convergence hypothesis use panel unit roots test with no fixed individual effects. The ...... In order to cure this insufficiency, we proceeded to the realization.
Using panel unit root tests to evaluate the income convergence hypothesis in middle East and North
halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007
Africa countries Imène GUETAT, TEAM Francisco SERRANITO, Univ. Paris 13
2005.03
Maison des Sciences Économiques, 106-112 boulevard de L'Hôpital, 75647 Paris Cedex 13 http://mse.univ-paris1.fr/Publicat.htm ISSN : 1624-0340
halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007
USING PANEL UNIT ROOT TESTS TO EVALUATE THE INCOME CONVERGENCE HYPOTHESIS IN MIDDELE EAST AND NORTH AFRICA COUNTRIES
! /
#$ + ! -%*
*
$ ,
! !
% -.
"
#
& ' %
#
() &
! " %* ( '%
halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007
# ' ' )/ ' ' 1 * / ! % 2 3 445. 4467. 8 9 3 44:7 ! ; !8 < 3 44:7 ## ! $ # ' )/ % ! ' # ! # / # * ' 1 ' ' ' ! #/ * # ' $ %= ! ! ' 1 / ' ## ! > , ! ?%0 !:% / ! * 4:@ 44@ !* # 4:@ 0@@@% ' )/ / 1 *A ! ! ! ** % ' / )/ / !* # ' / * ' ! ' / ! 3 4:@ 44@ ! 4:@ 0@@@7% *1 1 B . )/ / !* # ' /% ! ' $ / 1 *A ! ! ! ** % ' . ! ' 1 / !. ! ' / !* # C / * # '' / * % 9 )1 ! & * %
!
'
.
' /. /
.
!!
!
' ! /
! 3 44:7 ## ! / # !, ! ! / ! 4:@ 44@ ! / / ! ' / ! 4:@ 0@@@7% G, ! , )/ F ! ! * ! F / /
/ 1
#
//)
/!
* 1
/
.
!
B 1 !' . $
)
' / '
/!
'
0@@@%
#
'
'
)/
#
!
'
!
D.
! * #.
3 44:7
A# %=
#
!8
!/ !
* 3 44:7 ! # 1
!
#
*0L / )
) //) '
#
# %
*I
#
3
'
!
'
#/ ! 1 1 !
#
# /
!
%
'
)
)/
'
!
*
' 1
/!
'
' ' 1
D
! # 1 B% ;
#
//
# '
1
* *
!)
*
#
!
/ /
*!
!
% !
' 1
/
!*
3 44 7.
*/
*
*/
%
8
' ' 1
'
D !%
1 B *; !
1
' '
$
&
# ' !&
*#
' *
1
%
*
/ '
' 1
#
. 1 !*
/
#/
'
D!
!
! %
#/
*#
/
5. *
!
*!
-
' '
1
-. 1 !
:
2
'
3 44:7 1
! % ##
:. K
0@@@%
89
halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007
/
' 1 *'
'
% 5
).
3 44:7 /
!
//
!
#
*! )
!
*#
!
' '
% '
!
halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007
#/
!' 1
**
A
).
!' 1
!)
3 7
.
1
/
−
+
! M
* # )##
1 ' ! # )N !
#/
!
'
*
*#
'
' *. 3
!
!
%
). *
89
##
!.
. 44:7 &
% /
# !*
#
* # 1
*
)
!
1! )
'/ #
! %
1
3 7
* #
!
** '
)
/ %K ) / #
) D .
# ' 1 / %
. )
# * ! * A/
' 1
!
. $ )/
#) , /
'
! '
*
%
#
##
' '
#
A
!) *
* .
)=
/
1 !
/
*#
%
! .µ
*
#/
**
µ µ !
)/
#/
!
##
/ #
1
*
/
.0
.
#
. 44:7%
)/
'
).
µ .µ0 .
+
/
!8
@.
1
! →∞.
#/
'
=
!
=
3 .σ 0 7 =
3?7
1
!!
− 0
@% @&ρ
!
8G ,
!
*! '
1 * !& 3 7
*
!#
! .
)
!
3H7
! '
# ! 307 *
/
1 ' !) #
=µ +ρ
−
+
! '/ #
!
