Voting by Committees with Exit - CSIC Digital

1 downloads 0 Views 245KB Size Report
bers of the society (founders) may want to leave it if they do not like the resulting new ... In particular, they characterized voting by committees as the class of ...
  

           

          

            

             

 

!  " #$$#



                  

  

 !    "#$%    #  

&'(# ) (   *(#    # +     (#    $      (  (  , #  (  #  #    *  *   ** + &   ( -+    *  ' #**  '     ./00012  ./0//00 (  3     + &   ( + 4  *  ' #**  ' $     5/.206 (  3    4    7#+ &   ( +  8   + 9  *  ' #**  '     !.:$0;/5$06$0/  !.:$0:10 (   *  ' ( < #  *  '+ &   ( + 9    *  ' #**  '     6000$2= (        #'+ &   ( +  8     *  ' #**  '     !>-&00!?>5000/!4 (   ?#   + & **  *  '     + 9    >7   3    4    7# @ A #    ( * (   *  ' ( < # + 

&   

*    #    +

 %  " &  ' (  " &  ' ( ) ' (  *  (        '+,  &, 

-& , .//.0 1 ), ) 2"    &  '" &    3 ' ( &  " (    " )      ( &"   4 &  )  "0 % & ) & , ( (   &    ' 

3  (, & 5  "3 (   '    &  (   ("  6  "  &  (      &  )&  3

   &    "   (     &  "0      

    '"   )& 2      !   7 80 9   6    61   0         0 $:./;, 3      0  

.





 '+,  &,  -&  .//.    &  ' )& *  (  )&  "  4   " &     )&&    ,  ' &  (   , ) '  ) ' ( &  "0

&"  "   , &  )& & ' (       * 

 3*     &, (     5 "   "     &  " ( ' (  '  & &     0   &   ( ) 4         (  '+,  3 &,  -&  .//.6  0  ( &    5 ( & (  &  (   &   &  "  &   & (  6 ( &   ' *  ' )& &  2  0 % )  &  (     ? ') "   (    )&& &"   '   0

#

7  , (         (  , ) ) ,    '+,  &,  -&  .//., &  & (   &    ' (0  (   &   ( ( &   ') 

 '    &   ( ' ( ,  &  & 

      ' , )&

 '     )  0 1 ), )&     ' "     &  (   '      '"        &     '+,  &,  -&  .//.60 %   "          &  (  '3   &  "    &   (    &     3  & (     '       0       &   (  (   ', ) )        &  (  &      &  &   (   &     & *   " )         '"   (   &  ( &  " )   @   2   '"0 > ", ) 5 &     &  (   (" &  " (            0   &  (   ' '  (  6 (  ) ) "A    "       &   '  ,     "  '       '  0        &  & 5  "3 (   '    &  (   ("  6  "  &  (      &  & & , (   &  * (   ' (, & *  &   "   (    (    &         0  & )  , (       &  ", ' & 2 ( & 

   (   5  ( *        B # @/../AC

     *    * (  +   * #  @/..2A    @/..;A     @600/A (   D  # '   '$* (+

;

 '"   '  " & ' ( ) "       0  '" 5 &  ( &   5 *  @ "       0   , & 2" 5 *  @ "  4 2  "   & (   &    ) (        &    " )   "  ' (   (  0 %  & ) &    "  '",  "3 (,   6  "  &  (      3

    '  &   )  2  ( & )  '"  )    &  (    )&   (     &  "    (  *0 1 ),         &      ( B 00, & &  ( &     ( & *   "0      ",  (       "  & &  2 B     &    " 2    

    '   (  ' (    " @ '"   3 ) &   '&  & &  ' 2 0   , )      *      *   0            &    ( ) 4      &  & "A    &  (    6 (  &  (     0

& ,        ("  "3 (

   &  (   (  "     *   (  E  '   # ( **  #   # (        '+  >   2    #         (  D ( F G     (# +

L

     ' (          ,  '"  , "0   &      , , ,    (   *  &(     (  ? (          ,   '"    & '  (        0   5 (        &   50               3 ( (0  ) '  '"      &   ",

:

          3  $           '"       %                   2   '"     $             %                 $           '          "      #    '+,  &,  -&  .//. ) )    ( &    ' (           ) '  &   ( & 0    (           0 %  " &       

    )&     B &), )  " &       

    0 9  '"      &  (   '  (        , "0

("    ,         ,    

   ,         0  ), )   "  (  " *   ' (0  $         '                      %                  &  (   ' ( (  (         &         0   ) 4 ) &  '"  &   ( ( &  (  "3 (    &  (   " '   0 1 ), /

