Using panel unit root tests to evaluate the income convergence ...

1 downloads 0 Views 663KB Size Report
convergence hypothesis use panel unit roots test with no fixed individual effects. The ...... In order to cure this insufficiency, we proceeded to the realization.
Using panel unit root tests to evaluate the income convergence hypothesis in middle East and North

halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007

Africa countries Imène GUETAT, TEAM Francisco SERRANITO, Univ. Paris 13

2005.03

Maison des Sciences Économiques, 106-112 boulevard de L'Hôpital, 75647 Paris Cedex 13 http://mse.univ-paris1.fr/Publicat.htm ISSN : 1624-0340

halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007

USING PANEL UNIT ROOT TESTS TO EVALUATE THE INCOME CONVERGENCE HYPOTHESIS IN MIDDELE EAST AND NORTH AFRICA COUNTRIES

! /

#$ + ! -%*

*

$ ,

! !

% -.

"

#

& ' %

#

() &

! " %* ( '%

halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007

# ' ' )/ ' ' 1 * / ! % 2 3 445. 4467. 8 9 3 44:7 ! ; !8 < 3 44:7 ## ! $ # ' )/ % ! ' # ! # / # * ' 1 ' ' ' ! #/ * # ' $ %= ! ! ' 1 / ' ## ! > , ! ?%0 !:% / ! * 4:@ 44@ !* # 4:@ 0@@@% ' )/ / 1 *A ! ! ! ** % ' / )/ / !* # ' / * ' ! ' / ! 3 4:@ 44@ ! 4:@ 0@@@7% *1 1 B . )/ / !* # ' /% ! ' $ / 1 *A ! ! ! ** % ' . ! ' 1 / !. ! ' / !* # C / * # '' / * % 9 )1 ! & * %

!

'

.

' /. /

.

!!

!

' ! /

! 3 44:7 ## ! / # !, ! ! / ! 4:@ 44@ ! / / ! ' / ! 4:@ 0@@@7% G, ! , )/ F ! ! * ! F / /

/ 1

#

//)

/!

* 1

/

.

!

B 1 !' . $

)

' / '

/!

'

0@@@%

#

'

'

)/

#

!

'

!

D.

! * #.

3 44:7

A# %=

#

!8
!/ !

* 3 44:7 ! # 1

!

#

*0L / )

) //) '

#

# %

*I

#

3

'

!

'

#/ ! 1 1 !

#

# /

!

%

'

)

)/

'

!

*

' 1

/!

'

' ' 1

D

! # 1 B% ;

#

//

# '

1

* *

!)

*

#

!

/ /

*!

!

% !

' 1

/

!*

3 44 7.

*/

*

*/

%

8

' ' 1

'

D !%

1 B *; !

1

' '

$

&

# ' !&

*#

' *

1

%

*

/ '

' 1

#

. 1 !*

/

#/

'

D!

!

! %

#/

*#

/

5. *

!

*!

-

' '

1

-. 1 !

:

2

'

3 44:7 1

! % ##

:. K

0@@@%

89

halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007

/

' 1 *'

'

% 5

).

3 44:7 /

!

//

!

#

*! )

!

*#

!

' '

% '

!

halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007

#/

!' 1

**

A

).

!' 1

!)

3 7

.

1

/



+

! M

* # )##

1 ' ! # )N !

#/

!

'

*

*#

'

' *. 3

!

!

%

). *

89

##

!.

. 44:7 &

% /

# !*

#

* # 1

*

)

!

1! )

'/ #

! %

1

3 7

* #

!

** '

)

/ %K ) / #

) D .

# ' 1 / %

. )

# * ! * A/

' 1

!

. $ )/

#) , /

'

! '

*

%

#

##

' '

#

A

!) *

* .

)=

/

1 !

/

*#

%

! .µ

*

#/

**

µ µ !

)/

#/

!

##

/ #

1

*

/

.0

.

#

. 44:7%

)/

'

).

µ .µ0 .

+

/

!8
@.

1

! →∞.

#/

'

=

!

=

3 .σ 0 7 =

3?7

1

!!

− 0

@% @&ρ

!

8G ,

!

*! '

1 * !& 3 7

*

!#

! .

)

!

3H7

! '

# ! 307 *

/

1 ' !) #

=µ +ρ



+

! '/ #

!

