THE BOY WHO CRIED WOLF REVISITED: THE IMPACT OF FALSE ...

16 downloads 126 Views 286KB Size Report
In Aesop's fable about the "The Boy who Cried Wolf", a young shepherd boy guarding the village flock cries that there is a wolf worrying the sheep. The vil-.
          ! "#$   % #$&' ## $! ()* #( + ( ,$'.-/0$121 +(# $ 34657498:A@B:DC7EGF HI/CKJMLN4POQ4R5S*TU@WVREXF H EZY\[ SQ]^B:/_ [Q` :D=?= [baZ: gsr T?S [ 5 [ ^WT [ > c Lt:DCJq:DCu5qvwVK::B>€ 3I~^A_57498:A@B:DC Y\[ SQ]^B:/_ [Q` :D=?= [ba@WV9I~@'@WV [ ^ [ T?>¼I*¹½:D= g ¹š:BV [b[ }´4 r V [ iqT?=¿¾ ={I aš^B;>BVÀ:D;K@%@A:}^A:BV [b[ } c ]9;K@%@WV [ ^ [ T?>%CK:Á¹š:D= g 4 r VKT?> [ i [ CD@T?>Z^ [ } [ I“@ [ J @k¹š:Â:/^f@BVK^ [b[ @WT?S [ >] [bg :BVK:“¹;K}u:DC@WV [ VT?=?=?>BT?J [ 4 r V [ ]R:“j v|^BT [ > ¶kˆ :D= gbÃPºc ]9;K@p@A:CK:MI€i~I/T?= c @WV [ iqT?=?={I a/[ ^B> c CK:À=U:DC a v|^ [ JTU]9= [Dc´g I~T?=s@B:I/v|@lI/CJ @WV [ ¹½:D= g J [ v|T?SÂI“@ [ >p@WV [» :qvw_74 r V [ @A^wI/JTU@BTU:DC9I/=ÄSÁ:f@wI~= [ T?>f@BV9I~@1=?T{I~^W>¼I~^ [ CK:A:DC £/¥B>%SÂI~@B^BT e T?> ˆ d L´Ð Î dψd LÑÐ  ` ` Ò1²XLÑLÅOfÓ x 8¼5¸8 x 5 Yšd Î † ¥ Òp²XL´LÅO¼Ó x 8¼5 † d ÎQ³ r 8 x 5 Y½d Î † L ¹'V [ ^ [0Ô T?>p@WV [ }K^WT{v [ @BV [ iqT?=?={I a¼}‚I/T?J¹'V [ C.@WV [ ju^wI/C.@A:I/T?J.@BV [ >BV [ }9V [ ^WJ.]R:“jD4 r VT?>1}^WT{v [ ¹%I/>p={I~^ a/[ =UjuI~C.:A@ c @WV [ i~I/=?; [ : g @WV [a ::qJ> I/CKJÈ> [ ^AiqT{v [ > @WV [ j vz:D;K=?J V9I€i [ ] [b[ C}K^B:qJ;vbT?C a V9I/J @BV [ jÈCK:‡4¸Õ T?>l@WV [ =U:D>B>QI/>B>A:Kv|T{I~@ [ J ¹'TU@BV=U:WT?C a }‚I~^A@Q: g @BV [0» :KvW_È@A:.I=?;K}9T?C [ }^ [ JI~@B:WV [ }V [ ^WJ*]R:“jÁ] [ =?T [ i [ J@BV [ }^A:oIǹ½:D= g I“]R:D;K@o¹ZI/>ÅÖÂ@WV [ C*@BV [ [be } [ v|@ [ JMvz:D>A@%@B:@WV [ iqT?=?={I a ßà Ö7Õ T g jWVq:D;=?JMV9I€i [ vz^BT [ JÀ¹š:B>W;KS [ @WV9I~@¼@BV [Q» :KvW_M: g >WV [‡[ }u¹%I/>f:DC [ : g @WV [ iqT?=?