F7D?E A8 E73EA@E :3H7 F:7 ++, 3@A?3>;7E BD7E7@F763@;@5D73E7FD7@63F3>>EF3F;A@E6GD;@9EG??7D3GFG?@3@6I;@F7D3@63675D73E7FD7@6;@ 7F:;K7@F3>K33@6>3@K3 EF3F;A@E 3@63@;@5D73E7FD7@63>>AF:7D EF3F;A@E6GD;@9EBD;@9
M ,:7GF:ADE (G4>;E:764K >E7H;7D $F6 Open access under CC BY-NC-ND license. © 2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. Selection and peer-review under responsibility of the Organizing Committee of GEOMED2013.
+7>75F;A@3@6B77D D7H;7IG@67DD7EBA@E;4;>;FKA8*757B 87%G@;D'LFGD=3@6!4D3:;?F3>3K /B@8;.KB7D;A6A8 %76;F7DD3@73@5A3EFE,GD=7K
ADD7EBA@6;@93GF:AD ,7> 83J 6+35+..;/?73@E73EGD8357F7?B7D3FGD7++,H3>G7EA8F:7E7>75F76?7F7ADA>A9KEF3F;A@E3FF:7%76;F7DD3@73@ 5A3EFA8,GD=7KH3D;766GD;@9 FA 47FI77@ N%7DE;@ 3@6 N!E=7@67DG@,34>7
EK??7FD;56;EFD;4GF;A@;@@F3>K3EF3F;A@3@63@3EK??7FD;5 6;EFD;4GF;A@3F3>>AF:7DEF3F;A@E;EE77@355AD6;@9 FAF:7EF3@63D667H;3F;A@H3>G7E53>5G>3F76;@AD67DFA67F7D?;@7F:7 ?73EGD7A8F:76;EB7DE;A@3@6;@EF34;>;FK A8F:7 3@@G3> ?73@ ++, 3@A?3>;7E 8AD F:7 E7>75F76 EF3F;A@E #AP?3@ ,34>7 '@ F:7 AF:7D E;67 :3H7 F:7 ++, 3@A?3>;7EBD7E7@F763>>3@793F;H7H3>G76GD;@9F:7 EF CG3DF;>7;@%7DE;@3BAE;F;H7H3>G73@63@793F;H7H3>G73F3>> AF:7D>A53F;A@E;@F7D?EA8F:7?76;3@3@6BAE;F;H7H3>G7E3F3>>>A53F;A@E6GD;@9F:7 D6 CG3DF;>7,34>7 7E;67 F:7E73D7F:7?AEFFKB;53>3@A?3>;7EA4E7DH76FA47BAE;F;H7;@@F3>K33@6%7DE;@EF3F;A@E3@6@793F;H73FF:7AF:7D EF3F;A@E,34>7
AGDB7D;A6E3D767F7D?;@76;@AD67DFA7J3?;@7F:7++,3@A?3>;7E4KB7D;A6E,34>7 &793F;H73@A?3>;7E3F 3>>EF3F;A@E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A6E 3@6 3@6B7D;A6;53>BAE;F;H73@A?3>;7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A6E @793F;H7;@ ;@;=7 3@6 3D767F7D?;@76,34>7 675D73E747FI77@B7D;A6 3@6B7D;A6 3@;@5D73E747FI77@B7D;A6 3@6B7D;A6 ;@@F3>K33@6>3@K3EF3F;A@E3@635A@F;@GAGE;@5D73E747FI77@B7D;A6 3@6B7D;A6 3F3>>AF:7DEF3F;A@E;E 67F7D?;@76,34>7 ;9
479
Yüksel Güçlü / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 476 – 486 ,34>7 ,:73@@G3>?73@E73EGD8357F7?B7D3FGD7++, >AI7EF3@6:;9:7EF++,3@A?3>KH3>G7E3@6K73DEA8F:7E7>75F76?7F7ADA>A9KEF3F;A@E 3FF:7%76;F7DD3@73@5A3EFA8,GD=7K6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6
%7F7ADA>A9K EF3F;A@
H7D397++,H3>G7E6GD;@9F:7 B7D;A6 N