#
* ). 2
)
' /1
#
'
3 4457 #/
#
%
# ! &
= .
.
= .
.
4
(
KG / #
#
/ *
/% ! *7
1
!
!
3ρ
347
%0?
#
*#
!!
!
.
− 7+-
→
+
ρ
# '
' %K
> 1
#% ;
!8
@
&ρ = ρ 0 =
!!
#
'
#.
!
>
%;
'
'
8
3
%
# B
*
)!
' %
. 44:7
A
!
/
*
!
#
*
)
/
'
#*
#/
!)
*
! ) ' "
'
# !* ! 3 ?7
.
! '
(
Γ =
#
'
!
#
ρ = ρ0 = = ρ = ρ ! */
!
!
3 57
!)
'
!
! . 1
%
*
!!
' 1 # ! . !
)
#/ %
*
!
)/ #
#/
*
!
&
=ρ =ρ
!?
#
.
$
.< ! . ) !
!
B)
B) ! !< !
.< ! *
B '
!
B) *
$
!
!
' "
'
"
'
"
'
"
' *#
@L
1
##
, 30@@07 ! %
05
+ ; )2 (
φ
-:4 0:5 05: 0@? 0@? :5 :5 0006H 05: 0@? 000:5
@%4H?: @%450H @%4555 @%4H-5 @%4H 6 @%4:-@ @%4:@ @%4:0 @%4@4? @%4H : @%4H-0 @%4:H@ @ %4::@ @%4: 6 @%4H-: @%4:0? @.4H?@
halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007
.
' ' !! !! !! !! !! !! K K K K K K K K
0 0 5 !? : H 0 5 ? : H
//
*
'
2
# B
/
7( 7 %
!
) *
'
!
*/
+
.
3
7
'
! *
!
1
!
*' 1
!)%
* !#
*
' '
1 '
% = *
*
. 1
/
*
)
!)
/
*
%
4'
1 . )
/
!
%
! !. /
X
/ ! *
'
! # ! ! 1 3 44- 7
! *
D! )
!
'
# '
!
* # ! ! #/ # # B1 !# !%
!C #
1 ! )
%=
.1
*
8V
/' 1
'
'
') *!
/#
*
' ' ! *
)
B
#
*
3 4457
; 1
*
/
# "
!
**
!S // ' /
%
0:
!
/ ! * '
/
/
/
%=
! *
!
' *
*
!.
'
//
*
*
/
*
'%
!
halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007
! '
.# G
' */ ! '
'
.
#
/ !. 1
. !
*
.
!
* /
/
!.
/
!
!
460.
B )7
' *
*
' 1
*
!
!
.
.
/
# #
)
!< !
> *!
!.
.< ! .
7
46@% ; * !
*
*
!*
'
!/
!
φ ! .
** !
! *#
-@L. 1
1 ')/
.
$
1
% > 1 /
! .
/ K
.
!
$7.
* 1 '
/ *
/
*
1
/%
K
/
'
# / 1
')/.
'
* *
@L% > 1
!'
* #%
#
/
!
#/
1 '
/
*
03
%
1
' *
4H:%
46@.
1 !
* #/
! * **
*
!K
L
' *
! ')/7&
#
!
C
.
'
# !
*
#
'
4HH. )
#
46@.
$ !
46 .
-3
* ! ** **
/
)
466% > 1
'
#
#/. )
)
'
46@% 46@
!
!
$ !
)B 1
7
.
1
*
')/
*
B
/ 3 ')/. < ! . )
# ' !
!
A'
/
. * 4H4
1 '
!
!
*
%
!* K
' *
3
*
/. *
%
! *
!
! .
//
#
4H:
* /
) )
'
*
!!
)
D
: '
*
/ ! '
# /
#
!
1
!%
'
!!
'
.*
. #
*
'
'
* /
//)
? 3 ')/. .
*
% = . K
!
* :.
46 . !
! )# #
1 ' *
! #
) #)%
0H
'( ) !
* = + 4
&
&
9
10.0
11.2
9.6
7.5 8.0
6.4 5.0 4.8
halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007
3.2 2.5
1.6
0.0
5
7
9
11
13
15
17
19
21
23
25
0.0
27
&
5
7
9
11
13
&
18
15
17
19
21
23
25
27
1
10.0
16
14 7.5
12
10 5.0
8
6
4
2.5
2
0
5
7
9
11
13
15
17
19
21
23
25
27 0.0
+ &
,
,!