={I afSÁ:D>A@1T?S}R:/^B@wI~C–@1I/>B> [ @B>¼TU@ > [b[ S*>y^ [ I/>A:DC9I“]9= [ @B:Ç>WI€jl@BV9I~@s@WV [ iqT?=?={I a/[ ^B>‡³~vz:D>A@A¾G=U:W>\^wI~@BTU: csç;TU@ [ S:qJ [ >A@€4 O¼C [ >A@WT?SÂI“@ [ : gsÔÇæ Õ,;K>WT?C a vz:DCD@ [ S}R: a TUi [ > Ô ¡ iqT?=?={I a g :A@B:/^WT [ >'¹%^WTU@A@ [ C :“i [ ^*@k¹½:S*T?=?= [ CT{I.I a :‚4 Y >AjKvwVK:D=U: a T{vbI/= g I/v|@A:*T?C » ; [ Cv [ @WV [ } [ :Â} [ ^wv [ }@BTU:DC : g ^BT?>B_ c I~CJÉ@WVT?>} [ ^wv [ }@BTU:DCI~ô [ vz@B>@WV [ ¹%I‡j+@BV9I~@*@BV [ jÉT?C–@ [ ^A}^ [ @S [ @ [ :}‚I~} [ ^ c ¹ [ [|e I/S*T?C [ Vq:“¹Ï@WV [ }9;K]9=?T{v/³µ>fvz:DS}9=?T{I/Cv [ ¹TU@WV¹%I“^WCT?C a > S*T a V–@I~ô [ vz@Á@BV [ i/I~=?; [ : g @BV [Àg :A@W> c I~CJ)¹'V [ @BV [ ^@BV [Àg :A@Ái~I/=?; [ vbI/C+] [ T?C9vz^ [ I/> [ J]–jM@WI~_qT?C a @BV [ ;> [ ^€³µ>¼^ [ >A}R: [ T?C–@A:¸IB>N>Wv [ C9I~^WTU:94 r V [ >A@WI/CJ9I~^BJÂvz:D>A@A¾G=U:D>B>Ä>wv [ C9I~^BTU: T?>oI1õRöW÷íøbù|öíú6õ7ûüú±ý/÷ J [ vbT?>BTU:DCÈS:qJ [ = c TU@l>A} [ v|T ó[ >lVK:“¹þIM;> [ ^Âøwÿ Á^ [ >A}R:A@ c –÷íøbù|öíú6õ7ûüú±ý/÷ J [ vbT?>BTU:DC+SÁ:qJ [ =?>J [ >Wvz^WTU] [ VK:“¹ ;> [ ^W>IA}R:DCKJ Ê 5–@ [ ¹ZI~^B@ „‡Ë/˖¤A@A¾G=U:D>B>ÇS:qJ [ =s¹ [ }^ [ > [ C–@lT?> I>A:DS [ ¹'VI~@ T?J [ I/=?TUä [ J.J [ >Wv|^BTU}@WTUi [ S:qJ [ = c ]9;K@…TU@ }^A:“iqT?J [ >lIç–;9I/C–@BTU@wI~@BTUi [ T?=?=?;>A@B^WI~@WTU:Wvz^WTU}@BTUi [ JT?>A@WT?C9vz@BTU:DCÅ4 r :] [ ^ [ = [ i~I/C–@ cÞ[ i~I/=?;I~@WTU:DCK>1: g @WV [ i/I~=?; [ : g½g :/^ [ vbI/>A@W>p@A: >B:qvbT [ @Xj¸vbI/CCK:/@T a CK:J [ >Wvz^WTU}@BTUi [p[ = [ S [ CD@€4 

l¬ |ª ¬ ů © «“° ¬°±ª§ « ¯/ª!Q¬ " °#‚©\¯      

r :S:J [ =T?S} [ ^ g±[ vz@Âvz:DS}9=?T{I~C9v [ ¹'TU@BVɹZI~^WCKT?C a >*T?CÉ@BV [ vz:D>A@˜¾G=U:D>B>*>Wv [ C9I~^BTU:ȹ [ T?Cq¾ @B^B:J;9v [ I*v|:T?>@BV [ }^A: [ vz:DCKJ@ [ ^WS T?>f@BV [ [be } [ v|@ [ JÁvz:D>A@\: g If=U:D>B>yT g Cq:1}^B:/@ [ vz@WTUi [ I\@WI~_ [ CÅ4\² g ¹%I~^BCT?C a >yI~^ [ T?>B>B; [ J…T g @BV [ g :A@½}^B:/]‚I~]9T?