$AI7EF++,3@A?3>KH3>G7N 3@6K73D
;9:7EF++,3@A?3>KH3>G7 N3@6 K73D
7F:;K7
;@;=7
@F3>K3
>3@K3
@3?GD
%7DE;@
!E=7@67DG@
+AGD573>5G>3F763@6AD93@;L76355AD6;@9FAF:763F3A8,GD=;E:+F3F7%7F7ADA>A9;53>+7DH;57
,34>7 ,:7 D7EG>FEA8F:7EF3F;EF;53>7J3?;@3F;A@A8F:7 3@@G3>?73@E73EGD8357F7?B7D3FGD7++,A8F:7 E7>75F76?7F7ADA>A9KEF3F;A@E3FF:7 %76;F7DD3@73@5A3EFA8,GD=7K6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6
J3?;@3F;A@D7EG>FEA8F:7E73EGD8357F7?B7D3FGD7++,3@A?3>;7E %7F7ADA>A9K +F3F;A@
OH7D397 67H;3F;A@3@6D3F;A
^ +F3@63D6
67H;3F;A@3@6 D3F;A %76;3@N
) EF )G3DF;>7N
)@6 )G3DF;>7N
)D6 )G3DF;>7N
%A%A67 N
7F:;K7
EK
3E
;@;=7
3E
3E
@F3>K3
EK
EK
>3@K3
3E
3E
@3?GD
EK
EK
%7DE;@
3E
3E
!E=7@67DG@
3E
3E
3EEK??7FD;5EK+K??7FD;5 +AGD573>5G>3F763@6AD93@;L76355AD6;@9FAF:763F3A8,GD=;E:+F3F7%7F7ADA>A9;53>+7DH;57
,34>7 ,:73@@G3>?73@E73EGD8357F7?B7D3FGD7++, 3@A?3>KH3>G7E A8F:7E7>75F76?7F7ADA>A9KEF3F;A@E3FF:7%76;F7DD3@73@5A3EFA8 ,GD=7K 4KB7D;A6E %7F7ADA>A9K +73EGD8357F7?B7D3FGD7++,3@A?3>KH3>G7E N4KB7D;A6E +F3F;A@
(7D;A6
(7D;A6
7F:;K7
;@;=7
(7D;A6
(7D;A6
@F3>K3
>3@K3
@3?GD
%7DE;@
!E=7@67DG@
,:7 D7EG>FE ;@6;53F7 3 >3D97 B3D3>>7>;E? FA F:7 D7EG>FE A8 F:7 EFG6K B7D8AD?76 4K $7>;7H7>6 7F 3> 3@6 ;@6;53F;@9 F:3F F:7 5AA>;@9 6AI@ 6GD;@9 F:7 E :3E >78F ;FE B>357 FA 3 5A?BD7:7@E;H7 I3D?;@9 ;@ F:7 E &K=FEA8F:7EFG6K;@6;53F;@93@;@5D73E7A8F:7 I3F7DF7?B7D3FGD7;@F:7%76;F7DD3@73@+73 47FI77@ 3@6 3@6F:7D75AD6A83@7I;@5D73E747FI77@F:7479;@@;@9A8F:7 E3@6 I:7D7F:7 ?3J;?G?H3>G7EI7D7D75AD676DA5:;7D*3?;7D; 3@6F:7D7EG>FEA8F:7EFG6KB7D8AD?764K*;J7@7F3>
480
Yüksel Güçlü / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 476 – 486
3@6;@6;53F;@9F:3FF:7 3EF7D@%76;F7DD3@73@+735AA>766AI@47FI77@F:7?;6A8F:7 E3@6F:7?;6A8 F:7 E3@6I3D?76E>AI>KGB38F7DF:3F&K=?73@++,3@A?3>;7EI:;5:;E;@53F79ADKA8@AD?3>6;EFD;4GF;A@355AD6;@9FAF:7E7>75F76 EF3F;A@E 6GD;@9 F:7 B7D;A6 47FI77@ 3@6 ;E 53>5G>3F76 FA 47 ;@ 3H7D397 ,34>7 ,:;E D3F;A ;E 67F7D?;@76FA47;@3H7D397;@F:7+AGF: 3EF7D@%76;F7DD3@73@ +73%3;KL3+3;6#3?7> 3FF:77973@A3EFA8,GD=7K VP>V 3@63FF:7>35=+73A3EFA8,GD=7K VP>V
,34>7 @A?3>KH3>G753F79AD;7E@793F;H73@6BAE;F;H73@A?3>KH3>G7D3F;A@EA8F:73@@G3>?73@E73EGD8357F7?B7D3FGD7++,3@A?3>;7EA8 F:7E7>75F76?7F7ADA>A9;53>EF3F;A@E3FF:7%76;F7DD3@73@5A3EFA8,GD=7K(7D;A6 +73EGD8357F7?B7D3FGD7++,3@A?3>KH3>G753F79ADKD3F;AE %7F7ADA>A9K EF3F;A@