+
& -& , .&
./
5
7
0,$ 11 .#
9
11
13
+ )
15
17
19
21
23
25
27
( & -&
06
'( )
* = + 4 &
>
12.8
11.2
9.6
8.0
halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007
6.4
4.8
3.2
1.6
+ &
,
,!
+
5
.
K
46@ 4H:
? , ,
!
$ # , & ,+ ! & & 3& 3+ 444$44# $4# 5 + && * B
13
46 .
,
≤ 2
15
./
+
17
19
21
$ #
> 2 0+
23
25
0,$ 11 .#
, -
27
+ )
( & -&
4'
!
)/ 1 '
1
/
-
*
∆(
3 :7
*
//)
#
&
!
ρ $
.1 1
' / )/
#
>(
$
' *
* 1
*
)/
%
1
>
! '
* )/
'
KG
#
/ /
ρ%
!
*
! !D !
% /
! )
!
! .
$
( ρ%
3 H7
)
+%
σ%
#
! )
!#
'/
!
%
--
•
!
'
) '
B '
'
ρ = .1
!
)/
//
* )1
!
ρ
*
C )/
//
'
!
).
*
#/ /
'
#
)#/
!
'
*!
! !
*
#
)
.
%
!
D %
#/ )
)/ *
'
ρ
) // A# . 1
halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007
.
*
.
& * ( ρ%
*
!
!
1
* ! %
// A#
!
*
%
= !
!
8 9
)
$
,#
!
!
#
#
/ #
%
*
# !
. 1
*
'
! / *
&
∆(
3 H7
)=δ
−
!. 1 '
(δ #
.σ 0
* ). 1
*
%
'
D!
/
** 1
# #
. 44:7%
#/ %
! '
!
!#1 B 1
!* )! 1 '* #
,/
@@@@ #
!
/ B /
/ ! !.
! 1 3 44- 7 #
;
!1 1 ! 1
*
!8
((
-
*
5A
3 ..
)/ / ! / * :%
!C
'
/
C /
!
**
#
!
! %
/
' 1
#/
OO
B ' *
'
4 / 89:
/ *
'
#
# :%
!!
)/
!1 1 ! ' )/
1
# ' 1
'
%
! !.
//
!
!
# * '
/ *
1
)/ %
ρ
!!
' *
*
)
1
!*
%
/ !%
* !
!* #
/ *
*
! 1 !
'
88:
*
.
**
*
/ *
8G )/
- .
@L
**
/
# !* !G
!
# !
!
.
+ /
#
'
! !.
> 1
-
! )
#/
#
1 89
!)
*A ! ! ! 3 44:7 !
%
** # ) A/ 3 4467%
-?
+ ;1) ! 4 / 4 & * 5 & . φ φ ", φ " ,
.
!! K
:
05
@%H? @
@%6?65
-
4-
@%4064
%@@0
4-
@%6:45
@%4:?
halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007
? 8 && 0 && + 9. , !
3 ,, , + , ,
>((
5A
!
-
*
!C
!
C
!*
'
! * 4:@
+" +
0%-: 3 5% 5447 @%@5H? 3 %:6??7 @%:4:: 3 0%:@? 7
,$
!
+
/
@
( 5%H@50
)( 5% 05H
( -%H65@
@
5% -??
-%5? 6
-% 0H0
5%-5H:
-%H@:5
-%-500
#
0
-
+ /
- .
4 / 89:
*
1 '
:::
5%
*
)/ 5
!
H
0@@@%
+ ;1) ! 4 / 4 & * 5 & . φ φ ", φ " ,
+
(
5
0-
@%6 0H
@%64?:
H
:5
@%4@4H
@%44
8 && 0 && + 9. , !
3 ,, , + , ,
*
* !
>(
4
=
//) '
+
-
& +
!
'%0
4
*
/
@
( 5%-4-4
)( -%H??H
( -%554:
@
5%H@ @
5%@65
-%H:H0
'
1 /
! *
#
/
!!
*' 1
4'
*
%
*!
*#
%=
B
'
/ ')/.
/
K
#
!