=?TU@Xj [|e v [b[ JK>Z>A:DS [ @BVK^ [ >BVK:D=?J c %Ö + c @WV [ C0@WV [1[|e } [ vz@ [ J¸v|:B@ZI€i [ ^wI a a TUi [ C¸]–j , ×0Ø Ô Ù ÚsÛ%Ü#-oÝ/.102 Ê Ö Í Ö7Õ65|ÖÁž . E Ê Ö Í Ø $~Ô ž Ê „8&9$/Í Ö7Õ Ü 5bÖ ÊŸ Í 3 4 4 072 ¹'V [ ^ [ 4 Ê Ö Í T?>\@WV [šg ^ [ ç; [ C9vzjlJT?>A@B^WTU];K@WTU:DCl: g9g :/^ [ vbI/>A@ [ Jl}^B:‡4 r V [Zó ^B>B@y@ [ ^BS :DC@BV [ *8 )15&: gsx ç74NŸ*^ [ }^ [ > [ C–@B>'J9I€jq>%¹'V [ CMCK:*¹%I~^BCT?C a T?>T?>W>B; [ J c I~CJ@WV [ > [ v|:Z¹V [ CI…¹ZI~^WCT?C a T?>%T?>B>W; [ Jt4 x ç;9I~@BTU:DC¸Ÿ0vbI/C¸] [ ^ [ ¹%^WTU@A@ [ CI/> , ×0Ø Ô ÙlÚyÛ%#Ü -oÝ : Ê ¢WT?SÁ}9=?T ó[ J¸T g ¹ [ I/>B>W;KS [ @WV9I“@ Ê Ö ÍÄÝ „ :'vbI/> [Dcx ç74 ¢ vbI/C¸] [ ^ [ ¹^BTU@B@ [ C , ×&Ø ÔlÙ ÚyÛ=Ü „ ž $> Ê 8„ & %Ö + ?Í &($A@ „ & Ö +H Ê ¡DÍ Ý < Ý £ £ £B Õ ¹'V [ ^ [ '@WV [Q[|e } [ vz@ [ Jvz:D>A@A¾œ} [ ^˜¾G;CTU@˜¾G=U:D>B>¼I/CJ >pÝ Ôpæ ÕT?>f@WV [ ù “øzDû CE“øwøš^WI~@WTU:‚4² g @WV [ v|:½T?CJ [ } [ CJ [ C–@½: g %Ö +@WV [ C0@BV [ S*T?CKT?S…;S : g ½¹'V [ C Ý >~c I~>T?CÀ@BV [ >B@WI/CJ9I“^WJMvz:D>A@A¾G=U:W>Z>Wv [ CI~^WTU:‚4 Ö%+ G O2SÁ:A@BT?C a >BTU@W;9I“@WTU:DCI~^WT?> [ >&T g ¹ [ I/>B>B;S [ @WV9I“@¸@BV [ vz:DS}9=?T{I/Cv [ ^WI~@ [ T?>ÂI g ;KC9vz@WTU:DC): g @BV [g I/=?> [ I~={I~^WS ^wI“@ [ 4 r V [g I/=?> [ I/={I~^BS ^WI~@ [ T?>ÂIÈS:DCK:/@B:DCT{vbI/=?=Uj J [ v|^ [ I/>BT?C a*g ;C9vz@BTU:DC: g @BV [ ¹%I~^BCT?C a @WVK^ [ >BVK:A:¹ [ vbI/CÀ¹^BTU@ [A$QÝH$ Ê Ö%+ Í 4šOf> Ö%+0T?C9vz^ [ I/> [ > c @WV [šg I/=?> [ I/={I“^WSÏ^wI“@ [ J [ vz^ [ I~> [ >yI/CKJQ¹ [ v‡I~C [|e } [ vz@y@WV [ vz:DS}9=?T{I~C9v [ ^WI~@ [ @B:&^BT?> [ 4 r V;> c IÂ^ [ I/>A:DC9I~]9= [lg :/^WS : 6g $ Ê %Ö + Í T?>¼I0S:DCq:WT?C a0g ;C9vz@BTU:DC : g Ö +s4 r V [ >BT?S}= [ >A@ g ;C9vz@WTU: g : $ Ý %Ö +y4yOf>B>W;KS*T?C a >B;9vwVÂIp^ [ ={I~@WTU:DCK>WVKTU} I/CJJTUô [ ^ [ C–@BT{I~@WT?C a A} [ v|@%@B:*@BV [ >A@wI~CJ9I~^BJvz:D>A@A¾G=U:W>I~C9I/=Ujq>BT?