A c 3@A?3>K H3>G7 d A D3F;A
A c 3@A?3>K H3>G7 d A D3F;A
Ac3@A?3>KH3>G7 d A@AD?3>D3F;A
A c 3@A?3>K H3>G7 d AD3F;A
A c 3@A?3>K H3>G7 d A D3F;A
7F:;K7 ;@;=7 @F3>K3 >3@K3 @3?GD %7DE;@ YE=7@67DG@ H7D397
+AGD573>5G>3F763@6AD93@;L76355AD6;@9FAF:763F3A8,GD=;E:+F3F7 %7F7ADA>A9;53>+7DH;57 3@6 355AD6;@9FA%3;KL3+3;6 #3?7> ,34>7
'@F:7AF:7DE;67;F;E67F7D?;@76F:3FF:7 A c3@A?3> K H3>G7 d A 53F79ADKD3F;AEA8F:7++,3@A?3>;7E 5:3@97647FI77@ %7DE;@ 3@6 7F:;K7 ;@;=7 3@6>3@K3EF3F;A@E F:3FF:7 A c3@A?3> K H3>G7 d A 53F79ADKD3F;A;EA@>KE77@;@@F3>K3 3@6%7DE;@ F:3FI:;>EFF:7AF:7D7JFD7?7D3F;AA8
A c3@A?3> K H3>G7 d A 53F79ADKD3F;A;E@AFE77@;@ 7F:;K7 ;@;=7 3@6 >3@K3 EF3F;A@EF:;E:36H3>G7E3F AF:7DEF3F;A@E47FI77@ @3?GD 3@6 %7DE;@
,:7 3@@G3> 3@6 K73D DG@@;@9 ?73@ 3@6 3@A?3>K FD7@6 EF3FGE7E A8 F:7 ++, 3@A?3>;7E 8AD F:7 E7>75F76 ?7F7ADA>A9K EF3F;A@E 6GD;@9 F:7 B7D;A6 47FI77@ 3@6 3D7 9;H7@ 47>AI ;@ E7B3D3F7 5:3DFE 3@6 4D;78>K EG??3D;L76 ;9
;9 ,:75:3@97EA8F:73@@G3>?73@ K73DDG@@;@9?73@E73EGD8357F7?B7D3FGD7++,3@A?3>;7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 3@63@A?3>KFD7@63FF:7 7F:;K7?7F7ADA>A9KEF3F;A@
,:7 3@@G3> ?73@ ++, 3@A?3>;7E 3F F:7 7F:;K7 ?7F7ADA>A9K EF3F;A@ ;9 :3H7 ;@ 97@7D3> E:AI@ @793F;H7 H3>G7E47FI77@ 3@6 BAE;F;H7H3>G7E47FI77@ 3@6 @793F;H7H3>G7E47FI77@ 3@6 3@6 BAE;F;H7H3>G7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 7J57BF ;9 ,:73@A?3>KFD7@6:3E67H7>AB76
Yüksel Güçlü / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 476 – 486
FAI3D6E3@;@5D73E7FAA ,:73@@G3>(73DEA@5ADD7>3F;A@5A788;5;7@F3FF:;EEF3F;A@;E67F7D?;@76FA47 47FI77@ F:7++,3@A?3>;7E3@6F:7I73F:7DF7?B7D3FGD73@A?3>;7E3@6 47FI77@F:7++,3@A?3>;7E3@6F:7&(!
,:7 3@@G3> ?73@ ++, 3@A?3>;7E :3H7 BD7E7@F76 3F F:7 ;@;=7 ?7F7ADA>A9K EF3F;A@ 97@7D3>>K 3 @793F;H7 H3>G7 6GD;@9 F:7 B7D;A6 47FI77@ 3@6 ;9 3@6 BAE;F;H7 H3>G7E 6GD;@9 F:7 B7D;A6 47FI77@ 3@6 7J57BF 3@6 F:7 3@A?3>K FD7@6 :3E 67H7>AB76 FAI3D6E 3@ ;@5D73E7 ;9 ,:7 3@@G3> (73DEA@ 5ADD7>3F;A@ 5A788;5;7@F 3F F:;E EF3F;A@ ;E 67F7D?;@76 FA 47 47FI77@ F:7 ++, 3@A?3>;7E 3@6 F:7 I73F:7D F7?B7D3FGD7 3@A?3>;7E3@6 47FI77@F:7++,3@A?3>;7E3@6F:7&(!