 ( 2    (  (     ( ' ) & ) &  &   (    &  ( )       &  ( 

*  & '   (

 (, )& (        '    ( & 2 (            & &  (     )&     ,   (  " (





 (  " (



  

 

  

 

     0

E 4 & 

"    '" ' &    (  (    ,    '        " &       

      0 1 ), (  )

,      )  "       , ' & )    , & &,       (   "   , )&&   ' "      0 %        &  (   (" &  " (        ' 0  ",     &    (   (   &   '   &  "0  &   ",     &   ' (   (       '  0 >  ",         6  "  $                   %  

      

 

  

 '+,  &,  -&  .//. &  ,    )&   " 2    " '& )  ) (  6 ( ( @   "    & & '  .#

&  "B &  , (     " ( @   "    @  , 00,        , (   @   &  "   @  , 00,       -3  '"     0   ,  & (     ?  " )    )&& &    '   0

& ,  & (   '   & '  "B &  ,      (  

      ,         '" 0 % &4 &  & &    (   "    )& &    &   ' ) )    " &0 % )   & & ,    5 ( & (  &   &  '     

 & (   ) "   (  &( ) &   )  '   3 " (   '"     &      &  ( 0



 & ,    & (  ) )  '0  &  &  ,    "   (       & &     (       (  " (   ,      0       (           , )    &  ' &   '"          &      &  ( 0  & & &  , (      & &         (     ,     (     , & ' &   '"     &      &  ( 0

&3

( , '  ( & )   , (   )               ", ) )  &    (  (      " ( " ( '    0 >  ",   $                                "              %                    % .;

)          %   #



  ! " 

&  . ' ) &    ",                   # + %      %  %                       )     )  )    */  . /     %    *   . /     %   #   +     "   0 )                 # + %      %  %                     %     





  

      =",  &  (     ,          0  ",   * 2   '"   6 

 "  0     ,       (     ,  (    '   ("   , ) &  &            (      )&& & ) &    *    '"0 .C

& ) &     "3 (,    ,   ,     ' 3 ' "    &         &), &  (   0           , &  2    & &  &                   0           &  (  ' &  ,                    )&     ,      ,      0 &,                B &  ,   ' ( ) '    

       )&& & ) &     "3 (0   ",   '  "3 (   '    &  (   ("  6  "  0 >   &  & (  )   &  0  

1                 %    

  #         ' & &       (     0 "  6  "  ,    0  )      0

  &    

> ' &      

(     B &), (      (      ,  ) 

  ' 2 "  ' , '"   '" (  ,      , '" ,    , '" ,        ,  '"  ",          0     "#"    &  (      & &       (       (     & &       ,     0 % ) & ) &  (      & &       (       (      )&     ,      0   & 2    

   )&      & &       0 

& '    (    ' (  +

.D

           & &               0 % *      0 "  6  "  ,     0   &          0 &, '"   '"           '" 2   '",     0 & (  @  )& &    &" &  &  )   )        (      & &              0 (    , &  ,     , ) &  &            , )&&   &                "3 ( (  0

&,         0

            & &           

    0 9*       0      &   '  (   )      &              )&    0 E  &   ) '  &  & 2    & &             )&            , )&&     0 %    & "   ( &  (  )  0   /     %        %            3    0 (   , )

0     ' ' "  *   

 &      '"   .0

    "#"    &      &   (      & &    0   &      (           & &      , )

& & (  ) )  A

.J

         "    )& &   &         

(  &  

.

" &    &" &,        "  "3 (,        ,  '"    '",       0 "   3   .  &    (  ,       0            ' ( &       ,       0

&3

( , '"  " (  ,    &  0 7  , '" &  ?     ,    0      #   &     0    , & 2   & &      0 " &    ,   0    "      )& &  " &        (     & &         0 " &    &" &,          0           , '" *    (  ,       , )&&     "3 (0 1, (     ,    0

&( , (   &   ,  

, )&&   &  ( (  .0  /     %   #    % )  )  &  (  '+,  &,  -&  .//.    K    . ' 0      , ) )  ("       )&  '+,  &,  -&    &        (  )A      &  "    & &        (  " (   (        0 .L

&( ,

) &  *        B   &  &   " 60 9*        (  )A     (      0 % )   & ) &    )3 * ,  "3 (,   0    )3 * 0   =  & ) & , (      ,        (  "   ( (     0  &)B &  , & 23     ,    & &              1,     0                   ' & ) ? (  *0 "  . & 2         & &            

      

 )&     ",    ' 5    0 " &       &                   0 (          &        *     )&  0 (         ,  &         , &         *        )&  

    "3 (0  &)B &  , & 2    ,   ,     

& &       0    )3 * , )   *

  ,       & &              0 &( , '"  .  & *  (   ,                  , )&&  &       "3 (0      0 &       5 (   .,  *  (  

0

.:

& '" K    .,     '"  0    '  3    ( " (  0 % 2 & ) &      '"             ' & &     &    3       & 2 ( 5 (  * 0   & , (     ,        0

&( , (   &   ,

                                              & ) &        ,  &  & 2       & &     4        )& (          

  )&   

#

&,    "  .,   0  &      #   3

    '" ( 0

#

&   &  ( (  #0

$ " %

(  *& &   ) )  4  & ) & (  ) ) &A

.      & &  <   (

&  .    