>‡4 ²GS} [ ^ g±[ vz@Çvz:DS}9=?T{I~C9v [ :DC@BV [ }‚I~^A@p: g @WV [ };K]9=?T{vÁvz:D;=?Ju] [ I&}R:W>BTU]9= R[ Q ;K>B@BT ó vbI~@WTU:Ý¥c I/CJ @WV [ T?C–@B:D= [ ^WI/C–@…;> [ ^W>Á: g @WV [ S:qJT óK[ J)>Wv [ C9I~^WTU:¹VK:.¹'T?=?=½C [ i [ ^Á@wI~_ [ I@BV [ vz:DS}9=?T{I/Cv [ ^wI~@ [ I/>fI g ;C9vz@WTU:DC¸: g @WV [ ¹ZI~^WCKT?C a @WVK^ [ >BVK:€4 ì c ŸI~CJ ¢ ^ [ >A} [ vz@WTUi [ =UjD41Ð\T a ;K^ [ ì I0>WVq:“¹'>¼@BV [ :ÂI g ;C9vz@WTU:DC+: g \ I/CJ } 4ÉÐ\T a ;K^ [ ì ] a TUi [ >…@WV [ } [ ^wv [ C–@^ [ J;9vz@WTU:DCÉT?C)@BV [ I€i [ ^wI a/[[|e } [ vz@ [ J v|:B@ǹV [ CÈ@WVT?>Ç:/}@WT?S…;KS T?> ;> [ J c ^wI~@BV [ ^ @BV9I/CI¸i~I/=?; [ : g Ö + Ý >Ýé¥ïP¥„A@A¾G=U:D>B>ÇI/CI/=Ujq>BT?>1¹š:D;K=?JÈ>B; aA@\^ [ J;9vz@WTU:\:“i [ ^ ¢/¥–ñ I/CKJÁT?>y:/]@wI/T?C [ J g : v|:/^B^ [ >A}R:DCKJ>š@B:I/C¸I/=?S:D>A@š;CKT g :B@A^WTU]9;q@WTU:DCÂ: gÅg :A@½}^B:/]‚I~]9T?=?TU@BT [ > I/CJlI%^ [ ={I~@WTUi [ =Uj¼vz:DS}9=?T{I/CD@ c ]9;K@ÑCK:/@´} [ ^ g±[ vz@W=Ujpvz:DS}=?T{I/C–@Å;> [ ^€4 r V [ :/}@WT?SÂI~=/¹%I~^BCT?C a @WVK^ [ >BVK:lvbI/> [ T?>ZÖ + è ¥ï ì ¥c ¹'VT{vwVÈT?>Çv|:BT?J [ ^wI~]9=UjuVT a V [ ^Ç@WVI/C.@WV [ vz:D>A@A¾ =U:D>B>¼^wI~@BTU:&: go¥ 4 ¥K„ 4DzGC>A} [ v|@BTU:DCu: g ÐyT a 4 ì I&>B; aA@B>¼@WV9I“@1@WV [ i~I/=?; [ : gš¡/¥–ñ ;K> [ Ju]j @WV [ hl4nm4Î15 ˆˆ 5&T?S}9=?T [ >ZI…i~I/=?; [ : g } å „BT?C9v [ @WV [p[ ô [ vz@BTUi [ i~I/=?; [ : g \ g :/^ [be @B^ [ S [N[ i [ CD@W>ÑT?>Ñ=?TU_ [ =Uj¼@A:f] [ I~@Ñ@BV [ VKT a V [ CJl: g @WV [ ^WI/C aWVq:“¹'C c @BV [ T?S}9=?T [ JÇi~I/=?; [ : g } SÂI€j&] [ S:A}R:DCKJ@A:&I;K> [ ^@WVI~@'T?>'ç–;TU@ [ T?C–@B:D= [ ^WI/C–@Ç: gZg I/=?> [ I/={I~^WS>€4À8 [bg±[ ^ [ C9v [ @B:Ð\T a 4 ì ]+T?CJT{vbI~@ [ > @BV9I~@QT?C @WVKT?>ÁvbI/> [ @BV [ ^ [ J;9vz@WTU:½ç;TU@ [ =U:“¹ c = [ >B>o@BV9I/C ¢Dñ 4sÐ\T a ;K^ [ Ÿ…>BVK:“¹>½@BV [ >wI~S [ I/C9I/=Uj>WT?