;9 ,:75:3@97EA8F:73@@G3>?73@ K73DDG@@;@9?73@E73EGD8357F7?B7D3FGD7++,3@A?3>;7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 3@63@A?3>KFD7@63FF:7 ;@;=7?7F7ADA>A9KEF3F;A@
,:73@@G3>?73@++,3@A?3>;7E3FF:7@F3>K3 ?7F7ADA>A9KEF3F;A@ ;9 :3H7E:AI@BAE;F;H7H3>G7E6GD;@9 F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 97@7D3>>K@793F;H7H3>G7E47FI77@ 3@6 3@6BAE;F;H7H3>G7E47FI77@
3@6 7J57BF 3@6 F:7 3@A?3>K FD7@6 :3E 67H7>AB76 FAI3D6E 3@ ;@5D73E7 ;9 ,:7 ;@5D73E7 ;E B3DF;5G>3D>KE;9@;8;53@F6GD;@9F:7 B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 ,:73@@G3>(73DEA@5ADD7>3F;A@5A788;5;7@F3FF:;E EF3F;A@ ;E 67F7D?;@76 FA 47 47FI77@ F:7 ++, 3@A?3>;7E 3@6 F:7 I73F:7D F7?B7D3FGD7 3@A?3>;7E 3@6 47FI77@F:7++,3@A?3>;7E3@6F:7EG@EBAFE
;9 ,:75:3@97EA8F:73@@G3>?73@ K73DDG@@;@9?73@E73EGD8357F7?B7D3FGD7++,3@A?3>;7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 3@63@A?3>KFD7@63FF:7@F3>K3?7F7ADA>A9KEF3F;A@
,:7 3@@G3> ?73@ ++, 3@A?3>;7E 3F F:7 >3@K3 ?7F7ADA>A9K EF3F;A@ ;9 :3H7 ;@ 97@7D3> E:AI@ @793F;H7 H3>G7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 BAE;F;H7H3>G7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 7J57BF
3@6F:73@A?3>KFD7@6:3E67H7>AB76FAI3D6E3@;@5D73E7 ;9 ,:73@@G3>(73DEA@5ADD7>3F;A@5A788;5;7@F 3FF:;EEF3F;A@;E67F7D?;@76FA47 47FI77@F:7++,3@A?3>;7E3@6F:7I73F:7DF7?B7D3FGD73@A?3>;7E
481
482
Yüksel Güçlü / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 476 – 486
,:7 3@@G3> ?73@ ++, 3@A?3>;7E 3F F:7 @3?GD ?7F7ADA>A9K EF3F;A@ ;9 :3H7 ;@ 97@7D3> E:AI@ @793F;H7 H3>G7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 BAE;F;H7H3>G7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 7J57BF
3@6 F:7 3@A?3>K FD7@6 :3E 67H7>AB76 FAI3D6E 3@ ;@5D73E7 ;9 EB75;3>>K I:7@ 5A@E;67D;@9 K73DE 3H7D397E F:7 5A@F;@GAGE ;@5D73E7 3E A8 F:7 K73D ;E 3FFD35F;@9 F:7 3FF7@F;A@ ,:7 3@@G3> (73DEA@ 5ADD7>3F;A@ 5A788;5;7@F 3F F:;E EF3F;A@ ;E 67F7D?;@76 FA 47 47FI77@ F:7 ++, 3@A?3>;7E 3@6 F:7 I73F:7D F7?B7D3FGD7 3@A?3>;7E
;9 ,:75:3@97EA8F:73@@G3>?73@ K73DDG@@;@9?73@E73EGD8357F7?B7D3FGD7++,3@A?3>;7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 3@63@A?3>KFD7@63FF:7>3@K3?7F7ADA>A9KEF3F;A@