#

* ). 2

)

' /1

#

'

3 4457 #/

#

%

# ! &

= .

.

= .

.

4

(

KG / #

#

/ *

/% ! *7

1

!

!



347

%0?

#

*#

!!

!

.

− 7+-



+

ρ

# '

' %K

> 1

#% ;

!8
@

&ρ = ρ 0 =

!!

#

'

#.

!

>

%;

'

'

8

3

%

# B

*

)!

' %

. 44:7

A

!

/

*

!

#

*

)

/

'

#*

#/

!)

*

! ) ' "

'

# !* ! 3 ?7

.

! '

(

Γ =

#

'

!

#

ρ = ρ0 = = ρ = ρ ! */

!

!

3 57

!)

'

!

! . 1

%

*

!!

' 1 # ! . !

)

#/ %

*

!

)/ #

#/

*

!

&

=ρ =ρ


!?

#

.

$

.< ! . ) !

!

B)

B) ! !< !

.< ! *

B '

!

B) *

$

!

!

' "

'

"

'

"

'

"

' *#

@L

1

##

, 30@@07 ! %

05

+ ; )2 (

φ

-:4 0:5 05: 0@? 0@? :5 :5 0006H 05: 0@? 000:5

@%4H?: @%450H @%4555 @%4H-5 @%4H 6 @%4:-@ @%4:@ @%4:0 @%4@4? @%4H : @%4H-0 @%4:H@ @ %4::@ @%4: 6 @%4H-: @%4:0? @.4H?@

halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007

.

' ' !! !! !! !! !! !! K K K K K K K K

0 0 5 !? : H 0 5 ? : H

//

*

'

2

# B

/

7( 7 %

!

) *

'

!

*/

+

.

3

7

'

! *

!

1

!

*' 1

!)%

* !#

*

' '

1 '

% = *

*

. 1

/

*

)

!)

/

*

%

4'


1 . )

/

!

%

! !. /

X

/ ! *

'

! # ! ! 1 3 44- 7

! *

D! )

!

'

# '

!

* # ! ! #/ # # B1 !# !%

!C #

1 ! )

%=

.1

*

8V

/' 1

'

'

') *!

/#

*

' ' ! *

)

B

#

*

3 4457

; 1

*

/

# "

!

**

!S // ' /

%

0:

!

/ ! * '

/

/

/

%=

! *

!

' *

*

!.

'

//

*

*

/

*

'%

!

halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007

! '

.# G

' */ ! '

'

.

#

/ !. 1

. !

*

.

!

* /

/

!.

/

!

!

460.

B )7

' *

*

' 1

*

!

!

.

.

/

# #

)

!< !

> *!

!.

.< ! .

7

46@% ; * !

*

*

!*

'

!/

!

φ ! .

** !

! *#

-@L. 1

1 ')/

.

$

1

% > 1 /

! .

/ K

.

!

$7.

* 1 '

/ *

/

*

1

/%

K

/

'

# / 1

')/.

'

* *

@L% > 1

!'

* #%

#

/

!

#/

1 '

/

*

03

%

1

' *

4H:%

46@.

1 !

* #/

! * **

*

!K

L

' *

! ')/7&

#

!

C

.

'

# !

*

#

'

4HH. )

#

46@.

$ !

46 .

-3

* ! ** **

/

)

466% > 1

'

#

#/. )

)

'

46@% 46@

!

!

$ !

)B 1

7

.

1

*

')/

*

B

/ 3 ')/. < ! . )

# ' !

!

A'

/

. * 4H4

1 '

!

!

*

%

!* K

' *

3

*

/. *

%

! *

!

! .

//

#

4H:

* /

) )

'

*

!!

)

D

: '

*

/ ! '

# /

#

!

1

!%

'

!!

'

.*

. #

*

'

'

* /

//)

? 3 ')/. .

*

% = . K

!

* :.

46 . !

! )# #

1 ' *

! #

) #)%

0H

'( ) !

* = + 4

&

&

9

10.0

11.2

9.6

7.5 8.0

6.4 5.0 4.8

halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007

3.2 2.5

1.6

0.0

5

7

9

11

13

15

17

19

21

23

25

0.0

27

&

5

7

9

11

13

&

18

15

17

19

21

23

25

27

1

10.0

16

14 7.5

12

10 5.0

8

6

4

2.5

2

0

5

7

9

11

13

15

17

19

21

23

25

27 0.0

+ &

,

,!