>½I/>šÐyT a 4 ì cD[be v [ }@ g :/^ @WV [ vbI/> [ : g IÀvz:D>A@A¾G=U:D>B>1^wI“@WTU:À: g >…Ýþ¥ïU„ 4QO a I~T?C c @BV [¡Ç@A: ^ [ ={I~@WTUi [ =UjQVT a Vi~I/=?; [ >N: g } c I~CJ&I a I/T?C@WV [ vz:D>A@N^ [ J;9vz@BTU:DC>N: ^ [ba TU:DCÈ: g @WV [ \ & } }={I/C [Dc @BV [ VT a VÈi/I~=?; [ : g } S [ I/C>'@BV9I~@f@WV [ ;> [ ^f@ [ CJ@A:0:DCK=Uj^ [ >B}‚:DCJM@B:¸I/=?S:B@fv [ ^A@wI/T?C g :B@B> c ];K@¼@BV [ VT a V…i~I/=?; [ : g \ S [ I/CK>s@BV9I~@Ä>B;9vwV g :A@B>ÄI~^ [ VT a V=Ujl;C9vz:DS*SÁ:DC c V [ C9v [ @BV [ :i [ ^wI/=?= T?S}‚IA@*^ [ JK;9vz@WTU:DC>}R:D>B>BTU]9= [ ]–j,I%^wI~@BTU:0T?> ¥ 4 ¢ I~^ [ Cq:½I~^ [ ;> [ J c vz:DS}9I~^ [ JÂ@A: @WV [ I€i [ ^wI a/[ vz:D>A@\T?C9v|;K^B^ [ J…T?C @WV [ I~]9> [ C9v [ : gg :B@B>‡4 r V [ ^wI~@BTU:f: g @BV [ i~I/=?; [ >´: g @BV [ g :A@W>ÇT?CÈ@WV [ T?S} [ ^ g±[ v|@lvz:DS}=?T{I/C9v [ vbI/> [Dc ¹'TU@BVI/CÈ:BVK:D=?J c I/CJÀ@BV [ >B@WI/CJ9I“^WJÀ} [ ^ g±[ vz@'v|: [ T?> a TUi [ C¸]j&@BV [Çg :D=?=U:“¹T?C aÁ[|e }K^ [ >B>WTU:‡4tmÇI~@Bä c 8 4 ˆ 4ÅI/CJ 3u;K^A}9V–j c O…¹4 )Q4 Í'` I/SQ]^BT?J aB>B; [ J c I/>šI g ;C9vz@WTU:DC*: g @BV [ }9I~^wI/S [ @ [ ^ \ 4sLt:“¹i~I/=?; [ >N: g vz:A}R: g :A@A¾G=U:D>B>f^wI~@BTU:¸T?> ¥ 4 ¥„ Ê ] Ífr V [ } [ ^Çv [ C–@¼^ [ J;9vz@BTU:DCT?C@WV [Á[|e } [ vz@ [ Jvz:D>A@ ¹'V [ CÀ@BV [ :BVK:D=?JT?>%;> [ JÀ^wI~@BV [ ^@BV9I/CÀ@BV [ v|:B@˜¾G=U:D>B>Z^wI~@BTU:‚4 „ì

ÐyT a ;K^ [ Ÿ‚yO¼>%Ð\T a 4 ì [|e v [ }@ g :A@A¾G=U:W>o^wI~@BTU:…: gÑ¥ 4 „ 4ÄÎ:¼vz:D>A@A¾ =U:D>B>1^wI~@BTU:À@WV [ ^ [ T?>1i [ ^Aj=?TU@A@W= [ vz:D>A@p^ [ JK;9vz@WTU:DCÈI/CJ@WV [ :BVK:D=?J>pJK:CK:A@A¾G=U:W>Z^WI~@WTU:*I/>SQ;9vwVMI/>T?CÐyT a >€4 ì I/CKJŸ‚4 „‡¢

ÐyT a ;K^ [M¡  r V [ ^WI~@WTU: Ê T?C+} [ ^0v [ CD@ Í : g @WV [ i~I/=?; [ Ê I€i [ ^WI aA@^ [ J;9vz@WTU:DC Í : g @BV [ g :A@W>¼¹V [ C@WV [ ^ [ T?>pT?S} [ ^ g±[ vz@pvz:DS}9=?T{I/Cv [ @B:À@BV [ i~I/=?; [ ¹'V [ C@WV [ ^ [ T?>1} [ ^ g±[ vz@ v|:š@BV9I~@%T?C9vz:DS}9=?T{I/Cv [ V9I~>%CK:T?S}‚I