;9 ,:75:3@97EA8F:73@@G3>?73@ K73DDG@@;@9?73@E73EGD8357F7?B7D3FGD7++,3@A?3>;7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 3@63@A?3>KFD7@63FF:7 @3?GD?7F7ADA>A9KEF3F;A@
,:7 3@@G3> ?73@ ++, 3@A?3>;7E 3F F:7 %7DE;@ ?7F7ADA>A9K EF3F;A@ ;9 :3H7 ;@ 97@7D3> E:AI@ @793F;H7 H3>G7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 BAE;F;H7H3>G7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 7J57BF
3@6 3@6F:73@A?3>KFD7@6:3E67H7>AB76FAI3D6E3@;@5D73E7 ;9 ,:73@@G3>(73DEA@5ADD7>3F;A@ 5A788;5;7@F 3F F:;E EF3F;A@ ;E 67F7D?;@76 FA 47 47FI77@ F:7 ++, 3@A?3>;7E 3@6 F:7 I73F:7D F7?B7D3FGD7 3@A?3>;7E
,:73@@G3>?73@++,3@A?3>;7E3F F:7!E=7@67DG@?7F7ADA>A9KEF3F;A@ ;9 :3H7;@97@7D3>E:AI@@793F;H7 H3>G7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 BAE;F;H7H3>G7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 3@6F:7 3@A?3>K FD7@6 :3E 67H7>AB76 FAI3D6E 3@ ;@5D73E7 ;9GD7 ,:7 3@@G3> (73DEA@ 5ADD7>3F;A@ 5A788;5;7@F 3F F:;E EF3F;A@;E67F7D?;@76FA47 47FI77@F:7++,3@A?3>;7E3@6F:7I73F:7DF7?B7D3FGD73@A?3>;7E
,:73@@G3>3H7D397++,3@A?3>KH3>G7EI7D7@793F;H73F3>>EF3F;A@E;@F:7K73DE
3@6 3@6BAE;F;H73F3>>EF3F;A@E;@F:7K73DE &793F;H73@A?3>KH3>G7E 3D7 67F7D?;@76 8AD F:7 B7D;A6 47FI77@ 3@6 7J57BF 3@6 3@6 BAE;F;H7 3@A?3>K H3>G7E 3D7 67F7D?;@76 8AD F:7 B7D;A6 47FI77@ 3@6 7J57BF 3E F:7 3H7D397 A8 F:7 EFG6K 3D73E ,:;E D7EG>F
Yüksel Güçlü / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 476 – 486
B3DF;3>>K5ADD7EBA@6EFAF:7D7EG>FEA8F:7EFG6K%3;KL3 7F3> ;@6;53F;@9F:7 I3E3I3D?K73D3@6F:3F
3@6 I7D75A>6K73DE '@F:7AF:7DE;67:3H7F:73H7D397E A8F:73@A?3>;7E3F3>>EF3F;A@EE:AI@3@793F;H7 H3>G76GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 3@63BAE;F;H7H3>G76GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 ++, 3@A?3>KH3>G7E I7D767F7D?;@76FA47BAE;F;H7;@F:7 B7D;A63FF:7>35=+735A3EF VP>V
;9 ,:75:3@97EA8F:73@@G3>?73@ K73DDG@@;@9?73@E73EGD8357F7?B7D3FGD7++,3@A?3>;7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 3@63@A?3>KFD7@63FF:7%7DE;@?7F7ADA>A9KEF3F;A@
;9 ,:75:3@97EA8F:73@@G3>?73@ K73DDG@@;@9?73@E73EGD8357F7?B7D3FGD7++,3@A?3>;7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 3@63@A?3>KFD7@63FF:7YE=7@67DG@?7F7ADA>A9KEF3F;A@