#
?L
? # # ' *
!
!**
! * 3@%HH ?7%
4HH.
#
$
?L '
4HH 3@%H @57.
)/
-
' *
* 4H:
@L
/
'- .
!
:@,
!
%; .1
K
B! 1
1
! *
* %
'
'
# B! ) 1
4H5 3@%-@--7.
#
'
'
' *
* / !
! /
) ! 4 / 4& * 5 & 3 . !! K
? :
4H5
-
4HH 4:4
φ
< φ0
" ,:
@% 4?4 @%-@-3 -%-H?-7 30%6- 7 @%:-H@%H @5 3 -%4:? 7 3 -% :: 7 @%-6:4 @%560: 3 ?%:6467 3 5%6@ 67
4'
@ @
φ
" ,: 0
@%H44 @%4@:? 3 -%@ -67 3 %5@5@7 @%:465 @%HH ? 3 5%6:4@7 3 -%:6667 @%H@56 @%6@@? 3 5%?4067 3 -% @5 7
halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007
?
φ
4
-6
'( 1 )
* = +4
! 44+
9
+
35
1
45
40
30
35
25 30
20
25
20
15
15
10 10
halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007
5
0
5
0
8
10
12
14
+
16
18
20
22
24
26
16
18
20
22
24
26
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
22
24
26
>
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
+ &
8
,
10
12
,!
14
+
& -& , .&
. /
0,$ 11 .#
+ )
( & -&
-4
>((
4
+
* '
.
4
4'
5
' *
!
4:H%
!
1
!
!
)
)/
*
!
!
.
!!
!
/ !%
1
B 1
#/
8G % #
'
*
1
*G
3 44:7
!
C
/1
' '
4:@
B **
! !.
*
# C /
B
/
* 44 . '
' 1 %
!
%
/
!
*
B
' */
!
%
5:
B 1 1
!
# *
' '# '
* #
* #
'
!!
! / !% > 1 *
#
#
'
. 1
! !
/# '
' . '
%
'
'
*#
1 ).
/
!/
!
/#
* A
*
%
%
halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007
%
5H
) (B 881 C& Q
= ' /
R.
.
'
J
2
halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007
&
%B 889C& [
&
*
!
!
& #
/
!(( 6 A )
'
*
!
)
'
#
!
! '
\.
)/
\.
B ). =
&& (5 *
!!
!
# *
B ' / / 45@-%
D( %(B 889C) [ I 1
#
\.
& #
, ,. // -? 5:%
# !
!
D
!
I 1
\.
( 6
!
,
*
!!
!.
* *
'
/
B 887C& [ #/
&
#
: . ] . //60 6?:%
\. + C - 0
( 5 !( &(# ! !
.
B 1
H-%
(( B 889C& [
(5 D
#
!
E%B 88 C& [
,. H . // :
)
' 1
/ - . . // @H ?6%
&
?
!
# ! .
!
(5
B
)
R.
3,A ! ,
?
1 B ' // .
)
44:%
%( B 889C& [
"
;
"
,
' >
' 1
\. B
&
&. 0@. // @0H @54%
'
!\. B
&
=
-H. //054 0:?%
! A( 6% \.
)
( B 889C& [
%( 5 A ,.
/
QA
# !
( D(5
)
: . //60 6?:%
( B 881 C &
=
?
* / #
!( #(5 / /
!
#
$( B 889C& [ "
*
' * . #
' ! #%
56
!
& !
( B 889C[
( (5 =
1 #/
&
!
#/
!) *
*# #
!
1
/\. =
B '
/
!
/ .K
)%
!
& #
'!
)
B
C
3
& >+ 3 .
D
%
%B 88>C& [=
!
halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007
((5 A ! ( ( B 88FC & E
3+ 0 &
11 \. K
5@
".
%
,. 4?. 50H 55-%
&
2
#
( B 887C) G A/
!
\.
,
2
#
(B 889C& [ #/
'
*
*
!) #
,. 55. //4 4%
*
#
' 1
!
'
\.
!
C - 0. 5@. // -?- -H?%
& B
!
E%B 889C& [
'
)
\.
&. @:. // @ 4 @-:%
( B 88@C& [ //
//
/
! , )/
#/ #
. 4 0@