 # &  3  2         ' (  & 2 (  '    &  ( 0 >, &    (      (        "3 (   ' '      ("  6  "  0

./

  , & 2    &  (   ("  6  "     '" '    "3 (0 >  "    *     

 

          





   (     

    ) &    &  (        & &        )&             (  "    0 (     *  6  "     '"0  &           0 %  4  & &        ,       ,   (   0 7   )  4  & &       ,           ,   (   0

&

   0  ) )     & &       ,       ,  (      ,   (      0

&,

                   )&&   &       "3 (0 & , & 2  "3 (    &  (   ("  6  "   & , & & &"     ',  (" &    2   '"0 K    #  ; ' )  (",   &   (   '"  , &  &      2   ', 3 "0   K    # )  & (  ) * 0 %  " &          (   B   (   B 

  (       0 %&    )  " &  &    ,  ,       (    ,     ,     0  $             # + %               #$

*   .         # */  . 2                       # 2             %    %          # 

 &  20

%  ) &   &,    '"    ("  "3 (   6  "    &      (" ' &  0 >   , &  )& ' ( (     )  &  " 

 & '     &  "0

&   ' 2   

3   '"   '"  ) &  &   (  (     ' " &  , )&  " )     &   (  (     &  & "     )   0 > ", ) )    &  &  3  2       3

 ' (  & 2 (  '    &  ( B &  , & &   2    &  (   ("  '" (  ( 0 23  . ' )   & ( 0    &          ' "  (    0   ' &

 (  *   '" & (  ) " (3  A

#.













































)& & '    (   6  ="  0   &   (        %  ) &4 &  &      &  (   ("  '"0 

  " ' "

' ( 0  (     

&      (" 2   '" '     

   

 (     

&      (" 2   '" ' 

             (     

&      (" 2   '" ' 

             (     

&      (" 2   '" ' 

             (      

&      ("    '" ' 

             (      

&      ("    '" ' 

            ##

 (      

&      ("    '" ' 

             (     

&      ("    '" ' 

           

&

'(( 

   >, ) * &  (   (   &          (     0 % )  & (  ) 0  *. '        "              # + %        %    # *. '        "             # +        %       !    # * . '       "             # +      %       !   # 

 %    '"    0  &  & 2  

   & &     0   ' (  *  ("A               & &     &  (                        (   "           )    &    0 7  ,     '      (     '     '  &"    "

#;

 0  &       '"                

' %    '"    0  &  & 2       !     & &     0   ' (  *  ("A                 !        & &     & (   !             (   "          )    &    0 7  , !    '       (    !   '     '  &"    "  0  &       '"               

 %&    (  "  &     0 "   ' )  3   &  (         (   !    0      '"   ',    (            , '"   ',    (        

&,    (         

   &    &   (  # )      &     (            '"   ',    (         &,    (             &    &   (  ; )      &  (         (      



   &( )     &    '"   *   &   ( K    #  ("    '"0 %  )   &   0

& ) &     (  &   3

    ,  &  & 2       & & 

#C

  

4        & &       (    ,

     (    , 

  )&   

;

&,        0  &      ;       '" (  0 %  )   &   (  (   & )  A .    #   0    &   '      (    ,  (  &   )   &4 &  "    *   '"    ("    '"0 .0   0  , )    )  A



& 2      , & &       "      (  ;, )    &  (     ,    (   !      )    "     &        0

' >        ,           ' &    (  )&                     0  )        3   &     (  (           (  (      '  0 #0   0 %  ) &    0



& 2                 & &           0 &   , )&&   &                 '"   ' (  ;,       0 "     ' (  ; )    &        0 #D

1, (   !  , !   (   "   !   )    "     &        0

'

& 2                 & &      '     0 &      &    0 "     

' (  ; )    &        0 >     &  &           0

&  , &

   ,  ,    " 0

 >        ,           . ' ) '  &       3      '  0   



      (        (

 *     )    &    , (           , (      0   &      '"    (         &   * 2   '" '      (      %  )   &    '"    0         ' & &             & &           )&   0      '"   )    &            &    2   '" '                  0

)



" *  

 '+, 0 .//J0 H    "3 (    &  ( I  #J

 ), M0B , 0