7E;67F:;E:3H7F:73H7D397H3>G7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 BD7E7@F763@;@5D73E75A?B3D76 I;F:F:73H7D397H3>G7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 '@A@7E;67;@53@47E3;6F:3FF:7++,3@6F:7 3@A?3>;7E;@F:7EFG6K3D733D7>3D97>K67B7@67@FA@F:7I73F:7DF7?B7D3FGD7E3@6F:3F3>A@9I;F:F:;EF:7&(:3E 3@ 78875F 3F 3 678;@;F7 679D77 FAA J57BF F:;E ;F ;E 3>EA F:AG9:F F:3F AF:7D B3D3?7F7DE :3H7 3 678;@;F7 ;@8>G7@57 67B7@6;@9A@F:7EF3F;A@FAA
,:7++,3@A?3>;7E3FF:7%76;F7DD3@73@5A3EFA8,GD=7K:3H7BD7E7@F76E73EA@3>6;887D7@FF7@67@5;7E ,34>7
,:;ED7EG>FE:AIE3E;?;>3D;FKFAF:7D7EG>FEA8F:7EFG6K&K= 5:3@97E ;@ F:7 3EF7D@ %76;F7DD3@73@ +73 ,:7 E73EA@3> FD7@6 A8 F:7 ++, 3@A?3>;7E D7H73>76 FA 47 FAI3D6E 3@ ;@5D73E7 3F 3>> EF3F;A@E 6GD;@9 F:7 EG??7D 3GFG?@ 3@6 I;@F7D E73EA@E FAI3D6E 675D73E7 ;@ 7F:;K7 @F3>K3 3@6 >3@K3 3@6FAI3D6E;@5D73E73FF:7AF:7DEF3F;A@E6GD;@9EBD;@9,34>7 ,:;ED7EG>FE:AIEB3D3>>7>FAF:7;@5D73E7 A8F:7I73F:7DF7?B7D3FGD7E3>3D97E;?;>3D;FKFAF:78;@6;@9EA8F:7EFG6K AL=GDF +7@
BA;@F;@9A@F:7 E73EA@3>;@5D73E7A8F:7++,3EA8F:7479;@@;@9A8F:7 E
483
484
Yüksel Güçlü / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 476 – 486 ,34>7 +73EA@3>FD7@6E7J3?;@3F;A@D7EG>FED793D6;@9F:7 ++, 3@A?3>;7E A8F:7E7>75F76?7F7ADA>A9KEF3F;A@E3FF:7%76;F7DD3@73@5A3EFA8 ,GD=7K B7D;A6 +73EA@3>FD7@6EA8F:7++,3@A?3>;7E %7F7ADA>A9K+F3F;A@
/;@F7D
+BD;@9
+G??7D
GFG?@
7F:;K7
!@5D73E7
75D73E7
!@5D73E7
!@5D73E7
;@;=7
!@5D73E7
!@5D73E7
!@5D73E7
!@5D73E7
@F3>K3
!@5D73E7
75D73E7
!@5D73E7
!@5D73E7
>3@K3
!@5D73E7
75D73E7
!@5D73E7
!@5D73E7
@3?GD
!@5D73E7
!@5D73E7
!@5D73E7
!@5D73E7
%7DE;@
!@5D73E7
!@5D73E7
!@5D73E7
!@5D73E7
!E=7@67DG@
!@5D73E7
!@5D73E7
!@5D73E7
!@5D73E7
!F;E67F7D?;@76F:3F355AD6;@9FAF:7 (73DEA@ 5ADD7>3F;A@5A788;5;7@FF7EF6GD;@9I;@F7D F:7?3;@7>7?7@FD7>3F76 FA F:7 ++, 3@6 ;FE 3@A?3>;7E ;E F:7 I73F:7D F7?B7D3FGD7 3@6 F:3F 3>A@9 I;F: F:;E F:7 &( :3E 3@ ;@8>G7@57 FA 3 678;@;F7 679D77 3@6 F:3F BD75;B;F3F;A@ EF3@6E ;@ D7>3F;A@E ;@ >3@K3 3@6 @3?GD FA 3 678;@;F7 679D77 ,:;E D7EG>F E:AIE 3 B3D3>>7>;E? FA F:7 D7EG>FE A8 F:7 EFG6K DG@7FF; #GF;7>