+

& -& , .&

./

5

7

0,$ 11 .#

9

11

13

+ )

15

17

19

21

23

25

27

( & -&

06

'( )

* = + 4 &

>

12.8

11.2

9.6

8.0

halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007

6.4

4.8

3.2

1.6

+ &

,

,!

+

5

.

K

46@ 4H:

? , ,

!

$ # , & ,+ ! & & 3& 3+ 444$44# $4# 5 + && * B

13

46 .

,

≤ 2

15

./

+

17

19

21

$ #

> 2 0+

23

25

0,$ 11 .#

, -

27

+ )

( & -&

4'




!

)/ 1 '

1

/

-

*

∆(

3 :7

*

//)

#

&

!

ρ $

.1 1

' / )/

#

>(

$

' *

* 1

*

)/

%

1

>

! '

* )/

'

KG

#

/ /

ρ%

!

*

! !D !

% /

! )

!

! .

$

( ρ%

3 H7

)

+%

σ%

#

! )

!#

'/

!

%

--



!

'

) '

B '

'

ρ = .1

!

)/

//

* )1

!

ρ

*

C )/

//

'

!

).

*

#/ /

'

#

)#/

!

'

*!

! !

*

#

)

.

%

!

D %

#/ )

)/ *

'

ρ

) // A# . 1

halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007

.

*

.

& * ( ρ%

*

!

!

1

* ! %

// A#

!

*

%

= !

!

8 9

)

$

,#

!

!

#

#

/ #

%

*

# !

. 1

*

'

! / *

&

∆(

3 H7

)=δ



!. 1 '

(δ #

.σ 0

* ). 1

*

%

'

D!

/

** 1

# #

. 44:7%

#/ %

! '

!

!#1 B 1

!* )! 1 '* #

,/

@@@@ #

!

/ B /

/ ! !.

! 1 3 44- 7 #

;

!1 1 ! 1

*

!8
((

-

*

5A

3 ..

)/ / ! / * :%

!C

'

/

C /

!

**

#

!

! %

/

' 1

#/

OO

B ' *

'

4 / 89:

/ *

'

#

# :%

!!

)/

!1 1 ! ' )/

1

# ' 1

'

%

! !.

//

!

!

# * '

/ *

1

)/ %

ρ

!!

' *

*

)

1

!*

%

/ !%

* !

!* #

/ *

*

! 1 !

'

88:

*

.

**

*

/ *

8G )/

- .

@L

**

/

# !* !G

!

# !

!

.

+ /

#

'

! !.

> 1

-

! )

#/

#

1 89

!)

*A ! ! ! 3 44:7 !

%

** # ) A/ 3 4467%

-?

+ ;1) ! 4 / 4 & * 5 & . φ φ ", φ " ,

.

!! K

:

05

@%H? @

@%6?65

-

4-

@%4064

%@@0

4-

@%6:45

@%4:?

halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007

? 8 && 0 && + 9. , !

3 ,, , + , ,

>((

5A

!

-

*

!C

!

C

!*

'

! * 4:@

+" +

0%-: 3 5% 5447 @%@5H? 3 %:6??7 @%:4:: 3 0%:@? 7

,$

!

+

/

@

( 5%H@50

)( 5% 05H

( -%H65@

@

5% -??

-%5? 6

-% 0H0

5%-5H:

-%H@:5

-%-500

#

0

-

+ /

- .

4 / 89:

*

1 '

:::

5%

*

)/ 5

!

H

0@@@%

+ ;1) ! 4 / 4 & * 5 & . φ φ ", φ " ,

+

(

5

0-

@%6 0H

@%64?:

H

:5

@%4@4H

@%44

8 && 0 && + 9. , !

3 ,, , + , ,

*

* !

>(

4

=

//) '

+

-

& +

!

'%0

4

*

/

@

( 5%-4-4

)( -%H??H

( -%554:

@

5%H@ @

5%@65

-%H:H0

'

1 /

! *

#

/

!!

*' 1

4'

*

%


*!

*#

%=

B

'

/ ')/.

/

K

#

!