;@6;53F;@9 F:3F 3 @793F;H7 5ADD7>3F;A@ ;E 67F7D?;@7647FI77@F:7 &( 3@6++,D79;?7E;@F:7 3EF7D@%76;F7DD3@73@+73 !F;E67F7D?;@76F:3F355AD6;@9FA F:7 (73DEA@ 5ADD7>3F;A@5A788;5;7@FF7EF6GD;@9EBD;@9 F:7 ?3;@7>7?7@FD7>3F76FAF:7++,3@6;FE3@A?3>;7E;EF:7 I73F:7DF7?B7D3FGD73@6F:3F3>A@9I;F:F:;EF:7&(:3E3@;@8>G7@57FA3678;@;F7679D773@6F:3FBD75;B;F3F;A@ EF3@6E;@D7>3F;A@;@%7DE;@ 3@6 7F:;K73@6F:3F3>EAF:7 &+'EF3@6E;@D7>3F;A@;@!E=7@67DG@FA3678;@;F7679D77 FAA !F ;E 67F7D?;@76 F:3F 355AD6;@9 FA F:7 (73DEA@ 5ADD7>3F;A@ 5A788;5;7@F F7EF 6GD;@9 EG??7D F:7 ?3;@ 7>7?7@F D7>3F76FAF:7++,3@6;FE3@A?3>;7E3E;FI3EF:753E7 6GD;@9F:7AF:7DE73EA@E;EF:7I73F:7DF7?B7D3FGD73@6;F 53@47E3;6F:3F3>A@9I;F:F:;EF:7BD75;B;F3F;A@EF3@6E;@D7>3F;A@;@ 7F:;K7FA3678;@;F7679D77 !F;E67F7D?;@76 F:3F355AD6;@9FAF:7 (73DEA@ 5ADD7>3F;A@5A788;5;7@FF7EF6GD;@93GFG?@ F:7?3;@7>7?7@FD7>3F76FAF:7++,3@6;FE 3@A?3>;7E ;E F:7 I73F:7D F7?B7D3FGD7 3@6 F:3F 3>A@9 I;F: F:;E F:7 BD75;B;F3F;A@ ;E ;@8>G7@F ;@ ;@;=7 FA 3 678;@;F7 679D77
" ,:7++,H3>G7E3FF:7%76;F7DD3@73@5A3EFA8,GD=7K5:3@976;@3H7D39747FI77@ N%7DE;@ 3@6 N !E=7@67DG@ 6GD;@9 F:7 B7D;A6 47FI77@ 3@6 ,:7 ?AEF ;?BADF3@F B3D3?7F7D I:;5: 38875FE F:7 ++, 3@A?3>;7E;@3@@G3>F7D?E;EF:7I73F:7DF7?B7D3FGD7 !F53@47E3;6F:3F3>EAF:75:3@97A8F:7&(:3E3@;@8>G7@57 3F 3678;@;F7679D77 @6F:7&' &+'EG@EBAFE3@6BD75;B;F3F;A@3D7@AFEG5:67F7D?;@3@FD793D6;@9F:7++, 3@A?3>;7E
>>EF3F;A@E:3H7E:AI@F:7:;9:7EF3@@G3>++,3@A?3>KH3>G7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 3@6 F:7>AI7EFH3>G7E6GD;@9F:7 B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6
,:7++,3@A?3>;7E:3H7BD7E7@F763@@G3>>K EK??7FD;5 6;EFD;4GF;A@;@ 7F:;K7@F3>K3 3@6 @3?GD EF3F;A@E3@6 3EK??7FD;5 6;EFD;4GF;A@3FF:7AF:7DEF3F;A@E;@F7D?EA83H7D39767H;3F;A@E3EK??7FD;56;EFD;4GF;A@;@@F3>K33@6 @3?GDEF3F;A@E3@6 3EK??7FD;5 6;EFD;4GF;A@3FF:7AF:7D>A53F;A@E;@F7D?EA8EF3@63D667H;3F;A@E '@F:7AF:7DE;67 I7D73@@G3>>KFA A8F:7++,3@A?3>;7E;@F:7@AD?3>3557BF76H3>G753F79ADK
,:7 FD7@6 >;@7E A8 F:7 ++, 3@A?3>;7E 6GD;@9 F:7 B7D;A6 47FI77@ 3@6 3F 3>>EF3F;A@E :3H7 ;@ 97@7D3> 67H7>AB76FAI3D6E;@5D73E7 !@F7D?EA8B7D;A6E3D7@793F;H73@A?3>;7E67F7D?;@766GD;@9F:7B7D;A6E47FI77@ 3@6 3@6 47FI77@ 3@6 BAE;F;H73@A?3>;7E3D767F7D?;@766GD;@9F:7B7D;A6E47FI77@ 3@6 ;@ ;@;=7 @793F;H7 3@647FI77@ 3@6 3F3>>EF3F;A@E
,:73@@G3>3H7D397++,3@A?3>KH3>G7EI7D7@793F;H73F3>>EF3F;A@E;@F:7K73DE
3@6 3@6BAE;F;H7;@F:7K73DE '@F:7AF:7DE;67F:73H7D397EA8F:7 B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 I7D7@793F;H73@6F:73H7D397EA8F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 I7D7BAE;F;H7 3F3>>EF3F;A@E