#

?L

? # # ' *

!

!**

! * 3@%HH ?7%

4HH.

#

$

?L '

4HH 3@%H @57.

)/

-

' *

* 4H:

@L

/

'- .

!

:@,

!

%; .1

K

B! 1

1

! *

* %

'

'

# B! ) 1

4H5 3@%-@--7.

#

'

'

' *

* / !

! /

) ! 4 / 4& * 5 & 3 . !! K

? :

4H5

-

4HH 4:4

φ

< φ0

" ,:

@% 4?4 @%-@-3 -%-H?-7 30%6- 7 @%:-H@%H @5 3 -%4:? 7 3 -% :: 7 @%-6:4 @%560: 3 ?%:6467 3 5%6@ 67

4'

@ @

φ

" ,: 0

@%H44 @%4@:? 3 -%@ -67 3 %5@5@7 @%:465 @%HH ? 3 5%6:4@7 3 -%:6667 @%H@56 @%6@@? 3 5%?4067 3 -% @5 7

halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007

?

φ

4

-6

'( 1 )

* = +4

! 44+

9

+

35

1

45

40

30

35

25 30

20

25

20

15

15

10 10

halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007

5

0

5

0

8

10

12

14

+

16

18

20

22

24

26

16

18

20

22

24

26

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

22

24

26

>

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

5

0

+ &

8

,

10

12

,!

14

+

& -& , .&

. /

0,$ 11 .#

+ )

( & -&

-4

>((

4

+

* '

.

4

4'

5

' *

!

4:H%

!

1

!

!

)

)/

*

!

!

.

!!

!

/ !%

1

B 1

#/

8G % #

'

*

1

*G

3 44:7

!

C

/1

' '

4:@

B **

! !.

*

# C /

B

/

* 44 . '

' 1 %

!

%

/

!

*

B

' */

!

%

5:

B 1 1

!

# *

' '# '

* #

* #

'

!!

! / !% > 1 *

#

#

'

. 1

! !

/# '

' . '

%

'

'

*#

1 ).

/

!/

!

/#

* A

*

%

%

halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007

%

5H

) (B 881 C& Q

= ' /

R.

.

'

J

2

halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007

&

%B 889C& [

&

*

!

!

& #

/

!(( 6 A )

'

*

!

)

'

#

!

! '

\.

)/

\.

B ). =

&& (5 *

!!

!

# *

B ' / / 45@-%

D( %(B 889C) [ I 1

#

\.

& #

, ,. // -? 5:%

# !

!

D

!

I 1

\.

( 6

!

,

*

!!

!.

* *

'

/

B 887C& [ #/

&

#

: . ] . //60 6?:%

\. + C - 0

( 5 !( &(# ! !

.

B 1

H-%

(( B 889C& [

(5 D

#

!

E%B 88 C& [

,. H . // :

)

' 1

/ - . . // @H ?6%

&

?

!

# ! .

!

(5

B

)

R.

3,A ! ,

?

1 B ' // .

)

44:%

%( B 889C& [

"

;

"

,

' >

' 1

\. B

&

&. 0@. // @0H @54%

'

!\. B

&

=

-H. //054 0:?%

! A( 6% \.

)

( B 889C& [

%( 5 A ,.

/

QA

# !

( D(5

)

: . //60 6?:%

( B 881 C &

=

?

* / #

!( #(5 / /

!

#

$( B 889C& [ "

*

' * . #

' ! #%

56

!

& !

( B 889C[

( (5 =

1 #/

&

!

#/

!) *

*# #

!

1

/\. =

B '

/

!

/ .K

)%

!

& #

'!

)

B

C

3

& >+ 3 .

D

%

%B 88>C& [=

!

halshs-00193284, version 1 - 3 Dec 2007

((5 A ! ( ( B 88FC & E

3+ 0 &

11 \. K

5@

".

%

,. 4?. 50H 55-%

&

2

#

( B 887C) G A/

!

\.

,

2

#

(B 889C& [ #/

'

*

*

!) #

,. 55. //4 4%

*

#

' 1

!

'

\.

!

C - 0. 5@. // -?- -H?%

& B

!

E%B 889C& [

'

)

\.

&. @:. // @ 4 @-:%

( B 88@C& [ //

//

/

! , )/

#/ #

. 4 0@