Yüksel Güçlü / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 120 (2014) 476 – 486
,:7 ++, 3@A?3>;7E 3F F:7 %76;F7DD3@73@ 5A3EF A8 ,GD=7K :3H7 E:AI@ 3@ ;@5D73E7 3F 3>> EF3F;A@E 6GD;@9 F:7 EG??7D 3GFG?@ 3@6 I;@F7D E73EA@E 3@6 3 675D73E7 ;@ 7F:;K7 @F3>K3 3@6 >3@K3 EF3F;A@E 3@6 3@ ;@5D73E7 F7@67@5K3FF:7AF:7DEF3F;A@E6GD;@9F:7EBD;@9E73EA@
,:7 ?AEF D7>3F76 B3D3?7F7D 3?A@9 F:7 B3D3?7F7DE 7J3?;@76 D793D6;@9 F:7;D D7>3F;A@ FA F:7 ++, 3@6 F:7 3@A?3>;7E6GD;@93>>E73EA@EI;F:;@F:7EFG6K3D73;EF:7I73F:7DF7?B7D3FGD7 >A@9I;F:F:;E;F;E67F7D?;@76F:3F 3>EAF:7&(3@6F:7BD75;B;F3F;A@EF3@6E;@D7>3F;A@FA3678;@;F7679D776GD;@9I;@F7D 3@6EBD;@96GD;@9I;@F7D;@ >3@K3 3@6 @3?GD6GD;@9I;@F7D;@ %7DE;@ 3@6 7F:;K7 6GD;@9EG??7D;@ 7F:;K76GD;@93GFG?@;@ ;@;=7 3@6 F:3FF:7 &+'EF3@6E;@D7>3F;A@FA3678;@;F7679D77;@!E=7@67DG@FAA
!@F:;EEFG6K;F;EFD;76FA7J3?;@7 F:75:3@97EA8F:7++,3@A?3>;7E6GD;@9F:7B7D;A647FI77@ 3@6 !F ;E EG997EF76 FA 7J3?;@7 3>EA AF:7D B3D3?7F7DE F:AG9:F FA :3H7 3@ ;@8>G7@57 A@ F:7 ++, 3@6 3>A@9 I;F: F:7 BDA?AF;A@ A8 F:7 ++, ?73EGD7?7@FE 3>EA B7D8AD? D7E73D5:7E D793D6;@9 F:7 67F7D?;@3F;A@ A8 ;FE 78875F I;F:;@ F:7 I:A>75A3EF3>75A EKEF7?;@8GFGD7
53D3 "-/+7>E+ .;@7D !?B>;53F;A@EA89>A43>5>;?3F75:3@978ADFAGD;E?8>AIE3@6E73EA@3>;FK 8>;7+580&;+?/5 $/ 74DG3DK '!
+397(G4>;53F;A@E
F3>3KY /7/;+592B;E:;@9 !@,GD=;E: F3>3KY 9953/.536+=8581B !L?;D% ,(G4>;E:;@9 !@,GD=;E: F3>3KY
/81;+92B+7.1/89853=3-;4/B F:76 !L?;D%7F3(G4>;E:;@9 !@,GD=;E: AL=GDF +7@' $
(D75;B;F3F;A@;@F:7@3FA>;3@B7@;@EG>3+7@E;F;H;FKFA;@5D73E76++,E;@F:7EGDDAG@6;@9E73E 536B7
_ '!
E +BD;@97D .7D>39
DA5:;7D *3?;7D; >;?3F75:3@97;?B35FEA@F:7%76;F7DD3@73@5A3EF3>LA@7E !"& ("$" (*!$ $!% _ >;?3F7:3@97%A67>>;@93@6(A>;5K A@63L;A@7 @; @D;5A%3FF7; ,:7F;E.7@;57!F3>K
DG@7FF;% #GF;7>
,:7D7>7H3@57A8F:7&ADF: +733EB;3@(3FF7D@&(;E7JB>3;@;@9F7?B7D3FGD7H3D;34;>;FK;@ GDAB73@6F:7 %76;F7DD3@73@ !+=>;+5+C+;.;7+5803% + +73EGD8357F7?B7D3FGD73@A?3>;7E;@F:7+AGF: 3EF7D@%76;F7DD3@73@+73 ' +;%-3 .A> &A '!
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
!%" 7./A+--8;.371=8 %%& 9;/7L *AG5A" $GF7D435:7D" /3@@7D %76;F7DD3@73@EG??7D3;DF7?B7D3FGD7H3D;34;>;FK3@6;FE5A@@75F;A@ FAF:7>3D97 E53>73F?AEB:7D;55;D5G>3F;A@3@6++,E 536+=/B7+63-
